Merged Pearl Harbor: "Revisionists" vs. "Traditionalists"

I can't help but be curious as to how they might have fared in such a situation.

It would depend what tactics the American pilots were using. Traditional fighter tactics would see the P40s raining out of the sky. However in China they'd learned the advantages the P40 had over the Zero and could more than hold their own. Question is did the Hawaiian have this knowledge
 
Sorry for some reason I thought there were no Zeros in the first wave. Clearly there were so yes they were prepared for a fight.

If the attack was expected, and they had to fight their way in, the Zeros were to protect the bombers and torpedo planes. If not, they were to attack the airfields at Hickam and Ford Island, and then targets of opportunity.
 
If the attack was expected, and they had to fight their way in, the Zeros were to protect the bombers and torpedo planes. If not, they were to attack the airfields at Hickam and Ford Island, and then targets of opportunity.

Yeah sorry, just old age, for some reason I thought they only flew in the second wave lol
 
"It will be recorded that the distance of Hawaii from Japan makes it obvious that the attack was deliberately planned many days or even weeks ago. During the intervening time, the Japanese government has deliberately sought to deceive the United States by false statements and expressions of hope for continued peace. "

Hey I added some more info in the message above, a number of US ships were seized in China and Japan, the attack on the Cynthia Olsen would have probably started the war

also the Japanese interned the US Marines at Shanghai, Tientsin and Chingwangtao, China they also seized the US Patrol boat Wake in Shangahi harbour


http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/USS_Wake_(PR-3)

On 25 November 1941, Cdr. Smith was ordered to close the Navy installation at Hankow, and sail to Shanghai. When Pearl Harbor was attacked on 7 December 1941, Shanghai immediately fell to Japan. Smith was in command on 8 December 1941 (7 December in Hawaii), when the Japanese captured the ship, which was tied up at a pier in Shanghai. Smith had received a telephone call the night before from a Japanese officer he knew. The officer asked where Smith would be the next morning as he wanted to deliver some turkeys for Smith and his crew. The Japanese did the same to other American officers and officials so as to determine where they would be on December 8th. However, Commander Smith received word from his quartermaster about the Pearl Harbor attack and rushed to the ship only to find it under guard by the Japanese.[1] Surrounded by an overwhelming Japanese force, the crew attempted unsuccessfully to scuttle the craft. Wake surrendered, the only U.S. ship to do so in World War II.
 
Last edited:
Yeah sorry, just old age, for some reason I thought they only flew in the second wave lol

If that had happened the P-40s would have gotten into the air, but not before most of the damage was done to the BBs. Second wave would have had more fighters. The P-40s may have been back on the ground for rearm/refuel, but there would have been a CAP umbrella aloft until dark. (I best guess of the results of that tweak to reality.)
 
And to get some idea of what FDR was capable of, it's worth noting that it recently came to light, from released documents, that FDR covered up the Katyn Massacre and helped Stalin falsely blame it on the Germans. FDR and other high officials knew that the Soviets had carried out the horrific massacre, in which over 20,000 Poles were murdered, but he and others in his administration falsely denied Soviet guilt and joined Stalin in blaming it on the Germans.

US Hushed Up Soviet Guilt Over Katyn
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-19552745
EXTRACT: "New evidence appears to back the idea that the Roosevelt administration helped cover up Soviet guilt for the 1940 Katyn massacre of Polish soldiers."

FDR "Covered Up Soviet Atrocity to Appease Stalin"
http://www.newsmax.com/Newsfront/Katyn-massacre-Roosevelt-Stalin/2012/09/10/id/451258

The Katyn Massacre Cover-Up
http://nationalinterest.org/blog/ja...elt-helped-stalin-cover-the-katyn-massac-7464


False equivalence. The victims of Katyn were already dead. What was FDR going to do that was going to help them? Also, exactly what effect do you believe that FDR's proclaiming Soviet guilt at the time would have had?

And there's FDR's shameful deference to Stalin during the Warsaw Uprising. Columbia University historian Robert Nisbet called FDR's inexcusable appeasement of Stalin in this case an example of Roosevelt's "cravenness" in his relationship with Stalin (Roosevelt and Stalin: The Failed Courtship, Washington, D.C.: Regnery Gateway, 1988, pp. 57-61).


Along the same lines, please explain exactly what FDR could have done that would have helped the situation.

And just look at what FDR did to our army in the Philippines. He had no intention of trying to hold the Philippines. He gave them just enough war material to alarm and provoke the Japanese, yet, as diaries and memoirs and other evidence reveals, he did not plan on holding the Philippines. Dr. Victor covers this in detail in The Pearl Harbor Myth, pp. 192-202.


"This isn't right. This isn't even wrong." :rolleyes: Please explain how the US could have held the Philippines, whether or not the Pearl Harbor attack had occurred. Further, please explain what US forces were sent to the Philippines (an American territory) that could reasonably be construed as alarming or provocative.

Several historians have pointed out that there is considerable evidence that FDR's hostile pre-war policy toward Japan was driven by a desire to save the Soviet Union. Dr. Victor discusses this at some length (pp. 200-214). Historian Waldo Heinrichs provides abundant material on this point in Threshold of War: Franklin D. Roosevelt and American Entry into World War II (New York: Oxford University Press, 1988), pp. 92-117, 142, 163 (see also Raymond Dawson, The Decision to Aid Russia, University of North Carolina Press, 1959, pp. 55, 290).


So you're saying that he should have sacrificed millions of Chinese lives by not attempting to curb Japan's aggression? Further, please how explain how FDR's actions were not consistent with enforcing the Open Door Policy, which had been a major element of US foreign policy for the previous 40 years.

So FDR was certainly capable of sacrificing thousands of lives to achieve ends that he felt were necessary.


Your evidence, such as it is, does not support this conclusion, no matter how much you may wish it did.
 
If that had happened the P-40s would have gotten into the air, but not before most of the damage was done to the BBs. Second wave would have had more fighters. The P-40s may have been back on the ground for rearm/refuel, but there would have been a CAP umbrella aloft until dark. (I best guess of the results of that tweak to reality.)

Yeah actually you are right. With the P40s horrible climb rate, even taking off at the exact second the Japanese forces entered US airspace they would have had about 90 seconds to do something about the bombers assuming they didn't have to deal with any threats on the way up
 
Several historians have pointed out that there is considerable evidence that FDR's hostile pre-war policy toward Japan was driven by a desire to save the Soviet Union. Dr. Victor discusses this at some length (pp. 200-214). Historian Waldo Heinrichs provides abundant material on this point in Threshold of War: Franklin D. Roosevelt and American Entry into World War II (New York: Oxford University Press, 1988), pp. 92-117, 142, 163 (see also Raymond Dawson, The Decision to Aid Russia, University of North Carolina Press, 1959, pp. 55, 290).

So FDR was certainly capable of sacrificing thousands of lives to achieve ends that he felt were necessary.

Stange I looked up one of your sources

http://www.oup.com/us/catalog/general/subject/HistoryAmerican/19001945/?view=usa&ci=9780195061680

Heinrichs presents him as a leader who acted with extreme caution and deliberation, who always kept his options open, and who, once Hitler's invasion of the Soviet Union stalled in July, 1941, acted rapidly and with great determination

Perhaps you need to actually read the book
 
Yeah actually you are right. With the P40s horrible climb rate, even taking off at the exact second the Japanese forces entered US airspace they would have had about 90 seconds to do something about the bombers assuming they didn't have to deal with any threats on the way up

And the pictures taken by the Japanese show torpedo strikes against the BBs without a single dot of flak in the air. The swift stroke, a Zengen Sakusen from the air.
 
I think that's a strained argument.

You would know I guess.:D

Care to provide proof that the Japanese spy was signaling submarines or would you like to retract that strained argument.

How exactly would we have "caught them in the act"? In the act of attacking? That is an implausible scenario. To do that, FDR would have had to put the fleet on alert, which would have risked tipping off the Japanese and having the task force turn around and head for home. And if the Japanese attacked anyway, they could claim that FDR obviously knew they were coming, etc., etc.

If the US knew of the attack and let it happen anyway (as you contend) then they knew that the only japanese spy could only communicate via the 2 private telegraph companies. The U.S. had already broken the embassy code and if I recall correctly one of those companies was handing over the Japanese messages to the US anyway.

Given all of this they could have easily prepped for the attack and sprung an ambush without the IJN being any the wiser. There is nothing implausible about it. In fact, if they knew about the attack, this is exactly what one would do. What's implausible is letting your fleet be demolished and killing thousands of sailors on purpose with the intent of then going to war with that fleet and those sailors.
 
So, the fact that FDR's actions did not indicate foreknowledge of the attack indicates that he had foreknowledge of the attack?

Yes we're thru the looking glass here where everything can be twisted to support your theory.
 
I think Bob has admitted defeat and put me on ignore. That's always a signal that the person doing so has found it impossible to respond.

Not to me either, gracious me I wonder why?

Well he's being treated like a blob of mochi at a Tokushu Sakusen Gun mochitsuki party
 
Last edited:
I think that's a strained argument. How exactly would we have "caught them in the act"? In the act of attacking? That is an implausible scenario. To do that, FDR would have had to put the fleet on alert, which would have risked tipping off the Japanese and having the task force turn around and head for home. And if the Japanese attacked anyway, they could claim that FDR obviously knew they were coming, etc., etc.

If you mean "catching them" heading east in the North Pacific, the Japanese could have claimed they were doing training in the North Pacific and had no intention of attacking Pearl Harbor.

Either scenario would not have had nearly the emotional and diplomatic impact of a surprise attack in which thousands of Americans were killed. Not even close.

Odd, I've read that same line over in the 911 sub forum.
 
It would depend what tactics the American pilots were using. Traditional fighter tactics would see the P40s raining out of the sky. However in China they'd learned the advantages the P40 had over the Zero and could more than hold their own. Question is did the Hawaiian have this knowledge


Probably not. Claire Chennault, Chiang Kai-shek's air advisor, later commander of the Flying Tigers, tried to warn the Air Corps about the Zero in 1940, but his reports were discounted.
 
I think he was referring to Bob's logic.

The "your" was meant collectively not personally.

(knew I should have used a smiley)

(or written more clearly)

(or something)

BTW do you think Bob would be surprised to find out that fleets sailed across oceans before radio?
 
Probably not. Claire Chennault, Chiang Kai-shek's air advisor, later commander of the Flying Tigers, tried to warn the Air Corps about the Zero in 1940, but his reports were discounted.

Okay well that settles it, the Zeros would have brushed them aside like moths :(
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom