Merged Pearl Harbor: "Revisionists" vs. "Traditionalists"

Haven't checked out this thread in a couple weeks. Has bobtaftfan provided any evidence that Kido Butai transmitted yet?
 
Hmmm the fleet didn't transmit and their operators who were left behind specifically to spoof western 'listeners'. They did that by sending out operational messages to make people think the fleet was still in Japanese waters....hmmmmm

Bob just cannot seem to grasp this point.

Bob are you hard of thinking?
 
Here, I'll put something up. :)

The actual purpose is likely that by presenting the theory to a bunch of skeptics and "convincing" them that the theory has validity would be a VICTORY, of immense satisfaction, for the proposer. Even though the proposer would almost certainly never get any traction for the theory with anybody else, he would be able to think and, as the case may be, claim that he "convinced" a bunch of skeptics. It is validation that is sought even if it really makes no difference.

Another aspect would be that if the proposer subscribed to a FDR sabotaged the US response to the attack then having the US get actual warning (even if only limited as noted above) would give the proposer the satisfaction that he got to first base. Before he waited at the plate for the pitch but the pitch never came because there was no game going on, so poking an apparent hole in the conventional wisdom is tatamount to getting someone to pitch the ball so he can hit it.

This would be a similar result if:

The IJN broadcast the plans on the air in the Fleet main cryptographic system (JN-25) and the US had so thoroughly broken the code that it could read the plan and its details ala Midway.

The Japanese had transmitted the attack plans in Purple since the US monitored the diplomatic communications and had actually broken Purple.

Since each "alternate" theory requires certain things to happen, if the case cannot be made in any convincing manner, due to overwhelming counter evidence of how it all happened, the theorist can't get to first base because there is no ball to hit.

One can always infer whatever one likes but proving the case is much more difficult and quite unlikely.
 
Allow me to anticipate this somewhat.

The IJN broadcast the plans on the air in the Fleet main cryptographic system (JN-25) and the US had so thoroughly broken the code that it could read the plan and its details ala Midway.
That would be quite a feat as the plans were over 80 pages long and included some very convoluted tables. To send this telegraphically (radio comms used Morse code equivalent then for coded traffic) would be like typing out an 80+ page document AND including the instructions on how to format the tables.
The Japanese had transmitted the attack plans in Purple since the US monitored the diplomatic communications and had actually broken Purple.
Sadly the IJGHQ folks weren't idiots, so they didn't entrust strategic information to people who talked for a living (i.e., the Gaimudaijin (Foreign Office) staff.)
 
Another item of evidence that points to conspiracy in the Pearl Harbor case is the little-known but easily verifiable fact that immediately after the bombing the Roosevelt administration and its interventionist allies in Congress and the press began spreading false "reports" that German planes and pilots had participated in the attack. As if by prior arrangement, these erroneous, inflammatory reports were quickly plastered in newspapers and radio broadcasts across the country. Dr. Richard Hill discusses this fascinating and revealing episode in his book Hitler Attacks Pearl Harbor: Why the United States Declared War on Germany (Lynne Rienner Publishers, 2003). You can read most of the book online here:

http://books.google.com/books/about/Hitler_Attacks_Pearl_Harbor.html?id=61WMf6XRVT8C

FDR himself got into the act, repeating some of the reports and then saying that his administration was seeking to confirm them. Of course, FDR already knew from Japanese and German intercepts that the reports were absurd. And, as Dr. Hill notes, when German and Japanese archives were available after the war, these reports were proven to be utterly erroneous.

FDR's statements relating to this issue are revealing and provide another indication of a plot. Not only did FDR contribute to the myth that Germans helped bomb Pearl Harbor, but he immediately declared (1) that Hitler had urged Japan to bomb Pearl Harbor, (2) that Germany was the driving force behind the attack, and (3) that therefore the U.S. was in a state of war with Germany even if Congress did not declare war on Germany and even if Germany did not declare war on the U.S. This clearly suggests a prior intent to use Pearl Harbor as an excuse to enter the war in Europe.

In point of fact, as Dr. Hill discusses, not only did Germany not urge Japan to attack Pearl Harbor, but Hitler was surprised when he learned of the attack. Hitler had been trying to avoid war with America, since he wanted to focus on defeating the Soviet Union, and since--evil maniac though he was--even he knew enough history to know that America's entry into WWI had sealed Germany's fate (if anything, Hitler had hoped that Japan would attack the Soviet Union).

Indeed, in spite of FDR's brazen provocations in the Atlantic, Hitler had issued strict orders to the German Navy not to fire on American ships (and there were only a handful of violations of those orders, and in each case the Germans fired only in response to hostile actions). German diplomats in America were stunned by the propaganda about German culpability and German participation in the attack, and of course they quickly relayed this propaganda to an equally stunned Berlin.

I should add that when the reports of German participation in the Pearl Harbor attack began to appear, a few genuine journalists did try to investigate them and quickly realized they were nonsense, but those journalists were far outnumbered by journalists who took the reports and ran with them.

One of the tragedies of FDR's handling of WWII is that we missed a golden opportunity to rid Russia of Stalin and his henchmen and to prevent Soviet domination of Eastern Europe. Hitler and Stalin were both sick, evil men. We should have let them fight it out before even considering entering the European theater. As evil as Hitler was, Stalin was arguably worse. If FDR had not prevented Japan from attacking Russia, the Soviets probably would have collapsed in the face of a two-front assault by Germany and Japan. With Stalin and his gang of thugs deposed, we could have turned our attention to getting rid of Hitler. We could have agreed to work with and support those Germans who wanted to assassinate Hitler, as opposed to FDR and Churchill's tragic blunder of rejecting their entreaties.
 
Last edited:
Another item of evidence that points to conspiracy in the Pearl Harbor case is the little-known but easily verifiable fact that immediately after the bombing the Roosevelt administration and its interventionist allies in Congress and the press began spreading false "reports" that German planes and pilots had participated in the attack. As if by prior arrangement, these erroneous, inflammatory reports were quickly plastered in newspapers and radio broadcasts across the country. Dr. Richard Hill discusses this fascinating and revealing episode in his book Hitler Attacks Pearl Harbor: Why the United States Declared War on Germany (Lynne Rienner Publishers, 2003). You can read most of the book online here:

http://books.google.com/books/about/Hitler_Attacks_Pearl_Harbor.html?id=61WMf6XRVT8C

FDR himself got into the act, repeating some of the reports and then saying that his administration was seeking to confirm them. Of course, FDR already knew from Japanese and German intercepts that the reports were absurd. And, as Dr. Hill notes, when German and Japanese archives were available after the war, these reports were proven to be utterly erroneous.

FDR's statements relating to this issue are revealing and provide another indication of a plot. Not only did FDR contribute to the myth that Germans helped bomb Pearl Harbor, but he immediately declared (1) that Hitler had urged Japan to bomb Pearl Harbor, (2) that Germany was the driving force behind the attack, and (3) that therefore the U.S. was in a state of war with Germany even if Congress did not declare war on Germany and even if Germany did not declare war on the U.S. This clearly suggests a prior intent to use Pearl Harbor as an excuse to enter the war in Europe.

In point of fact, as Dr. Hill discusses, not only did Germany not urge Japan to attack Pearl Harbor, but Hitler was surprised when he learned of the attack. Hitler had been trying to avoid war with America, since he wanted to focus on defeating the Soviet Union, and since--evil maniac though he was--even he knew enough history to know that America's entry into WWI had sealed Germany's fate (if anything, Hitler had hoped that Japan would attack the Soviet Union).

Indeed, in spite of FDR's brazen provocations in the Atlantic, Hitler had issued strict orders to the German Navy not to fire on American ships (and there were only a handful of violations of those orders, and in each case the Germans fired only in response to hostile actions). German diplomats in America were stunned by the propaganda about German culpability and German participation in the attack, and of course they quickly relayed this propaganda to an equally stunned Berlin.

I should add that when the reports of German participation in the Pearl Harbor attack began to appear, a few genuine journalists did try to investigate them and quickly realized they were nonsense, but those journalists were far outnumbered by journalists who took the reports and ran with them.

One of the tragedies of FDR's handling of WWII is that we missed a golden opportunity to rid Russia of Stalin and his henchmen and to prevent Soviet domination of Eastern Europe. Hitler and Stalin were both sick, evil men. We should have let them fight it out before even considering entering the European theater. As evil as Hitler was, Stalin was arguably worse. If FDR had not prevented Japan from attacking Russia, the Soviets probably would have collapsed in the face of a two-front assault by Germany and Japan. With Stalin and his gang of thugs deposed, we could have turned our attention to getting rid of Hitler. We could have agreed to work with and support those Germans who wanted to assassinate Hitler, as opposed to FDR and Churchill's tragic blunder of rejecting their entreaties.

Oh. I see. Sorry I decided to visit this thread again. When asked what evidence you had that Kido Butai transmitted, your answer is this little conjectural diatribe? You make this thread boring.

Okay, see you folks in another few weeks.
 
So,wait until Hitler and Japan conquer Russia and link up. That would put the USA and GB in a better position to attack a Germany now able to concentrate all it's efforts in peace and have the raw materials and resources of all Europe and Asia at it's command?

Good plan.
 
So,wait until Hitler and Japan conquer Russia and link up. That would put the USA and GB in a better position to attack a Germany now able to concentrate all it's efforts in peace and have the raw materials and resources of all Europe and Asia at it's command?

Good plan.

He's seems ignorant of the fact that the Russians did the bulk of the fighting against Germany.
 
So the proof or evidence of Kudo Batai transmitting is.... a book so obscure it has had zero effect on the historical record and isn't even about the Japanese Fleet.

....yeah...
 
One of the tragedies of FDR's handling of WWII is that we missed a golden opportunity to rid Russia of Stalin and his henchmen and to prevent Soviet domination of Eastern Europe. Hitler and Stalin were both sick, evil men. We should have let them fight it out before even considering entering the European theater. As evil as Hitler was, Stalin was arguably worse. If FDR had not prevented Japan from attacking Russia, the Soviets probably would have collapsed in the face of a two-front assault by Germany and Japan. With Stalin and his gang of thugs deposed, we could have turned our attention to getting rid of Hitler. We could have agreed to work with and support those Germans who wanted to assassinate Hitler, as opposed to FDR and Churchill's tragic blunder of rejecting their entreaties.

Bob, I've highlighted a sentence where you've made a rather interesting assertion.

Now, I'd like to draw your attention to the Soviet-Japanese battles in Manchuria and Mongolia that took place between 1932 and 1945. The highlight of this rather unsettled state of affairs was probably the 1939 Battles of Khalkin Gol involving large concentrations of troops (over a corps on both sides) and the overwhelming Soviet success that cemented the reputation of Gregory Zhukov. The results of these battles in the 1930s was to lead to a Soviet-Japanese Non Agression Pact (signed April 13, 1941) that was largely kept (at least until after the defeat of Germany in 1945), and the shift of focus from the resource rich Siberia to the south of Asia and the Pacific Islands, due to the loss of face suffered by the Army, and the inevitable conflict with the US.

Your little assertion there seems to be, shall we say a little at odds with the known historical facts - not that you've let that stop you before.

Furthermore, which assassination attempt on Hitler are you referring to? There were around 38 of them, the July 20, 1944 one simply being the most famous. As for why we didn't accept the conspirators' word that they would stop all actions against the Western Allies and work with us against the USSR - they'd been fighting us at that time for 5 years (3 for you Americans) and frankly, trust was not there.
 
Does rather sound like something a Bircher would say, doesn't it?

Yes it has that particular stench to it but the good news is that Bob has abandon his previous silly conjecture that the fleet transmitted

Thanks for the concession
 
Yes it has that particular stench to it but the good news is that Bob has abandon his previous silly conjecture that the fleet transmitted

Thanks for the concession

Now we just need a way to debunk reports that they were spotted in one after the other of a string to Starbucks as they proceeded east across the Pacific. I don't really have a counter for that one. :o
 
Hitler had been trying to avoid war with America, since he wanted to focus on defeating the Soviet Union, and since--evil maniac though he was--even he knew enough history to know that America's entry into WWI had sealed Germany's fate (if anything, Hitler had hoped that Japan would attack the Soviet Union).

Indeed, in spite of FDR's brazen provocations in the Atlantic, Hitler had issued strict orders to the German Navy not to fire on American ships (and there were only a handful of violations of those orders, and in each case the Germans fired only in response to hostile actions). German diplomats in America were stunned by the propaganda about German culpability and German participation in the attack, and of course they quickly relayed this propaganda to an equally stunned Berlin.

...so Hitler then promptly declared war on the US four days after the attack on Pearl Harbor, then railed against Roosevelt and the US in a speech given the Reichstag that same day?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom