Merged Pearl Harbor: "Revisionists" vs. "Traditionalists"

They did darken ship, but showed navigation lights. (Darken ship, properly, is showing no unnecessary lights outside the ship, like port holes, etc. (Working from memory here, too lazy to go into the cavern and dig out that book.)


That's right. Darken ship is navigation lights only. It's been awhile since I did the skimmer thing.
 
That's right. Darken ship is navigation lights only. It's been awhile since I did the skimmer thing.

Any way, only one destroyer got separated from the pack, and regained the formation the next day, without having to yell for help. I remember something about lost lambs navigating for Midway, to join up with the Midway Bombardment Force when it stopped by for joe and a smoke.
 
Even on a moobless night the wake of a ship stands out if you are close and following it.
 
Bingo. And there was no USN CA in that area. RDF can be rather iffy. It's certainly not conclusive on it's own.


What day was this? Kido Butai was 600 miles north of Pearl on 07 Dec Tokyo Standard Time. Does the source say it was a US Navy cruiser? Was this info relayed to the Kido Butai?
 
What day was this? Kido Butai was 600 miles north of Pearl on 07 Dec Tokyo Standard Time. Does the source say it was a US Navy cruiser? Was this info relayed to the Kido Butai?

The report was from either the Combined Fleet or Imperial General Staff, I'm trying to sort that now. The date is also in question, which is why I asked for the original publications to be compared with the archival documents. The log books wouldn't necessarily have the source if it was known and trusted. Orders would need provenance, intell not so much.
 
Sightings post will be delayed, I need to put this stuff into a table and post it somewhere. And next time I won't say anything about something like this until it's done. Patience, people, PATIENCE. (Especially you lurkers who aren't members here.)
 
Considering the OP's attitude toward Old Abe (He's an evil Yankee tyrant) I suspect a whole new thread somewhere when Spielberg's "Lincoln" opens next week.....
 
Now that the election is over, I will be posting my (long awaited?) reply to Jacobsen's attack on Grogan in the near future. I received my copy of Grogan's "Record for Posterity" a couple weeks ago.

The first thing that jumped out at me as I read Grogan's report was how Jacobsen misrepresents what Grogan said about his bearings and the location of the ships he was hearing. And, mind you, that misrepresentation is Jacobsen's entire basis for claiming that Grogan's bearings were off by 18 and 44 degrees.
 
So what if the Japanese never get to attack PH? Catching them in the act of trying is just as good.

First off, according to credible anecdotal evidence, FDR did not think so. That's number one.

Two, it is hard to fathom how some of you folks can think that "catching them in the act of trying" would have had anywhere near the emotional shock value of a devastating surprise attack.

If we follow the various "catch them in the act" scenarios, all sorts of thorny and potentially explosive questions would have arisen. If we had put PH on alert and caused the task force to turn around, that would hardly have jolted the American people into supporting going to war.

If we had pulled off the impossible stunt of putting PH alert without the local Japanese noticing it, and if our forces had then put up a terrific fight when the Japanese attacked, (1) our losses still would have been horrendous because we still would have been markedly outnumbered and outgunned. and (2) tons of troubling, potentially explosive questions would have arisen about foreknowledge. Also, a battle does not evoke the feelings of outrage and shock that a surprise attack evokes.

Again, we have credible anecdotal evidence that FDR believed that the only way the American people would support entering the war was for us to suffer a surprise attack and to incur substantial losses (though apparently the losses were more severe than he thought they would be).
 
Two, it is hard to fathom how some of you folks can think that "catching them in the act of trying" would have had anywhere near the emotional shock value of a devastating surprise attack.
But it would have been *enough*.

Let me put it this way:

If someone comes at you with a knife -- do you wait for them to stab you to do something about it?

I certainly never have...
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom