erwinl
Illuminator
- Joined
- Sep 5, 2008
- Messages
- 4,079
I believe critical thinking and common sense can lead any open-minded person to discern the basics of the Pearl Harbor plot. Detectives often solve crimes because they refuse to accept the "innocent explanations" offered by suspects. They use critical thinking and common sense to determine that the suspects' stories simply aren't believable, that their stories defy common sense and reason, and that their stories strain credulity well beyond the breaking point.
Take Admiral Stark's "failure" to determine if Kimmel was getting Magic intercepts. Stark and Turner spent a lot of time before the JCC passing the buck on this issue. "I assumed he was getting them." "He told me Kimmel was getting them." Etc., etc., etc. Stark's story is simply ludicrous (as is Turner's, for that matter). One would have to believe that Stark was practically retarded to accept his tale. One would also have to be quite gullible to believe it.
Stark admitted that the question of whether Kimmel was getting Magic messages was a subject of some controversy back in D.C. Well, during the same time when Stark was supposedly seeking to make sure that Kimmel was getting Magic messages, Stark met with Kimmel for hours when Kimmel came to Washington for an official visit and yet "failed" to simply ask him if he was getting Magic intercepts. Gosh, are you kidding me?
We're supposed to believe, gulp and gullible, that it never occurred to Stark to simply ask Kimmel if he was getting Magic intercepts when he had him standing right there in front of him for hours at a time when he was supposedly seeking to determine if Kimmel was getting them! "Gosh, just slipped my mind!" Nobody is that stupid, that clueless, that brainless. Stark didn't ask because he didn't want Kimmel to get Magic messages, especially not the ones that clearly pointed to unusual Japanese interest in Pearl Harbor. He knew full well that Kimmel wasn't getting Magic messages.
Or, take Admiral Stark's failure to "pick up the phone and call Kimmel" on the morning of December 7 after Admiral Wilkinson urged him to do so once the 14-part message, the code-destruction message, and the time-of-delivery message had been received. Kimmel wasn't just responsible for Hawaii, he was the responsible for the entire Pacific Fleet and for a huge area of the Pacific Ocean. It was an obvious no-brainer that he should be notified immediately that war was imminent, and it was Stark's duty and right, as Chief of Naval Operations, to notify him as quickly as possible.
Or, take Marshall's failure to simply pick up the scrambler phone on his desk and call Short after Marshall read the 14-part message and the two accompanying messages. Marshall's various excuses not only defy common sense and reason, they are downright laughable. He could have told Short to put his forces on alert without saying a word about Japanese intercepts. Or, he could have used any number of plausible cover stories as an excuse to order the alert.
Marshall's claim that he feared the Japanese were monitoring the scrambler phone doesn't pass the smell test on a number of levels. FDR regularly used the scrambler phone to discuss very sensitive issues with Churchill. And, again, Marshall could have ordered an alert without saying a word about intercepted cables, and could have also used a cover story as his excuse for ordering the alert.
Marshall didn't pick up the scrambler phone and call Short because he wanted the Japanese attack to be a surprise. He was a good patriot and, like FDR, he believed this was the only way to get America into the war sooner rather than later. That's why, when Marshall finally did stop stalling and got around to penning a weakly worded warning just before noon, he didn't even bother to ensure that the cable was flagged as a priority message and marked as urgent. That's why, even when he was informed that his message might take up to 40 minutes to reach Hawaii, which he knew would be too late to do any good, he still didn't pick up the scrambler phone sitting right there on his desk and notify Short.
Hilited. So the attack on Wake, Guam, Malaya, Midway and the Philipines and all the other attacks, aside form the one on Pearl Harbor, would not be reason to be at war?
Is that what you are meaning? And if not why are you ignoring these attacks?