Merged Pearl Harbor: "Revisionists" vs. "Traditionalists"

Back to the radio silence myth again. The main "evidence" for the claim of radio silence is Japanese testimony. But the Japanese lied about all kinds of things after the war.

The Japanese solemnly swore that they had no spies on Hawaii. But years later this was proven false when Takeo Yoshikawa, Tokyo's official spy at the Hawaiian consulate, went public with his story.

The Japanese said that the Hawaiian consulate never sent Tokyo any information on the Pearl Harbor fleet. But this tale was later debunked.

The Japanese said that no Kido Butai documents survived the war. But this turned out to be another falsehood.

Some members of the task force said the weather was calm and clear for the entire trip. But at least one other KB member refuted this, and we know from weather reports that there was severe storm activity in the North Pacific for several days shortly before the attack.

And all this is not to mention that we have hard evidence that the task force broke radio silence. For example, we know that one of the submarines assigned to the Kido Butai sent a radio message advising that there were no American warships at the Lahaina anchorage. At the time Lahaina was an alternative anchorage to Pearl Harbor. We know that the Japanese had hoped that some ships would be at Lahaina; they believed that the anchorage was so deep that sunken ships would be unrecoverable.

Plus, there is a mass of credible anecdotal evidence that American, British, and Dutch intelligence units intercepted messages from or about the task force and were aware of its location.

I've discussed and documented other evidence against radio silence in previous replies.
 
Plus, there is a mass of credible anecdotal evidence that American, British, and Dutch intelligence units intercepted messages from or about the task force and were aware of its location.

Anecdotal is not good enough. Got anything first hand?
 
I liked his defense of Grogan being basically "well, he was using really vague and imprecise terms when describing the direction he heard the signals from, which is why it's obvious he knew the precise location and bearing of Kido Butai".
 
What in my comments could possibly lead you to such an erroneous conclusion?

The part where you want the Allies to have fought a victorious Nazi Germany without the aid of the country that did the vast majority of the actual fighting against Hitler.
 
Bob, I've highlighted a sentence where you've made a rather interesting assertion.

Now, I'd like to draw your attention to the Soviet-Japanese battles in Manchuria and Mongolia that took place between 1932 and 1945. The highlight of this rather unsettled state of affairs was probably the 1939 Battles of Khalkin Gol involving large concentrations of troops (over a corps on both sides) and the overwhelming Soviet success that cemented the reputation of Gregory Zhukov. The results of these battles in the 1930s was to lead to a Soviet-Japanese Non Agression Pact (signed April 13, 1941) that was largely kept (at least until after the defeat of Germany in 1945), and the shift of focus from the resource rich Siberia to the south of Asia and the Pacific Islands, due to the loss of face suffered by the Army, and the inevitable conflict with the US.

Your little assertion there seems to be, shall we say a little at odds with the known historical facts - not that you've let that stop you before.

My assertion is not at all at odds with known historical facts. I did not say that Japan and Russia did not fight. I said that FDR prevented Japan from launching an invasion of the Soviet Union. Dr. George Victor discusses this at length in The Pearl Harbor Myth. Percy Greaves discussed it in Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fruits of Infamy.

If the Japanese had launched a full-scale invasion of Russia in 1941, the Soviets almost certainly would have collapsed.

Furthermore, which assassination attempt on Hitler are you referring to? There were around 38 of them, the July 20, 1944 one simply being the most famous. As for why we didn't accept the conspirators' word that they would stop all actions against the Western Allies and work with us against the USSR - they'd been fighting us at that time for 5 years (3 for you Americans) and frankly, trust was not there.

I find this argument incredibly simplistic and naive. The opposition would have been a huge improvement over Hitler, but FDR and Churchill rejected all their entreaties.
 

Gosh, really?! What in the world did you expect? In the preceding three days, FDR had declared that a state of war existed between America and Germany and that this would remain even if Germany did not declare war on America and even if Congress did not declare war on Germany. FDR had also claimed that Germany was the puppet master behind the Pearl Harbor attack and that Japan had bombed us at the urging of Germany, both of which claims were false. The Germans also saw American newspapers flooded with false reports of German planes and pilots taking part in the Pearl Harbor attack. So it's hardly surprising that Germany declared war on us.

This does not negate the fact that prior to Pearl Harbor Hitler tried to avoid war with the U.S. Even an evil maniac like Hitler had enough sense to know that war with America was the last thing he wanted. But when he saw how FDR and his interventionist allies were blaming Pearl Harbor on Germany and were saying that a state of war existed between the two nations, he decided that Germany might as well declare war on America. It was a dumb move, but an understandable one.
 
In the preceding three days, FDR had declared that a state of war existed between America and Germany and that this would remain even if Germany did not declare war on America and even if Congress did not declare war on Germany.

Which had nothing to do with Pearl Harbor, and everything to do with Germany doing things like sinking US Navy destroyers in the Atlantic.
 
And why would the Japanese have done such a thing?

And why would they expect any more success than they had had 2 years earlier?

Indeed it is quite likely that the Soviets would have handed the Japanese their heads on a plate and still managed to transfer a sizeable number of divisions West in time to counter the German push onto Moscow.

They didn't start transferring them until the end of September, after all.
 
My assertion is not at all at odds with known historical facts. I did not say that Japan and Russia did not fight. I said that FDR prevented Japan from launching an invasion of the Soviet Union. Dr. George Victor discusses this at length in The Pearl Harbor Myth. Percy Greaves discussed it in Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fruits of Infamy.
Japan tried to attack the Soviets and got burned badly. They then decided to try and snatch up the wounded countries' colonies on the cheap. That failed two. FDR didn't thwart a Japanese invasion of Japan, no matter what those idiots Victor and Greaves claim.
If the Japanese had launched a full-scale invasion of Russia in 1941, the Soviets almost certainly would have collapsed.
The Japanese could defeat the Chinese, who were fighting a civil war. Zuhkov's Siberians would have mauled the Japanese army AGAIN if they they tried.
 
This does not negate the fact that prior to Pearl Harbor Hitler tried to avoid war with the U.S. Even an evil maniac like Hitler had enough sense to know that war with America was the last thing he wanted.

Hitler never considered the US much of a threat. The prospect of the US entering the war was brought up in early strategy meetings on the eve of the war, and the dangers were quickly dismissed. America was considered to be too far away and its people too soft to offer any threat.
 
Hitler never considered the US much of a threat. The prospect of the US entering the war was brought up in early strategy meetings on the eve of the war, and the dangers were quickly dismissed. America was considered to be too far away and its people too soft to offer any threat.

The "mongrelized" Americans would be no match for the Aryan supermen. I guess he'd never seen a Pekingese in a fight with a junkyard dog.
 
Back to the radio silence myth again. The main "evidence" for the claim of radio silence is Japanese testimony. But the Japanese lied about all kinds of things after the war.

The Japanese solemnly swore that they had no spies on Hawaii. But years later this was proven false when Takeo Yoshikawa, Tokyo's official spy at the Hawaiian consulate, went public with his story.

The Japanese said that the Hawaiian consulate never sent Tokyo any information on the Pearl Harbor fleet. But this tale was later debunked.

The Japanese said that no Kido Butai documents survived the war. But this turned out to be another falsehood.


Granting for the sake of argument that all of the above are substantially correct (which I doubt), the problem is that these are all issues of which those who were actually part of the strike force could not have had first-hand knowledge. The question of whether any of the ships transmitted during the transit to Hawaii, however, is an issue of which many of them did have first-hand knowledge. Therefore, your insinuation that the above somehow establishes the Japanese participants as unreliable liars is specious, and amounts to nothing more than a lame attempt to poison the well and spread FUD.

Some members of the task force said the weather was calm and clear for the entire trip. But at least one other KB member refuted this, and we know from weather reports that there was severe storm activity in the North Pacific for several days shortly before the attack.


Please provide sources for the assertion that any Japanese with first-hand knowledge claimed the weather was calm and clear during the transit to Hawaii. I'm frankly extremely skeptical of this claim, because the rough weather during the crossing is well documented.

And all this is not to mention that we have hard evidence that the task force broke radio silence. For example, we know that one of the submarines assigned to the Kido Butai sent a radio message advising that there were no American warships at the Lahaina anchorage.


No. "The submarines assigned to the Kido Butai" were I-19, I-21, and I-23. (See Dull, Paul S., A Battle History of the Imperial Japanese Navy, p. 11) The submarine that transmitted the report was I-72, one of many Japanese submarines supporting the operation. Fail.

Plus, there is a mass of credible anecdotal evidence that American, British, and Dutch intelligence units intercepted messages from or about the task force and were aware of its location.


By "credible" you obviously mean "supports my conspiracy theory". :rolleyes: You continue to ignore the fact that the Japanese engaged in a deliberate campaign of radio deception, so of course many Allied intelligence units thought they were aware of the strike force's location. Further, after a traumatic historical event such as Pearl Harbor, people tend to see their past experiences as somehow connected to that event. For example, look at how many people claimed to have seen Lee Harvey Oswald at various places (many at the same time) in the fall of 1963. This is simple human nature. Therefore your "anecdotal evidence" cannot be accepted without substantial corroboration.

I've discussed and documented other evidence against radio silence in previous replies.


No. You've presented no hard evidence that the strike force transmitted. The fact that certain individuals believed they monitored such transmissions does not constitute hard evidence, particularly in view of the aforementioned Japanese radio-deception efforts. As with most conspiracy theorists, you have difficulty distinguishing between evidence, and your interpretation of the evidence.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom