Merged Pearl Harbor: "Revisionists" vs. "Traditionalists"

I would certainly expect more Japanese casualties, even if they did win overall. Even the Brewster Buffalos of Midway did some damage.
 
I wonder when we would have had to divert Enterprise to get her to striking distance of the launching point?

CarrierChartE.jpg
 
All kidding aside, I think that if our fliers had gotten into the air in advance, fully briefed, that they'd have made at least a fair show.

I dont think I could agree with you there. The Japanese would, as they did in other encounters suck P40s into turning fights, and that never ended well for the P40.

Once pilots figured out not to let the Zero try to out maneuver you, instead going for bounce and run tactics, the P40 proved a very serviceable plane for a few airforces in WW2
 
I dont think I could agree with you there. The Japanese would, as they did in other encounters suck P40s into turning fights, and that never ended well for the P40.
I know there were people who heard Chennault's warnings on Hawaii that day. I imagine that they would be holding quick seminars about the Zeke. The American pilots that listened and learned could have done a good job. The rest would have died.
Once pilots figured out not to let the Zero try to out maneuver you, instead going for bounce and run tactics, the P40 proved a very serviceable plane for a few airforces in WW2
True, and the Mildcat had to learn the same lesson.
 
I know there were people who heard Chennault's warnings on Hawaii that day. I imagine that they would be holding quick seminars about the Zeke. The American pilots that listened and learned could have done a good job. The rest would have died.

In an earlier post Spitfire mentioned he didn't think anyone was listening to Chennault at the time. So I guess it comes down to that
 
It may be a case of "I told them for ten damn years..." but the AAF post mortem included folks who said they'd heard Chennault's warnings about the Zeke, some via back channels.

Yeah and I am happy to accept that - reality is we will never know given we are discussing an element of a 'maybe' with a dash of 'could have' lol.
 
Carrier Striking Task Force Operations Order No. 1 [6]

23 November 1941
To: Carrier Striking Task Force

1. The Carrier Striking Task Force will proceed to the Hawaiian Area with utmost secrecy and, at the outbreak of the war, will launch a resolute surprise attack on and deal a fatal blow to the enemy fleet in the Hawaiian Area. The initial air attack is scheduled at 0330 hours, X Day. Upon completion of the air attacks, the Task Force will immediately withdraw and return to Japan and, after taking on new supplies, take its position for Second Period Operations. In the event that, during this operation, an enemy fleet attempts to intercept our force or a powerful enemy force is encountered and there is danger of attack, the Task Force will launch a counterattack.

...
http://www.ibiblio.org/pha/myths/jm-097.html

Okay, Bob, how does "utmost secrecy" square with nattering away on the radio, please?

e. What preparations were made for the prevention of discovery enroute?

(1) By electing the route so as to pass between MIDWAY and the ALEUTIANS, we would pass outside the patrol zones of the patrol planes.

(2) Screening destroyers were sent ahead in the path of the fleet and in the event any vessels were encountered, the main body of the fleet would make a severe change of course and endeavor to avoid detection

Pp. 11

(3) Complete radio silence was carried out.

http://www.ibiblio.org/pha/pha/pt_12/x12-008.html

How does "Complete radio silence" square with nattering away on the radio, Bob?

Kido Butai did not transmit.
 
To add the next lines down

The Main Force in the INLAND SEA Area and the land-based air units in the KYUSHU Area carried on deceptive communications, and deceptive measures were taken to indicate that the Task Force was still in training in the KYUSHU Area.

Glad to see one knowledgeable individual looking at the Japanese records!
 
Last edited:
Perhaps lost in all the arguing over details is this: by late 1941 Japan had been carrying out disgusting acts of genocide resulting in the massacre of millions in China for several years already.

Reality is the USA had a moral obligation to do something to stop it. Now in some alternate universe where Pearl Harbor was allowed to be attacked, and FDR is a wizard who knew exactly just what type of attack he had to trick the Japanese into successfully conducting, that alternate FDR would still be someone that helped save millions of lives.
 
Last edited:
It would depend what tactics the American pilots were using. Traditional fighter tactics would see the P40s raining out of the sky. However in China they'd learned the advantages the P40 had over the Zero and could more than hold their own. Question is did the Hawaiian have this knowledge


Even with the knowledge, it would take those pilots with the relevant combat experience teaching the new pilots in the USAAF those combat tactics. It would require lots of training time. (This is one thing the Allies did right and the Axis did not: after finishing their tour Allied fighter pilots were usually sent back home to train new pilots, where the recruits could learn from the experienced veterans. In the Axis, pilots pretty much flew until they were killed or too injured to fly again. New pilots were deprived of that valuable combat experience from veterans in training and thus basically had to 'learn on the job'.)
 
Last edited:
Perhaps lost in all the arguing over details is this: by late 1941 Japan had been carrying out disgusting acts of genocide resulting in the massacre of millions in China for several years already.
The American public was quite aware of the atrocities. The Republican isolationists in Congress insisted on the fuel embargo in part because of this. People blame FDR for the "provocative embargo", but the isolationists insisted on it and despite State Dept. assurances that it was a bad idea if we wanted to keep things calm FDR went along with it in order to get the Two Ocean Navy Bill passed.

It was also a stupid idea to supply material of war to a very potential enemy. The Japanese were buying high octane gasoline in barrels "for civilian use", never mind that it's easy to transfer fuel that way to military units.

Reality is the USA had a moral obligation to do something to stop it. Now in some alternate universe where FDR is a wizard who knew exactly just what type of attack he had to trick the Japanese into successfully conducting that FDR would still be someone that helped save millions of lives.

The Japanese decided to go to war in July 1941 unless the US, UK and NEI did everything they were told to do. After that negotiation was moot.
 
Even with the knowledge, it would take those pilots with the relevant combat experience teaching the new pilots in the USAAF those combat tactics. It would require lots of training time. (This is one thing the Allies did right and the Axis did not: after finishing their tour Allied fighter pilots were usually sent back home to train new pilots, where the recruits could learn from the experienced veterans. In the Axis, pilots pretty much flew until they were killed or too injured to fly again. New pilots were deprived of that valuable combat experience in training and thus had to essentially 'learn on the job'.)

On a slightly off topic note. It was the same with German Armour. New crews got the new tanks while experienced crews rode in the same tank until destroyed. That meant theat new crews were getting Panthers and Tiger II etc while the 'old hands' were still in Pz IV.
 
Even with the knowledge, it would take those pilots with the relevant combat experience teaching the new pilots in the USAAF those combat tactics. It would require lots of training time. (This is one thing the Allies did right and the Axis did not: after finishing their tour Allied fighter pilots were usually sent back home to train new pilots, where the recruits could learn from the experienced veterans. In the Axis, pilots pretty much flew until they were killed or too injured to fly again. New pilots were deprived of that valuable combat experience in training and thus had to essentially 'learn on the job'.)

"Fear has a wonderful way of canalizing knowledge."
 
Trying to change the subject Bob?

Have you tried reading the

Japanese accounts yet?

No?

Oh that's right you're far to closed minded to do simple research, lol

That's unfair. He's merely ignoring the evidence source that he already knows disagrees with him. Why would anyone actually look at evidence that proves them wrong?

I think Bob has admitted defeat and put me on ignore. That's always a signal that the person doing so has found it impossible to respond.

It also means they literally don't even want to see your posts anymore. To be fair, I've put people who I could keep responding to on ignore, I just didn't want to. Because they disgusted me. It allows me to filter.
 
It also means they literally don't even want to see your posts anymore. To be fair, I've put people who I could keep responding to on ignore, I just didn't want to. Because they disgusted me. It allows me to filter.
However you want to phrase it. I sometimes get the impression that the person who puts people on ignore thinks he has silenced THEM. The obverse is truer, the ignored can comment on the ignorer's posts and has no restraints vis-a-vis the ignorer. It's rather humorous when you look at it. ;)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom