Merged Pearl Harbor: "Revisionists" vs. "Traditionalists"

Love it. Please let me know when it's ready.

I'd like to see that myself. I wonder which foreign naval officers were involved in that exercise?

Gawdzilla were you able to find anything on how the Japanese Sub transmitted to the main fleet. Been driving me crazy trying to find that....any luck?
 
Whether an Japanese knew of this is unknown to me however they were influenced by the British attack on Italian fleet at Taranto, with 21 obsolete aircraft they sunk one battleship and damage two more for the loss of just two aircraft

Whether or not the Japanese observed all or part of the 1932 maneuvers, their primary inspiration was the British attack on the Italian fleet at Taranto (Operation JudgementWP) in November 1940.

So, have the Japanese ever actually acknowledged or stated that Operation Judgement was their inspiration?

Love it. Please let me know when it's ready.

I have scanned it, made it into a PDF and uploaded it to my public dropbox folder, but this system wont let me post a link to it so I am going to try sending you a PM with the link instead.

Let me know if you get it.
 
I have scanned it, made it into a PDF and uploaded it to my public dropbox folder, but this system wont let me post a link to it so I am going to try sending you a PM with the link instead.

Let me know if you get it.
Post the link with spaces inserted, like W W W, and one of us will fix it, simples.
 
So, have the Japanese ever actually acknowledged or stated that Operation Judgement was their inspiration?


Genda (aforementioned by Gawdzilla) claimed that it had no influence on the conception or planning for Pearl Harbor attack, and he may well have sincerely believed this; however, the fact that the IJN studied the British operation in great detail during 1941 indicates that it most likely did have at least some influence. See notes 10 through 14 of the Wikipedia article I linked.
 
I'd like to see that myself. I wonder which foreign naval officers were involved in that exercise?

Gawdzilla were you able to find anything on how the Japanese Sub transmitted to the main fleet. Been driving me crazy trying to find that....any luck?

Just a table of frequencies for various units during the big push. I have other resources, but the bastard's in Cancun right now, and he won't be sober until the 9th, earliest.
 
Genda (aforementioned by Gawdzilla) claimed that it had no influence on the conception or planning for Pearl Harbor attack, and he may well have sincerely believed this; however, the fact that the IJN studied the British operation in great detail during 1941 indicates that it most likely did have at least some influence. See notes 10 through 14 of the Wikipedia article I linked.

Genda doesn't mention Taranto at all in The Pearl Harbor Papers.
 
The story goes on to say that a Japanese spy network on the island observed what was happening, and reported what they saw back to Tokyo.

Are you saying that this account is completely false?

The story is only four pages long. I am prepared to scan and post the pages if you like, to show that I haven't just lifted this from some dubious internet site.

Okay, I've read it, and it is rather superficial and highly exaggerated in places. The similarities between the two attacks are highlighted, but without supporting hard data. Basically the author says, "two attacks occurred, so the first one must have inspired the second one."

And the size of the supposed Japanese spy network is very impressive. How this worked is not mentioned, probably because it didn't exist except in trashy spy novels of the '40s.

When I get the information on the FleetEx I'll post a note in this thread.
 
I find it hard to believe Taranto wasn't at least in the planners' knowledge.

ETA-Don't post while drunk (me)
 
Last edited:
Sorry.

I am no expert about the attack, not by a long shot. But anyone who looks at the evidence of what happened that day, and can conclude a US conspiracy. EDITED
 
Last edited:
What I recall the Japanese being most interested about the Taranto raid was how the British were able to drop airborne torpedoes in the relatively shallow waters of the harbour. The answer, it was discovered, was fitting wooden fins to the torpedoes, which prevented them from going too deep after being dropped from the aircraft.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom