Merged Pearl Harbor: "Revisionists" vs. "Traditionalists"

Yep, after they found out the attacks were going well. Sort of an after thought.

http://metalab.unc.edu/pha/myths/matsum_1.html

Not so sure of that

Premier-At the conference of Dec. 1 they determined to commence
hostilities against England, America, and the Netherlands.

but it an academic concern, they had attacked and even without the PH attack they had taken a US warship and sunk US merchant vessels besides other attacks on US forces.

Trivia question I think that and the 11 December German & Italian declarations of war were the last in history against the US (not counting Japanese and German proxy nations which dribble in after the main declaration)

Edited to add: 17 December 1941 – Albania (under Italian occupation) declared war on the United States of America. I think that was the last one against the US
 
Last edited:
What makes the Stahlman disclosure compelling is that Stahlman reported that Knox disclosed the late-night December 6 White House meeting soon after Knox returned from Pearl Harbor because he was upset by the huge amount of damage and carnage he had just seen and was angry that his late-night December 6 warning to Kimmel never reached Hawaii (see, for example, John Costello, Days of Infamy, New York: Pocket Books, 1994, p. 209). This has the ring of truth to it.

And, as George Victor notes, Stahlman's disclosure also explains Knox's shock and disbelief when he discovered that Kimmel did not receive the 12/6 warning, which Knox himself penned (according to two of his aides).

Similarly, Helen Hamman's disclosure has the ring of truth to it. Mrs. Hamman was the daughter of Don Smith, the director of the Red Cross's War Service in 1941. When she saw news reports about the efforts of the Kimmel and Short families to clear Kimmel and Short's names, she wrote a letter to President Clinton to relate to him that her father had told her that FDR had ordered him to arrange for extra medical supplies to be sent secretly to Pearl Harbor because it was about to be attacked, and that when her father objected FDR told him that the American people would not support entering the war unless he allowed Pearl Harbor to be attacked. Said Mrs. Hamman,

Shortly before the attack in 1941 President Roosevelt called him [Smith] to the White House for a meeting concerning a Top Secret matter. At this meeting the President advised my father that his intelligence staff had informed him of a pending attack on Pearl Harbor, by the Japanese. He anticipated many casualties and much loss, he instructed my father to send workers and supplies to a holding area at a P.O.E. [port of entry] on the West Coast where they would await further orders to ship out, no destination was to be revealed. He left no doubt in my father's mind that none of the Naval and Military officials in Hawaii were to be informed and he was not to advise the Red Cross officers who were already stationed in the area. When he protested to the President, President Roosevelt told him that the American people would never agree to enter the war in Europe unless they were attack [sic] within their own borders.​

Mrs. Hamman never sought to profit from her story, nor did she seek to receive undue publicity from it. She only came forward with her account when she saw news stories about the efforts of Kimmel and Short's families to clear their names. Her father had told her his story in the 1970s, but she didn't think about it again until she saw the news reports about the Kimmel and Short families in 1995. All of this lends a strong ring of truth to her disclosure.

Furthermore, after Mrs. Hamman wrote to President Clinton, researchers discovered that a copy of the Hawaii Chapter's Annual Report for the fiscal year ending in June 1942 confirmed that the Red Cross at Pearl Harbor secretly received medical supplies immediately before the attack.

More on Mrs. Hamman's disclosure can be found in the following article:

Advance Warning? The Red Cross Connection
http://rense.com/general60/moreevidenceFDRknew.htm
 
Last edited:
Why would the Prez spill the beans to the Red Cross?

Why not just getthe Military Hopsitals to stock up on extra band aids?
 
Why would the Prez spill the beans to the Red Cross?
It's the CTer on the Beach syndrome. He wanders around on a beach, finding seashells here and there. He then assembles them in a small group and yells "The seacreatures are invading!!!" (Much waving of hands.)
Why not just getthe Military Hopsitals to stock up on extra band aids?
Why stock up at all if you're looking for a big body count. You can kill more Americans by not having sufficient supplies. If you're a murdering bastard then this would be the way to go.
 
What makes the Stahlman disclosure compelling is that Stahlman reported that Knox disclosed the late-night December 6 White House meeting soon after Knox returned from Pearl Harbor because he was upset by the huge amount of damage and carnage he had just seen and was angry that his late-night December 6 warning to Kimmel never reached Hawaii (see, for example, John Costello, Days of Infamy, New York: Pocket Books, 1994, p. 209). This has the ring of truth to it.

And, as George Victor notes, Stahlman's disclosure also explains Knox's shock and disbelief when he discovered that Kimmel did not receive the 12/6 warning, which Knox himself penned (according to two of his aides).

Similarly, Helen Hamman's disclosure has the ring of truth to it. Mrs. Hamman was the daughter of Don Smith, the director of the Red Cross's War Service in 1941. When she saw news reports about the efforts of the Kimmel and Short families to clear Kimmel and Short's names, she wrote a letter to President Clinton to relate to him that her father had told her that FDR had ordered him to arrange for extra medical supplies to be sent secretly to Pearl Harbor because it was about to be attacked, and that when her father objected FDR told him that the American people would not support entering the war unless he allowed Pearl Harbor to be attacked. Said Mrs. Hamman,

Shortly before the attack in 1941 President Roosevelt called him [Smith] to the White House for a meeting concerning a Top Secret matter. At this meeting the President advised my father that his intelligence staff had informed him of a pending attack on Pearl Harbor, by the Japanese. He anticipated many casualties and much loss, he instructed my father to send workers and supplies to a holding area at a P.O.E. [port of entry] on the West Coast where they would await further orders to ship out, no destination was to be revealed. He left no doubt in my father's mind that none of the Naval and Military officials in Hawaii were to be informed and he was not to advise the Red Cross officers who were already stationed in the area. When he protested to the President, President Roosevelt told him that the American people would never agree to enter the war in Europe unless they were attack [sic] within their own borders.​

Mrs. Hamman never sought to profit from her story, nor did she seek to receive undue publicity from it. She only came forward with her account when she saw news stories about the efforts of Kimmel and Short's families to clear their names. Her father had told her his story in the 1970s, but she didn't think about it again until she saw the news reports about the Kimmel and Short families in 1995. All of this lends a strong ring of truth to her disclosure.

Furthermore, after Mrs. Hamman wrote to President Clinton, researchers discovered that a copy of the Hawaii Chapter's Annual Report for the fiscal year ending in June 1942 confirmed that the Red Cross at Pearl Harbor secretly received medical supplies immediately before the attack.

More on Mrs. Hamman's disclosure can be found in the following article:

Advance Warning? The Red Cross Connection
http://rense.com/general60/moreevidenceFDRknew.htm

You know what would really be compelling and carry the ring of truth? Any hard evidence these conversations you keep bringing up ever took place. Instead we find that named parties are long since deceased and can neither confirm nor deny the accounts.

A small hint for you; the plural of anecdote is not evidence. I mean do you not find it astonishing that these parties apparently spoke about this deep dark secret to all and sundry but not one passed down a written account?
 
Why would the Prez spill the beans to the Red Cross?

Why not just getthe Military Hopsitals to stock up on extra band aids?



Or, alternatively, why tell the Red Cross the truth about why they needed the supplies? There was already a war on in lots of other places. Tell them you want to run an exercise in seeing how hard it would be to provide supplies to a distant station in case of an emergency. "We'll use Hawaii; it's fairly safe, but still pretty far out there, that makes it a perfect practice location!"
 
Said Mrs. Hamman,

Shortly before the attack in 1941 President Roosevelt called him [Smith] to the White House for a meeting concerning a Top Secret matter.​


All Red Cross directors have Top Secret clearances. Little known fact.

And all Salvation Army employees are cleared SCI.
 
I believe critical thinking and common sense can lead any open-minded person to discern the basics of the Pearl Harbor plot. Detectives often solve crimes because they refuse to accept the "innocent explanations" offered by suspects. They use critical thinking and common sense to determine that the suspects' stories simply aren't believable, that their stories defy common sense and reason, and that their stories strain credulity well beyond the breaking point.

Take Admiral Stark's "failure" to determine if Kimmel was getting Magic intercepts. Stark and Turner spent a lot of time before the JCC passing the buck on this issue. "I assumed he was getting them." "He told me Kimmel was getting them." Etc., etc., etc. Stark's story is simply ludicrous (as is Turner's, for that matter). One would have to believe that Stark was practically retarded to accept his tale. One would also have to be quite gullible to believe it.

Stark admitted that the question of whether Kimmel was getting Magic messages was a subject of some controversy back in D.C. Well, during the same time when Stark was supposedly seeking to make sure that Kimmel was getting Magic messages, Stark met with Kimmel for hours when Kimmel came to Washington for an official visit and yet "failed" to simply ask him if he was getting Magic intercepts. Gosh, are you kidding me?

We're supposed to believe, gulp and gullible, that it never occurred to Stark to simply ask Kimmel if he was getting Magic intercepts when he had him standing right there in front of him for hours at a time when he was supposedly seeking to determine if Kimmel was getting them! "Gosh, just slipped my mind!" Nobody is that stupid, that clueless, that brainless. Stark didn't ask because he didn't want Kimmel to get Magic messages, especially not the ones that clearly pointed to unusual Japanese interest in Pearl Harbor. He knew full well that Kimmel wasn't getting Magic messages.

Or, take Admiral Stark's failure to "pick up the phone and call Kimmel" on the morning of December 7 after Admiral Wilkinson urged him to do so once the 14-part message, the code-destruction message, and the time-of-delivery message had been received. Kimmel wasn't just responsible for Hawaii, he was the responsible for the entire Pacific Fleet and for a huge area of the Pacific Ocean. It was an obvious no-brainer that he should be notified immediately that war was imminent, and it was Stark's duty and right, as Chief of Naval Operations, to notify him as quickly as possible.

Or, take Marshall's failure to simply pick up the scrambler phone on his desk and call Short after Marshall read the 14-part message and the two accompanying messages. Marshall's various excuses not only defy common sense and reason, they are downright laughable. He could have told Short to put his forces on alert without saying a word about Japanese intercepts. Or, he could have used any number of plausible cover stories as an excuse to order the alert.

Marshall's claim that he feared the Japanese were monitoring the scrambler phone doesn't pass the smell test on a number of levels. FDR regularly used the scrambler phone to discuss very sensitive issues with Churchill. And, again, Marshall could have ordered an alert without saying a word about intercepted cables, and could have also used a cover story as his excuse for ordering the alert.

Marshall didn't pick up the scrambler phone and call Short because he wanted the Japanese attack to be a surprise. He was a good patriot and, like FDR, he believed this was the only way to get America into the war sooner rather than later. That's why, when Marshall finally did stop stalling and got around to penning a weakly worded warning just before noon, he didn't even bother to ensure that the cable was flagged as a priority message and marked as urgent. That's why, even when he was informed that his message might take up to 40 minutes to reach Hawaii, which he knew would be too late to do any good, he still didn't pick up the scrambler phone sitting right there on his desk and notify Short.
 
Last edited:
Too much nonsense to bother with, you've posted this all before.

For others, keep in mind that "Magic" was extremely sensitive and limited to 12 recipients, tops. Kimmel claimed getting Magic information would have made him do things differently, but it has been noted that the things he would have changed where things he wasn't supposed to be doing anyway, like keeping the Fleet on a regular schedule.

"Marshall didn't pick up the scrambler phone and call Short because he wanted the Japanese attack to be a surprise. He was a good patriot and, like FDR, he believed this was the only way to get America into the war sooner rather than later.

That is simply absurd, as noted earlier.

"That's why, when Marshall finally did stop stalling and got around to penning a weakly worded warning just before noon, he didn't even bother to ensure that the cable was flagged as a priority message and marked as urgent. That's why, even when he was informed that his message might take up to 40 minutes to reach Hawaii, which he knew would be too late to do any good, he still didn't pick up the scrambler phone sitting right there on his desk and notify Short."

There was nothing to indicate an attack was going to happen in the next few hours. You can apply all the hinie-sight you want, but at the time all we knew was Japan was getting ready to break off negotiations. We didn't have a clear indication of a declaration of war, not even a formal end of diplomatic talks, just the last paragraph of the "Final Communication to the United States." (And we didn't even know that's what the Japanese were calling it.)

You really need to read some of the facts. Start here:

http://www.ibiblio.org/pha/magic/
 
Stark admitted that the question of whether Kimmel was getting Magic messages was a subject of some controversy back in D.C. Well, during the same time when Stark was supposedly seeking to make sure that Kimmel was getting Magic messages, Stark met with Kimmel for hours when Kimmel came to Washington for an official visit and yet "failed" to simply ask him if he was getting Magic intercepts. Gosh, are you kidding me?

We're supposed to believe, gulp and gullible, that it never occurred to Stark to simply ask Kimmel if he was getting Magic intercepts when he had him standing right there in front of him for hours at a time when he was supposedly seeking to determine if Kimmel was getting them! "Gosh, just slipped my mind!" Nobody is that stupid, that clueless, that brainless. Stark didn't ask because he didn't want Kimmel to get Magic messages, especially not the ones that clearly pointed to unusual Japanese interest in Pearl Harbor. He knew full well that Kimmel wasn't getting Magic messages.

Too much nonsense to bother with, you've posted this all before.

For others, keep in mind that "Magic" was extremely sensitive and limited to 12 recipients, tops. Kimmel claimed getting Magic information would have made him do things differently, but it has been noted that the things he would have changed where things he wasn't supposed to be doing anyway, like keeping the Fleet on a regular schedule.


And on this, for such classified material, even the existence of the material is itself a secret. Bob's above scenario of one person, cleared for this knowledge, asking another person if he is cleared for this knowledge is itself a huge violation of operational security. Just knowing that such intercepts exist is sufficient information to allow the enemy to know they need to change their procedures, and as such, this simple fact is just as critical as the contents of the intercepts themselves.

No professional military officer with such clearances would just casually ask someone else if they're "in the know".
 
Kimmel claimed that the interest in Pearl Harbor would have been a red flag for him. But nobody who testified in any of the nine investigations and inquiries ever said they thought Pearl would be a target on Day One of a war. The fact that they didn't think this, and so didn't prepare for it, is telling of the "half-way to war" mentality extant at the time.

And Stark knew Kimmel wasn't getting the decrypts because Stark knew who was getting them. He didn't have to ask Kimmel.
 
Marshall didn't pick up the scrambler phone and call Short because he wanted the Japanese attack to be a surprise. He was a good patriot and, like FDR, he believed this was the only way to get America into the war sooner rather than later.

Assume for the sake of argument there was an attempted assault on PH by the Japanese that, due to advance knowledge, was defended against.
By what reasoning could anyone conclude that the U.S. wouldn't be in the war after that? Japan had decided that the U.S. was in the war.

It really doesn't matter what the American public wants at that point.

Can you give some modestly plausible response by the American public to a Japanese declaration of war that would somehow result in the U.S. and Japan not being at war?
 
Well, obviously the Japanese would have given up on the whole thing and ther ewouldn't have been a war in the Pacific. they would have just said 'Aww, you guys, you got us good that time, you win..'
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom