Merged Pearl Harbor: "Revisionists" vs. "Traditionalists"

Ooooo-k. Got some info for that? I am aware that such leads were known, but 50,000?

Not that I doubt you, but that is a whole shedload of leads. Further, it gives the lie less grounds, as somehow, someone had to select the correct lead for the conspiracy to fly. Which of fifty thousand rumours would one chose to believe? While I was aware there were many, that is a scale up.

That's from memory, and as always I admit my memory isn't perfect. I could dig up the information I think. I remember it was mentioned in relation to the Peruvian ambassador's word to Grew that the Japanese were planning to attack Pearl Harbor. This was in January, 1941, when Yamamoto was just beginning to put the idea down on paper for the IGHQ's consideration. The good ambassador appears to have gotten it from his Chinese cook, always a great source of information. ;)
 
Ever notice that when CTers trot out people who knew about the attack they just widen the circle of those who could have spilled the beans decades ago? Why didn't they? Why were they part of the cover up? Maybe it's because they all secretly loved FDR? Or they were just too stupid to realize they could be famous as the guys who brought FDR down? Franklin would have been impeached and tried in no time if he'd been exposed doing something like this. I can think of a dozen lame excuses for not doing the whistleblowing, but none of them make sense in a real world.
 
Ever notice that when CTers trot out people who knew about the attack they just widen the circle of those who could have spilled the beans decades ago? Why didn't they? Why were they part of the cover up? Maybe it's because they all secretly loved FDR? Or they were just too stupid to realize they could be famous as the guys who brought FDR down? Franklin would have been impeached and tried in no time if he'd been exposed doing something like this. I can think of a dozen lame excuses for not doing the whistleblowing, but none of them make sense in a real world.

What I want to know is why FDR and the others blabbed all about their plan to let the Japanese attack Pearl Harbor in the first place, much less to such a motley collection of random people. I mean, FDR told J. Edgar Hoover who then told some Army colonel? FDR told some FBI agent in Hawaii who promptly spilled the beans to a member of the Honolulu PD? FDR told some Red Cross official who then told his daughter? Why!?
 
What I want to know is why FDR and the others blabbed all about their plan to let the Japanese attack Pearl Harbor in the first place, much less to such a motley collection of random people. I mean, FDR told J. Edgar Hoover who then told some Army colonel? FDR told some FBI agent in Hawaii who promptly spilled the beans to a member of the Honolulu PD? FDR told some Red Cross official who then told his daughter? Why!?

So far as I can tell there were ~40,000,000 Americans who knew about the attack, if we take BTF's reports as true.

Does it qualify as a conspiracy if it's widely known at the time? :confused:
 
Ever notice that when CTers trot out people who knew about the attack they just widen the circle of those who could have spilled the beans decades ago? Why didn't they? Why were they part of the cover up? Maybe it's because they all secretly loved FDR? Or they were just too stupid to realize they could be famous as the guys who brought FDR down? Franklin would have been impeached and tried in no time if he'd been exposed doing something like this. I can think of a dozen lame excuses for not doing the whistleblowing, but none of them make sense in a real world.

Because it fits the delusion in the head of the CT to begin with?
 
So far as I can tell there were ~40,000,000 Americans who knew about the attack, if we take BTF's reports as true.

Does it qualify as a conspiracy if it's widely known at the time? :confused:

...and if it was so wide spread why didn't Lindberg and other oponents to going to war hear about it? Why didn't the Soviet and Fascist agents in the US not hear it not to mention the Japanese ones?
 
Also funny that Joe T. Flynn, editor for the Chicago Tribune never came up with any good dope on this conspiracy and had to go with the same mythology and myth information that BTF is using today. (Not that BTF gives us anything original.)

There were also Robert F. Theobald and Kemp Tolley.

:blackcat:
 
Let's consider the serious, credible people who have come forward with disclosures regarding foreknowledge of the attack on the part of FDR and certain high officials in his administration:
Oh, yes, by all means let's.

But while we wait for you to produce them, we'll have to consider the feeble offering below.

* James Stahlman, a former Navy officer and a longtime close friend of Sec. of the Navy Frank Knox, who said Knox told him that FDR and other high officials knew positively by December 6 that Pearl Harbor would be attacked and that they knew attack would occur the next day.
Hearsay. The claimant is not a witness. The alleged witness is not alive to confirm or deny the claim. The claim is not corroborated by any documentation left behind by the alleged witness or by anybody else.

* Joseph Leib, a journalist who was friends with Sec. of State Cordell Hull, who said Hull told him that FDR and certain others in his administration knew from Japanese intercepts that Pearl Harbor would be attacked, and that FDR did not want this information passed to the Hawaiian commanders because he felt that only a surprise attack would galvanize the American people to support entering the war. Leib said that Hull added that FBI Director J. Edgar Hoover was aware of this information.
Hearsay. The claimant is not a witness. The alleged witness is not alive to confirm or deny the claim. The claim is not corroborated by any documentation left behind by the alleged witness or by anybody else.

* Carlton Ketchum, a retired Army colonel, who said that J. Edgar Hoover told him in 1942 that by the fall of 1941 FDR knew from various sources that Pearl Harbor was going to be attacked and that he had decided to allow the attack to occur.
Hearsay. The claimant is not a witness. The alleged witness is not alive to confirm or deny the claim. The claim is not corroborated by any documentation left behind by the alleged witness or by anybody else.

* John Burns, a former head of the Honolulu Police Department's Espionage Bureau and later a governor of Hawaii, who disclosed shortly before he died that several days before the attack occurred the FBI Agent in Charge of the Honolulu FBI office told him that Pearl Harbor would be attacked by the end of the week. Burns' account was confirmed by one of his subordinates.
The claim is not corroborated by any documentation left behind by the alleged witness or by anybody else.

* Helen Hamman, daughter of former senior Red Cross official Don Smith, who contacted the Kimmel family when she heard of efforts to clear Kimmel's name. Mrs. Hamman wrote that her father had told her that FDR had told him that Pearl Harbor would be attacked and ordered him to secretly arrange for additional medical supplies to be sent to the Red Cross unit in Hawaii and ordered him not to tell anyone in Hawaii why the medical supplies were being sent. Mrs. Hamman added that her father explained that when he expressed objections to this, FDR told him that he needed to allow the Japanese to attack Pearl Harbor in order to spark the American people to support entering the war. The arrival of additional medical supplies to Hawaii shortly before the attack has now been confirmed, adding credibility to Mrs. Hamman's disclosure.
Hearsay. The claimant is not a witness. The alleged witness is not alive to confirm or deny the claim. The claim is not corroborated by any documentation left behind by the alleged witness or by anybody else.

The arrival of additional medical supplies is not corroboration: Pearl Harbor was a major military installation, in a theater already at war. Any Red Cross supplies intended for the western Pacific would have passed through Hawaii.

* Congressman Martin Dies of Texas, who revealed in his memoir that his committee, while investigating espionage and subversion, came into possession of a Japanese military map that indicated plans to attack Pearl Harbor. Dies explained that he called Sec. of State Hull about the map and that Hull told him that he had discussed the matter with the president and that Dies should keep quiet about the map because of the sensitive, delicate diplomatic situation with Japan. Dies added that Hull asked him to let the president handle this information as he saw fit, and that officials from the Army and the State Department examined the map.
And the Us has maps and plans for the invasion of Canada.

A Japanese attack on Pearl is a reasonable possibility to consider; both the Japanese and US governments had considered it for decades--just like they'd also considered Japanese attacks on other reasonable targets.

Knowing Pearl is on the Japanese target list is not the same thing as knowing Pear is a Japanese target for attack on a certain date.

Given the tension between the US and Japan at the time, it's only natural that the President would want to handle any such delicate matter as Japanese target lists in a diplomatic way.

* Thomas Gillette, the nephew of Senator Guy Gillette, who revealed that his uncle had told him that he had been aware of information that Pearl Harbor would be attacked and that he had advised senior State Department officials of this information.
And now we're back to hearsay. The claimant is not a witness. The alleged witness is not alive to confirm or deny the claim. The claim is not corroborated by any documentation left behind by the alleged witness or by anybody else.

* Victor Cavendish-Bentick, the former head of England's Joint Intelligence Committee, who revealed that British intelligence knew from Japanese intercepts that Pearl Harbor would be attacked and that this information was relayed to American officials. For more information on this disclosure and the attempts to discredit it, see Richard Aldrich, Intelligence and the War Against Japan (Cambridge University Press, 2000), pp. 86-88.
You own this text? You can quote the relevant passages?

Notice the mutually corroborating nature of some of these disclosures.
No, mutual corroboration would be if the alleged witnessess' written records corroborated the hearsay claims of third parties.

Different people making the same uncorroborated hearsay claims that "the FBI knew" is not corroboration.

These disclosures are all discussed in Dr. George Victor's book The Pearl Harbor Myth: Rethinking the Unthinkable. Most of them are also discussed in John Toland's book Infamy, in Pearcy Greaves' book Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fruits of Infamy, and in Dr. George Nash's book Freedom Betrayed.
You own these texts? You can quote the relevant passages? You can show where these authors trace the claims back to primary sources and corroborate them with independent evidence?
 
Why would anyone deliberately let the Japanese attack Pearl? Wouldn't a far more inspirational tale be "Thanks to the dedication and superior intelligence and technology of the United States Navy, a surprise attack was successfully thwarted at Pearl Harbor, Hawaii"? Seriously, once Japan decided to attack the U.S., it WAS a declaration of war. Why start out the war looking like complete and total boobs?
 
Admission of MAGIC Demolishes FDR's Claim of Surprise
http://codoh.com/library/document/2067

No, it doesn't. It's the same old mind-reading and what-iffing. Safford thought he heard the of the "Winds Execute Message", and couldn't find it. One message out of thousands was missing, so that was it, and it had been removed. Problem is, the Winds system was never activated, because it was to be used when communications with Japan's embassies was cut off PRIOR TO WAR. That never happened, so Winds was never used.

If you want to read ever single Magic intercept, and the context for each, here you go. http://www.ibiblio.org/pha/magic/
 
Why would anyone deliberately let the Japanese attack Pearl? Wouldn't a far more inspirational tale be "Thanks to the dedication and superior intelligence and technology of the United States Navy, a surprise attack was successfully thwarted at Pearl Harbor, Hawaii"? Seriously, once Japan decided to attack the U.S., it WAS a declaration of war. Why start out the war looking like complete and total boobs?

Hush! If we start thinking like that then this whole conspiracy falls apart. Can't have that, now can we? :cool:
 
Not to mention that the Japanese DID declare war on the US formally too
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom