Merged Pearl Harbor: "Revisionists" vs. "Traditionalists"

The confusion may have started with my post a few pages back asking if triangulation of a moving source using another moving source is possible. I should have asked, "Is triangulation at sea possible using only bearing finding equipment when both the tracker and the trace are moving."

I completely agree that finding a radio collared bear is possible using only one source but that is completely irrelevant as its nothing like Grogen was doing.

Thanks to everyone for all the radio information and such, very entertaining.

I have to repeat Redworm's question - What's the difference between what happened and destroying the Japanese as they tried to sneak attack Pearl Harbor? Don't we go to war with Japan either way?
 
Last edited:
After the fitting of HFDF with a PPI to RN Escorts they were able to home in on U-Boats transmissions of only a few seconds, they didn't do it by triangulation they did it by turning towards the source of the transmission and running down the bearing, no triangulation. It helped that they knew the power of the U-Boat transmissions so could get a rough range from them.
 
No. Present evidence for your claims.
You have lost all credibility. I knew nothing about it, but
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Adcock_antenna

Something like that is quite easy to determine.

Again, useless.

No, you're response is false, hence it applies to you.

Somebody posts some facts, and you simply say "No", and it turns out you don't know what you are talking about. What is up with that?

Same for all this nonsense about determining location from radio transmissions.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-frequency_direction_finding

Now sure it may not apply to the fleet, but that wasn't what people were saying. They claimed it was impossible!
 
Don't we go to war with Japan either way?

I'm not claiming this source is accurate, but it paints the picture of why the US would leave the commanders in the dark about what was happening.

Secretary of State Hull's note to the Japanese government of November 26. Before sending this communication Hull had considered proposing a compromise formula which would have relaxed the blockade of Japan in return for Japanese withdrawal from southern Indochina and a limitation of Japanese forces in northern Indochina.

However, Hull dropped this idea under pressure from British and Chinese sources. He dispatched a veritable ultimatum on November 26, which demanded unconditional Japanese withdrawal from China and from Indochina and insisted that there should be "no support of any government in China other than the National government [Chiang Kai-shek]." Hull admitted that this note took Japanese-American relations out of the realm of diplomacy and placed them in the hands of the military authorities.

The negative Japanese reply to this note was delivered almost simultaneously with the attack on Pearl Harbor. There was a strange and as yet unexplained failure to prepare for this attack by giving General Short and Admiral Kimmel, commanders on the spot, a clear picture of the imminent danger. As Secretary of War Stimson explained the American policy, it was to maneuver the Japanese into firing the first shot, and it may have been feared that openly precautionary and defensive moves on the part of Kimmel and Short would scare off the impending attack by the Japanese task force which was known to be on its way to some American outpost.
http://www.ihr.org/jhr/v14/v14n6p19_Chamberlin.html

There is a possible reason. From reading the commanders views they certainly wanted to know why they weren't warned. And to clear their names. The official story makes them look like incompetent fools.
 
"Veritable ultimatum"? Do you know the definition of an ultimatum or are you just winging it?

The commanders had to cover themselves, so of course they squawked "foul", but that was not justified. They knew war was coming, but considered themselves immune. The actions of an area commander are his decisions, Washington only directs, they do not micromanage. So Kimmel and Short should have been alert to the danger, but Kimmel provided Yamamoto the lever he needed to get permission from the Imperial General Headquarters, a "guaranteed big bag". Kimmel ran the fleet on bankers hours, a large portion of it was in port regularly, every weekend. Takeo reported this to Japan and it was the thing that made the IGHQ agree to the attack.

There is a cardinal rule passed down from Sun Tzu, "Do not become predictable." Kimmel failed the fleet, and he deserved to be hammered into the ground for that. As it was, he only got relieved of his command. He should have been court-martialed.

And quoting IHR will get you laughed at. Be advised.
 
You have lost all credibility. I knew nothing about it, but
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Adcock_antenna

Something like that is quite easy to determine.



No, you're response is false, hence it applies to you.

Somebody posts some facts, and you simply say "No", and it turns out you don't know what you are talking about. What is up with that?

Same for all this nonsense about determining location from radio transmissions.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-frequency_direction_finding

Now sure it may not apply to the fleet, but that wasn't what people were saying. They claimed it was impossible!

Both of the pages that you linked to talk about stationary transmitters. This conversation was about transmitters and receivers that were moving.

Reading for comprehension helps. :boggled:

ETA: Someone is trying to hold their position at all costs. If you guessed r-j then you win the prize.
 
Last edited:
I'm not claiming this source is accurate, but it paints the picture of why the US would leave the commanders in the dark about what was happening.


http://www.ihr.org/jhr/v14/v14n6p19_Chamberlin.html

There is a possible reason. From reading the commanders views they certainly wanted to know why they weren't warned. And to clear their names. The official story makes them look like incompetent fools.

I didn't ask for a reason, I asked what the difference was. Either way FDR gets his war.

It doesn't matter who fires the first shot, if the U.S. catches the IJN sneaking up on Pearl we still go to war. Even if he never gets to attack the IJN because they get word and retreat the U.S. still goes to war.

If you are going to insist on "the first shot" then you quietly get your base on standby, your carriers are already at sea, you start sending some destroyers and subs to flank the IJN. Wait till they fire and spring your trap.
 
What he described is not triangulation, it's playing Marco-Polo with two players.

To an extent this is true, but, if you plot all the bearings taken over varied positions, always comparing your last 2 positions, compensating around the intersect for speed and direction, then essentially you are triangulating using very acute angles and a time delay.

Obviously 2 receivers are the ideal for real time intersect plots.
 
It doesn't matter who fires the first shot, if the U.S. catches the IJN sneaking up on Pearl we still go to war. Even if he never gets to attack the IJN because they get word and retreat the U.S. still goes to war.


Not only that, but war doesn't even require the attack on Pearl Harbor. The original Japanese plan, after all, was an assault upon the Philippines as well as the Dutch East Indies and other targets in the area. The only difference is that by attacking Pearl they knock the U.S. battleships out of the fight at the start, allowing them more time to make their conquests closer to home free from USN interference. Without the Pearl Harbor raid, the U.S. fleet sorties after the Philippines are attacked and a pitched naval battle is fought between the IJN and USN once the latter's forces arrive in the area.

That was how both sides originally expected things to unfold.
 
I didn't ask for a reason, I asked what the difference was. Either way FDR gets his war.

It doesn't matter who fires the first shot, if the U.S. catches the IJN sneaking up on Pearl we still go to war. Even if he never gets to attack the IJN because they get word and retreat the U.S. still goes to war.

If you are going to insist on "the first shot" then you quietly get your base on standby, your carriers are already at sea, you start sending some destroyers and subs to flank the IJN. Wait till they fire and spring your trap.

And, of course, there were other attacks that day. FDR listed them in his "Infamy" speech. So a total wash at Pearl would not have stopped the other attacks, and the US would have been at war with Japan. This is a prime reason LIHOP is crackers. We were at war with Japan if not a single IJN plane appeared above Pearl.
 
Not only that, but war doesn't even require the attack on Pearl Harbor. The original Japanese plan, after all, was an assault upon the Philippines as well as the Dutch East Indies and other targets in the area. The only difference is that by attacking Pearl they knock the U.S. battleships out of the fight at the start, allowing them more time to make their conquests closer to home free from USN interference. Without the Pearl Harbor raid, the U.S. fleet sorties after the Philippines are attacked and a pitched naval battle is fought between the IJN and USN once the latter's forces arrive in the area.

That was how both sides originally expected things to unfold.

Oh, snap!
 
I am not refusing to to demonstrate how to achieve triangulation.

I have explained my approach to triangulation already.

Why should I repeat myself for your benefit, you have already made your position clear on my level of ignorance.:p

And I am giving you an excellent chance to publicly prove me wrong. I'll even PM the picture to another active poster of this thread, so they can verify that I have an answer.
 
It's really pretty funny in retropsect.



It's like the issue of radios and triangulation has become some sort of position to be held at all costs. Then when it is obvious you can locate with one moving receiver, and a moving transmitter, the goal posts change suddenly. ....
No, they're the exact same goalposts. Moving receiver taking bearings at points X and Y. I even allowed you to ignore the margin of error

I like how you don't even acknowledge my post asking you to prove that it can be done, and have to respond to someone responding to a similar challenge to him.

I figured it out,
Doubtful.

and I'm sort of an idiot.
I can't imagine why you would be giving us these straight lines otherwise.

That is so wrong! If you triangulate, you know exactly how far away something is! That's the point!!
Then make a guess at post 451. In MSPaint if you have to.
I think everyone needs to read that again.
Which is why you've not actually presented any evidence in this thread, and just repeated your assertion and made personal attacks and responded to individual sentences instead of actual points?

Tell me; if our ears are so stuffed with wax, why are you here? Clearly, you're not actually going to discuss anything.
 
That may very well be, but it doesn't change the fact that people acting all smarter than everyone else were obviously wrong about it being possible. It's geometry!
Well, this is ironic. You keep saying it's obvious, yet have presented no evidence.

Using a moving receiver and a moving transmitter. This does not mean the fleet was detected, as they were not broadcasting. We know this because the Japanese said they weren't.
So why have you been arguing about this? And why haven't you tried your hand yourself?

The biggest problem with the Grogan theory is that the SS Lurline was not trying to locate the position of the source.

All they got was rough bearings over several days. This was in no way triangulating.

To achieve triangulation, the SS Lurline should have been altering course and repeating course corrections in accordance with the RDF plots.

Instead the SS Lurline continued steaming on it's original course away from the source.

To triangulate using mobile, single transmitters and mobile single receivers, you need to actively alter course and keep correcting, all the time with every new plot, until within visual range.

Hence, my earlier statement about brains and mk1 eyeballs. The range and inaccuracies can only be improved when adopting this approach.

Wrong. Doesn't matter how much "course correction" you do. You can't accurately triangulate with just bearings over several days. The assertion being made was that just the two bearings were enough, and now you're trying to move the goalposts.
 
And I am giving you an excellent chance to publicly prove me wrong. I'll even PM the picture to another active poster of this thread, so they can verify that I have an answer.

Judging by this, it is apparent that you are not reading my posts.:rolleyes:
 
It is, but not in the way that you think it is.



It is not obvious because it cannot be done.

Using the image that 00063 provided:

[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/thum_5559550770788a4af3.jpg[/qimg]

I have added 5 courses (of the infinite many) that a moving transmitter could be on and return the bearings that ship X received.

The black ones are moving in the same general direction as X, the green ones are moving in the other general direction. Hell, the purple line is a possible course!!!!11

(I borrowed MSPaintFireTM from one of the resident 9/11 Truthers :D)



Admitting your lack of intelligence doesn't help your case either.



What he described is not triangulation, it's playing Marco-Polo with two players.



If the receiver and transmitter are both moving, the transmitter will not be one of the corners of the triangle. It may be far outside of the triangle. Triangulation pretty much requires a triangle. The best you can get is the general direction.



Try to really get the meaning this time.

ETA: 00063 - sorry if I accidentally marked your course. But with infinite possibilities I'm guessing that didn't happen.

Actually, one of them is pretty close. Here's a hint; not the purple.
 
You have lost all credibility. I knew nothing about it, but
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Adcock_antenna

Something like that is quite easy to determine.
You keep saying that, yet are unwilling to explain in any detail.

No, you're response is false, hence it applies to you.

Somebody posts some facts, and you simply say "No", and it turns out you don't know what you are talking about. What is up with that?

Same for all this nonsense about determining location from radio transmissions.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-frequency_direction_finding

Now sure it may not apply to the fleet, but that wasn't what people were saying. They claimed it was impossible!

No, we claimed it was impossible with just two bearings taken days apart. That's a straw man. Linking to Wikipedia pages does nothing to demonstrate your comprehension of the issues involved, especially when you try to preemptively backpedal by declaring yourself an idiot, especially when people here have demonstrated more understanding than you. And, as 777 pointed out, you linked to pages about stationary transmitters, not moving ones, which is what we're talking about.

To an extent this is true, but, if you plot all the bearings taken over varied positions, always comparing your last 2 positions, compensating around the intersect for speed and direction, then essentially you are triangulating using very acute angles and a time delay.
The time delay is rather critical. You can take all the bearings you want over time, and you'll have great difficulty determining a course. Any derived course will be little better than a random guess.

Obviously 2 receivers are the ideal for real time intersect plots.
Which are not under discussion. Heck, even two readings taken hours apart aren't going to be much good, much less days.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom