Merged Pearl Harbor: "Revisionists" vs. "Traditionalists"

What I recall the Japanese being most interested about the Taranto raid was how the British were able to drop airborne torpedoes in the relatively shallow waters of the harbour. The answer, it was discovered, was fitting wooden fins to the torpedoes, which prevented them from going too deep after being dropped from the aircraft.

Do tell.
(Kudos to Dan Virgilio.)
 

Attachments

  • type91_torpedo_devirgilio_art.jpg
    type91_torpedo_devirgilio_art.jpg
    107.5 KB · Views: 25
My copy of Grogan's report to the Matson Line just arrived--like half an hour ago. I can tell you this much right away: Jacobsen brazenly misrepresented what Grogan said about his bearings and the location of the Japanese ships. It is hard to see how this could have been an innocent mistake.

I will have more to say in a few days, once I've had a chance to read over Grogan's report a few more times and then to go over and add to my previous comments about Jacobsen's Lurline article.
 
Might you someday address the issue of why a Japanese fleet on a top secret, risky mission would be transmitting so many radio messages? Might you someday address the fact that the U.S. did not need the attack on Pearl Harbor to be successful in order to be at war with Japan since the mere attempt of an attack would have been more than sufficient justification? Might you someday address the fact that the attack on Pearl Harbor wasn't needed at all to get war between the U.S. and Japan, the Japanese assault upon the Philippines would have been more than sufficient?
 
Might you someday address the issue of why a Japanese fleet on a top secret, risky mission would be transmitting so many radio messages? Might you someday address the fact that the U.S. did not need the attack on Pearl Harbor to be successful in order to be at war with Japan since the mere attempt of an attack would have been more than sufficient justification? Might you someday address the fact that the attack on Pearl Harbor wasn't needed at all to get war between the U.S. and Japan, the Japanese assault upon the Philippines would have been more than sufficient?

Well Im sure you can already answer that. Bobtaftfan is determined to flog this minutiae of radio bearings to death in search of the 'smoking gun' beloved of CTs. They all seem to imagine the evidence for the reality of a particular event is a house of cards and if only they pull out the right one it will all come tumbling down. In reality it's more like jigsaw puzzle; yanking out one piece doesn't change what the picture is.
 
Well Im sure you can already answer that. Bobtaftfan is determined to flog this minutiae of radio bearings to death in search of the 'smoking gun' beloved of CTs. They all seem to imagine the evidence for the reality of a particular event is a house of cards and if only they pull out the right one it will all come tumbling down. In reality it's more like jigsaw puzzle; yanking out one piece doesn't change what the picture is.

He's reading from a script and doesn't realized that the stage is a pit and the audience is just laughing at him
 
Might you someday address the issue of why a Japanese fleet on a top secret, risky mission would be transmitting so many radio messages? Might you someday address the fact that the U.S. did not need the attack on Pearl Harbor to be successful in order to be at war with Japan since the mere attempt of an attack would have been more than sufficient justification? Might you someday address the fact that the attack on Pearl Harbor wasn't needed at all to get war between the U.S. and Japan, the Japanese assault upon the Philippines would have been more than sufficient?

True that.
Hawaii wasn't even a state of the USA in 1941; that didn't happen until 1959. At the time, Hawaii was a US Territory, just the same as Guam, Wake Island, Micronesia, the Marshall Islands. Attacks on those were/would have been politically no more or less serious than the attack on Pearl, and just as good a reason for the war with Japan to start.
 
As were the capture of a US warship and the sinking of merchant ships on December 7/8.

A bit difficult to misread those as anything but warlike acts......but bobtaftfan is off in some other alternative dimension........
 
My copy of Grogan's report to the Matson Line just arrived--like half an hour ago. I can tell you this much right away: Jacobsen brazenly misrepresented what Grogan said about his bearings and the location of the Japanese ships. It is hard to see how this could have been an innocent mistake.

I will have more to say in a few days, once I've had a chance to read over Grogan's report a few more times and then to go over and add to my previous comments about Jacobsen's Lurline article.

Kido Butai did not transmit. Ergo, your quibbles are moot.
 
Any of you precisionist folks want a list of the noon sightings for the Kido Butai for every day of the trip? This would provide hard data locations to compare with Groggy's DF work.


Heck yeah I want it. Do you have the morning and evening star sightings, too?
 
Not sure. I have some docs coming by FedEx from Tokyo. Monday, I think.


The more fixes the better. Do the docs include a record of ordered courses and speeds? That would be sweet. If they're in English that would be even sweeter!
 
The more fixes the better. Do the docs include a record of ordered courses and speeds? That would be sweet. If they're in English that would be even sweeter!

I'm getting getting copies of various decklogs printed in the Manichi Shimbun (for give the spelling, Sato-san) in 1952, reprinted from the original surviving documents. I'll check these against another source I have and report back.
 
I'm getting getting copies of various decklogs printed in the Manichi Shimbun (for give the spelling, Sato-san) in 1952, reprinted from the original surviving documents. I'll check these against another source I have and report back.

Yes but do you have a log of the messages not sent/CT mode
 
Might you someday address the issue of why a Japanese fleet on a top secret, risky mission would be transmitting so many radio messages?

I have discussed this twice already. And I take it you still have not bothered to read Villa and Wilford's reply to Jacobsen's attack on Grogan.

The Japanese fleet broke radio silence because they thought it was safe to do so since they were using low-power LF. They didn't think those signals could be heard beyond a short range and that therefore there was no one close enough to hear them. As Farago noted, the German Navy made the same mistake in WW I.

From around 31 November to 3 December, the task force encountered horrific weather that included dense fog, fierce winds, and enormous waves. Communication via lamps/lights would have ranged from ineffective to worthless in those conditions. So they resorted to low-power LF transmissions to coordinate, thinking it was safe to do so.

For more on the myth of radio silence, see Villa and Wilford's reply to Jacobsen:

“Signals intelligence and Pearl Harbor: The State of the Question,” Intelligence and National Security, 21:4, 2006, pp. 520-556, http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/02684520600885665).

Might you someday address the fact that the U.S. did not need the attack on Pearl Harbor to be successful in order to be at war with Japan since the mere attempt of an attack would have been more than sufficient justification?

That is an absurd argument from a logical standpoint alone, and we have credible anecdotal evidence that FDR believed that only a substantial attack would generate enough outrage to get a majority of the public to support entering the war.

Every attack-attempt-only scenario that you can posit would involve huge risks of exposure of FDR's foreknowledge, which in turn would have raised all sorts of questions and objections.

Furthermore, previous incidents where small numbers of American lives were lost in German attacks had proven insufficient to cause the public to call for the enormous step of entering the war in Europe (and keep in mind that that was FDR's main goal). Many Americans were aware or suspected that FDR was pursuing a confrontational policy in the Atlantic, so they were not about to support a call for war over such incidents, even though they had no use for Hitler.

Might you someday address the fact that the attack on Pearl Harbor wasn't needed at all to get war between the U.S. and Japan, the Japanese assault upon the Philippines would have been more than sufficient?

This is getting into silly territory. I've already talked about the evidence that FDR likewise used our forces in the Philippines as bait, that he brazenly misled MacArthur about his intention to reinforce the Philippines, etc., etc.

But FDR needed a surprise attack, not a regular battle. Given the location of the Philippines and the disposition of the various forces in the region, a surprise attack would have been impossible to claim. Not even the most gullible people alive would believe that FDR and other high officials "had no idea" that the Japanese were going to attack the Philippines.

FDR egregiously miscalculated. He thought that an attack on Pearl would be bad, but not nearly as bad as it ended up being. Similarly, he didn't think that MacArthur's forces would suffer the catastrophic defeat that they ended up suffering. That was why FDR and his accomplices engaged in such a vicious, determined cover-up.

What must be faced is the credible evidence that FDR and other high officials knew the Japanese were going to attack Pearl Harbor: the Dies disclosure, the Don C. Smith disclosure (via his daughter, Helen Hamman), the Stahlman disclosure, the Burns disclosure, the Ranneft diary, the mutually corroborating disclosures of Ogg and Hosmer, the fierce attempt to suppress the Magic intercepts, the ludicrous lies about why Kimmel and Short were cut off from Magic in November and December, the bizarre decision to move the Pacific Fleet to Pearl Harbor, the Vacant Sea order (issued shortly after the Kido Butai began its journey--my, what a coincidence), Marshall and Stark's surreal actions on December 7, the Gillette disclosure (via his nephew, Thomas Gillette), the Ketchum disclosure, the mutually corroborating disclosures of Cavendish-Bentick and Ridsdale, the Seymour disclosure, the mass of disclosures about the existence of the Winds execute message, etc., etc., etc.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom