mikegriffith1
Muse
- Joined
- Sep 25, 2012
- Messages
- 805
I see lots of claims being made about what the Japanese were doing. What I don't see is any corroborating evidence for those claims. In the quote you cites it supplies precisely zero in the way of corroboration. Just arguments from incredulity which boil down to: "Well, ships in a task force must use radio communication or else they get lost/don't know what to do/insert other reason here!"
So again we are still left with my question from before, and still unanswered: What do Japanese sources say about radio communication from the task force? If Japanese records indicate the fleet made no transmissions, then either Grogan is wrong about the source, or the Japanese falsified their records. If the latter is the claim, then one must provide compelling reasons why the Japanese would falsify their records to indicate the task force did not transmit radio messages when in fact it did.
I cited one example of a Kido Butai transmission found in a traditionalist collection of Japanese naval documents. On 12/6 submarine I-72, one of the subs of the task force's supporting sub forces, transmitted a message to the advance force and the task force that "the enemy is not in the Lahaina anchorage" (The Pearl Harbor Papers, p. 243).
Villa and Wilford, among others, have documented several other task force intercepts that clearly were not among the false messages broadcast from Japan (e.g., Wilford, Pearl Harbor Redefined: USN Radio Intelligence in 1941, pp. 45-95).
And, as I've mentioned previously, those same IJN sources that claimed absolute radio silence made other claims that turned out to be false. They claimed that they received no intel from the Hawaiian consulate, but they received intel from it on at least two occasions. They claimed that no written records survived, but that was proven false too.
I also repeat the fact that there is a mass of evidence that British and Dutch intelligence intercepted transmissions from the task force, and that they warned American officials that Japanese ships were headed toward Pearl Harbor (e.g., Wilford, Pearl Harbor Redefined: USN Radio Intelligence in 1941, pp. 97-102).
And to keep replying to this evidence with the bald assertion that "the Kido Butai did not transmit" is specious circular reasoning. It's like saying "all your evidence that the Earth is round is wrong because the Earth is flat." The IJN was not about to broadcast false messages that would indicate comms between carriers and tankers when they were trying to make us think those carriers were in home waters.
