Merged Pearl Harbor: "Revisionists" vs. "Traditionalists"

First off, according to credible anecdotal evidence, FDR did not think so. That's number one.

Two, it is hard to fathom how some of you folks can think that "catching them in the act of trying" would have had anywhere near the emotional shock value of a devastating surprise attack.

If we follow the various "catch them in the act" scenarios, all sorts of thorny and potentially explosive questions would have arisen. If we had put PH on alert and caused the task force to turn around, that would hardly have jolted the American people into supporting going to war.

If we had pulled off the impossible stunt of putting PH alert without the local Japanese noticing it, and if our forces had then put up a terrific fight when the Japanese attacked, (1) our losses still would have been horrendous because we still would have been markedly outnumbered and outgunned. and (2) tons of troubling, potentially explosive questions would have arisen about foreknowledge. Also, a battle does not evoke the feelings of outrage and shock that a surprise attack evokes.

Again, we have credible anecdotal evidence that FDR believed that the only way the American people would support entering the war was for us to suffer a surprise attack and to incur substantial losses (though apparently the losses were more severe than he thought they would be).

What do you think. Would attacks on Wake, Midway and the Philipines be enough for war though?
 
Now that the election is over, I will be posting my (long awaited?) reply to Jacobsen's attack on Grogan in the near future. I received my copy of Grogan's "Record for Posterity" a couple weeks ago.

The first thing that jumped out at me as I read Grogan's report was how Jacobsen misrepresents what Grogan said about his bearings and the location of the ships he was hearing. And, mind you, that misrepresentation is Jacobsen's entire basis for claiming that Grogan's bearings were off by 18 and 44 degrees.

Kido Butai did not transmit.
 
First off, according to credible anecdotal evidence, FDR did not think so. That's number one.

Two, it is hard to fathom how some of you folks can think that "catching them in the act of trying" would have had anywhere near the emotional shock value of a devastating surprise attack.

If we follow the various "catch them in the act" scenarios, all sorts of thorny and potentially explosive questions would have arisen. If we had put PH on alert and caused the task force to turn around, that would hardly have jolted the American people into supporting going to war.

If we had pulled off the impossible stunt of putting PH alert without the local Japanese noticing it, and if our forces had then put up a terrific fight when the Japanese attacked, (1) our losses still would have been horrendous because we still would have been markedly outnumbered and outgunned. and (2) tons of troubling, potentially explosive questions would have arisen about foreknowledge. Also, a battle does not evoke the feelings of outrage and shock that a surprise attack evokes.

Again, we have credible anecdotal evidence that FDR believed that the only way the American people would support entering the war was for us to suffer a surprise attack and to incur substantial losses (though apparently the losses were more severe than he thought they would be).

You mean illogical hearsay evidence. Your premise just doesn't work.
 
There's a very stupid question that irks me about all this.

Didn't the Japanese cross half the ocean covertly in a meticulously laid plan to strike by surprise a base on US soil, no to mention simultaneously invade several pacific places including the Philippines which for all intents or purpose was a sort of US colony defended by US troops?

No matter the outcome or foreknowledge, doesn't that mean the USA is at war with Japan anyway as the result of a clear aggressive intent that expected to start by a sneak move (with at best a thirty minutes delay after some sort of declaration that wasn't done in time)?

The whole "alternative" FDR-knew seems to place a lot of importance on the outrage over the attack, but would that have changed a lot of things?

EDIT: I see Corsair115 raised that already. The LIHOP seems to make so little sense on its very premise...
 
Last edited:
There's a very stupid question that irks me about all this.

Didn't the Japanese cross half the ocean covertly in a meticulously laid plan to strike by surprise a base on US soil, no to mention simultaneously invade several pacific places including the Philippines which for all intents or purpose was a sort of US colony defended by US troops?

No matter the outcome or foreknowledge, doesn't that mean the USA is at war with Japan anyway as the result of a clear aggressive intent that expected to start by a sneak move (with at best a thirty minutes delay after some sort of declaration that wasn't done in time)?

The whole "alternative" FDR-knew seems to place a lot of importance on the outrage over the attack, but would that have changed a lot of things?
That's how reality would have worked, but CTers don't like reality, it's so annoying.
 
First off, according to credible anecdotal evidence, FDR did not think so. That's number one.

Credible anecdotal evidence from whom? Just saying it doesn't make it so.

What was said, who was it said to, what was the context, when was it reported, how did the person doing the reporting come into possession of the quote? Little questions that would allow people to make a reasoned evaluation of the matter.

Two, it is hard to fathom how some of you folks can think that "catching them in the act of trying" would have had anywhere near the emotional shock value of a devastating surprise attack.

To the generals and admirals on say December 5, 1941 - "We have credible intelligence that a major Japanese naval task force is steaming towards Pearl Harbour, the Phillipines and towards Hong Kong. Take all necessary measures to protect military assets. Fleet to sortie ASAP and proceed to (co-ord). Engagement is authorized."

To the American people December 6 or 7, 1941 - "The US Navy, and US Army Air Corps, detected and engaged a Japanese Naval Task force in the North Pacific which was in the process of launching an attack on US possessions at Hawaii and Wake Island, with heavy casualties on both sides. The Phillipines have also been attacked in a nearly simultaneous attack by Japanese Imperial Forces. As of this moment, the United States is at war with the Empire of Japan."

Either way, you're at war.

If we follow the various "catch them in the act" scenarios, all sorts of thorny and potentially explosive questions would have arisen. If we had put PH on alert and caused the task force to turn around, that would hardly have jolted the American people into supporting going to war.

You still have to deal with the attack on the Phillipines.

If we had pulled off the impossible stunt of putting PH alert without the local Japanese noticing it, and if our forces had then put up a terrific fight when the Japanese attacked, (1) our losses still would have been horrendous because we still would have been markedly outnumbered and outgunned. and (2) tons of troubling, potentially explosive questions would have arisen about foreknowledge. Also, a battle does not evoke the feelings of outrage and shock that a surprise attack evokes.

You're still hypothesizing that the Japanese agents could have gotten word to Japan in 24-48 hours, who then would have been able to get word to the fleet in time.

You still have the effect of a sneak attack, its just then you get the added morale boosting effect that the int boys were able to detect the sneak attack and neutralize it. Given that the US would have gone from "tense, but still peace" to "war" in a very short period of time you still would have had the shock to the system of the general population.

Again, we have credible anecdotal evidence that FDR believed that the only way the American people would support entering the war was for us to suffer a surprise attack and to incur substantial losses (though apparently the losses were more severe than he thought they would be).

Again, your source for said anecdote.
 
Last edited:
First off, according to credible anecdotal evidence, FDR did not think so. That's number one.

Two, it is hard to fathom how some of you folks can think that "catching them in the act of trying" would have had anywhere near the emotional shock value of a devastating surprise attack.

If we follow the various "catch them in the act" scenarios, all sorts of thorny and potentially explosive questions would have arisen. If we had put PH on alert and caused the task force to turn around, that would hardly have jolted the American people into supporting going to war.

If we had pulled off the impossible stunt of putting PH alert without the local Japanese noticing it, and if our forces had then put up a terrific fight when the Japanese attacked, (1) our losses still would have been horrendous because we still would have been markedly outnumbered and outgunned. and (2) tons of troubling, potentially explosive questions would have arisen about foreknowledge. Also, a battle does not evoke the feelings of outrage and shock that a surprise attack evokes.

Again, we have credible anecdotal evidence that FDR believed that the only way the American people would support entering the war was for us to suffer a surprise attack and to incur substantial losses (though apparently the losses were more severe than he thought they would be).

So the Japanese declaring war against the US wouldn't have been sufficient? Capturing a US warship? Sinking US merchant ships - beside attacking Guam etc?

You live in a strange little world

LOL
 
Last edited:
bobtaftfan, here's a question for you.

Let's say that the Pearl Harbor attack never happened at all. No Kido Butai, no sinking of the Arizona, nothing. However, let's also say that everything else the Japanese did happened exactly the same as it happened historically - the Japanese attack and land invasion of the Philippines, the declaration of war issued by the Emperor, and so on.

How would FDR's plans (you know, the ones that led him to allow the Pearl Harbor attack to proceed despite his foreknowledge) be affected by that? What did FDR accomplish by letting the Pearl Harbor attack occur that he would not have been able to accomplish had the attack never even happened in the first place, but everything else mentioned above did happen?
 
Gawdzilla, and the rest (not including bobtaftfan) . This has been a great thread! thanks. I used some of what I learned here in my lecture on WWII today, and was able to answer some student questions after class. thanks!!!!! :D
 
There's a very stupid question that irks me about all this.

Didn't the Japanese cross half the ocean covertly in a meticulously laid plan to strike by surprise a base on US soil, no to mention simultaneously invade several pacific places including the Philippines which for all intents or purpose was a sort of US colony defended by US troops?

No matter the outcome or foreknowledge, doesn't that mean the USA is at war with Japan anyway as the result of a clear aggressive intent that expected to start by a sneak move (with at best a thirty minutes delay after some sort of declaration that wasn't done in time)?

The whole "alternative" FDR-knew seems to place a lot of importance on the outrage over the attack, but would that have changed a lot of things?

Not if you believe William Sanders: In his story "Billy Mitchell's Overt Act" he has Mitchell taking his lumps and then being assigned to be air commander in Hawaii in 1941. He patrols aggressively, sees the Kido Butai coming in, and launches an attack on the carriers.

Somehow, this grossly divides American attitudes on the Japanese aggression, and enthusiasm for fighting is severely weakened. I wonder what Sanders would say about this thread.

Story Listing:
http://www.uchronia.net/bib.cgi/label.html?id=sandbillym

Discussion of the story (and other PH conspiracy material, and in fact other conspiracies):
http://www.uwgb.edu/dutchs/PSEUDOSC/ConspirThx.htm

:blackcat:
 
The IJN fleet would have had to be spotted quite far at sea for any doubt on its explicitly attacking purpose to be viable...

To be honest, I only became aware of the basic context -which makes the whole CT absurd- of the Japanese offensive pretty late, and I would suspect this is true for a lot of people that have little to no interest in history.

Maybe there's an argument to be had that the offensive without Pearl Harbor altogether would be met with a different response by the public opinion -although I find it hard to believe USA would have hesitated to enter a war declared upon them-, but the IJN massive presence near PH in the larger context of this day (or days) could only have been understood as a way to search a surprise engagement of the USN.
 
An interesting letter regarding the ABC-1 talks. Your attention is invited to Para. 10.

BTW, the ABC-1 talks drew a line in the sand beyond which the Japanese could not go without faciing armed resistance from the Allies.

In addition, these talks firmed up the "Germany First" rule. It was confirmed at the Atlantic Conference and formally announced at Casablanca, IIRC.
 

Attachments

  • ABC-1 letter.jpg
    ABC-1 letter.jpg
    149.3 KB · Views: 17
Not if you believe William Sanders: In his story "Billy Mitchell's Overt Act" he has Mitchell taking his lumps and then being assigned to be air commander in Hawaii in 1941. He patrols aggressively, sees the Kido Butai coming in, and launches an attack on the carriers.

...and misses, because Mitchell could only hit his targets by cheating.

:p
 
Not if you believe William Sanders: In his story "Billy Mitchell's Overt Act" he has Mitchell taking his lumps and then being assigned to be air commander in Hawaii in 1941. He patrols aggressively, sees the Kido Butai coming in, and launches an attack on the carriers.

...and misses, because Mitchell could only hit his targets by cheating.
:p

Which may be why Sanders had Mitchell crash his bomber into the Kaga.

:D

:blackcat:
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom