Merged Pearl Harbor: "Revisionists" vs. "Traditionalists"

All I know about the Pearl Harbour attack is the US miltary authorities were aware the Japanese were going to attack they were just not certain of where and exatctly when.

They were very sure that the Philippines would be attacked, Japan would have been very stupid to leave an enemy on her flank. There was never any reasonable indication that Hawaii would be attack, especially before war was declared by Japan.


Oh, and Kido Butai did not transmit. Grogan was full of ****.
 
The Lahaina anchorage was used as an alternative anchorage to Pearl Harbor. Given this fact, and how close the Lahaina anchorage was to Pearl Harbor, it makes perfect sense that the task force would have wanted to know if any U.S. naval ships were there in any numbers.

This information was relayed from a submarine division HQ to I-72, which in turn relayed it to the task force. Since I-72 was operating in support of the task force, it's no surprise that it received this info and then relayed it to the task force.

Do you know what "broadcast" means, Bob?
 
I am mystified as to why it would be necessary (other than to feed a CT) for the task force to risk detection by transmitting when all it would need would be to receive messages. It was not as if they were on a highly complex mission that required close coordination with other forces.

Their mission was to sail, undetected, to Hawaii, bomb the US Pacific fleet into scrap, then return to Japan hopefully with their carriers intact.

Other than intell updates, perhaps a warning if the IJN determined that the task force might have been detected, and, if it happened, a recall order, there was essentially no reason to have more communications.
 
I am mystified as to why it would be necessary (other than to feed a CT) for the task force to risk detection by transmitting when all it would need would be to receive messages. It was not as if they were on a highly complex mission that required close coordination with other forces.

Their mission was to sail, undetected, to Hawaii, bomb the US Pacific fleet into scrap, then return to Japan hopefully with their carriers intact.

Other than intell updates, perhaps a warning if the IJN determined that the task force might have been detected, and, if it happened, a recall order, there was essentially no reason to have more communications.
(other than to feed a CT)

There you go. The CTers are very good at ignoring reality. Its the reason some folks are campaigning to have "belief in conspiracy theories" added to the DSM. I once met Ralph Rene, an Moon-hoaxer from Indiana. His peers in that small town used to avoid him and shout him down when he got going on that nonsense. (He was the guy with the vodka bottle labeled "water" in a Penn and Teller episode.) Their rants used to be of the sandwich board type almost exclusively. Now, with the internet, they can pretend to be "part of a larger movement" for something or other.
 
Somehow the term 'large movement' describes the Pearl Harbour CT exactly.
 
Is bobtaftfan's claim about spies signaling submarines prior to the PH attack true? Does anyone have evidence?

In my very limited research I can find their only means of communication was either in person or via one of the two commercial telegraph lines.
 
Is bobtaftfan's claim about spies signaling submarines prior to the PH attack true? Does anyone have evidence?
Yoshikawa Takeo was the only official spy for the Japanese, and very good at his job. All of his information was sent via Western Union.

They recruited Otto Kuhn to be a fall-back spy if they were booted out of the country. Kuhn is considered to have been too inept for the job. He never actively worked at the job IIRC.
In my very limited research I can find their only means of communication was either in person or via one of the two commercial telegraph lines.
Kuhn would have used an extremely clumsy signalling system, rather Keystone Kops in nature.
 
There is another problem with the argument that a forewarned FDR who was determined to let Pearl Harbor be attacked could have put the Hawaiian forces on alert on 12/6 and could have also ordered the closure of the Japanese consulate to prevent the consulate from warning Tokyo. Such an action would have been a clear indication that FDR knew the attack was coming.

It was one thing for FDR to verbally tell a high-ranking Red Cross official to send extra supplies to Pearl Harbor and to direct him not to tell anyone why the supplies were being sent (and Red Cross records confirm that extra supplies were received shortly before the attack).

But it would have been quite another thing for FDR to not only put Pearl Harbor's forces on alert on 12/6 but to order the closure of the Japanese consulate as well. This would have smelled to high heaven of foreknowledge, and such an order would have been impossible to deny or to claim "misunderstanding" over later.
 
Last edited:
There is another problem with the argument that a forewarned FDR who was determined to let Pearl Harbor be attacked could have put the Hawaiian forces on alert on 12/6 and could have also ordered the closure of the Japanese consulate to prevent the consulate from warning Tokyo. Such an action would have been a clear indication that FDR knew the attack was coming.

It was one thing for FDR to verbally tell a high-ranking Red Cross official to send extra supplies to Pearl Harbor and to direct him not to tell anyone why the supplies were being sent (and Red Cross records confirm that extra supplies were received shortly before the attack).

But it would have been quite another thing for FDR to not only put Pearl Harbor's forces on alert on 12/6 but to order the closure of the Japanese consulate as well. This would have smelled to high heaven of foreknowledge, and such an order would have been impossible to deny or to claim "misunderstanding" over later.
Meaningless conjecture. You still have not established FDR foreknowledge. ADD moment?
 
There is another problem with the argument that a forewarned FDR who was determined to let Pearl Harbor be attacked could have put the Hawaiian forces on alert on 12/6 and could have also ordered the closure of the Japanese consulate to prevent the consulate from warning Tokyo. Such an action would have been a clear indication that FDR knew the attack was coming.
Yeah, and he didn't, so he wasn't aware of the attack.
It was one thing for FDR to verbally tell a high-ranking Red Cross official to send extra supplies to Pearl Harbor and to direct him not to tell anyone why the supplies were being sent (and Red Cross records confirm that extra supplies were received shortly before the attack).
When were those supplies ordered, how long had the Hawaiian Red Cross been preparing for war? You're sound bytes aren't backed with any information, so they fail you.
But it would have been quite another thing for FDR to not only put Pearl Harbor's forces on alert on 12/6 but to order the closure of the Japanese consulate as well. This would have smelled to high heaven of foreknowledge, and such an order would have been impossible to deny or to claim "misunderstanding" over later.

He didn't, so he wasn't aware. We've been talking about what he could have done if he did know. It would have been the intell coup of the war to have known about the attack, and "Just Let It Happen" would have been the stupidest response imaginable. I'm really concerned that you don't understand this.
 
But it would have been quite another thing for FDR to not only put Pearl Harbor's forces on alert on 12/6 but to order the closure of the Japanese consulate as well. This would have smelled to high heaven of foreknowledge, and such an order would have been impossible to deny or to claim "misunderstanding" over later.

So, the fact that FDR's actions did not indicate foreknowledge of the attack indicates that he had foreknowledge of the attack?
 
So acting like he had foreknowledge is suspicious, and not acting like he had foreknowledge is suspicious. Sounds like FDR was between a rock and a hard place. It must have been quite the dilemma for him
 
So acting like he had foreknowledge is suspicious, and not acting like he had foreknowledge is suspicious. Sounds like FDR was between a rock and a hard place. It must have been quite the dilemma for him

Of course he also had the real world to contend with.

The funny part is I know almost exactly when this conspiracy **** started. Sen. Gerald P. Nye was giving a speech to the America Firsters when news of the attack arrived. When he came off stage his aides gave him the news and he immediately spluttered, "He must have tricked 'em!" No rational reasoning was behind that thought, blurted out with no thought. He just reacted, reflexively responding to the events with his built-in prejudices.
 
Of course he also had the real world to contend with.

The funny part is I know almost exactly when this conspiracy **** started. Sen. Gerald P. Nye was giving a speech to the America Firsters when news of the attack arrived. When he came off stage his aides gave him the news and he immediately spluttered, "He must have tricked 'em!" No rational reasoning was behind that thought, blurted out with no thought. He just reacted, reflexively responding to the events with his built-in prejudices.

I didn't realize it began that early. I was always under the impression that the whole "FDR knew" meme was a more modern phenomenon.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom