Merged Pearl Harbor: "Revisionists" vs. "Traditionalists"

Don't expect much challenge these days. I hope someone will come up with a new one, but that's unlikely.


In parting may I just say that the atomic bombs were dropped to guarantee that Eisenhower would have something to warn us about. Or so I'm told.
 
Don't expect much challenge these days. I hope someone will come up with a new one, but that's unlikely.


In parting may I just say that the atomic bombs were dropped to guarantee that Eisenhower would have something to warn us about. Or so I'm told.
You just reminded me of something I meant to add to one of the Hiroshima threads; this post on the level of knowledge of the radiation dangers of the atomic bombs.
 
You just reminded me of something I meant to add to one of the Hiroshima threads; this post on the level of knowledge of the radiation dangers of the atomic bombs.

Thanks for that! I like to point out the scene in "Fat Man and Little Boy" where the core goes active and they sort out who got fatal doses by distance. Only the one guy dies ... right away.

Two things to add: The plans to use the atomic bombs in the invasion of Japan called for them to be used against strongpoints, and then the troops would be sent in one half hour later, when it was safe.

AND: The US was conducting training into the '50s that had troops lined up to watch an atomic bomb go off so they'd be ready for the effects in case battlefield nukes were needed.

Both the above point up the lack of information we had on the effects of atomic bombs even into the '50s.
 
Thanks for that! I like to point out the scene in "Fat Man and Little Boy" where the core goes active and they sort out who got fatal doses by distance. Only the one guy dies ... right away.

Two things to add: The plans to use the atomic bombs in the invasion of Japan called for them to be used against strongpoints, and then the troops would be sent in one half hour later, when it was safe.

AND: The US was conducting training into the '50s that had troops lined up to watch an atomic bomb go off so they'd be ready for the effects in case battlefield nukes were needed.

Both the above point up the lack of information we had on the effects of atomic bombs even into the '50s.

I've gathered a smattering of knowledge on the atomic "indoctrination" of troops in the 50s due to several ongoing lawsuits by some of the people who were brought into witness the shots.

The military manuals of the day definitely do not reveal any appreciation of the long term health problems that might arise from the use of atomic weapons (although health studies in Canadian vets don't reveal a large difference between them and other veterans). After the Soviet development of the bomb, doctrine on both sides seemed to look at atomic weapons as really effective bombs, and that thye could be used effectively in a tactical battlefield to break up concentrations of soldiers and supplies, reducing the operational effectiveness of the opposiing forces.

There was also a lot of misconceptions about atomic weapons. Getting soldiers to witness atomic "shots" was to reinforce that with appropriate precautions, atomic blasts were survivable, and that you could still keep fighting. The idea was to ensure that there was a critical mass of soldiers in units that had the relevant experience and could pass it on to their fellows. This was seen to be very important for troops being deployed to Europe as Soviet manuals suggested that they would use atomics on know supply depots and troop concentrations quite liberally.


The last time this was done generally was in 1957, and later atmospheric tests tended not to involve troops.

With the development of better strategic weapons delivery systems, and a better appreciation of the radiological effects on the environment in the 1960s, the idea of using atomics as tactical weapons was quietly removed from the manuals and the doctrine of most armies.
 
The last time this was done generally was in 1957, and later atmospheric tests tended not to involve troops.
Well, not *ground* troops.

It was a family joke that we didn't need a night light at home, because Dad (who retired as a Major in the USAF) glowed in the dark...
 
Well, not *ground* troops.

It was a family joke that we didn't need a night light at home, because Dad (who retired as a Major in the USAF) glowed in the dark...

Somebody had to ride the bombs in (too soon for a Dr. Strangelove reference?)
 
Somebody had to ride the bombs in (too soon for a Dr. Strangelove reference?)
Actually, he pioneered a dive-bomb like procedure to take the plane through the cloud to take air samples. But took so many rads the first time it was actually used it came close to being the last time they let him do it. The military version of publish or perish kicked in, and...
 
Thisisthetexttheforumsoftwarerequired.

Ya know all them superheroes who owe their powers to radiation?

All of this was before I was born.

Which means...

Pardon me, I have to preen the wings now.
 
Ya know all them superheroes who owe their powers to radiation?

All of this was before I was born.

Which means...

Pardon me, I have to preen the wings now.

And don;t forget the effect that radiation has on some living organisms of making them Grow to Humengeous size.....


"THEM! THEM!"
 
Did you notice Leonard Nimoy in an uncredited role in the message center?

Not until it was pointed out to me.

Another great cameo in a 50's Giant Bug movie is,of course, Clint Eastwood as the pilot dropping napalm on the Giant Spider in "Tarantula".

BTW what was the first time that Bill Shatner and Leonard Nimoy appreared on screen together:
Hint, it was NOT a Sci fi film/show.
 
BTW what was the first time that Bill Shatner and Leonard Nimoy appreared on screen together:
Hint, it was NOT a Sci fi film/show.

Well I looked it up as I did not know this. It was an episode of the "Man From Uncle" I also saw that.....

"Nimoy served as a sergeant in the U.S. Army from 1953 through 1955,[17] alongside fellow actor Ken Berry and architect Frank Gehry".

Frank Gehry was the Riddler in "Batman". Ken Berry was in "F-Troop". Imagine the joy on soldier's faces after serving under Nimoy, Berry & Gehry and seeing them later in Star Trek, F-Troop and Batman.
 
Not until it was pointed out to me.

Another great cameo in a 50's Giant Bug movie is,of course, Clint Eastwood as the pilot dropping napalm on the Giant Spider in "Tarantula".

BTW what was the first time that Bill Shatner and Leonard Nimoy appreared on screen together:
Hint, it was NOT a Sci fi film/show.

I guessed it was 'Mission Impossible' but a quick search on Google says it was the other sixties series that people still remember...
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom