Merged Pearl Harbor: "Revisionists" vs. "Traditionalists"

Wow,bobtaftfan sure got off his "FDR Saved Russia From the Japanese" theory quick, and is back to displaying his ignorance about naval operations in another desperate attempt to prove his crackpot FDR knew in advance conspiracy theories.
And I suspect he is using a old CT tactic;not actually reading through the material he links to and quotes, but just gives it a glance looking for stuff to "quote mine" to prove his theories....
 
Last edited:
Which means they probably refueled every day or every other day, which would be prudent in case you hit bad weather that would preclude underway replenishment.

The deck logs I mentioned above record fueling operations. I'd have to walk all the way across the room to get my copy. And there's a beer fridge waiting to pounce if I make a wrong move on that trip.
 
Wow,bobtaftfan sure got off his "FDR Saved Russia From the Japanese" theory quick, and is back to displaying his ignorance about naval operations in another desperate attempt to prove his crackpot FDR knew in advance conspiracy theories.
And I suspect he is using a old CT tactic;not actually reading through the material he links to and quotes, but just gives it a glance looking for stuff to "quote mine" to prove his theories....

Its more a case of trying a Gish Gallop or spray and pray tactic. He's hoping that somewhere there is a gap in our collective WW2 knowledge that he can find, not realizing that even a cursory historical hobbyist will know how things really are. He's also hoping that our knowledge level is based on something from more than a few decades ago.

For example: The whole Japan vs. Soviet thing. Its really only in about the last 15-20 years that the importance of KhalKhin Gol was appreciated. Japanese, even under surrender, didn't mention it a whole lot and the Soviets kept secrets even when they didn't need to. Once records freed up and a resurgence of interest in WW2 kicked in a lot of things were reexamined. Prior to knowledge about the Gol it was simply assumed that Japan just wasn't interested in tangling with the Soviets. Bobby seems to hope that we are still at that level of knowledge/assumption. Wrong.
 
Its more a case of trying a Gish Gallop or spray and pray tactic. He's hoping that somewhere there is a gap in our collective WW2 knowledge that he can find, not realizing that even a cursory historical hobbyist will know how things really are. He's also hoping that our knowledge level is based on something from more than a few decades ago.

For example: The whole Japan vs. Soviet thing. Its really only in about the last 15-20 years that the importance of KhalKhin Gol was appreciated. Japanese, even under surrender, didn't mention it a whole lot and the Soviets kept secrets even when they didn't need to. Once records freed up and a resurgence of interest in WW2 kicked in a lot of things were reexamined. Prior to knowledge about the Gol it was simply assumed that Japan just wasn't interested in tangling with the Soviets. Bobby seems to hope that we are still at that level of knowledge/assumption. Wrong.
Well, you'd think by now Bob would realize many of us know fair bit about these subjects, several others know a lot more, and then there is Gawdzilla, who's a freakin' expert on Pearl Harbor and related events. But I guess I sometimes overestimate the ability of the CTist to see when he's obviously and completely out of his league.
 
Well, you'd think by now Bob would realize many of us know fair bit about these subjects, several others know a lot more, and then there is Gawdzilla, who's a freakin' expert on Pearl Harbor and related events. But I guess I sometimes overestimate the ability of the CTist to see when he's obviously and completely out of his league.

After he first got shot down he came back with some nitpicking about the Jacobsen article. Most of us ignored it as it was like complaining about which direction the deck chairs were facing on the Titanic. Then finally someone got fed up because he kept bringing it up and destroyed it as an argument. So now he's basically trying to cow us with odd angles and declaring that every paleo-con who ever cracked a book is a 'respected scholar' as long as they find odd ways to prove that FDR started World War 2, The Franco Prussian War, and the Thirty Years War.

The fact that he is simply outclassed and is trying to bluff his way through things can be summed up with such howlers as "The fact that FDR prevented Japan from launching an invasion of the Soviet Union is too well documented to warrant debate."
 
Back to the radio silence myth again. The main "evidence" for the claim of radio silence is Japanese testimony.
And records. And records of their orders. You could always tell the people who served on the ships they're liars. They probably wouldn't take it well.

But the Japanese lied about all kinds of things after the war.
So did America. So did everyone. It was a war.

The Japanese solemnly swore that they had no spies on Hawaii. But years later this was proven false when Takeo Yoshikawa, Tokyo's official spy at the Hawaiian consulate, went public with his story.
If you're trying to claim imply that the Japanese were and are lying about transmitting - which you carefully avoid stating directly, I note - you might want to use an example that does not involve someone publicly confessing to lying.

...
Plus, there is a mass of credible anecdotal evidence that American, British, and Dutch intelligence units intercepted messages from or about the task force and were aware of its location.
None of which comes any closer than second-order, or has been backed up by actual physical or documentary evidence. I also note you've completely dropped the claim that their location could be plotted fairly accurately via triangulation. You never chose to respond to my little challenge either. Odd.

I've discussed and documented other evidence against radio silence in previous replies.
You've implied but not directly stated the Japanese were lying about radio silence in particular, yes.

Well, you'd think by now Bob would realize many of us know fair bit about these subjects, several others know a lot more, and then there is Gawdzilla, who's a freakin' expert on Pearl Harbor and related events. But I guess I sometimes overestimate the ability of the CTist to see when he's obviously and completely out of his league.

It's called the Dunning-Kruger effect.
 
Here is some of what Dr. Villa and Dr. Wilford have to say about the radio silence claim:

A dispatch of 25 November confirmed that emergency communications were possible during radio silence: "From 26 November, ships of Combined Fleet will observe radio communications procedure as follows...Except in extreme emergency the Main Force and its attached force will cease communicating."" It is thus clear that the Japanese navy admitted the possibility that it might be necessary in particular circumstances to use radio.​


Let me ask you, Bob, on a scale of 0 to 10, exactly how stupid do Villa and Wilford think their readers are, and, by extension, how stupid do you think your readers are? "Except in extreme emergency, the Main Force and its attached units will cease communicating." This is proof that the strike force might have broken radio silence? Not enough laughing dogs to do this one justice.

The Kido Butai, sailing under difficult conditions in winter seas, faced a number of circumstances that seemed to compel the use of radio for its secret operation. As Rear Admiral Kusaka of the 1st Air Fleet later explained that "It was needless to say that the strictest radio silence was ordered to be maintained in every ship of the Task Force. To keep radio silence was easy to say, but not so easy to maintain."31​


Kusaka says that radio silence was difficult to maintain. He never says it wasn't maintained. That's simply wishful thinking on the authors' (and your) parts. Also, "seemed to compel"? How would they know? Are they experts on Imperial Japanese Navy procedures and protocols?

How could the Kido Butai, spread out over 360 square miles of ocean by day and ninety square miles by night, cope with fog, storms and a ban on night illumination without recourse to radio communications?32 Under these circumstances, the ships certainly needed low-power radio to assemble at a common point in the north Pacific for refuelling.​


Yet more wishful thinking and ignorance of naval procedures. Further, even granting for the sake of argument that the authors' insinuation that radio would have been required for night operations without lights, where's your evidence that the strike force didn't just show lights, rather than break radio silence?



<snip>

It is unlikely that these USN intercepts all represented Japanese radio deception. Secret call signs intercepted by American monitoring stations suggested clandestine operations. Code movement reports, as well as traffic between carriers and their oil tankers, reflected operations far away from home, rather than stationary anchorage in home ports, as Japanese deception was trying to convey using routine call signs. The Japanese would not have sent a false message indicating that Akagi was conversing on a " tactical circuit" with oil tankers when previous false messages were trying to convince American naval intelligence that the carriers were in home waters. The oil tanker traffic with the carriers clearly meant long voyages, not anchorage in Kyushu. ("Warning at Pearl Harbor: Leslie Grogan and the Tracking of the Kido Butai," The Northern Mariner, 11:2, April 2001, pp. 1-17, http://www.thestormunleashed.com/files/docs/warning_at_ph.pdf, emphasis added)​


First, to reiterate, Villa and Loring are not qualified to determine what "is unlikely" in terms of Japanese radio deception; this is simply more wishful thinking and insinuation. Second, as has been mentioned, the fact that an aircraft carrier is talking to an "oil tanker" (actually an oiler) does not mean that long-range operations are occurring. Along those lines, notice how the authors conflate "in home waters" with being anchored. Japanese carriers conducting intensive flight training in the Sea of Japan (in home waters) would require frequent replenishment of their supplies of aviation gasoline; aviation gasoline is carried by oilers. And even if the carriers were supposed to be anchored, ships in port often refueled from oilers moored alongside.

The last point is one for which traditionalists have no good answer. If you're trying to trick your enemy into thinking that your carriers are in home waters, the last thing in the world you're going to do is send out fake messages that have one of your carriers conversing with oil tankers. Even a rookie analyst would understand that oil tankers talking with carriers indicates long voyages, not anchorage in home waters.


No. As has been shown, this is totally wrong, and if you've never received a good answer it's because you never asked the right people. Are you willing to "man up" and admit that you don't really understand WWII naval operations well enough to evaluate Villa's and Wolford's claims?

I'll address the rest of your post later.
 
Grogan determined on the second and third nights that the ships he was hearing were moving eastward, and he twice stipulated that he was using the term "northwest by west" to say that they were northwest of Hawaii. Obviously, that corresponds very well with the Kido Butai. And simple common sense should tell us that Grogan could not have concluded that the ships were moving eastward and that they were northwest of Hawaii on the basis of bearings that were off by 18 and 44 degrees.

Jacobsen never explained how Grogan determined that the ships were moving eastward toward Hawaii if he was using "northwest by west" literally, i.e., if his "good bearings" were off by 18 and 44 degrees. But, of course, as I've documented, Grogan twice made it clear that was using "northwest by west" to refer to the location of the ships as being northwest of Hawaii. And it's worth repeating that Jacobsen never bothered to inform his readers that Grogan explained how he was using the term "northwest by west."

Nor did Jacobsen explain how Grogan could have believed the ships were trying to "sneak up" on Hawaii and that they posed a threat to Hawaii on the basis of "good bearings" that were so wildly off the mark.

Finally, a word about the polemics regarding my simple statement of fact that if you take multiple DF bearing on a huge, slow-moving target you can "essentially," "roughly" triangulate the target on a "ballpark" basis. I absolutely stand by that statement, because it happens to be factual.

If you have a target that stretches at least 90 miles and that is moving at around 15 knots, and if you take multiple DF bearings on that target over the course of two or three days, you're going to have a decent, ballpark idea of the target's location and heading. Will your DFing be as accurate as if done by three stationary DF stations. No, of course not. But you will have rough, ballpark idea of the target's location and heading. For one thing, Grogan knew where he was when he took each set of bearings, and then you compared that set to the next sets, and his next step would have been to draw lines on the map from the DF locations and see to where they intersected. On a target as huge and slow-moving as the Kido Butai, yes, that is absolutely going to give you a ballpark idea of the target's location and heading. Anyone who has done DFing or who knows anything about DFing should understand this fact.

That's why Grogan determined after his second and third nights of taking DF bearings that the ships were moving eastward and that they were northwest of Hawaii.
 
Lack of transmissions aside (rather important though tha hole is), how is relying on someone for directional evidence who uses the phrase "NorthWest by West" to mean "North West"? I would doubt their competence, frankly.

It's the equivalent of saying "turn left" followed by "when I said left, I meant right".
NWbW is very specific direction, and to imply that he actually meant NW simply doesn't wash. If he meant NW then why the bliminy flip did he not say NW? It's shorter!
 
Lack of transmissions aside (rather important though tha hole is), how is relying on someone for directional evidence who uses the phrase "NorthWest by West" to mean "North West"? I would doubt their competence, frankly.

It's the equivalent of saying "turn left" followed by "when I said left, I meant right".
NWbW is very specific direction, and to imply that he actually meant NW simply doesn't wash. If he meant NW then why the bliminy flip did he not say NW? It's shorter!

For CTers "sorts close" easily becomes "close enough" and then morphs into "exactly accurate". I think it parallels a certain amount of mental decline.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom