Merged Pearl Harbor: "Revisionists" vs. "Traditionalists"

Just a lurker on this thread, but wouldn't it be critical if one were to argue conspiracy to consider the Japanese accounts?
 
Just a lurker on this thread, but wouldn't it be critical if one were to argue conspiracy to consider the Japanese accounts?

They were obviously in on it so you can't believe them.
 
There was also amateur radio astronomers around the world catching snippets of exchanges between NASA and the guys orbiting the Moon

There was a guy on ATS who said he and his friends had actually pirated and watched the TV signal being received by Australia, by tapping into it on its way to the States. I don't think the hoaxers ever got around to responding to that.
 
Before I complete my reply to Jacobsen's article on Grogan's bearings, I want to get a copy of the report that Grogan submitted to the Matson Line (the "Record for Posterity"). I have located a source and should have a copy of the report by the end of next week.

In the meantime, I continue to note the abrasive, dismissive attitude that some people display in response to arguments against the traditional Pearl Harbor story.

I get the impression that many tradtionalists have only read one side of the story. If they have read any revisionist works at all, they apparently skimmed through them and/or read with minds determined not to be persuaded in the slightest degree.

At least one person on this board has claimed that DF cannot be used to determine a target's location and course. This is an erroneous and easily refuted view, but it's been stated with adamant certainty. There are numerous accounts in books about WW II of DF providing the location and course of enemy ships. Layton mentions a couple in his book And I Was There.

In an e-mail dialogue, a person who was I was told was one of most knowledgable traditionalists around classified John Toland as a "Roosevelt hater" and at the same time assured me that Toland's book Infamy was worthless. Well, if this person had actually read Toland's book, he would have known that Toland was a huge fan of FDR's. In several places in Infamy, Toland praises FDR for his domestic policies, even though Toland also thought that FDR acted unethically and unwisely in regard to Pearl Harbor.

When I mentioned Stimson's diary entry about FDR discussing the need to maneuver Japan into "firing the first shot," this person howled and scoffed and said this claim had been debunked. Really? And do you know what his "explanation" was? His "refutation" was that Stimson later claimed he had misspoken! Now, of course, that's nonsense. By normal rules of evidence, when someone repeats something twice in two paragraphs in a journal and also discusses the point in those same paragraphs, a later claim of having "misspoken" is not credible.

In that same e-mail dialogue, when I opined that FDR did not risk alerting Hawaii the day before because he could have feared that Japanese spies on the island would have noted the change in alert posture and could have warned the task force, he, in all apparent seriousness, mocked this argument and sarcastically asked how Japanese spies on Oahu could have contacted the task force.

He was apparently unaware that we have known for years that intelligence about Pearl Harbor from the Japanese consulate in Hawaii was relayed to the task force via Tokyo on at least two occasions. I was amazed that it did not occur to him that it would have been a simple matter for intel from spies on Oahu to be relayed from the consulate via Tokyo to the task force, even if he didn't know that this was in fact done on other occasions.

In that same e-mail dialogue, another example of an apparent failure to read both sides surfaced when the discussion turned to FDR's strange decision to move the Pacific Fleet to Hawaii. The absurdity of this decision was detailed at the time by the fleet's commander, Admiral James Richardson. He repeated his arguments against the move in his 1973 book On the Treadmill to Pearl Harbor, and numerous scholars have noted the lack of any valid reasons for the move.

FDR proved by his subsequent actions that his excuse for the move (that it would discourage Japanese aggression in Asia) was phony--and, needless to say, events proved that his excuse was also horribly wrong. Moving the fleet to Hawaii made no tactical or strategic sense; it made no training sense; it made no logistics sense; and it made no financial sense. But, if the intent was to use the fleet as bait, then it made perfect sense.

In reply, my traditionalist correspondent, while basically conceding that there were arguments against the move, opined that the move was not proof of conspiracy because FDR would have moved the fleet to Singapore if he had intended to use it as bait! Of course, such an argument only kicks the can down the road to another venue and does not explain the absence of any valid reason for the move and the fact that FDR soon proved by his own actions that his stated reason for the move was phony.

Finally, getting back to Jacobsen's article on Grogan, my coming reply will not add too terribly much to what Villa and Wilford have already said about Grogan's claims in their article "Signals Intelligence and Pearl Harbor." I will have some additional points to make, but not too many more than what Villa and Wilford have said. They respond to nearly every claim that Jacobsen makes, point by point, and I think they dismantle his arguments.

http://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/02684520600885665
 
Before I complete my reply to Jacobsen's article on Grogan's bearings, I want to get a copy of the report that Grogan submitted to the Matson Line (the "Record for Posterity"). I have located a source and should have a copy of the report by the end of next week.

In the meantime, I continue to note the abrasive, dismissive attitude that some people display in response to arguments against the traditional Pearl Harbor story.

I get the impression that many tradtionalists have only read one side of the story. If they have read any revisionist works at all, they apparently skimmed through them and/or read with minds determined not to be persuaded in the slightest degree.

Unfortunately I have had to read much of the garbage presented by the retards who espouse the LIHOP theory, and others even stupider. British frogmen putting limpet mines on our battleships to make sure enough were sunk to get Americans angry enough to agree to go to war against Japan? Yep, read that.

It always strikes me as humorous that the folks who refuse to read the material supplied turn around and claim the other side doesn't read what they so love. True, not everybody has a stomach strong enough to Stinnett, but some of us do. In 2007 I had a collection of such tripe, book, magazine articles, newspaper clippings, etc., plus my own inquiries and interviews with True Believers and skeptics.
 
BTW, I was a silent witness to that email dialog. You wildly misrepresent the contents of Tracy's messages.

no surprise there then.

Big wall of text in last post, no answers to any questions asked by other posters.
 
Last edited:
Still nothing about the Japanese records.

I was amazed that it did not occur to him that it would have been a simple matter for intel from spies on Oahu to be relayed from the consulate via Tokyo to the task force, even if he didn't know that this was in fact done on other occasions.

You're trying to conflate possibility, probability, and reality again.
 
Last edited:
At least one person on this board has claimed that DF cannot be used to determine a target's location and course. This is an erroneous and easily refuted view, but it's been stated with adamant certainty.

Yep. One of those would be me. If it's so easily refuted, why don't you run through the procedure ( you have, after all, claimed expertise in this), and show how a single receiver finds an unambiguous position of a moving transmitter, where the transmitter is never in sight of the receiver, and refute it?

"Homing in" on a transmitter does find its location, but that isn't what we're talking about.
 
Last edited:
Originally Posted by BazBear
I think what disgusts me most about this PH LIHOP theory is that we are asked to believe that the USN SIGINT operators, analysts and translators would deliberately hide this supposed foreknowledge, just throwing their fellow sailors and servicemen who died or were injured at Pearl under the bus. Then we are also asked to believe that all these people managed to keep this secret for over 70 years.

First of all, some intelligence personnel have come forward to expose foreknowledge of the attack, but your side has either summarily dismissed them or has dismissed on flimsy grounds, even when these individuals have been senior officers and/or people who went on to successful careers in other fields and were regarded as responsible, credible persons.

Also, your argument ignores the fact that many of those individuals may have assumed that there was some innocent explanation for why the intelligence indicating an attack on Pearl Harbor was not acted upon by high officials.

We should keep in mind, too, that the very first version of the official story was that Kimmel and Short did have all the same intelligence that high officials in Washington had and that they had simply failed to act on it. If Safford had not blown the whistle, it may have been decades before we even found out about the Magic intercepts.
 
Before I complete my reply to Jacobsen's article on Grogan's bearings, I want to get a copy of the report that Grogan submitted to the Matson Line (the "Record for Posterity"). I have located a source and should have a copy of the report by the end of next week.

Source? Matson Line archives, or something a little more obscure that will raise a few eyebrows?

In the meantime, I continue to note the abrasive, dismissive attitude that some people display in response to arguments against the traditional Pearl Harbor story.

I get the impression that many tradtionalists have only read one side of the story. If they have read any revisionist works at all, they apparently skimmed through them and/or read with minds determined not to be persuaded in the slightest degree.

Many are abrasive because these "arguments" have long since been debunked, aren't supported by any kind of evidence, etc. Many of us have read some of the "revisionist" works and found them lacking for various reasons.

At least one person on this board has claimed that DF cannot be used to determine a target's location and course. This is an erroneous and easily refuted view, but it's been stated with adamant certainty. There are numerous accounts in books about WW II of DF providing the location and course of enemy ships. Layton mentions a couple in his book And I Was There.

Well, more than one actually - and I would be one of them.

DF'ing can certainly be used to locate targets. However, what Mr. Grogan reports is a series of bearings - not bearings and distances. There was no triangulation allowing for position fixing - no second receiver with bearings, etc. There are accounts of using DF to locate things in WWI, but all ot the accounts use multiple receivers (whether you're looking at radio transmissions, flash-rangers, or sound-ranging) to triangulate position - and all the accounts I've seen for WWII do the same - multiple bearings to fix location.

<snip>

In that same e-mail dialogue, when I opined that FDR did not risk alerting Hawaii the day before because he could have feared that Japanese spies on the island would have noted the change in alert posture and could have warned the task force, he, in all apparent seriousness, mocked this argument and sarcastically asked how Japanese spies on Oahu could have contacted the task force.

He was apparently unaware that we have known for years that intelligence about Pearl Harbor from the Japanese consulate in Hawaii was relayed to the task force via Tokyo on at least two occasions. I was amazed that it did not occur to him that it would have been a simple matter for intel from spies on Oahu to be relayed from the consulate via Tokyo to the task force, even if he didn't know that this was in fact done on other occasions.

So, how could the spies have gotten the word to the taskforce within 24 hours? How long did it take for messages sent by the consulate to get to the fleet? It's not like the frequencies used by the Kido Butai were on hand at the consulate, or that the encryption codes used by the fleet were on hand either.

The chain of intel would look like this:

1. Spy obtains intel;
2. Spy encrypts intel;
3. Spy transmits encrypted intel to consulate;
4. Consulate decrypts intel;
5. Consulate evaluates intel, determines it needs priority transmission;
6. Consulate encrypts intel;
7. Consulate transmits intel to Tokyo;
8. Tokyo decrypts intel;
9. Tokyo evaluates intel, determines it needs priority transmission;
10. Tokyo encrypts intel;
11. Tokyo transmits intel to Kido Butai;
12. Kido Butai decrypts intel; and
13. Kido Butai diseminates intel via flags, lights, etc. - or possibly by radio if the message is to abort.

Given the technical realities of WWII - that is very likely more than 24 hours. This is not now with near real-time transmission of information.



In that same e-mail dialogue, another example of an apparent failure to read both sides surfaced when the discussion turned to FDR's strange decision to move the Pacific Fleet to Hawaii. The absurdity of this decision was detailed at the time by the fleet's commander, Admiral James Richardson. He repeated his arguments against the move in his 1973 book On the Treadmill to Pearl Harbor, and numerous scholars have noted the lack of any valid reasons for the move.

Richardson was not a commander I would want in place in the event of war - he was convinced that the US would be unable to project power west of Hawaii, and that therefore the plan was doomed to failure. Generally when commanders are saying the plan is flawed, and not changing the plan you replace them.

FDR wanted a forward base to counter Japanese naval presence.

FDR proved by his subsequent actions that his excuse for the move (that it would discourage Japanese aggression in Asia) was phony--and, needless to say, events proved that his excuse was also horribly wrong. Moving the fleet to Hawaii made no tactical or strategic sense; it made no training sense; it made no logistics sense; and it made no financial sense. But, if the intent was to use the fleet as bait, then it made perfect sense.

Moving the fleet to Hawaii does make sense - and not to use as bait. Hawaii is an excellent forward base in the Pacific. Given the distances involved in the Pacific, such a position allows you to strike faster than would a fleet based in San Franciso and Seattle.

You can of course back up your other claims about the move making no sense with references to right?

In reply, my traditionalist correspondent, while basically conceding that there were arguments against the move, opined that the move was not proof of conspiracy because FDR would have moved the fleet to Singapore if he had intended to use it as bait! Of course, such an argument only kicks the can down the road to another venue and does not explain the absence of any valid reason for the move and the fact that FDR soon proved by his own actions that his stated reason for the move was phony.

Which actions prove the reason for the move to be false?

Finally, getting back to Jacobsen's article on Grogan, my coming reply will not add too terribly much to what Villa and Wilford have already said about Grogan's claims in their article "Signals Intelligence and Pearl Harbor." I will have some additional points to make, but not too many more than what Villa and Wilford have said. They respond to nearly every claim that Jacobsen makes, point by point, and I think they dismantle his arguments.

http://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/02684520600885665

Except that Prof Villa gets his dates wrong, the bearing to the fleet wrong, doesn't account for the decoy transmissions being on the same bearing and for the Japanese documents that show that, barring one transmission, the Kido Butai maintained radio silence. Other than that an excellent refutation:rolleyes:
 
First of all, some intelligence personnel have come forward to expose foreknowledge of the attack, but your side has either summarily dismissed them or has dismissed on flimsy grounds, even when these individuals have been senior officers and/or people who went on to successful careers in other fields and were regarded as responsible, credible persons.

Also, your argument ignores the fact that many of those individuals may have assumed that there was some innocent explanation for why the intelligence indicating an attack on Pearl Harbor was not acted upon by high officials.

We should keep in mind, too, that the very first version of the official story was that Kimmel and Short did have all the same intelligence that high officials in Washington had and that they had simply failed to act on it. If Safford had not blown the whistle, it may have been decades before we even found out about the Magic intercepts.
Again, you show your ignorance of the primary source material.
 
FDR proved by his subsequent actions that his excuse for the move (that it would discourage Japanese aggression in Asia) was phony--and, needless to say, events proved that his excuse was also horribly wrong. Moving the fleet to Hawaii made no tactical or strategic sense; it made no training sense; it made no logistics sense; and it made no financial sense. But, if the intent was to use the fleet as bait, then it made perfect sense.

No not at all, a military and political concept called "Fleet In Being" was behind FDRs decision

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fleet_in_being

Where it did go wrong is the Japanese did not think like their Western counterparts and saw the additional fleet units as a juicer target. But the fact they went after this fleet proves they saw it as the danger to their plans FDR intended.

If you really wanted to use the fleet as bait, Manila is the logical place to position it. If FDR had done that I would have concerns about his thought process.

I would like to talk to Gawdzilla's point about opposition to the plan. A good leader will always surround themselves with people who have differing views. That way the leader hears good arguments for and against particular plans, and can consider themselves fully briefed on all facts, then make their call from there.

Obviously those who opposed the plan to move the fleet are going to try and play the "Told you so" card when public discussion occurs after the fact
 
Last edited:
J.O. Richardson was CinCUS before Kimmel, and objected to the forward deployment of the US Fleet (the formal name of the Pacific contingent of the USN) on grounds that Pearl did not have the facilities to maintain the Fleet. Conspiracy theorist ignore part of that and say "Richardson didn't want the fleet in Hawaii", often adding "because he knew it was vulnerable, but FDR put it there just for that reason", which is not true. Richardson testified before Congress that he was not worried about the safety of the Fleet, but logistics.

The draw-backs to the forward deployment were obvious and made clear to FDR by Knox, et al., and the final decision was that its value as a deterrent outweighed the problem caused. Efforts were made to get the facilities built up as much as possible, this was on-going as of the date of the attack.

BTW, in all the thousands of pages of testimony before Congress and the prior investigations, only one person said he'd predicted an attack in advance, and withdrew that statement when pressed for details.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom