Merged Pearl Harbor: "Revisionists" vs. "Traditionalists"

We found a very intact Zero in the Aleutians, upside down in a bog (pilot drowned on "dry land" IIRC) and took it back to some godforsaken air strip in California for tests. The pilots wrung every bit of information out of it they could.


Yep, one of the unexpected bonuses of the Midway battle.
 
At first, certainly. But once its weaknesses were understood, the Wildcat, when flown with proper tactics, could just hold its own against the Zero. When the Hellcat came on the scene, the Zero was outmatched.

There was an interesting show on dogfights in the Military Channel that showed some of the tactics used by both sides.
 
Looking for pictures of the SS Lurline. Found one of the late '30s configuration, and another from 1943. The '43 pic shows her service as a troopship, in this case transporting the 442d Regimental Combat Team to Europe. Go For Broke!
 

Attachments

  • 800px-SS_Lurline_at_Honululu_in_the_1930s.jpg
    800px-SS_Lurline_at_Honululu_in_the_1930s.jpg
    68.9 KB · Views: 14
  • img5937.jpg
    img5937.jpg
    33.6 KB · Views: 17
We've presented plenty of evidence. Skwinty and Bob are the ones refusing to demonstrate how to do something they say is easy.

I am not refusing to to demonstrate how to achieve triangulation.

I have explained my approach to triangulation already.

Why should I repeat myself for your benefit, you have already made your position clear on my level of ignorance.:p
 
Interesting pictures. In the second one you can see on top of the bridge an RDF loop but not on the earlier pre-troopship picture.
 
It's really pretty funny in retropsect.

I am not refusing to to demonstrate how to achieve triangulation.

I have explained my approach to triangulation already.

Why should I repeat myself for your benefit, you have already made your position clear on my level of ignorance.:p

It's like the issue of radios and triangulation has become some sort of position to be held at all costs. Then when it is obvious you can locate with one moving receiver, and a moving transmitter, the goal posts change suddenly.

That's what I'd like to see too. I'm not an expert in radio DF, but I know some basic physics and geometry. No matter how hard I try, I can't for the life of me figure out how you can triangulate on a moving target, using one receiver that is itself on a moving platform.

I figured it out, and I'm sort of an idiot.

Triangulating the source of a radio transmitter using a single mobile direction finder is common practice.

Wildlife tracking
Location of radio-tagged animals by triangulation is a widely applied research technique for studying the movement of animals. The technique was first used in the early 1960s, when the technology used in radio transmitters and batteries made them small enough to attach to wild animals, and is now widely deployed for a variety of wildlife studies. Most tracking of wild animals that have been affixed with radio transmitter equipment is done by a field researcher using a handheld radio direction finding device. When the researcher wants to locate a particular animal, the location of the animal can be triangulated by determining the direction to the transmitter from several locations.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Direction_finding

And before you say this only started in 1960, this refers to the attachment of radio transmitters to animals.

But facts like that aren't going to stop anyone!!

I said you can not know if a signal you heard was from a high-power transmitter that is far away or from a low-power transmitter that is close. The direction a signal comes from is irrelevant to its power, except stronger signals give more accurate bearings than weak signals.

That is so wrong! If you triangulate, you know exactly how far away something is! That's the point!!

Repeating the wrong thing over and over again does not suddenly make it right.

I think everyone needs to read that again.
 
Last edited:
It's really pretty funny in retropsect.



It's like the issue of radios and triangulation has become some sort of position to be held at all costs. Then when it is obvious you can locate with one moving receiver, and a moving transmitter, the goal posts change suddenly.



I figured it out, and I'm sort of an idiot.



But facts like that aren't going to stop anyone!!



That is so wrong! If you triangulate, you know exactly how far away something is! That's the point!!



I think everyone needs to read that again.

And all of this has absolutely no application to the specific problem of direction-finding at sea, where the immense ranges involved cause the triangulation angles to be so small as to fall within the margin of error of the bearings taken. Or would you care to take a stab at the problem posed upthread, that of finding the exact position and course of a ship given two bearings?
 
That is so wrong! If you triangulate, you know exactly how far away something is! That's the point!!

You seem to have lost the context. I was replying to this comment:
* Some of the replies about my comments regarding DFing in relation to signal strength and signal characteristics assume arguments I have not made. I did not say Grogan used DFing to determine that the signals he was hearing were low power.

No one said you did. I said you can not know if a signal you heard was from a high-power transmitter that is far away or from a low-power transmitter that is close. The direction a signal comes from is irrelevant to its power, except stronger signals give more accurate bearings than weak signals.


Grogan's claim was that he was hearing a low-power transmitter. Not that he heard a low-power signal, but that he heard a low-power transmitter. This is entirely irrelevant to triangulating a ship's position.
 
And all of this has absolutely no application to the specific problem of direction-finding at sea, where the immense ranges involved cause the triangulation angles to be so small as to fall within the margin of error of the bearings taken.

That may very well be, but it doesn't change the fact that people acting all smarter than everyone else were obviously wrong about it being possible. It's geometry!

Using a moving receiver and a moving transmitter. This does not mean the fleet was detected, as they were not broadcasting. We know this because the Japanese said they weren't.
 
I don't get the Pearl CTs. If the U.S. had found out about the surprise attack, would the narrative really have changed all that much if we managed to suffer less damage, and shot down a few more aircraft? The Japanese still launched a surprise attack, which declared war on the U.S.
 
I don't get the Pearl CTs. If the U.S. had found out about the surprise attack, would the narrative really have changed all that much if we managed to suffer less damage, and shot down a few more aircraft? The Japanese still launched a surprise attack, which declared war on the U.S.

Gawdzilla started another thread discussing this exact question - what would have changed? The ultimate answer was "not much"
 
And all of this has absolutely no application to the specific problem of direction-finding at sea, where the immense ranges involved cause the triangulation angles to be so small as to fall within the margin of error of the bearings taken. Or would you care to take a stab at the problem posed upthread, that of finding the exact position and course of a ship given two bearings?

The biggest problem with the Grogan theory is that the SS Lurline was not trying to locate the position of the source.

All they got was rough bearings over several days. This was in no way triangulating.

To achieve triangulation, the SS Lurline should have been altering course and repeating course corrections in accordance with the RDF plots.

Instead the SS Lurline continued steaming on it's original course away from the source.

To triangulate using mobile, single transmitters and mobile single receivers, you need to actively alter course and keep correcting, all the time with every new plot, until within visual range.

Hence, my earlier statement about brains and mk1 eyeballs. The range and inaccuracies can only be improved when adopting this approach.
 
Last edited:
I don't get the Pearl CTs. If the U.S. had found out about the surprise attack, would the narrative really have changed all that much if we managed to suffer less damage, and shot down a few more aircraft? The Japanese still launched a surprise attack, which declared war on the U.S.

According to the historic record, the commanders slandered as responsible wanted a court martial to clear their names. When that didn't happen, the story was debated with little evidence, and clearly is still a hot debate.
 
According to the historic record, the commanders slandered as responsible wanted a court martial to clear their names. When that didn't happen, the story was debated with little evidence, and clearly is still a hot debate.

The very last exhibit in the Congressional Hearings is a letter to both Kimmel and Short, asking them to hold off on any court-martial proceedings until after the war, due to the sensitive nature of so much important material. At that time they would be guaranteed a chance to clear their names in court.

Short died a few years after the war, but Kimmel swanned on, playing the martyr into the '60s, IIRC. Both of them dropped the ball severely and their wide range of excuses still sound hollow after all these years.
 
According to the historic record, the commanders slandered as responsible wanted a court martial to clear their names. When that didn't happen, the story was debated with little evidence, and clearly is still a hot debate.



Again, how would that change the narrative? Japan still declared war with a surprise attack. We still finished that war with not one but two atomic weapons. How does anything of substance change if the U.S. intercepts a few more aircraft?

Basically, I'm asking why would anyone in the U.S. intentionally let the attacks happen?
 
Basically, I'm asking why would anyone in the U.S. intentionally let the attacks happen?
Let It Happen On Purpose (LIHOP) is a slander on FDR, claiming that he would sacrifice thousands of American lives and a major portion of the US Fleet in order to get into war on the other side of the planet. The logic is torturous and 99% absurd.
 
Let It Happen On Purpose (LIHOP) is a slander on FDR, claiming that he would sacrifice thousands of American lives and a major portion of the US Fleet in order to get into war on the other side of the planet. The logic is torturous and 99% absurd.


Basically, the LIHOPers of 9/11/2001, just minus a few decades :D
 
It's really pretty funny in retropsect.

It is, but not in the way that you think it is.

It's like the issue of radios and triangulation has become some sort of position to be held at all costs. Then when it is obvious you can locate with one moving receiver, and a moving transmitter, the goal posts change suddenly.

It is not obvious because it cannot be done.

Using the image that 00063 provided:



I have added 5 courses (of the infinite many) that a moving transmitter could be on and return the bearings that ship X received.

The black ones are moving in the same general direction as X, the green ones are moving in the other general direction. Hell, the purple line is a possible course!!!!11

(I borrowed MSPaintFireTM from one of the resident 9/11 Truthers :D)

I figured it out, and I'm sort of an idiot.

Admitting your lack of intelligence doesn't help your case either.

But facts like that aren't going to stop anyone!!

What he described is not triangulation, it's playing Marco-Polo with two players.

That is so wrong! If you triangulate, you know exactly how far away something is! That's the point!!

If the receiver and transmitter are both moving, the transmitter will not be one of the corners of the triangle. It may be far outside of the triangle. Triangulation pretty much requires a triangle. The best you can get is the general direction.

I think everyone needs to read that again.

Try to really get the meaning this time.

ETA: 00063 - sorry if I accidentally marked your course. But with infinite possibilities I'm guessing that didn't happen.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom