Merged Pearl Harbor: "Revisionists" vs. "Traditionalists"

Roosevelt bears responsibility for the outbreak of the war in the Pacific. He sent the Japanese government a war ultimatum. When he found out Republican leader Hamilton Fish was outraged and correctly stated that the US government would not accept a war ultimatum from Japan so why would Japan accept one from the US? Roosevelt made war inevitable by his embargo policy. www.cwporter.com/japanwas.htm A good article on the treachery of FDR at Pearl Harbor. www.whatreallyhappened.com/WRHARTICLES/pearl/www.geocities.com/Pentagon/6315/pearl.html
Of course the Japanese were a totally innocent and peaceful nation and did nothing to deserve the sanctions against them :rolleyes::rolleyes:
 
Mondial, you have your own thread for your attacks on Roosevelt, why not keep it there?
 
As for VHF, one of the 'secret weapons' used against the U-Boats by the Escort Groups later in the war was the newly developed VHF Radio telephone, Radio sets using a 'duplex' system of two radio channels to allow simultanious transmit and receive. it allowed the commanders of the ships in the Escort Group to be in direct contact with each other to co-ordinate their attacks. It also used low power transmissions to restrict it's range.
 
Roosevelt bears responsibility for the outbreak of the war in the Pacific. He sent the Japanese government a war ultimatum. When he found out Republican leader Hamilton Fish was outraged and correctly stated that the US government would not accept a war ultimatum from Japan so why would Japan accept one from the US? Roosevelt made war inevitable by his embargo policy. www.cwporter.com/japanwas.htm A good article on the treachery of FDR at Pearl Harbor. www.whatreallyhappened.com/WRHARTICLES/pearl/www.geocities.com/Pentagon/6315/pearl.html

An ultimatum says that the target party will do something by sometime or suffer something.

So, you're premise is absurd.
 
Obviously it was so that DF technicians in Japan could get a bearing on the fleet and make sure it was somewhere over towards Hawaii, and not heading to Dutch Harbor.

Well, if they were going to break direct orders from Yamamoto Isoruku to not transmit they could just as easily decide to attack a place with no significant military presence to avoid losses to their own force. They could then, having proven themselves to be a serious player, go on to offer themselves as the first mercenary carrier fleet in the world. I'm sure that after negotiations with the US, who had all the really big money in that Pacific area, they would have taken a contract to bomb Tokyo, including the Imperial Palace. This could then be blamed on a separatist element in Tasmania and they would get another contract to bomb Aukland.

Makes as much sense as the OP.
 
Send war materials to a probable enemy are just plain stupider, son.


Australia did it in 1938. The conservative government called out the troops to disperse trade unionists who were trying to stop the export of pig iron to Japan. The Japanese kindly returned the pig iron to us, by air, in 1941-42.
(By the way, Australians eventually rewarded “Pig Iron Bob”, the guy responsible for selling vital resources to our enemy, by making him the country’s longest-serving Prime Minister.)
 
Roosevelt bears responsibility for the outbreak of the war in the Pacific. He sent the Japanese government a war ultimatum. When he found out Republican leader Hamilton Fish was outraged and correctly stated that the US government would not accept a war ultimatum from Japan so why would Japan accept one from the US? Roosevelt made war inevitable by his embargo policy. www.cwporter.com/japanwas.htm A good article on the treachery of FDR at Pearl Harbor. www.whatreallyhappened.com/WRHARTICLES/pearl/www.geocities.com/Pentagon/6315/pearl.html


Unlikely, since the diplomatic note you refer to was presented 24 hours AFTER the Kido Butai sailed. Now I realize that your experience with command and control of military forces is not as extensive as say, Beetle Bailey, but you should realize that the planning and organization of the Japanese attacks on the Phillipines, Hong Kong, and Pearl took just a little longer to set up than a game of Pacific General or Risk.

As to making war inevitable by an embargo - why should the US have shipped war materiel to a country at war with an ally?
 
Australia did it in 1938. The conservative government called out the troops to disperse trade unionists who were trying to stop the export of pig iron to Japan. The Japanese kindly returned the pig iron to us, by air, in 1941-42.
(By the way, Australians eventually rewarded “Pig Iron Bob”, the guy responsible for selling vital resources to our enemy, by making him the country’s longest-serving Prime Minister.)

To be fair, in 1938 the Japanese plans for expansion weren't so obvious. It was only the second year of the China Incident.
 
The primary reason we stopped exporting strategic materials to Japan was because we needed them to fight the Nazis. Send war materials to a probable enemy are just plain stupider, son.
I hope my sarcasm was obvious, and the son was for someone else. :) Even if the Japanese hadn't been the likely enemy that they certainly were, IMO their actions in China alone warranted the sanctions the U.S. imposed against them.
 
I hope my sarcasm was obvious, and the son was for someone else. :) Even if the Japanese hadn't been the likely enemy that they certainly were, IMO their actions in China alone warranted the sanctions the U.S. imposed against them.

Yeah, I'm just used to adding that to keep it clear for the casual reader. Working for a government entity makes me get a bit redundant at times. :o
 
Yeah, I'm just used to adding that to keep it clear for the casual reader. Working for a government entity makes me get a bit redundant at times. :o
No prob, I was pretty sure that was the case, but I just wanted to make sure you didn't think I had started drinking the kook-aid :)
 
Roosevelt bears responsibility for the outbreak of the war in the Pacific. He sent the Japanese government a war ultimatum. When he found out Republican leader Hamilton Fish was outraged and correctly stated that the US government would not accept a war ultimatum from Japan so why would Japan accept one from the US? Roosevelt made war inevitable by his embargo policy. www.cwporter.com/japanwas.htm A good article on the treachery of FDR at Pearl Harbor. www.whatreallyhappened.com/WRHARTICLES/pearl/www.geocities.com/Pentagon/6315/pearl.html


From the second link:
7 Oct 1940 - Navy IQ analyst McCollum...


I had always thought McCollum worked in SIGINT, but apparently he was an Intelligence Quotient Analyst.
 
Of course the Japanese were a totally innocent and peaceful nation and did nothing to deserve the sanctions against them :rolleyes::rolleyes:

Mondial is a Holocuast Denier,so it is only to be expected he will be an apologists for Der Fuehrer's Asian Allies......
 
"Honorary Aryans."

Not only is that massively condescending, but if I were Japanese I'd be royally pissed off when I heard that. :boggled:

Yeah, I always wondered what the Japanese (no slouch in the racism department themselves back then) thought of that. Definitely sounds like a "thanks, but no thanks" kind of thing.
 
Apparently you did not read the article by Wilford and Villa, which I linked in a previous reply and to which I have referred in other replies.

The Lurline antenna array was at the top of the huge luxury liner, nearly 80 feet above the water, and, yes, the ship had direction-finding capability. Grogan mentioned that he was able to get good bearings on the Japanese ships...

The more I think about this, the less sense it makes.
  • We know the Japanese wanted to maintain radio silence.
  • We know that the fleet could operate successfully without radio comms, by widely-understood and accepted methods for such operations.
  • We know that fleet radio operators remained in Japan, to simulate the radio signals of the fleet at home.
  • We know that Japan was on the bearing determined by Grogan.
  • We know that, pace Grogan, Stinnett, bobtaftan, et al. Grogan was not well-equipped to determine range to the transmitters he was picking up
  • We know that LF signals can propagate quite far.

So I think what makes more sense is that Grogan was picking up the Japanese ruse ashore, and was totally taken in by it; he heard the fleet radio activity in Japan, and thought it was fleet radio activity at sea.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom