Merged Pearl Harbor: "Revisionists" vs. "Traditionalists"

I take it that's a peer-reviewed journal?

It's this.

The journal published a refutation of that article three years later in their "Reviews and Commentary" section, Edwin C. Fishel's and Louis W. Tordella's "FDR's mistake? Not likely."

Personally, I wonder why Berkin and Meyer felt that Prange needed to assume anything, considering that his cited source in At Dawn We Slept is an interview that he himself personally conducted with the Vice Admiral in charge of Battleship Division 3, which Hiei was assigned to.
 
More "con" than "Co", the way they had it set up. :mad:

Yes, the various local nationalist groups that sided with the Japanese rapidly discovered that they weren't the nice liberators from western imperialism they had been led to believe they were.
 
These points are either irrelevant or incomplete or problematic, mostly the first. Nothing you say here refutes the revisionist case on this point. I'll tell you what: Why don't you dare yourself to read the evidence on this matter presented by Dr. George Victor in The Pearl Harbor Myth and by Percy Greaves in Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fruits of Infamy? Surely if that case is so weak, you should have nothing to fear from reading it.

You've made a positive assertion that FDR somehow compelled the Japanese to stop an invasion of the Soviet Union and provided nothing more than two books that back your assertion up - no quotes from the books, no references to primary documents, no dates of when FDR managed to do this, etc.

On the other hand I have given you a chronology of events that show the Soviet-Japanese conflict preceded FDR becoming president, etc. with references to documents, dates, and verified historical events and a rational explanation of why your assertion is false.

What specific evidence do Dr. Victor and Mr. Greaves have that would cause me to revise the general understanding of historical events, in favour of your assertion? I'm a busy man - Battery Merit boards to prepare for, a change of armouries, managing several large and small litigation files, family to interact with, and a hockey sock of new titles from Black Library along with some decent history books to read, make me want to spend the time to read their work.

Alternately, which of the points I have raised in objections are irrelevant (and why), incomplete (and what has been overlooked), or problematic (and why)?
 
Roosevelt, in fact, spent a lot of effort trying to get Stalin to join the war against Japan as early as 1943, something Stalin only pledged to do once Hitler had been defeated. And even after the surrender of Germany, Stalin dragged his feet on entering the pacific side of the war despite territorial bribes from FDR, and didn't actually launch his offensive until after the first atomic bomb had been dropped.
 
Roosevelt, in fact, spent a lot of effort trying to get Stalin to join the war against Japan as early as 1943, something Stalin only pledged to do once Hitler had been defeated. And even after the surrender of Germany, Stalin dragged his feet on entering the pacific side of the war despite territorial bribes from FDR, and didn't actually launch his offensive until after the first atomic bomb had been dropped.

He agreed to enter the Pacific War 90 days after the surrender of Germany, whenever that was to be. Takes a while to move troops across eleven time zone.
 
Waiting for Nomonhan from the local library, but I found an analysis of the battles from the US Combat Studies Institute that I'll upload tomorrow.
 
I'll stick with these two.
* You referred to John Toland as one of the "Roosevelt haters." Now, obviously, you've never read his book Infamy, even though you've attacked it. If you'd read the book, you'd know that Toland was a huge fan of FDR's. Toland makes this clear in several places in the book. He's very critical of FDR's handling of relations with Japan, but he heaps praise on FDR on other issues and expresses his overall high regard for the man. You'd know that if you'd read the book.

"* You trumpeted Jacobsen's article on Grogan's bearings as the definitive, final word on the matter, yet you apparently weren't even aware that Drs. Hill and Wilford shredded Jacobsen's article in a detailed 2006 reply. And it's clear from your polemics on Hill and Wilford's response that you have no credible answer for their arguments and documentation."



What made John Toland bad was that he just got caught too many times telling falsehoods about his sources and creating false information that his own sources didn't support. His most famous example was the diary of Rear Admiral J. E. Meijer Ranneft of the Dutch Navy. During the subsequent printings of his book (softcover) he later removed the section showing the pictures of the diary since what he claimed about the diary was not true. I believe John Zimmerman, and a couple of others also wrote an article on this. I myself also have a copy of the diary pages.

The 2006 article hardly refutes anything, I didn't think much of it in 2006 when I got the early copy from Jacobsen.

If you look around hard enough you will see Jacobsen wrote in fact numerous letters and an article after the 2006 publication. See for example his 2007 article (Radio Silence of the Pearl Harbor Strike Force Confirmed Again: The Saga of Secret Message Serial (SMS) Numbers). (posthumous)
After talking with these guys like Wiley, Stinnett, and Villa, (Wilford never seems to talk) I've long considered the ball in their court and have been waiting to see something new.

Villa and Wilford never put out the book they were claiming to write that would in fact refute Jacobsen.

Have they written anything since 2006? If they have please point me to it.
Otherwise frankly I'm not too interested.
 
Last edited:
"Nomonhan. Japanese-Soviet Tactical Combat, 1939" from the US Army Staff College is just a little too big to upload to here (11MB).
 
They are open to reasoned argument supported by solid evidence from primary sources.

What you have offered are quotes from books describing accounts that have been offered long after the even and are by and large unverifiable. You've also demonstrated a lack of knowledge about technical matters and your only refutation of counter arguments is to claim that records have been falsified and people lied, while refusing to consider the possibility it is you own sources that are engaged in deception.

In summary you are big on claims and short on evidence. Unless you can address that deficiency you will convince no one.
Wrong. He says it's possible that they lied, that they lied about other things, and strongly implies that they are lying about not transmitting. AFAIK, he has never directly stated they were. He has, oddly enough, stated that they were transmitting, or at least that there's evidence toward it.
 
Wrong. He says it's possible that they lied, that they lied about other things, and strongly implies that they are lying about not transmitting. AFAIK, he has never directly stated they were. He has, oddly enough, stated that they were transmitting, or at least that there's evidence toward it.

He's flat out called them liars by saying that they transmitted when they say they didn't. The offer for him to go to Tokyo and tell the surviving members of the force that to their faces still stands.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom