Merged Pearl Harbor: "Revisionists" vs. "Traditionalists"

"Their A game", not "an A game". CTer's have very low standards. I sometimes feel like it's the Purdue Boilermakers vs. Cunningham Middle School.

I don't even believe this. I have found with Truthers particularly, they don't even know what they believe. I have often pretended to be a Truther and argued crazy positions just to see what would happen. I get caught in places where I don't know the facts. It doesn't matter with CTers. Just make it up. They don't know. It's kind of like talking with Republicans about patriotism. It's not a debate or a discussion or anything to do with thinking. It's just throwing out crap to sound more patriotic than the other guys. And CT is the same thing. Status comes from being willing to say that crazier thing than the last guy.

There is no A game for the CTers, and they don't want one. They would kick you out if you tried to play one.
 
Well, if they were going to break direct orders from Yamamoto Isoruku to not transmit they could just as easily decide to attack a place with no significant military presence to avoid losses to their own force. They could then, having proven themselves to be a serious player, go on to offer themselves as the first mercenary carrier fleet in the world. I'm sure that after negotiations with the US, who had all the really big money in that Pacific area, they would have taken a contract to bomb Tokyo, including the Imperial Palace. This could then be blamed on a separatist element in Tasmania and they would get another contract to bomb Aukland.

Makes as much sense as the OP.

Sounds like the makings of a really cool Harry Turtledove novel. :)
 
I don't even believe this. I have found with Truthers particularly, they don't even know what they believe. I have often pretended to be a Truther and argued crazy positions just to see what would happen. I get caught in places where I don't know the facts. It doesn't matter with CTers. Just make it up. They don't know. It's kind of like talking with Republicans about patriotism. It's not a debate or a discussion or anything to do with thinking. It's just throwing out crap to sound more patriotic than the other guys. And CT is the same thing. Status comes from being willing to say that crazier thing than the last guy.

There is no A game for the CTers, and they don't want one. They would kick you out if you tried to play one.
I'm not sure where you're coming from here, but I don't care what the CTers would do or not. I just complained that they used to be a lot better at this. Their own A game was never good enough, of course, but the new ones just seem to be parrots.
 
If that was the case (and it makes more sense than anything else) it's slightly ironic that the Japanese attempt to make people think the fleet was still stationed in Japanese waters was misinterpreted to be the Japanese fleet heading to Pearl (at least according to Grogan).

Presumably cruise ship radio operators with inadequate gear would be placing the Japanese fleet all over the western Pacific--anywhere between Japan and the cruise ship's current position.

The US Navy, meanwhile, with cutting edge ELINT tools and methods, would consistently place the ruse transmissions at their actual source in Japan.
 
Presumably cruise ship radio operators with inadequate gear would be placing the Japanese fleet all over the western Pacific--anywhere between Japan and the cruise ship's current position.
And what made Grogan more believable than the guys who didn't hear anything like what he heard? Simples, CTers will accept anything that remotely supports their position.
The US Navy, meanwhile, with cutting edge ELINT tools and methods, would consistently place the ruse transmissions at their actual source in Japan.
Not mention Stations Hypo and Case were perfectly situated to do triangulation, whereas Grogan had only one line. And he ASSUMED the signals came from the West. The reciprocal rule had many students of DF red-faced. The USN even sent Enterprise south to look for IJN on the basis of bearing that were either 357N or 177S.
 
Furthermore, the DF bearings obtained by the SS Lurline are additional proof that radio silence was not maintained. The bearings were taken by Leslie Grogan, an experienced radio operator on the ship. He took the bearings over the course of several days, which means they had a very reasonable degree of accuracy at the very least. One of the things that caught Grogan's attention was that the flotilla he was monitoring was using automatic rebroadcasts (aka "repeat-backs") at certain times. The only ships that would have repeatedly used repeat-backs in the North Pacific at that time were the vessels of the Kido Butai. Grogan discerned that the ships were trying to conceal their movements, and he concluded they intended to sneak up on Hawaii. Moreover, Grogan noted that the ships halted on 12/2, which is powerful evidence that he was tracking the Kido Butai--because we know that the task force stopped on 12/2 to refuel and to await final confirmation of orders.
Philip H. Jacobsen destroys this myth in his article "Pearl Harbor: Radio Officer Leslie Grogan of the SS Lurline and His Misidentified Signals." Cryptologia, Vol. XXIX No. 2, April 2005, pp. 97-120.

It ain't pretty.
 
"Their A game", not "an A game". CTer's have very low standards. I sometimes feel like it's the Purdue Boilermakers vs. Cunningham Middle School.


Ten dollars on Cunningham to win the game! (If they do, I'll be RICH!!!)

:D
 
Bob, no one is arguing that radio DF ing cannot determine the location of a transmitter.

What we are saying, and saying pretty consistently, is that a single device like that on the SS Lurline, can only get you a bearing to a transmitter. To get a location you need at least a second device tracking at the same time to get a resection.

All Grogan got was a series of bearings from his location at different days, which is not sufficient to demonstrate location of whatever was transmitting.

I'll repeat what I've explained before: Grogan's bearings were essentially/substantially triangulated because he took numerous bearings of the course of several days on a huge, slow-moving target. The fact that his bearings are so consistent with the course that the task force took is strong evidence that he was tracking the task force.

I've been busy doing another article, but I intend to post more material on Grogan's bearings in the near future.

Oh, and my name is Mike Griffith. "Bobtaftfan" is just my handle for this forum.
 
Jesh, where to start (wait, the thread is already several pages long, maybe I don't even need this. Oh nevermind):

These arguments have been answered in detail. I'd link to some material, but I'm not allowed to link yet. So, a few points:

1. Marshall led FDR to believe that the damage from an air attack on Pearl Harbor would be minimal. So FDR thought he could allow a surprise attack to occur at very little cost. He was stunned when he heard how much damage had been done.

An air attack on an unsuspecting large navy base to cause only minor damage??? On what planet? Even though the capabilities of Japanese planes were somewhat underestimated, nobody sane would believe that.

2. FDR could not risk trying to meet the oncoming Japanese task force because Japanese spies on Oahu would have noticed and reported the deployment preparations, which in turn would have led the Japanese to call off the attack.

That does not explain while the base was not put on full alert. This could have been done after the Japanese plaens had left their carriers, and would have cost them dearly. The battleships could have been out of the harbour and in pursuit of the Japanese fleet, and the US carriers, which were out of the base could have been ready to pounce while the Japanese planes were away, or better still, when they were returning, low on fuel, with spent ammo.

There is absolutely no grounds, not even insanity, to suffer the full force of an initial attack even if you would, for political reasons, opt to let the enemy take the initiative.

We know that the Japanese were going to call off the attack if they lost the element of surprise. FDR would have logically assumed this to be the case, which provides a logical explanation for the "vacant sea" order that Washington issued for the North Pacific (this cleared a path for the Japanese task force).

No, this is modern hindsight, forgetting the simple fact that in 1941 the means to know exactly what the enemy did or even where he was did simply not exist.

3. FDR and a few other high officials certainly seemed to do all they could to prevent Kimmel and Short from accidentally detecting the oncoming Japanese fleet. The vacant sea order was part of this apparent effort. So was the order for Kimmel to pull his ships from doing training north of the island.

Even if this is true, it is, at worst, incompetence. However, more likely it was simply bad luck.

4. And of course there's the fact that Kimmel and Short were never told about the bomb plot messages, about the warning of imminent war that Tokyo gave Berlin, about the Japanese military map obtained by Martin Dies' congressional committee, about the warnings from the British that a Japanese fleet was heading toward Hawaii (the former head of England's Joint Intelligence Committee said after the war that British intel knew about the Japanese task force and that the Americans were warned).

Rubish. That the Japanese might attack somewhere was indeed rather clear, however, the target was a surprise.

Hans
 
I'll repeat what I've explained before: Grogan's bearings were essentially/substantially triangulated

You cannot claim they were "essentially/substantially triangulated" and in the same breathe claim you know where they were to the certainty you are claiming. Grogan attempted to DF low frequency radio waves on a communication antenna, which means he did not have the benefit of using the null. RDF sets designed for direction finding use the null because it is far more accurate than using the maximum power bearing. The bearing difference in full power and 99% power, which is a minor fluctuation in signal strength beyond the capability of any radio operator to be able to differentiate, is 8 whopping degrees. Claiming to have tracked skywaves also adds more inaccuracy. The direction a skywave is received can vary greatly from the direction of the transmitter. Add another 5°~10° of error. Add that to a loop antenna's 5° bearing accuracy and you got a whole lot of nothing.

Until you see the record of lat and long, date and time, and true bearings it is a waste of time supporting Grogan's claim.

because he took numerous bearings of the course of several days on a huge, slow-moving target.

Again with the "huge" target canard. It is completely backwards. Adding slop to your bearings does not make them more accurate.

Ships in formation do not spread out willy-nilly and drive around at the whim of the CO. They stay in their assigned sector in the formation until tasked otherwise or from urgent necessity. There would be no "huge" target. All ships would have been within a few miles of each other. This is just Grogan trying to rescue his bearing scatter by claiming the task force spread out.


The fact that his bearings are so consistent with the course that the task force took is strong evidence that he was tracking the task force.

Too bad they are also completely consistent with coming from Japan. Download and install Google Earth. Add pins and and paths to mark the task force positions and then use the ruler to trace them all the way across the Pacific and see where they fall. They fall on Japan and the East China Sea. I suspect you were plotting bearings on a Mercator projection chart. Straight lines on a Mercator projection are called Rhumb lines; they are not the path a radio wave travels over the surface of the Earth; radio waves follow Great Circles. The ruler in Google Earth traces a Great Circle.

How do you know the bearings are consistent? Have you seen them?

I've been busy doing another article, but I intend to post more material on Grogan's bearings in the near future.

Oh, and my name is Mike Griffith. "Bobtaftfan" is just my handle for this forum.

Your bio is at the bottom of your latest link. 20 years of DF experience, eh?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom