Merged Pearl Harbor: "Revisionists" vs. "Traditionalists"

The problem here seems to be you and Gawdzilla think Isolationism was a fringe movement and most Americans were in the warmongering camp of Roosevelt. After experiencing World War I there was little will for American involvement into another war.

See, that shows that you have no idea what was going on in America. You directly contradict the vast body of evidence without blinking. It puts your credibility at risk.
 
... Isolationism was a fringe movement.../QUOTE]

When asked if they would vote for a Presidential candidate put forward by the America First Movement 17% of people polled said "yes". Public Opinion Quarterly, 2nd Quarter, 1941, stated that only one in 10 Americas could identify a potential candidate for the America First Movement's presidential candidacy.
 
See, that shows that you have no idea what was going on in America. You directly contradict the vast body of evidence without blinking. It puts your credibility at risk.

If you look at the public support for war, you will find mostly Jews and communists at those rallies. The America First Committee had a cross section of America which also included Socialists.

Another important group which was part of America First was the Mother’s Movement.
http://en.metapedia.org/wiki/Mothers'_Movement
 
If you look at the public support for war, you will find mostly Jews and communists at those rallies. The America First Committee had a cross section of America which also included Socialists.

Another important group which was part of America First was the Mother’s Movement.
http://en.metapedia.org/wiki/Mothers'_Movement

Yada, yada, yada. The German-American Bund was very interested in supporting the non-interventionists, but Hitler told them to shut up. He was concerned that the obvious reason for that support would be obvious.
 
The Bund was in the background during the debate. Father Coughlin and the Christian Front had a bit more influence.
http://en.metapedia.org/wiki/Christian_Front

You should stop bothering to post links to metapedia, you're just killing pixels for no reason. And yes, the Bund was in the background on orders from that murderous bastard in Berlin.
 
I have followed this thread from the beginning, and it has been interesting and educational. Thanks to Gawdzilla (and others) who have done the research and can point us to reasonable and reliable sources. As opposed to the simple credulity and argument from ignorance of the OP.

Now with the entrance of a seeming fascist sympathiser (quoting metapedia, no less) there looks to be a whole new entertainment factor coming into play.

Thanks, all!
 
The problem here seems to be you and Gawdzilla think Isolationism was a fringe movement and most Americans were in the warmongering camp of Roosevelt. After experiencing World War I there was little will for American involvement into another war.

No the problem is you didn't suggest that Isolationism was a prominent movement, which it obviously was and no one has denied, You argued:

Their focus was preventing a war with the European powers; many were sympathetic with NS Germany and wanted to see Hitler victorious.

And then failed it to back your claim up with anything but metapedia links; that's the problem.
 
If you look at the public support for war, you will find mostly Jews and communists at those rallies. The America First Committee had a cross section of America which also included Socialists.

Still more claims, still no evidence.
 
With regard to what? The "isolationist movement" did not have a coherent policy because they had very many different views as to what should be done.

Some wanted to simply stay out of the European War.
Some wanted to keep the European War out of the Western Hemisphere.
Some wanted to keep the European War out of North America.
Some wanted to keep the European War out of the United States.
Some wanted to express no violence in any fashion, regardless of the provocation.

Wayne Cole, a veteran of the America First Movement, has written a couple of books on this, including one that is a collection of documents from the AFM's archives showing internal debate on the matter of non-intervention.

And, just for fun, the isolationists insisted that we not aid the Japanese in their aggression in China, and demanded that the supply of aviation gasoline to Japan be stopped. This is the embargo that CTers frequently say was FDR's method of provoking Japan. The State Department warned against the embargo for that very reason, but the extension of the draftee's time on active duty was up for a vote and FDR had to make a compromise. So you can say with some confidence that the isolationists were instrumental in Japan's decision to go to war with the US.

That's the kind of policies the isolationists had pre-Pearl Harbor.
Thanks G, I did not know that the isolationists were a driving force behind the embargo! Talk about irony. It makes the FDR LIHOP scenario sound even more ridiculous, if that's possible.
 
Thanks G, I did not know that the isolationists were a driving force behind the embargo! Talk about irony. It makes the FDR LIHOP scenario sound even more ridiculous, if that's possible.

They were requiring it for the draft extension to pass. Other people were also demanding the embargo. FDR issued an executive order stating that the US military's needs came first, then US civilian needs, then foreign countries, by order of their request for fuel. By "happenstance" Great Britain's orders were dated a few weeks ahead of Japan's. ;)
 
They were requiring it for the draft extension to pass. Other people were also demanding the embargo. FDR issued an executive order stating that the US military's needs came first, then US civilian needs, then foreign countries, by order of their request for fuel. By "happenstance" Great Britain's orders were dated a few weeks ahead of Japan's. ;)


I've also read that a) the US really was going to have to stop selling Japan oil because gearing up the military really was taking up a lot more fuel, and b) any embargo was probably moot anyway because Japan was running out of foreign exchange with which to buy oil and strategic materials.
 
I've also read that a) the US really was going to have to stop selling Japan oil because gearing up the military really was taking up a lot more fuel, and b) any embargo was probably moot anyway because Japan was running out of foreign exchange with which to buy oil and strategic materials.

Largely, yes, but a more important consideration for me was that we were supplying fuel to a potential enemy. That's just daft. The fact that the FDR administration considered continuing to sell the fuel preferable to not selling it points up nicely how serious they considered the situation and how much they were doing to avoid a war in the Pacific.
 
I was kidding (obviously) but that's interesting. Did they transmit "Tora, Tora, Tora" or was it a longer message giving details??

They didn't pass the details along for a while, but "Tora, tora, tora" was relayed immediately. They didn't want to make too long a transmission because it would give the US more time to locate them. We still got a bearing of 357 degrees from aircraft calling back to the carriers with reports, but the reciprocal of 177 was considered more likely given the suspected IJN carrier group south of T. H.
 
The problem here seems to be you and Gawdzilla think Isolationism was a fringe movement and most Americans were in the warmongering camp of Roosevelt. After experiencing World War I there was little will for American involvement into another war.

There was only one warmonger back then and he was a Charlie Chaplin lookalike.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom