Merged Pearl Harbor: "Revisionists" vs. "Traditionalists"

I believe critical thinking and common sense can lead any open-minded person to discern the basics of the Pearl Harbor plot. Detectives often solve crimes because they refuse to accept the "innocent explanations" offered by suspects. They use critical thinking and common sense to determine that the suspects' stories simply aren't believable, that their stories defy common sense and reason, and that their stories strain credulity well beyond the breaking point.

Take Admiral Stark's "failure" to determine if Kimmel was getting Magic intercepts. Stark and Turner spent a lot of time before the JCC passing the buck on this issue. "I assumed he was getting them." "He told me Kimmel was getting them." Etc., etc., etc. Stark's story is simply ludicrous (as is Turner's, for that matter). One would have to believe that Stark was practically retarded to accept his tale. One would also have to be quite gullible to believe it.

Stark admitted that the question of whether Kimmel was getting Magic messages was a subject of some controversy back in D.C. Well, during the same time when Stark was supposedly seeking to make sure that Kimmel was getting Magic messages, Stark met with Kimmel for hours when Kimmel came to Washington for an official visit and yet "failed" to simply ask him if he was getting Magic intercepts. Gosh, are you kidding me?

We're supposed to believe, gulp and gullible, that it never occurred to Stark to simply ask Kimmel if he was getting Magic intercepts when he had him standing right there in front of him for hours at a time when he was supposedly seeking to determine if Kimmel was getting them! "Gosh, just slipped my mind!" Nobody is that stupid, that clueless, that brainless. Stark didn't ask because he didn't want Kimmel to get Magic messages, especially not the ones that clearly pointed to unusual Japanese interest in Pearl Harbor. He knew full well that Kimmel wasn't getting Magic messages.

Or, take Admiral Stark's failure to "pick up the phone and call Kimmel" on the morning of December 7 after Admiral Wilkinson urged him to do so once the 14-part message, the code-destruction message, and the time-of-delivery message had been received. Kimmel wasn't just responsible for Hawaii, he was the responsible for the entire Pacific Fleet and for a huge area of the Pacific Ocean. It was an obvious no-brainer that he should be notified immediately that war was imminent, and it was Stark's duty and right, as Chief of Naval Operations, to notify him as quickly as possible.

Or, take Marshall's failure to simply pick up the scrambler phone on his desk and call Short after Marshall read the 14-part message and the two accompanying messages. Marshall's various excuses not only defy common sense and reason, they are downright laughable. He could have told Short to put his forces on alert without saying a word about Japanese intercepts. Or, he could have used any number of plausible cover stories as an excuse to order the alert.

Marshall's claim that he feared the Japanese were monitoring the scrambler phone doesn't pass the smell test on a number of levels. FDR regularly used the scrambler phone to discuss very sensitive issues with Churchill. And, again, Marshall could have ordered an alert without saying a word about intercepted cables, and could have also used a cover story as his excuse for ordering the alert.

Marshall didn't pick up the scrambler phone and call Short because he wanted the Japanese attack to be a surprise. He was a good patriot and, like FDR, he believed this was the only way to get America into the war sooner rather than later. That's why, when Marshall finally did stop stalling and got around to penning a weakly worded warning just before noon, he didn't even bother to ensure that the cable was flagged as a priority message and marked as urgent. That's why, even when he was informed that his message might take up to 40 minutes to reach Hawaii, which he knew would be too late to do any good, he still didn't pick up the scrambler phone sitting right there on his desk and notify Short.

Hilited. So the attack on Wake, Guam, Malaya, Midway and the Philipines and all the other attacks, aside form the one on Pearl Harbor, would not be reason to be at war?
Is that what you are meaning? And if not why are you ignoring these attacks?
 
Hilited. So the attack on Wake, Guam, Malaya, Midway and the Philipines and all the other attacks, aside form the one on Pearl Harbor, would not be reason to be at war?
Is that what you are meaning? And if not why are you ignoring these attacks?


Obviously Bob only uses common sense when he wants to support his theory.
 
The thing about Critical Thinking is it works on the GIGO principal:Garbage In,Garbage Out. As Bob's attempts at Critical Thinking about Pearl Harbor proves....
 
BTF, the Hawiian Chapter of the Red Cross started ordering extra supplies in January of 1941. Why do you keep ignoring that?
Oh, ask me. Because that wouldn't support, and would even weaken, his conspiracy theory.

All Red Cross directors have Top Secret clearances. Little known fact.
Like USAid Disaster Logistics Officers?

I believe critical thinking and common sense can lead any open-minded person to discern the basics of the Pearl Harbor plot.<snippage of much gibbering conspiratorial rubbish>
Yes. It was a clever, daring, Japanese plan to cripple the US Pacific fleet.
 
The following appears in a 2008 article by Douglas Deitrich

On 5 December 1941 at a Cabinet meeting, Secretary of the Navy Frank Knox said, "Well, you know Mr. President, we know where the Japanese fleet is?"

"Yes, I know, …Well, you tell them what it is Frank," said Roosevelt (Toland 294). Knox became extremely excited with the ok from Roosevelt, and he went to tell the group of where the Japanese were and where they were headed. Just as Knox was about to speak Roosevelt interrupted saying, "We haven’t got anything like perfect information as to their apparent destination." (Toland 294).

All Navy reports showed the Japanese were in Pacific Water, and were in a direction towards Hawaii and Pearl Harbor. Roosevelt knew this information, but one must wonder why in the world would he not want to tell his cabinet this information, unless he wanted to hide something? On 6 December 1941 at a White House dinner Roosevelt was given the first thirteen parts of a fifteen part decoded Japanese diplomatic declaration of war and said, "This means War". (Toland 318)


Reference:
"Infamy" by John Toland. New York: Doubleday & Company, Inc, 1982

This guy appears to be using secondary (and biased) supporting sources. Elsewhere in the article he references Robert Stinnett, John Costello, Mark Willey et al; other authors saying the same things he is (rather like quoting the Bible to support your belief in Christ's divinity).

However, he quotes FDR directly (in quotation marks)! Are there any primary sources for what he alleges FDR said?
 
FDR was advised in regular intelligence reports as to where we thought the IJN units were located. Toland lies when he says "All Navy reports showed the Japanese were in Pacific Water, and were in a direction towards Hawaii and Pearl Harbor." This is not supported by any evidence from legitimate sources.

""We haven’t got anything like perfect information as to their apparent destination.""

So FDR says there he doesn't know where the ships are heading. However, the ships he's referring to had sailed from Cam Ranh Bay, Indochina, and were heading south. Twenty-four Army transports with escorts.
 
So Deitrich is quoting from sources that are taking (a lot of) journalistic licence, and in particular, one who is misrepresenting the meaning of FDR's words?
 
Kido Butai did not transmit.

How many times are you going to use that circular argument? When faced with evidence that the Kido Butai did in fact transmit, your only answer is to repeat your assertion of a negative that you cannot prove.

Yes, the Kido Butai sailors who commented on the subject swore up and down that they did not transmit. But, as has been pointed out to you, those sailors made other claims that were later proven to be false.

When faced with declassified Kido Butai intercepts, the traditionalist answer is that they were all part of the Japanese deception effort. Yeah, so we're supposed to believe that the Japanese deception effort included sending messages that clearly indicated that carriers were operating far from Japan, when the whole purpose of the deception effort was to make us think the carriers were in home waters. Jacobsen never did address this obvious glaring hole in the traditionalist explanation for those intercepts. He passed over it in silence, even though Drs. Wilford and Villa pointed it out in articles that he attacked. Why would the Japanese send out "fake" messages that would have indicated to a rookie analyst on his first day on the job that carriers were operating far out at sea?

The foreknowledge witnesses also include Commanders Malcolm Burnett and Raymond Mortimer, who served as British naval intelligence officers with the Far East Combined Bureau during the war. Burnett told his wife and a government historian (who happened to be a close family friend) that he personally heard Japanese military messages that led him to believe that Pearl Harbor would be attacked and that he was certain this information was relayed to the Americans. Both his wife and the government historian confirmed this.

And Mortimer stated that British naval intelligence could decipher JN-25 until just a couple days before the attack (when the Japanese introduced another additive set), that he and others at his FECB station knew Pearl Harbor would be attacked, that this information was relayed to the Americans, and that after the attack he personally checked the station transmission logs to confirm that the information had been given to the Americans.
 
Last edited:
But there is no record from Japan that they did transmit and there is evidence from Japan that they didn't transmit.


What are these Japanese claims that were proven to be false that cast doubt on all the Japanese sources?
In favour of your conspiracy you have second and third hand accounts written many years later.
 
And Mortimer stated that British naval intelligence could decipher JN-25 until just a couple days before the attack (when the Japanese introduced another additive set), that he and others at his FECB station knew Pearl Harbor would be attacked, that this information was relayed to the Americans, and that after the attack he personally checked the station transmission logs to confirm that the information had been given to the Americans.

If they could decrypt JN-25B before the mass attacks on UK/US/NEI territories, why didn't they use that information? They got caught with their pants down.

Silly claims are silly.
 
In June of 1942, after a massively ramped-up effort, Rochefort and his boys could read 10% of JN-25 messages. One Word In Ten.

If anybody had been reading JN-25 before December 1941, and hid the information to "Just Let It Happen"(tm), why would they continue to conceal this great break through? Why not pipe up and say "Hey, we've had sudden run of good luck and we can read JN-25 now!"

One question for good old Bob: What information about the attack on Pearl Harbor was transmitted in JN-25?
 
How many times are you going to use that circular argument? When faced with evidence that the Kido Butai did in fact transmit, your only answer is to repeat your assertion of a negative that you cannot prove.

Yes, the Kido Butai sailors who commented on the subject swore up and down that they did not transmit. But, as has been pointed out to you, those sailors made other claims that were later proven to be false.

When faced with declassified Kido Butai intercepts, the traditionalist answer is that they were all part of the Japanese deception effort. Yeah, so we're supposed to believe that the Japanese deception effort included sending messages that clearly indicated that carriers were operating far from Japan, when the whole purpose of the deception effort was to make us think the carriers were in home waters. Jacobsen never did address this obvious glaring hole in the traditionalist explanation for those intercepts. He passed over it in silence, even though Drs. Wilford and Villa pointed it out in articles that he attacked. Why would the Japanese send out "fake" messages that would have indicated to a rookie analyst on his first day on the job that carriers were operating far out at sea?

The foreknowledge witnesses also include Commanders Malcolm Burnett and Raymond Mortimer, who served as British naval intelligence officers with the Far East Combined Bureau during the war. Burnett told his wife and a government historian (who happened to be a close family friend) that he personally heard Japanese military messages that led him to believe that Pearl Harbor would be attacked and that he was certain this information was relayed to the Americans. Both his wife and the government historian confirmed this.

And Mortimer stated that British naval intelligence could decipher JN-25 until just a couple days before the attack (when the Japanese introduced another additive set), that he and others at his FECB station knew Pearl Harbor would be attacked, that this information was relayed to the Americans, and that after the attack he personally checked the station transmission logs to confirm that the information had been given to the Americans.

So, let's see. You have an argument from incredulity stacked on top of an unsourced bare assertion, and a handful of unsourced personal anecdotes. How about you review what the Japanese documents say first, and then we can come back around to this whole mishmash of fail. And for the rest, I hold that Kido Butai did not transmit.
 
In June of 1942, after a massively ramped-up effort, Rochefort and his boys could read 10% of JN-25 messages. One Word In Ten.

If anybody had been reading JN-25 before December 1941, and hid the information to "Just Let It Happen"(tm), why would they continue to conceal this great break through? Why not pipe up and say "Hey, we've had sudden run of good luck and we can read JN-25 now!"

One question for good old Bob: What information about the attack on Pearl Harbor was transmitted in JN-25?

My understanding, such as it is, was that the code breakers could read about 10% of a message by about December 1941 (the current edition of JN-25 had come into service about December 1940). With the increase in traffic and the increasing availability of personnel (especially with an increasing degree of experience in code breaking, you don't just sit some new guy down, after some training, and *poof* he can work as well as the experienced ones, i.e. they (at Pearl Harbor CIU) started with 3 real cryptanalysts in December 1941 and by May 1942 had 6 more fairly competent and 50 who were getting the feel for the work...).

By May 1942 they had recovered about 1/3 of the JN-25B lexicon and could read perhaps 90% of a typical message. On June 1, a new edition came into force (its deployment had been delayed some months) and the cryptanalysts had to essentially start anew but by that time the Midway orders had been transmitted and decrypted (to give an idea of how close the timing of the change was).

The PH attack force was on a secret mission that would start the war, presumably with the advantage falling exclusively to the Japanese. The idea that the IJN would not try to ensure that the force could carry out its mission and return intact by ordering it to maintain radio silence is laughable. Detection, ambush, and defeat in detail by the USN, even if the USN suffered very heavy losses, would utterly compromise the Japanese Empire's war ambitions. The possibility that, despite every precaution, the force might be detected likely weighed heavily on Yamamoto because its loss would be a real game changer.
 
The following appears in a 2008 article by Douglas Deitrich



Reference:
"Infamy" by John Toland. New York: Doubleday & Company, Inc, 1982

This guy appears to be using secondary (and biased) supporting sources. Elsewhere in the article he references Robert Stinnett, John Costello, Mark Willey et al; other authors saying the same things he is (rather like quoting the Bible to support your belief in Christ's divinity).

However, he quotes FDR directly (in quotation marks)! Are there any primary sources for what he alleges FDR said?

John Toland is a sad case. A good Historian who got seduced to the Dark Side late in his career.
 
"Selective quoting", or lying, is rather popular with some folks. Toland should have stayed with the ETO, where he knew something.

To be fair, his "But Not in Shame" is an excellent book about the first Six Months of the Pacific War. But Starting in "The Rising Sun",he begun to be an apologist for Japan during World War 2, and destroyed his reputation with "Infamy".
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom