Merged Pearl Harbor: "Revisionists" vs. "Traditionalists"

There is another problem with the argument that a forewarned FDR who was determined to let Pearl Harbor be attacked could have put the Hawaiian forces on alert on 12/6 and could have also ordered the closure of the Japanese consulate to prevent the consulate from warning Tokyo. Such an action would have been a clear indication that FDR knew the attack was coming.

It was one thing for FDR to verbally tell a high-ranking Red Cross official to send extra supplies to Pearl Harbor and to direct him not to tell anyone why the supplies were being sent (and Red Cross records confirm that extra supplies were received shortly before the attack).

But it would have been quite another thing for FDR to not only put Pearl Harbor's forces on alert on 12/6 but to order the closure of the Japanese consulate as well. This would have smelled to high heaven of foreknowledge, and such an order would have been impossible to deny or to claim "misunderstanding" over later.
So what if the Japanese never get to attack PH? Catching them in the act of trying is just as good.
 
That's the point that they choke on. Stopping an attack will make FDR a bigger hero than he already was, so he can't do that, not an option for CTers. That leave LIHOP, an abysmally stupid concept.

Do we know what the US rules of engagement where? At what point could the US intercept the Japanese fleet
 
Working from the wayback machine I think it would be when the air attack was enroute Hawaii and they crossed into Hawaiian waters. That would be about twelve miles from Oahu.

Given roughly 240 mph cruising speed for most of the Japanese aircraft, thats what a 6 minute response time. If the Americans are already in the air the Japanese would hear the chatter, great potential for the Japanese to be spooked and bug out
 
Given roughly 240 mph cruising speed for most of the Japanese aircraft, thats what a 6 minute response time. If the Americans are already in the air the Japanese would hear the chatter, great potential for the Japanese to be spooked and bug out

In that case, no damage to Pearl. The attacks on the PI in conjunction with the aborted attack on Hawaii would be enough to get a declaration of war.

However, I don't picture the IJA pilots running away from a fight. The orders were to press home the attack even if discovered in the last 24 hours, so they would have tried to fight their way to Pearl.
 
In that case, no damage to Pearl. The attacks on the PI in conjunction with the aborted attack on Hawaii would be enough to get a declaration of war.

However, I don't picture the IJA pilots running away from a fight. The orders were to press home the attack even if discovered in the last 24 hours, so they would have tried to fight their way to Pearl.

I can't help but be curious as to how they might have fared in such a situation.
 
Maybe I'm wrong about this but the Japanese did not often attack fortified and prepared targets from the air in the war did they?
 
So what if the Japanese never get to attack PH? Catching them in the act of trying is just as good.

I think that's a strained argument. How exactly would we have "caught them in the act"? In the act of attacking? That is an implausible scenario. To do that, FDR would have had to put the fleet on alert, which would have risked tipping off the Japanese and having the task force turn around and head for home. And if the Japanese attacked anyway, they could claim that FDR obviously knew they were coming, etc., etc.

If you mean "catching them" heading east in the North Pacific, the Japanese could have claimed they were doing training in the North Pacific and had no intention of attacking Pearl Harbor.

Either scenario would not have had nearly the emotional and diplomatic impact of a surprise attack in which thousands of Americans were killed. Not even close.
 
I think that's a strained argument. How exactly would we have "caught them in the act"? In the act of attacking? That is an implausible scenario. To do that, FDR would have had to put the fleet on alert, which would have risked tipping off the Japanese and having the task force turn around and head for home. And if the Japanese attacked anyway, they could claim that FDR obviously knew they were coming, etc., etc.
Bob still ignores the Philippines and the Malayan invasion. Plus the fact that the Japanese had orders to press the attack if detected within 24 of the scheduled launch.
If you mean "catching them" heading east in the North Pacific, the Japanese could have claimed they were doing training in the North Pacific and had no intention of attacking Pearl Harbor.

Either scenario would not have had nearly the emotional and diplomatic impact of a surprise attack in which thousands of Americans were killed. Not even close.
The near-simultaneous Japanese attacks on widely separated points show, as FDR noted in his speech on the 8th, show a grand plan of aggression. The war in the Pacific was ON even if Hawaii was not attacked. US soldiers and sailors were fighting and dying and the US public, as everybody but Bob has seen, was aware that we'd have to get into the war, and that Japan was considered a threat equal to if not greater than Germany.
 
I think that's a strained argument. How exactly would we have "caught them in the act"? In the act of attacking? That is an implausible scenario. To do that, FDR would have had to put the fleet on alert, which would have risked tipping off the Japanese and having the task force turn around and head for home. And if the Japanese attacked anyway, they could claim that FDR obviously knew they were coming, etc., etc.

If you mean "catching them" heading east in the North Pacific, the Japanese could have claimed they were doing training in the North Pacific and had no intention of attacking Pearl Harbor.

Either scenario would not have had nearly the emotional and diplomatic impact of a surprise attack in which thousands of Americans were killed. Not even close.

You ignore the near simultaneous attack on the Phillipines ( an American colony for lack of the more technical term) which would have brought the US in.

Coupled with the attacks in Malaya and Hong Kong, we're definitely clear signs of Jspanese ability to achieve tactical surprise. Nothing surprising about the Japanese ability to do this to PH. Unless of course your doctrine of American exceptionalism means that it is impossible for US forces to be surprised unless the US is in on it.
 
And to get some idea of what FDR was capable of, it's worth noting that it recently came to light, from released documents, that FDR covered up the Katyn Massacre and helped Stalin falsely blame it on the Germans. FDR and other high officials knew that the Soviets had carried out the horrific massacre, in which over 20,000 Poles were murdered, but he and others in his administration falsely denied Soviet guilt and joined Stalin in blaming it on the Germans.

US Hushed Up Soviet Guilt Over Katyn
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-19552745
EXTRACT: "New evidence appears to back the idea that the Roosevelt administration helped cover up Soviet guilt for the 1940 Katyn massacre of Polish soldiers."

FDR "Covered Up Soviet Atrocity to Appease Stalin"
http://www.newsmax.com/Newsfront/Katyn-massacre-Roosevelt-Stalin/2012/09/10/id/451258

The Katyn Massacre Cover-Up
http://nationalinterest.org/blog/ja...elt-helped-stalin-cover-the-katyn-massac-7464

And there's FDR's shameful deference to Stalin during the Warsaw Uprising. Columbia University historian Robert Nisbet called FDR's inexcusable appeasement of Stalin in this case an example of Roosevelt's "cravenness" in his relationship with Stalin (Roosevelt and Stalin: The Failed Courtship, Washington, D.C.: Regnery Gateway, 1988, pp. 57-61).

And just look at what FDR did to our army in the Philippines. He had no intention of trying to hold the Philippines. He gave them just enough war material to alarm and provoke the Japanese, yet, as diaries and memoirs and other evidence reveals, he did not plan on holding the Philippines. Dr. Victor covers this in detail in The Pearl Harbor Myth, pp. 192-202.

Several historians have pointed out that there is considerable evidence that FDR's hostile pre-war policy toward Japan was driven by a desire to save the Soviet Union. Dr. Victor discusses this at some length (pp. 200-214). Historian Waldo Heinrichs provides abundant material on this point in Threshold of War: Franklin D. Roosevelt and American Entry into World War II (New York: Oxford University Press, 1988), pp. 92-117, 142, 163 (see also Raymond Dawson, The Decision to Aid Russia, University of North Carolina Press, 1959, pp. 55, 290).

So FDR was certainly capable of sacrificing thousands of lives to achieve ends that he felt were necessary.
 
Several historians have pointed out that there is considerable evidence that FDR's hostile pre-war policy toward Japan was driven by a desire to save the Soviet Union. Dr. Victor discusses this at some length (pp. 200-214). Historian Waldo Heinrichs provides abundant material on this point in Threshold of War: Franklin D. Roosevelt and American Entry into World War II (New York: Oxford University Press, 1988), pp. 92-117, 142, 163 (see also Raymond Dawson, The Decision to Aid Russia, University of North Carolina Press, 1959, pp. 55, 290).

Yep, the right does have a problem with FDR's policies. But the fact that Japan was going to war if we didn't help them destroy China is overlooked in those unbalanced studies.
 
Not to forget the attack on Guam and Wake island

For Guam

At 04:45 on 8 December, the Governor of the island, George McMillin was informed about the attack on Pearl Harbor. At 08:27, Japanese aircraft from Saipan attacked the Marine Barracks, the Piti Navy Yard, Libugon radio station, Standard Oil Company, and the Pan American Hotel.

For Wake

The Japanese bombers came in after the attack on PH had begun

Oh and what about the Cynthia Olson? On 7 December 1941, the I-26 sank the 2140-ton U.S. Army chartered lumber freighter Cynthia Olson[2] 300 nmi (550 km) off the coast of California — the first American merchant ship to be sunk by a Japanese submarine in the war. I-26 had orders not to commence hostilities until 0330 8 December (Tokyo time) -- the anticipated time of the attack on Pearl Harbor. I-26 found Cynthia Olson prior to that time, but remained submerged until surfacing near the freighter at 0330 Tokyo time (0800 7 December Hawaiian time or 0900 in the +9 time zone of the sinking.) I-26 fired a warning shell over Cynthia Olson from its 14-cm deck gun

There were also a number of US merchant ships and tugs seized with minutes or hours of the attack on PH, mainly in China but also I believe in Japan

Also the Islas Visayas was captured in the South China sea. It was running under a Panamian flag but was US crewed and carrying a US cargo
 
Last edited:

Trying to change the subject Bob?

Have you tried reading the

Japanese accounts yet?

No?

Oh that's right you're far to closed minded to do simple research, lol
 
Last edited:
Not to forget the attack on Guam

Yesterday, the Japanese government also launched an attack against Malaya.

Last night, Japanese forces attacked Hong Kong.

Last night, Japanese forces attacked Guam.

Last night, Japanese forces attacked the Philippine Islands.

Last night, the Japanese attacked Wake Island.

And this morning, the Japanese attacked Midway Island.

"It will be recorded that the distance of Hawaii from Japan makes it obvious that the attack was deliberately planned many days or even weeks ago. During the intervening time, the Japanese government has deliberately sought to deceive the United States by false statements and expressions of hope for continued peace. "
 
In that case, no damage to Pearl. The attacks on the PI in conjunction with the aborted attack on Hawaii would be enough to get a declaration of war.

However, I don't picture the IJA pilots running away from a fight. The orders were to press home the attack even if discovered in the last 24 hours, so they would have tried to fight their way to Pearl.

Sorry for some reason I thought there were no Zeros in the first wave. Clearly there were so yes they were prepared for a fight.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom