Since I know nothing about this Grogan person (nor have I read any of the revisionist books), I was wondering if he actually stated the call signs of the ships he believes he detected? Also, the call signs of whoever they were communicating with?
I presume he also indicated whether the messages were being passed in international morse or the IJN special morse code? If it was in the IJN morse code then he was conversant with it? If he was the signal officer and supervised operators and the radio room, where or why did the operators learn IJN morse which would only otherwise be useful in communicating with the IJN?
It would be unlikely that he could discern the ship types from the call signs since those would be arbitrarily assigned. In addition, the call signs were reassigned, I believe, on December 1 which was off schedule and very early after the expected reassignment a few months before.
I can only assume that he is given credence by revisionists because otherwise there would be little, if any, evidence that the task force actually transmitted during its journey to Hawaiian waters.