Merged Pearl Harbor: "Revisionists" vs. "Traditionalists"

On the IndoChina thing: They'd offered to pull their troops out if we resumed selling oil to Japan. We then read a follow-up message that said (roughly) "Don't mention it may take us 30 years to withdraw all the troops." In other words, they were playing games.

The Final Communication message was viewed as preliminary to a formal breaking off of talkings prior to a full break in diplomatic relations which would then be followed by a declaration of war. That's what the forms required in civilized society.

The full note can be seen here: http://ww2db.com/doc.php?q=80

Oral Response by Secretary of State Hull to Ambassador Nomura

I must say that in all my conversations with you [the Japanese Ambassador] during the last nine months I have never uttered one word of untruth. This is borne out absolutely by the record. In all my 50 years of public service I have never seen a document that was more crowded with infamous falsehoods and distortions - infamous falsehoods and distortions on a scale so huge that I never imagined until today that any Government on this planet was capable of uttering them.
 
John Toland is a sad case. A good Historian who got seduced to the Dark Side late in his career.

The only think I know about Toland is he was one of the first to write an objective biography of Hitler. Did you have something else in mind?
 
For that matter, why waste time waiting for a Japanese attack all?
It's the Germans you want to be at war with, so why not try to set them up instead? That the attack led to war with Germany was hardly a foregone conclusion, so why take the chance Hitler might abandon his allies and not declare war on the US?

Isn’t that what Roosevelt initially wanted to do, create an incident like the Maine or Lusitania to rally the nation to go war with Hitler? That was the reason he ordered US ships to fire upon German ships.
 
The Back-Door-To-War theory falters badly when we remember that we didn't declare war on Germany until after the Germans had declared war on us.

However the US was waging war against Germany thru provocative actions and Lend Lease.
 
However the US was waging war against Germany thru provocative actions and Lend Lease.

Yep, but you'll notice there was a continent and a large chunk of ocean between those activities and Pearl Harbor?

FDR made no bones about wanting to get into the war against the Nasties. His policy of "short of war" was a step along the path. And the US public supported him, they knew we'd have to kill Hitler and his cronies before peace would return to Europe. And they were even more certain that Japan would have to be dealt with as well.

There was no need for a "back door to war", especially not one so stupidly and clumsily engineered as the CTers claim.
 
Yep, but you'll notice there was a continent and a large chunk of ocean between those activities and Pearl Harbor?

FDR made no bones about wanting to get into the war against the Nasties. His policy of "short of war" was a step along the path. And the US public supported him, they knew we'd have to kill Hitler and his cronies before peace would return to Europe. And they were even more certain that Japan would have to be dealt with as well.

There was no need for a "back door to war", especially not one so stupidly and clumsily engineered as the CTers claim.

There was no majority public support for the US going to war against Hitler except for the Jews, communists, and British agents. The majority of Americans were isolationists and it took a Pearl Harbor to change this.
Here is the speech by Lindbergh identifying those who were pushing for war.
http://en.metapedia.org/wiki/Charles_Lindbergh's_Des_Moines,_Iowa_speech
 
There was no majority public support for the US going to war against Hitler except for the Jews, communists, and British agents. The majority of Americans were isolationists and it took a Pearl Harbor to change this.
Here is the speech by Lindbergh identifying those who were pushing for war.
http://en.metapedia.org/wiki/Charles_Lindbergh's_Des_Moines,_Iowa_speech

Boy, you're just all about the Jews, aren't you. Gawdzilla disabused me of the "majority isolationist" notion upthread, if you'd bothered to read it.

ETA: Here's the link that he gave me: http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=184152
 
There was no majority public support for the US going to war against Hitler except for the Jews, communists, and British agents. The majority of Americans were isolationists and it took a Pearl Harbor to change this.
Here is the speech by Lindbergh identifying those who were pushing for war.
http://en.metapedia.org/wiki/Charles_Lindbergh's_Des_Moines,_Iowa_speech

And yet, if you take a look at this poll at page 20, it would appear that the US recognized that there was a threat to the US and that isolationism wouldn't allow them to keep their freedoms. Mr. Lindbergh would seem to have been out of touch with the attitudes of the American people, either that or the majority of Americans were "Jews, communists, and British agents."
 
However the US was waging war against Germany thru provocative actions and Lend Lease.

Quite true, and Hitler was a big enough sucker to fall for it and declare war but no one ever said he was smart.
 
Isn’t that what Roosevelt initially wanted to do, create an incident like the Maine or Lusitania to rally the nation to go war with Hitler? That was the reason he ordered US ships to fire upon German ships.

And this is why the Pearl Harbour conspiracy is so stupid; we know full well that Roosevelt was working to get the USA into the war against the monstrosity that was Nazi Germany and how he was going about it. In the end Hitler was dumb enough to make it easy for him.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom