Merged Pearl Harbor: "Revisionists" vs. "Traditionalists"

Now, of course, it would not have taken a genius to figure out that the message was a bit suspicious--a Japanese sub reporting on the absence of U.S. Navy ships at the alternate port to Pearl Harbor.



What did you think the message said??? "This is the Imperial Japanese Navy submarine I-72 on a top secret mission to reconnoiter the Lahaina anchorage for any United States Navy ships as part of our surprise attack on the United States Naval fleet at Pearl Harbor. There are no United States Navy ships at the Lahaina anchorage. I repeat, there are no United States Navy ships at the Lahaina anchorage. Out."???

JFC, put in half a second's thought before you hit submit.
 
What did you think the message said??? "This is the Imperial Japanese Navy submarine I-72 on a top secret mission to reconnoiter the Lahaina anchorage for any United States Navy ships as part of our surprise attack on the United States Naval fleet at Pearl Harbor. There are no United States Navy ships at the Lahaina anchorage. I repeat, there are no United States Navy ships at the Lahaina anchorage. Out."???

JFC, put in half a second's thought before you hit submit.

Well, that's how the Movies do it so the audience knows what's happening.
 
That was part of my point, that perhaps I should've made more explicit. The sub would have had no need to transmit if it was actually with the main body of the force, as the ships to whom it was transmitting could've seen with their own eyes.

Heck, maybe the whole Striking Force was off Lahaina, but FDR was doing magic to hide it from the American eyes.
 
What did you think the message said??? "This is the Imperial Japanese Navy submarine I-72 on a top secret mission to reconnoiter the Lahaina anchorage for any United States Navy ships as part of our surprise attack on the United States Naval fleet at Pearl Harbor. There are no United States Navy ships at the Lahaina anchorage. I repeat, there are no United States Navy ships at the Lahaina anchorage. Out."???

JFC, put in half a second's thought before you hit submit.

Well, the Japanese signal, "to, to, to!" (first syllable of the word for "charge") translates into English as "Okay, guys, lets go down and attack the Yankee fleet!"
 
The message from I-72 was "American fleet is not in ALL" (Japanese Deception and Denial in the Hawaii Operation, USN message form on pg. 13). The meaning of code group ALL was not known by Navy Intel at the time. This message is hardly a smoking gun tip off that Pearl Harbor was about to be attacked. The I-72 was also obviously no where near the Kido Butai's position. Bob would know this if he had looked to see where Lahaina Roads was located.
 
The message from I-72 was "American fleet is not in ALL" (Japanese Deception and Denial in the Hawaii Operation, USN message form on pg. 13). The meaning of code group ALL was not known by Navy Intel at the time. This message is hardly a smoking gun tip off that Pearl Harbor was about to be attacked. The I-72 was also obviously no where near the Kido Butai's position. Bob would know this if he had looked to see where Lahaina Roads was located.

Did you notice the time on that message?
 
He's flat out called them liars by saying that they transmitted when they say they didn't. The offer for him to go to Tokyo and tell the surviving members of the force that to their faces still stands.

In #1241, he very carefully does not claim they were lying about transmitting. He said the Japanese were not trustworthy. He said there is evidence of them transmitting and that they did transmit. But he does not make the next logical step and say "they lied about whether they transmitted", despite that being the obvious implication.

One possibility is that he's trying to keep some backpedal room, so he can also suggest the Americans altered the records and forced the Japanese to go along with the lie, as he has already suggested elsewhere in the thread, IIRC.
 
In #1241, he very carefully does not claim they were lying about transmitting. He said the Japanese were not trustworthy. He said there is evidence of them transmitting and that they did transmit. But he does not make the next logical step and say "they lied about whether they transmitted", despite that being the obvious implication.

One possibility is that he's trying to keep some backpedal room, so he can also suggest the Americans altered the records and forced the Japanese to go along with the lie, as he has already suggested elsewhere in the thread, IIRC.
Just another, sneakier, way of calling them liars.
 
Copy of the actual annotated radio intercept here, times, dates and all. Page thirteen of the pdf.
Yep, that's where I found it. I had never read it, and I was curious if the IJN was using the usual code groups for locations, which of course they had been. It didn't dawn on me to check the times. I guess I had just assumed the CTists would at use an intercept that the timing made at least somewhat plausible...and you'd think I would know better than to trust them about anything by now. :o
 
Last edited:
Yep, that's where I found it. I had never read it, and I was curious if the IJN was using the usual code groups for locations, which of course they had been. It didn't dawn on me to check the times. I guess I had just assumed the CTists would at use an intercept that the timing made at least somewhat plausible...and you'd think I would know better than to trust them about anything by now. :o
Obviously at some point in the attack radio silence would be broken first by someone. That someone happened to be I-72. That's all there is. I-72 just happened to be the first to break radio silence before the attack. Somebody had to, at some point when the attack was imminent. BTF seems to believe the entire attack should have occurred under radio blackout conditions or else it must be fake. I have no idea why.
 
Obviously at some point in the attack radio silence would be broken first by someone. That someone happened to be I-72. That's all there is. I-72 just happened to be the first to break radio silence before the attack. Somebody had to, at some point when the attack was imminent. BTF seems to believe the entire attack should have occurred under radio blackout conditions or else it must be fake. I have no idea why.

The time on the intercept form is 2046, or 8:46 pm on the 7th.
 
It gives time zone "I" for that time. Which would be 1146Z and 0146W on 07 Dec 41 (Hawaii time). When was it decrypted?

Okay, the intercept was dated 12/071450/I, TOI (time of interecept, I think) 12/072046. Navy Trans(lation) date was 11/15/45. I'm good with that as they ID the sub, I-72, which would only be known from post-war interrogations. So it was nearly 4 years before they sorted it out, and then only with help.
 
Copy of the actual annotated radio intercept here, times, dates and all. Page thirteen of the pdf.

JAPANESE RADIO DENIAL (SILENCE)
NO Transmissions by Kido Butai
Semaphore or Flag between Ships
Transmitters are “spiked”
Cruiser air reconnaissance flights send in blind Cruiser air reconnaissance flights send “in blind”
Broadcast Support from Tokyo: Multiple frequencies and repeats of messages
All ships copy broadcast
NO Combat Air Patrol; no CAP (which precludes navigational beacon)
Chatter on day of attack

Gee, everybody but the CTers say there was no transmissions before the attack.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom