Merged Pearl Harbor: "Revisionists" vs. "Traditionalists"

Just a reminder the fleet left it radio personnel behind so that the same 'hands', were transmitting to deceive the americans the fleet didn't transmit. again find a Japanese source that says the fleet was transmitting
 
Just a reminder the fleet left it radio personnel behind so that the same 'hands', were transmitting to deceive the americans the fleet didn't transmit. again find a Japanese source that says the fleet was transmitting

They didn't go without radio personnel, of course. They just took men who the USN wouldn't associate with the heavies. Their "fist", or style of transmitting, was familiar to other telegraphers stationed in Hawaii and Cavite.
 
It did not order radio silence—the ships already had been ordered into HF silence, and they could not transmit on VLF frequencies.
"

Does that mean the ships could not actually transmit at the frequency Grogan was picking up? I'm not a comms expert, but that's what that implies to me.


No, the signals Grogan claimed to detect were 375 kHz, which is at the very low end of the MF band.
 
No one is disputing it works, only the accuracy. ........ Finally! You finally admit accuracy can be variable!

I am not disputing the levels of accuracy either. I made that clear yesterday morning.

Please re read my posts.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=8677898&postcount=385
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=8678131&postcount=406



It's like you're from a different planet. Is everything on your planet black and white, completing lacking in any shade of gray?

Not really, but it seems your planet is pretty similar. :)


I already corrected you about "relative bearings".

Are you sure your lesson is correct?

The measurement of relative bearings of fixed landmarks and other navigational aids is useful for the navigator because this information can be used on the nautical chart together with simple geometrical techniques to aid in determining the position of the vessel and/or its speed, course, etc.
The measurement of relative bearings of other vessels and objects in movement is useful to the navigator in avoiding the danger of collision.
  • Example: The navigator on a ship observes a lighthouse when its relative bearing is 45° and again when it is 90°. he now knows that the distance from the ship to the lighthouse is equal to the distance travelled by the vessel between both observations.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Relative_bearing

In RDF, you derive compass headings from relative bearings.

Compass headings are not absolute either.

for example, your diagram.

Bearings 1 and 2 are relative to the ships headings.

The target for bearing 1 is somewhere along that line.
The target for bearing 2 is also somewhere along that line.

You can infer from those plots 2 things.

The target is moving pretty close to the same heading as you are travelling.

It can also be inferred that the target is travelling faster than you are.

Now increase speed and manoevre your ship to get 2 intersecting plots and and you can be a bit more certain about a more definite location.

Repeat this activity and pretty soon you will be on top of the target.


If and only if the transmitter is stationary, as shown in the link you provided. Did you not notice the transmitter is stationary???

Yes I know the diagram shows the transmitter is stationary.

Did you notice that the animals are not standing still.:)

What am I doing in the conspiracy theory forum?:D
 


Fair enough. Now all you have to do is understand this inaccuracy makes it impossible to track a ship from 3000 nautical miles away.

Are you sure your lesson is correct?


I navigated ships and submarines for 20 years in the US Navy, so yes, it is correct. True bearing = relative bearing + ship's true heading. You plot true bearings on a chart, not relative bearings.


In RDF, you derive compass headings from relative bearings.


That makes no sense. "Compass heading" is the direction your ship is pointing.

Compass headings are not absolute either.


What does that mean? Compasses always have a little error, but so what?

for example, your diagram.

Bearings 1 and 2 are relative to the ships headings.

The target for bearing 1 is somewhere along that line.
The target for bearing 2 is also somewhere along that line.

You can infer from those plots 2 things.

The target is moving pretty close to the same heading as you are travelling.

It can also be inferred that the target is travelling faster than you are.

Now increase speed and manoevre your ship to get 2 intersecting plots and and you can be a bit more certain about a more definite location.


Yes, we all know you can maneuver and optimize bearings on a moving target but that wasn't the question. According to you, you can know where the target is based on bearings alone. So answer the question: where is the target?

Yes I know the diagram shows the transmitter is stationary.

Did you notice that the animals are not standing still.:)


So why show a diagram of a stationary transmitter and say it applies to moving animals?
 
As far as the SS Lurline is concerned, this was a top of the range luxury liner. It is not unreasonable to expect a ship of this calibre to utilise a RDF seeing as they had been in use for some 20 years before the war.

It is gross speculation for Grogan to determine the source to have been the Japanese fleet. The source could have been a decoy or land based transmissions. ( I thought I made this clear in an earlier post).

So, whatever argument is used to refute this conspiracy theory, the intricacies of HF/DF is not going to cut the mustard.:)
I see several ETA: two problems with this analysis.

First, if we're going to admit your reasonable expectations about the Lurline's equipment, then we also get to admit all sorts of other reasonable expectations. For example:

* It's reasonable to expect that the fleet was not transmitting.
* It's reasonable to expect that decoy transmissions were being made from Japan.
* It's reasonable to expect that Grogan detected the latter, not the former.
* It's reasonable to expect that Grogan didn't have the equipment necessary to differentiate between the two anyway.

And thus it's reasonable to conclude that Grogan's report "does not cut the mustard" when it comes to supporting the claim that the fleet's position and destination were known to the US before the attack on Pearl Harbor. Indeed, you say as much.

Second, you're blatantly and unacceptably shifting the burden of proof. It's not up to anybody to refute the conspiracy theory using the "intricacies of HF/DF". It's up to the conspiracy theorist to demonstrate that the intricacies of HF/DF are sufficient to support their claim.

Which they are not. What everybody has been pointing out to you is that your introduction of the intricacies of HF/DF don't actually provide the necessary support for the claim. That's why they keep getting rejected as support for the claim.

Your claims about HF/DF may well be true. The problem for the conspiracy theorist is that your claims don't support their claims.

Sure the accuracy is not fantastic, but by altering your course and comparing plots will bring you within visual range of your target.

Exactly. The Lurline never did overcome the glaring accuracy problem in Grogan's method. If the Lurline had actually homed in on the transmissions and brought the fleet within visual range, we wouldn't be having this conversation right now. Instead, the Lurline would probably have warned Pearl, the USN would probably have pounced on the Kido Butai, and the Lurline would probably have been sunk.

Indeed, the Lurline never did warn Pearl, because Grogan's analysis was not nearly as conclusive or indicative as the conspiracy theorists like to believe.
 
Last edited:
Fair enough. Now all you have to do is understand this inaccuracy makes it impossible to track a ship from 3000 nautical miles away.

Well that claim does not come from me.

My assertion is that Grogan may well have triangulated a radio source out in the Pacific. As the radio officer he had the equipment and expertise to obtain a general position of the source.

The SS Lurline made no attempt to intercept and just steamed on.

That the source was the IJN on it's way to Pearl Harbour is another matter entirely and an only be described as speculation


I navigated ships and submarines for 20 years in the US Navy, so yes, it is correct. True bearing = relative bearing + ship's true heading. You plot true bearings on a chart, not relative bearings.

Far enough, my direction finding experience relates to aviation and as such have always treated bearings from direction finding equipment as relative, which is correct and this bearing is added to the aircraft heading to get the magnetic heading to steer if you wish to arrive at the radio source.


That makes no sense. "Compass heading" is the direction your ship is pointing.
Or the course to steer to reach a specific target.


Yes, we all know you can maneuver and optimize bearings on a moving target but that wasn't the question. According to you, you can know where the target is based on bearings alone. So answer the question: where is the target?

Once again, I stated that this was possible when your plots intersect. Then you can make a general statement wrt to the location of the target.

I answered your question as to the position of the target.
The target was somewhere along the bearing plot line.
That you need to have intersecting plots to determine a general position, I have stated a few times.


So why show a diagram of a stationary transmitter and say it applies to moving animals?

Please show evidence where I applied the graphic to moving animal tracking.
Animals are moving and the transmitter is stationary.

Perhaps I mistook you for another poster who was quite certain that it was impossible to triangulate on a target, stationary or mobile, with only 1 transmitter and 1 receiver.

The intent of the diagram was to show triangulation with 1 receiver.

We are getting off topic in my opinion, but would be glad to discuss this topic further in a more appropriate section of the forum.
 
That's strange. Skwinty didn't even acknowledge my post. Odd. Maybe Bobby will.
 
I see several
* It's reasonable to expect that the fleet was not transmitting.
* It's reasonable to expect that decoy transmissions were being made from Japan.
* It's reasonable to expect that Grogan detected the latter, not the former.
* It's reasonable to expect that Grogan didn't have the equipment necessary to differentiate between the two anyway.

And thus it's reasonable to conclude that Grogan's report "does not cut the mustard" when it comes to supporting the claim that the fleet's position and destination were known to the US before the attack on Pearl Harbor. Indeed, you say as much.

I have no issues whatsoever with those expectations. As you duly note I have said so.

Second, you're blatantly and unacceptably shifting the burden of proof. It's not up to anybody to refute the conspiracy theory using the "intricacies of HF/DF". It's up to the conspiracy theorist to demonstrate that the intricacies of HF/DF are sufficient to support their claim.

Which they are not. What everybody has been pointing out to you is that your introduction of the intricacies of HF/DF don't actually provide the necessary support for the claim. That's why they keep getting rejected as support for the claim.

Your claims about HF/DF may well be true. The problem for the conspiracy theorist is that your claims don't support their claims..

My intention has never been to support the conspiracy theory.
I am refuting specific claims that it would have been impossible to triangulate on a specific radio source by the SS Lurline.

With respect to shifting the burden of proof.

Yes, the conspiracy theorist needs to provide the evidence for his claims, but so then do the opposition.

My position is clear.

So what if Grogan was able to triangulate, that did not identify who or what the source was.

Exactly. The Lurline never did overcome the glaring accuracy problem in Grogan's method. If the Lurline had actually homed in on the transmissions and brought the fleet within visual range, we wouldn't be having this conversation right now. Instead, the Lurline would probably have warned Pearl, the USN would probably have pounced on the Kido Butai, and the Lurline would probably have been sunk.

Indeed, the Lurline never did warn Pearl, because Grogan's analysis was not nearly as conclusive or indicative as the conspiracy theorists like to believe.

Agreed
 
Well that claim does not come from me.

My assertion is that Grogan may well have triangulated a radio source out in the Pacific. As the radio officer he had the equipment and expertise to obtain a general position of the source.


Except he wasn't claiming "general position"; he claimed his bearings exactly matched the task force's track.

The SS Lurline made no attempt to intercept and just steamed on.

That the source was the IJN on it's way to Pearl Harbour is another matter entirely and an only be described as speculation


Yep. We're arguing hypothetically.


Far enough, my direction finding experience relates to aviation


Ah! This explains our miscommunication.

Once again, I stated that this was possible when your plots intersect. Then you can make a general statement wrt to the location of the target.


Quite right. Key word there is "general", as in "somewhere in the North Pacific" and definitely not "along this track".

I answered your question as to the position of the target.
The target was somewhere along the bearing plot line.
That you need to have intersecting plots to determine a general position, I have stated a few times.


Right. And you need extremely accurate bearings when the bearings cross at a very shallow angle, like they would for a cruise liner enroute from Los Angeles to Honolulu tracking a task force heading east in the Northwest Pacific. A little error and your bearings would cross anywhere from 1000 nm to 10,000 nm from you or they might not cross at all.


Please show evidence where I applied the graphic to moving animal tracking.


I understand now that was not your intention.
 
This DF chatter is all a Red Herring anyway

That may be, but it was the mob howling that you can't triangulate a moving target from a moving receiver that started it.

No one is disputing it works, only the accuracy
No, a lot of people disputed that it was possible. Now that it's looking like they were blowing smoke, they want to change the story.

Yes, the conspiracy theorist needs to provide the evidence for his claims, but so then do the opposition.

I'm not familiar with this part of the forum, but from following this topic, it seems like the opposition uses handwaving, gish gallops and a lot of insults, rather than evidence.

This radio thing made it obvious that the people trying to dominate the conversation are sort of ignorant, and not very skeptical at all.
 
Kido Butai did not transmit.

Okay, but someone will say they were spotted by a Dutch submarine and so it will continue.:D

Sometimes **** happens and the enemy sneaks a successful attack without warning.

That's war. This type of thing is to be expected.
 
Okay, but someone will say they were spotted by a Dutch submarine and so it will continue.:D
All Dutch subs were in their normal operations area.
Sometimes **** happens and the enemy sneaks a successful attack without warning.

That's war. This type of thing is to be expected.
That doesn't take a conspiracy by the US. It just takes planning and secrecy. The racist idea that the Japanese weren't up to this without American help says much about the CTers in this matter.
 
That may be, but it was the mob howling that you can't triangulate a moving target from a moving receiver that started it.
No, that would be the guy who claimed it was possible to do so, not the people who contradicted him. We've already pointed out the Japanese say they didn't transmit and had every reason not to several times. Bobby just ignores it.

Now, if you'd like to address the evidence instead of the people and stop responding to individual sentences while ignoring the overall points...

No, a lot of people disputed that it was possible. Now that it's looking like they were blowing smoke, they want to change the story.
Maybe you want to try your hand at #451, then.

I'm not familiar with this part of the forum, but from following this topic, it seems like the opposition uses handwaving, gish gallops and a lot of insults, rather than evidence.
We've presented plenty of evidence. Skwinty and Bob are the ones refusing to demonstrate how to do something they say is easy. And, I have no doubt, so will you.

This radio thing made it obvious that the people trying to dominate the conversation are sort of ignorant, and not very skeptical at all.
I've noticed that you never actually backed up your claim in #393.

I've provided an example of a moving receiver which has approximate bearings in #451. I'll even waive the margin of error. Ignore the yellow parts, and put up or shut up. You can even draw on the image in MSPaint or whatever. Make sure to remember to indicated direction of travel.

And when you're done with that, start addressing why the Japanese said they didn't transmit.
 
While I see somebody beat me too it, it's obvious and easy to use one transmitter and one receiver, both of which can be moving, to determine the location. And I'm not even that smart.
What is surprising is how after the ignorant are shown something they didn't know, they then move the goal posts, and try to say the other team wasn't really even in the game.

Shameful.

Your posts here are evidence of this.
 
The Zero fighter was a very nasty surprise for the Americans.


At first, certainly. But once its weaknesses were understood, the Wildcat, when flown with proper tactics, could just hold its own against the Zero. When the Hellcat came on the scene, the Zero was outmatched.
 
At first, certainly. But once its weaknesses were understood, the Wildcat, when flown with proper tactics, could just hold its own against the Zero. When the Hellcat came on the scene, the Zero was outmatched.

We found a very intact Zero in the Aleutians, upside down in a bog (pilot drowned on "dry land" IIRC) and took it back to some godforsaken air strip in California for tests. The pilots wrung every bit of information out of it they could.

On a fun note, they had to have it escorted by several US fighters because trainee pilots had tried to ram it on sight, despite being in US markings. Full points to the trainees for recognizing the silhouette. Full points to the instructors for not letting those idiots go up armed.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom