Merged Pearl Harbor: "Revisionists" vs. "Traditionalists"

Does history record how FDR felt after the attack about his decision to put those ships at Pearl. And I am not talking about his day of infamy speech, but any private reflections he may have noted in diaries etc?
 
Does history record how FDR felt after the attack about his decision to put those ships at Pearl. And I am not talking about his day of infamy speech, but any private reflections he may have noted in diaries etc?

FDR's cabinet met at 2030 hours to get their information straight about the attack, and then the Congressional leaders came in and FDR briefed them. Prange doesn't say anything about the forward deployment issue. I'd love to read the notes of that meet. I guess I could get a copy from the FDR library.
 
Seriously. Do all conspiracy theorists take the same debate technique class?

I've noticed similar tricks in people who aren't CTs, just dogmatic, including from people in this forum who have argued against CTs, on other issues. It's more about sophism itself that anything else.
 
I am quite curious about this fellow, Takeo Yoshikawa. He would be the one that would tell the IJN if the fleet suddenly left pearl harbor. In fact he noted when the AC left the harbor.
 
Repeating myself yet again:

I see bobtaftfan is still refusing to explain (a) the Japanese accounts; (b) why a task force engaged on a top secret mission would be transmitting so many radio messages; and (c) why the U.S. would need to let the Pearl Harbor attack be successful in order to go to war when the mere attempt of an attack would have been more than sufficient, and even without the raid on Pearl Harbor the attacks on the Philippines would have meant war.
 
"Vessels moored in harbor: 9 battleships; 3 class B cruisers; 3 seaplane tenders, 17 destroyers. Entering harbor are 4 class B cruisers; 3 destroyers. All aircraft carriers and heavy cruisers have departed harbor….No indication of any changes in U.S. Fleet or anything unusual."

At what point would Takeo have thought something was unusual?

Given he had no idea when the attack would occur how would he even deem something to be unusual?
 
I'll repeat what I've explained before: Grogan's bearings were essentially/substantially triangulated because he took numerous bearings of the course of several days on a huge, slow-moving target.

And I'll repeat what others have said: you can't triangulate from a single, immobile position.
 
How about we talk about the bomb plot messages? Someone seemed to suggest that there was no important or unique intelligence in those messages and that therefore the fact that they were not relayed to Kimmel and Short proves nothing.
Someone else pointed out they weren't needed, wanted, or used by the IJN, so their being termed "bomb plot" is an affectation. The Gaimudaijin didn't forward the information in that format, just a summary of the ships in port.
 
...and still going on with the deliberate obtuseness regarding limitations of DF in the absence of triangulation - but this is understandable as it guts the credibility of the claim.

Nothing new going on here, but most educational as a result of contributions by the people who actually know what they're talking about.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom