Merged Pearl Harbor: "Revisionists" vs. "Traditionalists"

...

Two, it is hard to fathom how some of you folks can think ...
That's your problem, not ours.


that "catching them in the act of trying" would have had anywhere near the emotional shock value of a devastating surprise attack.
I don't believe anyone has asserted such. Straw man.

If we follow the various "catch them in the act" scenarios, all sorts of thorny and potentially explosive questions would have arisen. If we had put PH on alert and caused the task force to turn around, that would hardly have jolted the American people into supporting going to war.
He said, based on his personal incredulity and nothing else.

If we had pulled off the impossible stunt of putting PH alert without the local Japanese noticing it,
Incredulity again.

and if our forces had then put up a terrific fight when the Japanese attacked,
Again, assertions no one made.

(1) our losses still would have been horrendous because we still would have been markedly outnumbered and outgunned.
Yet they still would've been less than from a sneak attack.

and (2) tons of troubling, potentially explosive questions would have arisen about foreknowledge.
As opposed to the ones CTs like you have raised, which are calming and soothing?

Also, a battle does not evoke the feelings of outrage and shock that a surprise attack evokes.
No, but it would be much better in literally every possible way. An attack from the perfidious Japs (I hate typing that) beaten off by those brave Navy boys is much better for morale and logistics than a crippling blow to PH.

Again, we have credible anecdotal evidence that FDR believed that the only way the American people would support entering the war was for us to suffer a surprise attack and to incur substantial losses (though apparently the losses were more severe than he thought they would be).
Assuming it's true; it's still not evidence of foreknowledge. It's not even evidence he was right.

Still not addressing the Japanese records. Why not?
 
Last edited:
So the Japanese declaring war against the US wouldn't have been sufficient? Capturing a US warship? Sinking US merchant ships - beside attacking Guam etc?

You live in a strange little world

LOL
Given the reaction to the attack on the USS Panay in 1937 and the fear of war that attack raised the idea that the attacks on Guam, the Phillipines, US shipping et cetera wouldn't have been sufficient causus belli is just plain stupid.

An interesting letter regarding the ABC-1 talks. Your attention is invited to Para. 10.

BTW, the ABC-1 talks drew a line in the sand beyond which the Japanese could not go without faciing armed resistance from the Allies.

In addition, these talks firmed up the "Germany First" rule. It was confirmed at the Atlantic Conference and formally announced at Casablanca, IIRC.
Thank you for that.
 
Given the reaction to the attack on the USS Panay in 1937 and the fear of war that attack raised the idea that the attacks on Guam, the Phillipines, US shipping et cetera wouldn't have been sufficient causus belli is just plain stupid.

Heck, the US jumped feet-first into World War I with little more provocation than the sinking of the Lusitania, and she wasn't even our ship. For all the power of isolationism in the WWII-era United States, I don't think anybody had the idea that we would just stand by and let our citizens get blown to kingdom come without a response.
 
Heck, the US jumped feet-first into World War I with little more provocation than the sinking of the Lusitania, and she wasn't even our ship. For all the power of isolationism in the WWII-era United States, I don't think anybody had the idea that we would just stand by and let our citizens get blown to kingdom come without a response.


The Lusitania played a minor part. It was mostly the Zimmermann Telegram that did it.
 
Heck, the US jumped feet-first into World War I with little more provocation than the sinking of the Lusitania, and she wasn't even our ship. For all the power of isolationism in the WWII-era United States, I don't think anybody had the idea that we would just stand by and let our citizens get blown to kingdom come without a response.

"For all the power of isolationism in the WWII-era United States, "

I've been over this before. http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=184152
 
Fair enough, the correction is well taken. And I learned a lot in the bargain.

It's one of the most pervasive myths surrounding the war. I had a professor at Purdue flat-out state that no amount of evidence I could bring her would change her mind about this. I took no further classes with her. (And I got an A in her class because she knew I'd kill her in an appeal.)

The problem is that people don't go back to the source material anymore, at least not for WWII. "You should stop looking at that stuff and read what X has to say about it." Sorry, but I don't respect X for the reason that he didn't read the sources, he wrote about what Y had to say in response to Z.

I guess I have no future in academia. That's one bright spot.
 
It's one of the most pervasive myths surrounding the war. I had a professor at Purdue flat-out state that no amount of evidence I could bring her would change her mind about this. I took no further classes with her. (And I got an A in her class because she knew I'd kill her in an appeal.)

The problem is that people don't go back to the source material anymore, at least not for WWII. "You should stop looking at that stuff and read what X has to say about it." Sorry, but I don't respect X for the reason that he didn't read the sources, he wrote about what Y had to say in response to Z.

I guess I have no future in academia. That's one bright spot.

History repeats itself. Historians repeat each other.
 
It was a general disgust with the Germans, the telegram just topped that off.

Plus sabotage such as Black Tom and u-boats starting to sink US ships on February 1. Even then it wasn't until Wilson's entire cabinet voted for war that he was convinced. You also can't ignore Wilson's desire to influence the postwar peace settlement.
 
The same can be said for archaeologists. I remember a memorable fist fight amongst archaeologist in Cyprus over the consolidation of pottery nomenclature into one list
 
"The battle was so bitter because the prize was so small."

Hey there was nothing trivial about whether Late Cypriote base ring II jugs should be associated with the late Bronze Age level IIA or IIB. I mean it was worth fighting about! <chuckle>
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom