Merged Pearl Harbor: "Revisionists" vs. "Traditionalists"

Well I looked it up as I did not know this. It was an episode of the "Man From Uncle" I also saw that.....

"Nimoy served as a sergeant in the U.S. Army from 1953 through 1955,[17] alongside fellow actor Ken Berry and architect Frank Gehry".

Frank Gehry was the Riddler in "Batman". Ken Berry was in "F-Troop". Imagine the joy on soldier's faces after serving under Nimoy, Berry & Gehry and seeing them later in Star Trek, F-Troop and Batman.

There were also all the WWII gunners who got to see James Doohan in the same series.

I got to meet him once at a mess dinner for surviving air OP pilots in the late 80s.
 
And don;t forget the effect that radiation has on some living organisms of making them Grow to Humengeous size.....

Well, I *have* been told that ... certain things about me are humongous, but never in the form of a complaint...
 
Can I turn the subject back to the OP?

I am new here and as you can see from my introduction (in the "Welcome" thread) I pretty much don't believe any of the common conspiracy theories,

Regarding Pearl Harbor, I am inclined to believe the "traditional" view rather then "revisionist" view, but I do have a couple of questions. I may be shaky on the facts surrounding those questions and I will use (?) to indicate that, so please correct any misconceptions

1. Has there ever been a satisfactory reason given for why the Carriers left only days (?) before the attack?

2. Was there any plausible reason given why the mobile radar (?) system that they got from the British (?) failed to detect the Japanese fleet?

3. Was it standard practice for the USAAF to park their aircraft in neat, straight rows (?) so that a potential enemy ground attack aircraft could easily damage/destroy them with single strafing runs.

4. Has there ever been a reason given why the Japanese strike force did not send the third wave of aircraft (?) to deliver the coup de grace, given that they had the base on its knees.

Also, about 40 years ago (as a teenager) I read a short account in a book about the WWII that suggested Japanese attack plan for Pearl Harbor was very similar to a "mock" attack planned and executed by the US Navy nine years earlier, right down to the number of squadrons and the types of weapons and aircraft used. Is this true or not?
 
Can I turn the subject back to the OP?

I am new here and as you can see from my introduction (in the "Welcome" thread) I pretty much don't believe any of the common conspiracy theories,

Regarding Pearl Harbor, I am inclined to believe the "traditional" view rather then "revisionist" view, but I do have a couple of questions. I may be shaky on the facts surrounding those questions and I will use (?) to indicate that, so please correct any misconceptions

1. Has there ever been a satisfactory reason given for why the Carriers left only days (?) before the attack?

2. Was there any plausible reason given why the mobile radar (?) system that they got from the British (?) failed to detect the Japanese fleet?

3. Was it standard practice for the USAAF to park their aircraft in neat, straight rows (?) so that a potential enemy ground attack aircraft could easily damage/destroy them with single strafing runs.

4. Has there ever been a reason given why the Japanese strike force did not send the third wave of aircraft (?) to deliver the coup de grace, given that they had the base on its knees.

Also, about 40 years ago (as a teenager) I read a short account in a book about the WWII that suggested Japanese attack plan for Pearl Harbor was very similar to a "mock" attack planned and executed by the US Navy nine years earlier, right down to the number of squadrons and the types of weapons and aircraft used. Is this true or not?

1.
It was suspected by the US that war with Japan was imminent. So the Enterprise and the Lexington were tasked to ferry aircraft to Wake and Midway. To better prepare them for defense.
Saratoga had to go to the west coast for repairs, which is sensible if you suspect you have to use that ship in the near future.

2.
It was totally new, with not a lot of people trained to use it yet. Those were not the days like today where about everybody has some sort of radar (even small yachts have them today). So the most sensible time to use the radar you have (you can only use it for so many hours par day, because of lack of trained operators) would be at night. During the day you might do without, because then people can see the sky better.

3.
Because war was thought to be imminent and with it the risk of saboteurs. It was thought better to park the airplanes together to better guard them. How would people have judged it then, when Japan would have attacked the Philipines first (as the US thought they would do) and the planes at Pearl Harbor were destroyed by saboteurs because they were dispersed?

4.
Because of the absence of the US carriers.
As long as you don't know where the only vessels capable of hurting your fleet are, it is very unwise to send away the only attack force that could hurt them and protect you.
Aside from that. Pearl Harbour wasn't exactly on it's knees. Witness the Japanese losses between the raids (nine in the first wave, twenty in the second wave, with many more damaged). How many planes would they lose in a third wave? Planes (and more their pilots) they would certainly going to need in the coming operations against Wake, the Philipines, Dutch East India and more.

The other thing I don't know anything about.
 
Last edited:
1. Has there ever been a satisfactory reason given for why the Carriers left only days (?) before the attack?
Which Carriers (by which I assume you mean aircraft carriers) do you mean? The US had 7 at that point:

Enterprise and Lexington were escorting fighter squadrons to Wake Island and Midway.

Enterprise *was* supposed to have been back December 6 but storms prevented her arrival.

She was close enough, tho, that her own aircraft were shot at by friendly fire during the attack.


Hornet was off Norfolk VA undergoing a shakedown cruise, which was also where Yorktown and Ranger were -- nowhere near Pearl.

Saratoga was at least in the right ocean, but was in San Diego while Wasp was at anchor in the Atlantic.

So who was it that you have heard left "just days before"?
2. Was there any plausible reason given why the mobile radar (?) system that they got from the British (?) failed to detect the Japanese fleet?
Again -- who was it that told you it didn't?

On That Day, the Opana Radar Site detected approaching aircraft at 7:02 a.m. This was well after the end of the site's scheduled operating day.

Again, this was a matter of luck: they were detected because the transport to take PVTs Lockard and Elliot back to base for breakfast was late and they were goofing with the equipment (which, BTW, had been developed by the US).

The info went to Fort Shafter, were it was assumed that the contact was a flight of Army B-17's who were scheduled to arrive that morning and Opana was advised not to worry.

Still goofing, Elliot and Lockard continued plotting the incoming planes until 7:40 when contact was lost.

They went to get their breakfast, only to hear about the attack when they got there. They skipped breakfast and hauled *** back to Opana, where they monitored the attack until it ended.
3. Was it standard practice for the USAAF to park their aircraft in neat, straight rows (?) so that a potential enemy ground attack aircraft could easily damage/destroy them with single strafing runs.
Yes, it was and is -- because it also makes it much easier to get them in the air without crashing into each other.
4. Has there ever been a reason given why the Japanese strike force did not send the third wave of aircraft (?) to deliver the coup de grace, given that they had the base on its knees.
Actually, four generally accepted reasons, in no particular order:

1. The Japanese didn't really know how close Enterprise and Lexington were.

2. They realized that their carriers were now within range of land based bombers, and they had no idea how many could be brought to bear.

3. After the initial surprize, the US really was kicking ***: nearly two thirds of their losses came from the second strike. Had a third strike proceeded, this would have continued -- some estimates of the academic "what if" crowd run to 3/4.

4. And finally, the clock was running. Basically only the Brits were good at night carrier landings at that point, and a third wave would have required quite a bit on on the job training (and associated losses) that the Japanese simply weren't will to risk

I would personally add that having crippled the Pacific fleet was enough -- there was no strategic advantage in total destruction.

Also, about 40 years ago (as a teenager) I read a short account in a book about the WWII that suggested Japanese attack plan for Pearl Harbor was very similar to a "mock" attack planned and executed by the US Navy nine years earlier, right down to the number of squadrons and the types of weapons and aircraft used. Is this true or not?
I won't go down to the numbers and types, but yes a mock attack was staged in '33 and monitored by the Japanese. They followed that example pretty much exactly -- including the fact that ships were taken out, but not facilities. Had the latter happened, maybe another three? four? years of war -- but no change in the final outcome.

HTH.
 
Last edited:
I seem to have started a bit of a derail. :o
Thanks for that! I like to point out the scene in "Fat Man and Little Boy" where the core goes active and they sort out who got fatal doses by distance. Only the one guy dies ... right away.

Two things to add: The plans to use the atomic bombs in the invasion of Japan called for them to be used against strongpoints, and then the troops would be sent in one half hour later, when it was safe.

AND: The US was conducting training into the '50s that had troops lined up to watch an atomic bomb go off so they'd be ready for the effects in case battlefield nukes were needed.

Both the above point up the lack of information we had on the effects of atomic bombs even into the '50s.
Well I think the information was around, just not in the hands of the right people. The planning for Downfall had extensive planning for tactical use of nuclear bombs, with troops passing through the bombed areas within 12 hours, IIRC.

Actually, he pioneered a dive-bomb like procedure to take the plane through the cloud to take air samples. But took so many rads the first time it was actually used it came close to being the last time they let him do it. The military version of publish or perish kicked in, and...
:eek:
The 'perish' part is usually metaphorical.
 
The 'perish' part is usually metaphorical.

Yeah, but he's old school tough. When the Reaper comes for him, not only is Dad going to go kicking and cursing, but unless he made an appointment, Dad won't even have the time for the interview.

And it looks like he's booked solid until some time in 2090...
 
Last edited:
Thanks for the answers guys.

Obviously, the level of knowledge here about the subject is considerable, with plenty of detail.

I'm not well read on Pearl Harbor, but these were just a few questions that bugged me a little.

Back in 1987, I spent a week in Hawaii on my way back from an exchange posting with the RAF. While there, I visited the USS Arizona Memorial. It was the most profoundly moving place I have ever been to.
 
Can I turn the subject back to the OP?

I am new here and as you can see from my introduction (in the "Welcome" thread) I pretty much don't believe any of the common conspiracy theories,

Regarding Pearl Harbor, I am inclined to believe the "traditional" view rather then "revisionist" view, but I do have a couple of questions. I may be shaky on the facts surrounding those questions and I will use (?) to indicate that, so please correct any misconceptions

1. Has there ever been a satisfactory reason given for why the Carriers left only days (?) before the attack?
Washington ordered Kimmel to reinforce Wake and Midway with P-40 fighters. They left the details to him, as usual. He sent Enterprise out one week and Lexington out the next. Enterprise was nearly back on the day, she would have been in port on Saturday except that weather slowed refueling of her escorting DDs. No mystery here.
2. Was there any plausible reason given why the mobile radar (?) system that they got from the British (?) failed to detect the Japanese fleet?
Opana Point did dectect the incoming flight, but the Aircraft Warning Service Center had shut down at 7 AM, as per routine. (Radar was run every day to train the operators, but the AWS was not functional at this time, it was still being developed. They had no way to vector fighters.)
3. Was it standard practice for the USAAF to park their aircraft in neat, straight rows (?) so that a potential enemy ground attack aircraft could easily damage/destroy them with single strafing runs.
General Short ordered that to prevent sabotage. He considered that the most likely threat.
4. Has there ever been a reason given why the Japanese strike force did not send the third wave of aircraft (?) to deliver the coup de grace, given that they had the base on its knees. /QUOTE]
That would be the second attack, the first being in two waves. Nagumo had been against a second attack from day one, if you believe Genda and others. Nagumo was commander on the scene and had discretion to launch the second attack. He believed, and I agree, that a second attack would have been handled roughly and being satisfied he'd carried out his orders he decided to conserve his air crews and head to the Kido Butai's second mission, assisting in the attacks in the Southwest Pacific.
[
Also, about 40 years ago (as a teenager) I read a short account in a book about the WWII that suggested Japanese attack plan for Pearl Harbor was very similar to a "mock" attack planned and executed by the US Navy nine years earlier, right down to the number of squadrons and the types of weapons and aircraft used. Is this true or not?
No.
 
They went to get their breakfast, only to hear about the attack when they got there. They skipped breakfast and hauled *** back to Opana, where they monitored the attack until it ended.
They passed a truck going back up to Opana to restart the radar as they went down the mountain.

The tracks they recorded, as well as the tracks showing the first wave retiring northward are in the Hearings' Exhibits, volume 38 I believe. It's notable that the Army knew which way the Japanese came from and retired toward, but didn't feel this was information the Navy might want to know.

The USN, using RDF (not Dawkins, btw) had to choices based on radio bearings, north and south. Previous intel had suggested that there might be a carrier unit around Johnston Atoll made them chose south as the direction to send Halsey in Enterprise.
 
3. After the initial surprize, the US really was kicking ***: nearly two thirds of their losses came from the second strike. Had a third strike proceeded, this would have continued ...


Just to put some numbers to that, of the 183 aircraft dispatched in the first wave, 9 were lost, or 4.9% of the force. There were 171 aircraft in the second wave, of which 20 were lost. That's 11.7% of the force. Losing more than one in ten aircraft dispatched is a sizable casualty rate.
 
They followed that example pretty much exactly -- including the fact that ships were taken out, but not facilities. Had the latter happened, maybe another three? four? years of war -- but no change in the final outcome.

The Japanese simply didn't have enough bombers to knock out the facilities even if they had made it their #1 target.
 
me said:
Also, about 40 years ago (as a teenager) I read a short account in a book about the WWII that suggested Japanese attack plan for Pearl Harbor was very similar to a "mock" attack planned and executed by the US Navy nine years earlier, right down to the number of squadrons and the types of weapons and aircraft used. Is this true or not?




Last night I went down into my basement and rummaged through some banana boxes of old books, and managed to find the book in question. The story appeared in Book 1 of a two volume set called "Secrets & Stores of the War". The story was called "The Pacific 1932: Blueprint For Pearl Harbour" by Edwin Muller.


It begins.....


The Japanese attack on Pearl Harbour, as everyone knows, followed a craftily conceived and elaborately detailed plan. But, as few people outside the Navy know, that plan was not conceived in Tokyo. It was created in Washington, D.C., by the U.S. Naval Planning Board.

The story goes back to January 1932, when the U.S. fleet of nearly 200 warships, perhaps the most tremendous concentration of naval power ever assembled up to that time, gathered in California waters for manoeuvres which were to test the defences of Pearl Harbour. One part of the fleet would "attack"; the other with the army garrison, would defend.

The attacking fleet revolutionized naval strategy when, leaving all the proud battleships and cruisers behind, two aircraft carriers - the Saratoga and the Lexington - streaked across the eastern Pacific with four destroyer escorts. Admiral H.E. Yarnell himself was on the Saratoga (instead of a battleship), in command of a brand-new naval group called a "task force." The admiral was an air-minded officer who had made many flights with his squadrons - unusual in the navy of that day. Now he was applying the new carrier attack strategy on an objective already familiar to him from the air.

The defence of Pearl Harbour, planned primarily to meet a naval attack, was entrusted to a fleet that protected the approaches to the islands, a flotilla of submarines in the harbour, a full division of troops ashore and an immense concentration of heavy coast artillery which could be rapidly shifted on a well-planned system of railways and roads. an air defence had also been superimposed - batteries of anti-aircraft guns and 100 fighter planes and bombers.

The story goes on to say that a Japanese spy network on the island observed what was happening, and reported what they saw back to Tokyo.

Are you saying that this account is completely false?

The story is only four pages long. I am prepared to scan and post the pages if you like, to show that I haven't just lifted this from some dubious internet site.
 
Whether an Japanese knew of this is unknown to me however they were influenced by the British attack on Italian fleet at Taranto, with 21 obsolete aircraft they sunk one battleship and damage two more for the loss of just two aircraft
 
Last night I went down into my basement and rummaged through some banana boxes of old books, and managed to find the book in question. The story appeared in Book 1 of a two volume set called "Secrets & Stores of the War". The story was called "The Pacific 1932: Blueprint For Pearl Harbour" by Edwin Muller.


It begins.....




The story goes on to say that a Japanese spy network on the island observed what was happening, and reported what they saw back to Tokyo.

Are you saying that this account is completely false?

The story is only four pages long. I am prepared to scan and post the pages if you like, to show that I haven't just lifted this from some dubious internet site.


Whether or not the Japanese observed all or part of the 1932 maneuvers, their primary inspiration was the British attack on the Italian fleet at Taranto (Operation JudgementWP) in November 1940.
 
Last night I went down into my basement and rummaged through some banana boxes of old books, and managed to find the book in question. The story appeared in Book 1 of a two volume set called "Secrets & Stores of the War". The story was called "The Pacific 1932: Blueprint For Pearl Harbour" by Edwin Muller.


It begins.....




The story goes on to say that a Japanese spy network on the island observed what was happening, and reported what they saw back to Tokyo.

Are you saying that this account is completely false?

The story is only four pages long. I am prepared to scan and post the pages if you like, to show that I haven't just lifted this from some dubious internet site.
Your statement was "Japanese attack plan for Pearl Harbor was very similar to a "mock" attack planned and executed by the US Navy nine years earlier, right down to the number of squadrons and the types of weapons and aircraft used. Is this true or not? " It wasn't. Genda got his inspiration from a news reel showing four US carriers, two Lexingtons and two Yorktowns in formation. The rest of the attack is only incidentally similar to the 1932 maneuvers. I trust you've reviewed those in the original documents? If not I'll see if I can locate my copies.
 
"The story goes on to say that a Japanese spy network on the island observed what was happening, and reported what they saw back to Tokyo." The first real naval spy on the islands was Yoshikawa Takeo. If there were others 9 years earlier they were regular embassy staff. This begs the question, "How did they know what forces were being used?"
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom