Merged Pearl Harbor: "Revisionists" vs. "Traditionalists"

The British, French, Spanish, Dutch, Danish, Swedes and Portuguese were able during the centuries before radio to keep large fleet together (usally) - with some success, sea keeping ability and the management of doing so was taught to the Japanese by the British and they had taken the lesson well.

To be fair, they always had rally points for the fleets because some of them would get lost if the weather was foul. The IJN just ran a straight line course, so ships that feel behind just had to steam due east until they caught up.
 
I've been waiting for him to declare all Japanese records were faked that is what most CT do

To include the Japanese declaration of war against the US and Britain. Why would FDR need anything more than that? lol

At which point someone would point out some Japanese testimony which doubtless exists.

Every single document found after WWII that mentioned radio silence with regard to Kido Butai stated quite clearly it was strictly observed. Every surviving officer that had knowledge of the events concurred. There is simple no reason on Sauron's green Earth to believe they transmitted.

Just like that, for example.
 
To be fair, they always had rally points for the fleets because some of them would get lost if the weather was foul. The IJN just ran a straight line course, so ships that feel behind just had to steam due east until they caught up.
I'm sure there were contingency plans for ships "gone missing"? Not so much a question about such plans existing, I'm just curious if such IJN plans/intentions survived`to be in the historical record.
 
I'm sure there were contingency plans for ships "gone missing"? Not so much a question about such plans existing, I'm just curious if such IJN plans/intentions survived`to be in the historical record.

Yep, the ships that couldn't keep up for any reason were to lie doggo until after the attack and the retirement phase. If one ship was completely unable to operate it would be abandoned.
 
I'm sure each ship in the Kido Butai was issued the intended track. A track includes position (lat & long), dates and times to arrive at each position, and SOA (Speed Of Advance, the speed required to arrive at the next point on time). The modern US Navy track promulgation system is called the MOVREP (Movement Reporting) system. Here is a very detailed guide: http://www.fas.org/man/dod-101/navy/docs/swos/ops/72-7.html Ships must remain within a certain distance left or right of the track (e.g. 20 miles) and must not move too far ahead or too far behind PIM (Position of Intended Movement, a point on the track that moves at the speed of advance). If you stay exactly on top of PIM you will arrive at the next point on time. PIM is annotated on the navigation charts at hourly intervals so the navigation team can monitor their progress along the track. The MOVREP system was started because several organizations failed to notice the USS Indianapolis did not arrive at her destination.

Because of the sensitive nature of submarine operations they did not use the MOVREP system except to check-in to it when arriving at a port. When a sub got underway it would check-out of the system. Submarine operating authorities started a similar system after the collapse of the Soviet Union, called the SUBNOTE system. Before the SUBNOTE system every submarine operating authority had their own system and format for issuing tracks. My first shore command after serving on my first sub was at ComSubGru Seven where I generated, plotted, and issued via message about 500 tracks for the submarines assigned to our area. We spelled out each point designation in our messages; ALPHA, BRAVO, CHARLIE, etc. Ugh. Every month for the three years I was there I tried to get it changed to A, B, C, but without success.
 
Last edited:
They have a pretty simple navigation job, get to the hold point then turn southeast.


Did the fleet "darken ship", i.e. not use their running lights at night and ensure all sources of internal lighting were not visible from the outside? If they did then it would be very easy for ships to drift apart on a moonless night. But following the track and PIM it would be a routine thing to rejoin the group at twilight.
 
Did the fleet "darken ship", i.e. not use their running lights at night and ensure all sources of internal lighting were not visible from the outside? If they did then it would be very easy for ships to drift apart on a moonless night. But following the track and PIM it would be a routine thing to rejoin the group at twilight.

They did darken ship, but showed navigation lights. (Darken ship, properly, is showing no unnecessary lights outside the ship, like port holes, etc. (Working from memory here, too lazy to go into the cavern and dig out that book.)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom