Merged Pearl Harbor: "Revisionists" vs. "Traditionalists"

And all this is not to mention that we have hard evidence that the task force broke radio silence. For example, we know that one of the submarines assigned to the Kido Butai sent a radio message advising that there were no American warships at the Lahaina anchorage. At the time Lahaina was an alternative anchorage to Pearl Harbor. We know that the Japanese had hoped that some ships would be at Lahaina; they believed that the anchorage was so deep that sunken ships would be unrecoverable.

This again? Do you know when the sub sent that message, and from what location? Do you even know where the anchorage is?
 
My assertion is not at all at odds with known historical facts. I did not say that Japan and Russia did not fight. I said that FDR prevented Japan from launching an invasion of the Soviet Union. Dr. George Victor discusses this at length in The Pearl Harbor Myth. Percy Greaves discussed it in Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fruits of Infamy.

If the Japanese had launched a full-scale invasion of Russia in 1941, the Soviets almost certainly would have collapsed.

The Soviet-Japanese wars were going on for about a year before FDR became president. They ended (for a period from April 13, 1941 to around June 1945) with the signing of a Neutrality Pact that BOTH sides honoured. How do figure that FDR prevented the two parties from going to war? You may note that the Soviet-Japanese Pact preceeded Operation Barbarossa by a little over 2 months.

The only people who prevented the Japanese from invading the USSR were the Japanese High Command - who in light of the failure of the IJA to win Siberia decided to back the IJN's favoured plan to go after southern Asia and the Pacific Islands.

I find this argument incredibly simplistic and naive. The opposition would have been a huge improvement over Hitler, but FDR and Churchill rejected all their entreaties.

Yes they would have been an improvement over Hitler - still doesn't mean that the Western Allies would have trusted them once they got out of their sight, and turned on an ally, even one as odious as Stalin
 
This again? Do you know when the sub sent that message, and from what location? Do you even know where the anchorage is?


I don't think that's BT's point. I think he's trying to imply, by handwaving, that KB either wasn't under orders to maintain radio silence, or that those orders could have been ignored.
 
The "mongrelized" Americans would be no match for the Aryan supermen. I guess he'd never seen a Pekingese in a fight with a junkyard dog.

You'd think he would've learned at least something from the smoking Jesse Owens gave his so-called "supermen" in the 1936 Olympics track and field events.
 
I wonder if bobtaftfan really wants to go where he seems to be going with his semi defense of Hitler. Calling him a "Evil Dictator" is not a Get OUt Of Jail Free card where that is concerned.
Pat Buchanan continually calls Hitler "evil" but continues to white wash him at every opportunity.
 
I don't think that's BT's point. I think he's trying to imply, by handwaving, that KB either wasn't under orders to maintain radio silence, or that those orders could have been ignored.

The Attacking Force had to know where to attack. The only way to get this information to them was via radio. Given that the orders read "if discovered within 24 hours of the planned attack time, you are directed to press home the attack regardless of cost" the transmission of a two letter code group would not be a violation of secrecy. AND I know btf's radio guys can perform miracles, but even they would have had a tough time tracking in on two letters.

In other words, a deliberate red herring by Mr. btf.
 
I wonder if bobtaftfan really wants to go where he seems to be going with his semi defense of Hitler. Calling him a "Evil Dictator" is not a Get OUt Of Jail Free card where that is concerned.
Pat Buchanan continually calls Hitler "evil" but continues to white wash him at every opportunity.

The extreme right doesn't seem to have a problem with Hitler. FDR, on the other hand, seems to panic them no end.
 
Back to the radio silence myth again. The main "evidence" for the claim of radio silence is Japanese testimony. But the Japanese lied about all kinds of things after the war.

Ummm. No. We also have the orders, the paperwork, the after-action reports, etc. etc. We have a very large paper trail that the US and allies went over very carefully. We didn't just ask them nicely.
 
The part where you want the Allies to have fought a victorious Nazi Germany without the aid of the country that did the vast majority of the actual fighting against Hitler.

Thanks, I hoped I wasn't being to indirect.

Most Americans are convinced they beat the Nazis all by themselves with just a little help from the British, any mention of Russia is pro communist and besides we gave them trucks.
 
Regarding the argument that FDR and Churchill didn't trust the German resistance because "they had been fighting us," well, gosh, they didn't have much choice. Most of them were military officers who risked execution if they refused to fight. The point is that they didn't want to fight us and wanted to get rid of the guy who was making them fight us.

The fact that FDR prevented Japan from launching an invasion of the Soviet Union is too well documented to warrant debate. Scholars such as George Victor and Percy Greaves have documented FDR's disastrous policy in detail. Many other scholars have--sometimes unintentionally--provided ample documentation of this fact as well.

FDR began to really put the screws to Japan and sabotaged the Japanese moderates when he learned from intercepts that Japan was considering going to war against the Soviet Union. Historians of all stripes have noted that the massive reinforcements that Stalin was able to bring in from eastern Russia were the key factor in halting the German advance. And why was he able to pull so many troops from his eastern flank? Because the Japanese were focusing their war effort against America and the British. This would not have happened if FDR had accepted Japan's very reasonable peace offers.

Finally, Hitler's decision to declare war against America was a dumb move in terms of PR in the eyes of history, but it was perfectly understandable given the fact (1) that FDR was falsely blaming Germany for pushing Japan to attack Pearl Harbor, (2) that in the preceding three days FDR had declared that a state of war existed between America and Germany even if Congress declined to declare war and even if Germany did not declare war on America, and (3) that the Roosevelt administration and its allies in Congress and the press were spreading baseless "reports" that German planes and pilots had taken part in the Pearl Harbor attack (they also claimed that German planes and pilots helped the Japanese attack the Philippines).
 
Back to the radio silence myth again. The main "evidence" for the claim of radio silence is Japanese testimony. But the Japanese lied about all kinds of things after the war.

The Japanese solemnly swore that they had no spies on Hawaii. But years later this was proven false when Takeo Yoshikawa, Tokyo's official spy at the Hawaiian consulate, went public with his story.

The Japanese said that the Hawaiian consulate never sent Tokyo any information on the Pearl Harbor fleet. But this tale was later debunked.

The Japanese said that no Kido Butai documents survived the war. But this turned out to be another falsehood.

Some members of the task force said the weather was calm and clear for the entire trip. But at least one other KB member refuted this, and we know from weather reports that there was severe storm activity in the North Pacific for several days shortly before the attack.

And all this is not to mention that we have hard evidence that the task force broke radio silence. For example, we know that one of the submarines assigned to the Kido Butai sent a radio message advising that there were no American warships at the Lahaina anchorage. At the time Lahaina was an alternative anchorage to Pearl Harbor. We know that the Japanese had hoped that some ships would be at Lahaina; they believed that the anchorage was so deep that sunken ships would be unrecoverable.

Plus, there is a mass of credible anecdotal evidence that American, British, and Dutch intelligence units intercepted messages from or about the task force and were aware of its location.

I've discussed and documented other evidence against radio silence in previous replies.

If as you say there is hard evidence then kindly present it, no more anecdotes or claims; just the evidence to substantiate the ones you have already made.
 
(2) that in the preceding three days FDR had declared that a state of war existed between America and Germany even if Congress declined to declare war and even if Germany did not declare war on America, and
Citation required. From a source other than your lunatic authors.
(3) that the Roosevelt administration and its allies in Congress and the press were spreading baseless "reports" that German planes and pilots had taken part in the Pearl Harbor attack (they also claimed that German planes and pilots helped the Japanese attack the Philippines).
Citation required. From a source other than your lunatic authors.
 
Regarding the argument that FDR and Churchill didn't trust the German resistance because "they had been fighting us," well, gosh, they didn't have much choice. Most of them were military officers who risked execution if they refused to fight. The point is that they didn't want to fight us and wanted to get rid of the guy who was making them fight us.

Ummm, no. Most of the officers involved were not upset they were in a war, they were upset that the war was going badly for Germany and felt that without Hitler's "help" they could either do much better and win, or have a chance at something other than unconditional surrender.

None of the conspirators that tried anything after about 1938 were democrats in any way, shape or form.

The fact that FDR prevented Japan from launching an invasion of the Soviet Union is too well documented to warrant debate. Scholars such as George Victor and Percy Greaves have documented FDR's disastrous policy in detail. Many other scholars have--sometimes unintentionally--provided ample documentation of this fact as well.

So well documented as to not warrant debate? No, sorry (well, not really) you do not get a pass. Actual documents, or analyses with some way of confirming them.

FDR began to really put the screws to Japan and sabotaged the Japanese moderates when he learned from intercepts that Japan was considering going to war against the Soviet Union.

You need to account for the fact that the first of the Soviet-Japanese border wars started in 1932, BEFORE Rooseveldt took office. The big series of battles that led to the signing of the Non Agression Pact took place in August 1939.

The US embargoes didn't start until after the Japanese had switched their effort to Southern Asia, as evidenced by the attacks on Indo China in 1940.

So, I ask again, when did he compel Japan to not invade a country they were already at war with, and switch the main effort of their war 180 degrees? And to include a massive attack on his own country and its protectorates, so that he could get Germany to declare war on the US?

Historians of all stripes have noted that the massive reinforcements that Stalin was able to bring in from eastern Russia were the key factor in halting the German advance. And why was he able to pull so many troops from his eastern flank? Because the Japanese were focusing their war effort against America and the British. This would not have happened if FDR had accepted Japan's very reasonable peace offers.

"Let us do what we want, keep selling us the materiel we need to attack your allies, while you also sell to them and we'll just take your overseas protectorates off your hands?"

The mafia negotiator starts with a more reasonable position.

May I say that I am glad you don't have any more influence on foreign policy than any other voter.
 
Even if FDR had stopped Japan attacking Russia, why would that be a bad thing? Why would he have wanted to help the Germans win the war?
 
Utter and complete nonsense. You have two conspiracy nuts who wrote books without any requirement to back up their claims with facts.

Particulary since when Japan did tangle with Russia at Khalkin Gol/Nomohan in 1939, the Japanese got their butts kicked...badly. Even the Japanese Army "Strike North" faction has their enthusiasm for a full scale attack on Russia considerably quelled by that.
Only way that would have happened is if Moscow has fallen to the Germans and The Soviet regime seemed near total collapse.
 
Last edited:
Far far more resources were available to the Japanese to the south especially oil in the Dutch East Indies

It was a no brainer
 
Particulary since when Japan did tangle with Russia at Khalkin Gol/Nomohan in 1939, the Japanese got their butts kicked...badly. Even the Japanese Army "Strike North" faction has their enthusiasm for a full scale attack on Russia considerably quelled by that.
Only way that would have happened is if Moscow has fallen to the Germans and The Soviet regime seemed near total collapse.

True. Hokushin changed to nanshin abruptly, so fast that the IJN had trouble accommodating the IJA's amphibious requirements.
 
Here's an alternative question for the many smart military historians here.

What would have happened if the Japanese hadn't attacked the US and instead concentrated their endeavours on destroying the British and Dutch?

What would have been the US position or action in response?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom