Merged Pearl Harbor: "Revisionists" vs. "Traditionalists"

* He repeats the myth of radio silence but doesn't address the fact that Goldstein and Dillon's The Pearl Harbor Papers, which he cites, documents the fact that one of the submaries of the Kido Butai's submarine forces did in fact break silence: on 12/6 submarine I-72 radioed the task force that "the enemy is not in the Lahaina anchorage" (p. 243).



What other chatty conversations did the fleet have?
 
It sure is weird how Bobby isn't going for a point-by point rebuttal of any the people who disagree with him.
 
Yes LtCdr ichiro Togami sent a message, but as he was detached and off Maui when he did so this wouldn't have mattered. Care to tell us how long the message was? AFAIK this wasn't detected by the US

So bob have you looked at the message logs yet?
 
Last edited:
Proof that Lurline was actually doing the transmitting, not the Japanese:



Oops. That's Lurleen. :blush:

Still makes more sense than anything BTF posted.
 
* He repeats the myth of radio silence but doesn't address the fact that Goldstein and Dillon's The Pearl Harbor Papers, which he cites, documents the fact that one of the submaries of the Kido Butai's submarine forces did in fact break silence: on 12/6 submarine I-72 radioed the task force that "the enemy is not in the Lahaina anchorage" (p. 243).


Once again: Now find something indicating the carrier strike force itself transmitted. That is the key point here. We'll wait.

Once again: Why would a Japanese strike force engaged on a risky, top secret mission transmit so many radio messages that could be detected? All you've offered is some vague suggestion that ships must use radio communication to keep on station and coordinate activities, but you've not supported that suggestion with evidence in any way whatsoever.

Those are specific points which need addressing. More generally, there is, once again this: A successful Pearl Harbor attack was hardly necessary for war between the U.S. and Japan; the mere attempt of an attack would have been more than sufficient. Even without the Pearl Harbor raid the attack on the Philippines would have resulted in war. So on purely logical grounds your allegation makes no sense.
 
Since I know nothing about this Grogan person (nor have I read any of the revisionist books), I was wondering if he actually stated the call signs of the ships he believes he detected? Also, the call signs of whoever they were communicating with?

I presume he also indicated whether the messages were being passed in international morse or the IJN special morse code? If it was in the IJN morse code then he was conversant with it? If he was the signal officer and supervised operators and the radio room, where or why did the operators learn IJN morse which would only otherwise be useful in communicating with the IJN?

It would be unlikely that he could discern the ship types from the call signs since those would be arbitrarily assigned. In addition, the call signs were reassigned, I believe, on December 1 which was off schedule and very early after the expected reassignment a few months before.

I can only assume that he is given credence by revisionists because otherwise there would be little, if any, evidence that the task force actually transmitted during its journey to Hawaiian waters.
 
I think what disgusts me most about this PH LIHOP theory is that we are asked to believe that the USN SIGINT operators, analysts and translators would deliberately hide this supposed foreknowledge, just throwing their fellow sailors and servicemen who died or were injured at Pearl under the bus. Then we are also asked to believe that all these people managed to keep this secret for over 70 years.
 
I think what disgusts me most about this PH LIHOP theory is that we are asked to believe that the USN SIGINT operators, analysts and translators would deliberately hide this supposed foreknowledge, just throwing their fellow sailors and servicemen who died or were injured at Pearl under the bus. Then we are also asked to believe that all these people managed to keep this secret for over 70 years.

Plus there's the Naval Aide FDR had. Name of Beardall. He has a son in the Navy at Hawaii. LIHOP says he'd be fine with risking his son's life so FDR could get something he didn't need in reality.
 
I think what disgusts me most about this PH LIHOP theory is that we are asked to believe that the USN SIGINT operators, analysts and translators would deliberately hide this supposed foreknowledge, just throwing their fellow sailors and servicemen who died or were injured at Pearl under the bus. Then we are also asked to believe that all these people managed to keep this secret for over 70 years.

Seems to be a common CT theme, probably says more about them than the people they accuse.
 
Seems to be a common CT theme, probably says more about them than the people they accuse.


There was a recent study (last year?) that showed that people who believe in grand conspiracy theories are far more likely to join a conspiracy than those that don't believe in them.
 
I think what disgusts me most about this PH LIHOP theory
......

is how they ignore the Japanese records......kinda like discussing Waterloo and not mentioning what the French had to say about it
 
I think what disgusts me most about this PH LIHOP theory is that we are asked to believe that the USN SIGINT operators, analysts and translators would deliberately hide this supposed foreknowledge, just throwing their fellow sailors and servicemen who died or were injured at Pearl under the bus. Then we are also asked to believe that all these people managed to keep this secret for over 70 years.

And there were not all that many before the war started. The US Army had about 331 people involved (half in Washington, half in the field) in Sigint and the USN had about 700 (2/3 in DF and traffic analysis and 1/3 in code breaking which had most of the 80 officers). Since the officers regularly rotated through other assignments, especially as part of the peacetime navy, it is inconceiveable that they would, as a block, acquiese to something that would cause large loss of life and ships to their service and country.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom