Merged Pearl Harbor: "Revisionists" vs. "Traditionalists"

I have discussed this twice already. And I take it you still have not bothered to read Villa and Wilford's reply to Jacobsen's attack on Grogan.

The Japanese fleet broke radio silence because they thought it was safe to do so since they were using low-power LF. They didn't think those signals could be heard beyond a short range and that therefore there was no one close enough to hear them.
...
Did you obtain that information from Japanese records? If not, do their records corroborate the claim? Why have you consistently ignored what Japan says happened?
 
Either he is the world's worse researcher or he has seen the Japanese records, noted that they don't support his silly claims and just acts like they don't exist


Bob what do you think of the Japanese declaration of war against the British and the United States?

Here is a Japanese document from the US records - just to show you that they have them....lol

http://www.ibiblio.org/pha/myths/matsum_1.html

and here is a translation of the printed declaration of war, however the ambassadors of such countries were told before this was printed

http://files.abovetopsecret.com/files/img/nm50954231.gif
 
Last edited:
I have discussed this twice already. And I take it you still have not bothered to read Villa and Wilford's reply to Jacobsen's attack on Grogan.

The Japanese fleet broke radio silence because they thought it was safe to do so since they were using low-power LF.


As already explained to you, LF has a greater range than HF.


From around 31 November to 3 December, the task force encountered horrific weather that included dense fog, fierce winds, and enormous waves. Communication via lamps/lights would have ranged from ineffective to worthless in those conditions.


Citation needed for these alleged weather conditions. Do you have the fleet's hourly weather logs?

Citation needed for the luminosity of the ship's yardarm blinkers. Then you can do the math to figure out the visual range of the yardarm blinkers given the meteorological visibility, then you can compare that to the distances between the ships in the fleet. The formula to do this is in the United States Coast Guard Navigation Rules, Annex I, section 8.


So they resorted to low-power LF transmissions to coordinate, ...


Coordinate what? Everything was planned in advance. Are you suggesting they forgot to give all the ships in the attack fleet the track they intended to follow?
 
So the entire counter-argument seems to be "they did so transmit because I say so!"?
 
The Japanese fleet broke radio silence because they thought it was safe to do so since they were using low-power LF. They didn't think those signals could be heard beyond a short range and that therefore there was no one close enough to hear them.


Now all you need to do is supply the proof. What do Japanese records say about it?

From around 31 November to 3 December, the task force encountered horrific weather that included dense fog, fierce winds, and enormous waves. Communication via lamps/lights would have ranged from ineffective to worthless in those conditions. So they resorted to low-power LF transmissions to coordinate, thinking it was safe to do so.


Now all you need to do is supply the proof. What do Japanese records say about it?


That is an absurd argument from a logical standpoint alone, and we have credible anecdotal evidence that FDR believed that only a substantial attack would generate enough outrage to get a majority of the public to support entering the war.


You've asserted this but you have not supplied supporting direct evidence. (You're basing your case on anecdotal evidence? Really?) And in any case, it doesn't matter. Attacking the Philippines would have resulted in war, Pearl Harbor or not.


But FDR needed a surprise attack, not a regular battle.


You've asserted this but you have not supplied supporting evidence. And in any case, it doesn't matter. Attacking the Philippines would have resulted in war, Pearl Harbor or not.


FDR egregiously miscalculated. He thought that an attack on Pearl would be bad, but not nearly as bad as it ended up being. Similarly, he didn't think that MacArthur's forces would suffer the catastrophic defeat that they ended up suffering. That was why FDR and his accomplices engaged in such a vicious, determined cover-up.


Your own words are the best reply to the above: "This is getting into silly territory." Do you even read your own words? When you write them, do you not realize how crazy they sound? Yes, a cover-up that only a determined few like yourself can ferret out, while large numbers of historians and scholars cannot and are oblivious to it. Or instead are they all secret FDR fans pledged to support the great conspiracy? I guess the Japanese must be in on it too, since they have falsified their records to say their fleet didn't transmit a bunch of radio messages when they did.

Man, that's one wide-ranging conspiracy that's being posited! (All that's missing is for MaGZ or one of his compatriots to chime in and say it's all because of the Jews!)
 
Last edited:
Either he is the world's worse researcher or he has seen the Japanese records, noted that they don't support his silly claims and just acts like they don't exist
..
C: Deliberately ignoring them because he fears they say something bad for his argument.

Ergo asked for a statistic once. I gave him three links. He said he tried 2 and they weren't right, so he didn't bother with the third. The first link was to the Wikipedia article clearly stating the statistic. He never said why he apparently skipped the one most likely to have the answer. In fact, IIRC, he left the thread for a while. Curious.

So the entire counter-argument seems to be "they did so transmit because I say so!"?

And "Japanese records? What Japanese records? I don't know what you're talking about!"

I wish he'd double down already and say the Japanese records were "clearly" altered post-war.
 
Wouldn't LF be the absolute worst way to transmit?

Almost no way you would gamble there regardless of power.
 
I've been waiting for him to declare all Japanese records were faked that is what most CT do

To include the Japanese declaration of war against the US and Britain. Why would FDR need anything more than that? lol
 
Kido Butai did not transmit. The idea is absurdly stupid. You do not try to sneak up on an enemy bases while broadcasting Glenn Miller tunes.

How about blasting Hank Williams Jr.?



It's odd having a song written in 1970 playing in a WWII movie. :)
 
How about blasting Hank Williams Jr.?



It's odd having a song written in 1970 playing in a WWII movie. :)

Not that odd if you are going for the absurdity of the moment. The whole movie is about the irony of anti-hero types being seen as heroes. It's a bit off topic, but the video is cool.
 
Kido Butai did not transmit. The idea is absurdly stupid. You do not try to sneak up on an enemy bases while broadcasting Glenn Miller tunes.

Aww c'mon. Moonlight Serenade is such a soothing song. :)

On a seriousnote, why would the IJN be dumb enough to give away operational security to begin with.

On the off chance that weather didn't cooperate or any other legitimate reason the attack would have been postponed, wouldn't you call it off and retry when the element of surprise was still in you favor?
 
Aww c'mon. Moonlight Serenade is such a soothing song. :)

On a seriousnote, why would the IJN be dumb enough to give away operational security to begin with.

On the off chance that weather didn't cooperate or any other legitimate reason the attack would have been postponed, wouldn't you call it off and retry when the element of surprise was still in you favor?

Every single document found after WWII that mentioned radio silence with regard to Kido Butai stated quite clearly it was strictly observed. Every surviving officer that had knowledge of the events concurred. There is simple no reason on Sauron's green Earth to believe they transmitted.
 
Every single document found after WWII that mentioned radio silence with regard to Kido Butai stated quite clearly it was strictly observed. Every surviving officer that had knowledge of the events concurred. There is simple no reason on Sauron's green Earth to believe they transmitted.

Please don't think that I'm disagreeing with you.

They had their orders and knew what they were supposed to do. They had the element of secrecy and were not going to give that up.
 
The British, French, Spanish, Dutch, Danish, Swedes and Portuguese were able during the centuries before radio to keep large fleet together (usally) - with some success, sea keeping ability and the management of doing so was taught to the Japanese by the British and they had taken the lesson well.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom