Merged Pearl Harbor: "Revisionists" vs. "Traditionalists"

I've had people put me on ignore, and all it did was allow me to eviscerate them with impunity. It also makes it look like they're avoiding responding to you which, technically, they are. Great fun.
 
That's unfair. He's merely ignoring the evidence source that he already knows disagrees with him. Why would anyone actually look at evidence that proves them wrong?

Yeah he doing what might be called, 指鹿為馬 'deliberate misrepresentation for ulterior purposes' but the Japanese actually has something to do with a horse and a deer
 
BTW, I'm very drunk right now. Took me five tries to type BTW.

Don't take me seriously until tomorrow.

And Isle of Skye whisky is from GOD!

I prefer Orkney's Highland Park myself, but the argument can be made for Skye - drinks to discuss?
 
I'm getting a bottle of Talisker sent over. I got a Bruichladdich Second Edition last week, haven't opened it yet.

I like Balvenie Double Wood (with Coke and ice....). At least that's what I told one of my colleagues who is a single malt fanatic. From the look on his face you'd think I'd just pooped on his keyboard.

Never fear, the Balvenie has not actually been desecrated - I just discovered that I'm not a fan of whiskey.... and it's there for visitors who are.
 
I like Balvenie Double Wood (with Coke and ice....). At least that's what I told one of my colleagues who is a single malt fanatic. From the look on his face you'd think I'd just pooped on his keyboard.

Never fear, the Balvenie has not actually been desecrated - I just discovered that I'm not a fan of whiskey.... and it's there for visitors who are.

You nearly died there. Just sayin'.
 
Not to propose a dreaded, what if, but wouldn't the Japanese attacks on Guam, taking the US warship in China, sinking a US charted army merchant ship, the Cynthia Olsen etc., etc. have been sufficient action to trigger a war?
 
Not to propose a dreaded, what if, but wouldn't the Japanese attacks on Guam, taking the US warship in China, sinking a US charted army merchant ship, the Cynthia Olsen etc., etc. have been sufficient action to trigger a war?

Yeah or Wake Island, or the Philippines for that matter lol
 
I like Balvenie Double Wood (with Coke and ice....). At least that's what I told one of my colleagues who is a single malt fanatic. From the look on his face you'd think I'd just pooped on his keyboard.
Not an unreasonable reaction to adding Coke to good whisk(e)y.
 
Not really, because slandering FDR is the primary purpose of the Pearl Harbor conspiracy theories. PHCTers will draw the line at nothing to make him look bad. And it's frustrating for them that most people thing that's very, very, very stupid.

That's the part I understand the least. You can have serious problems with the policies of the New Deal and still think that FDR was an excellent war time president. It's not like the guys he was fighting (Hitler, Mussolini, and Tojo) were worth admiring in any way. So trying to paint FDR as some kind of bloodless maniac willing to sacrifice American lives to get the US into a war it was headed into anyway is both stupid and crazy.
 
That's the part I understand the least. You can have serious problems with the policies of the New Deal and still think that FDR was an excellent war time president. It's not like the guys he was fighting (Hitler, Mussolini, and Tojo) were worth admiring in any way. So trying to paint FDR as some kind of bloodless maniac willing to sacrifice American lives to get the US into a war it was headed into anyway is both stupid and crazy.

It's the Republican way. If you figure out why that is, please let the rest of the planet know.

(I have never met a Democrat who believed FDR would do the LIHOP.)
 
Not really, because slandering FDR is the primary purpose of the Pearl Harbor conspiracy theories. PHCTers will draw the line at nothing to make him look bad. And it's frustrating for them that most people thing that's very, very, very stupid.

I've found that this is often linked to attempting to portray FDR as evil because they were allied (by circumstance) with Stalin against their hero Hitler
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom