Boy, you're just all about the Jews, aren't you. Gawdzilla disabused me of the "majority isolationist" notion upthread, if you'd bothered to read it.
ETA: Here's the link that he gave me: http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=184152
And I thought this was a skeptic’s forum
So Gallop is the new Oracle. Thanks for explaining that. Over 60% of the public wanted war with Germany.
And I thought this was a skeptic’s forum.
It is a skeptics forum, just as long as your definition of a skeptic isn't "a person who doubts anything that doesn't fit their preconceived world view, biases, prejudices, or ideology; regardless of what the preponderance of the evidence indicates".So Gallop is the new Oracle. Thanks for explaining that. Over 60% of the public wanted war with Germany.
And I thought this was a skeptic’s forum.
Go read the Congressional Record, all of it, from 1939 through 1942. Read the editorial pages for the Chicago Tribune, New York Times, the LA papers. Read the news stories. Do some actual research and see what you come up with.
The Chicago Tribune was an isolationist paper run by Robert McCormick.
Yep, and that's one of the reasons I added it to my reading list. I spent hundreds of hours in the Undergrad Library at Purdue and in the GovDocs stacks at the Liberal Arts and Humanities Library going over this stuff. I went to newspaper morgues in small towns in New Mexico to get my eyeballs on what they were thinking.
In you expert opinion what was the strength of the isolationist movement in the US 1940-1941?
With regard to what? The "isolationist movement" did not have a coherent policy because they had very many different views as to what should be done.
Some wanted to simply stay out of the European War.
Some wanted to keep the European War out of the Western Hemisphere.
Some wanted to keep the European War out of North America.
Some wanted to keep the European War out of the United States.
Some wanted to express no violence in any fashion, regardless of the provocation.
Wayne Cole, a veteran of the America First Movement, has written a couple of books on this, including one that is a collection of documents from the AFM's archives showing internal debate on the matter of non-intervention.
And, just for fun, the isolationists insisted that we not aid the Japanese in their aggression in China, and demanded that the supply of aviation gasoline to Japan be stopped. This is the embargo that CTers frequently say was FDR's method of provoking Japan. The State Department warned against the embargo for that very reason, but the extension of the draftee's time on active duty was up for a vote and FDR had to make a compromise. So you can say with some confidence that the isolationists were instrumental in Japan's decision to go to war with the US.
That's the kind of policies the isolationists had pre-Pearl Harbor.
From what I have read the isolationists were not really concerned with what Japan was doing in the east and had no fears of a war with Japan. Their focus was preventing a war with the European powers; many were sympathetic with NS Germany and wanted to see Hitler victorious.
From what I have read the isolationists were not really concerned with what Japan was doing in the east and had no fears of a war with Japan. Their focus was preventing a war with the European powers; many were sympathetic with NS Germany and wanted to see Hitler victorious.
And I thought this was a skeptic’s forum.
Then you need to do more reading.
Scribner's Commentator was the leading isolationist journal during that time. From the sampling of the articles listed only two refer to Japan.
http://en.metapedia.org/wiki/Scribner's_Commentator
Astonishing that having posted this:
You offer up your opinion without one reference or source to back it up. Please do as Gawdzilla did in response to your posts and provide the opinion polls, newspaper archives, etc. that support your viewpoint. Oh and original sources please; no cherry picked quotes from metapedia.