Merged Pearl Harbor: "Revisionists" vs. "Traditionalists"


The irony is that the Special Effects people who did the original 1954 "Godzilla/Gojira" film did the special effects for the Japanese Propaganda film about Pearl Harbor released in 1943,the one which you see a lot of footage from in World War 2 documentaries.
 
The irony is that the Special Effects people who did the original 1954 "Godzilla/Gojira" film did the special effects for the Japanese Propaganda film about Pearl Harbor released in 1943,the one which you see a lot of footage from in World War 2 documentaries.

It can now be revealed that the Japanese had a second plan for destroying the fleet at Pearl:

They would send in these three really big guys to stomp the BBs.

http://www.ww2incolor.com/d/448573-4/mock-up

Edited by LashL: 
Changed hotlink to regular link. Please see Rule 5.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Hahh, wading through Pearl without the right gear, they would be nibbled to death by hammerheads.

This neatly supports my pet theory of Pearl Harbor, which is that hammerhead sharks were created in government labs (seriously, look at them!) and then secretly introduced to Hawaiian waters specifically to prevent the Japanese from using their three Really Big Guys to destroy the US Fleet at Pearl. This was necessary because if the Japanese had brought the three Really Big Guys, it would have taken them months to cross the Pacific (they were not strong swimmers) and they would almost certainly have been discovered, ruining the surprise.

Teh pieces is fallin' inta place.
 
So I think what makes more sense is that Grogan was picking up the Japanese ruse ashore, and was totally taken in by it; he heard the fleet radio activity in Japan, and thought it was fleet radio activity at sea.

If that was the case (and it makes more sense than anything else) it's slightly ironic that the Japanese attempt to make people think the fleet was still stationed in Japanese waters was misinterpreted to be the Japanese fleet heading to Pearl (at least according to Grogan).
 
It can now be revealed that the Japanese had a second plan for destroying the fleet at Pearl:

They would send in these three really big guys to stomp the BBs.

[qimg]http://www.ww2incolor.com/d/448573-4/mock-up[/qimg]

***Nerd alert nerd alert***

That photo is a production shot of a film made by Tomoyuki Tanaka about the attack on Pearl Harbor - He is better known in the west as the creator of Godzilla

***Nerd alert over***
 
If that was the case (and it makes more sense than anything else) it's slightly ironic that the Japanese attempt to make people think the fleet was still stationed in Japanese waters was misinterpreted to be the Japanese fleet heading to Pearl (at least according to Grogan).

Even better is the fact that he assumed they were heading to Pearl when Stations Case and Hypo can triangulated those signals as coming from the Sagami Wan.
 
***Nerd alert nerd alert***

That photo is a production shot of a film made by Tomoyuki Tanaka about the attack on Pearl Harbor - He is better known in the west as the creator of Godzilla

***Nerd alert over***

I made that point, but Tanaka's name eluded me.
 
The commentary for the excellent Collector edition DVD of Godzilla (which has both the original Japanese film and the dubbed American version with Raymond Burr footage added) gives details as to background of most of the key Godzilla crew members doing minatures for the War Time Japanese films.
 
His claim appears to be taken virtually verbatim from here. Google Books' snippet of Toland's book ascribes the information to one "Robert E. Israel", a company commander of an infantry unit. The snippet unfortunately doesn't say what unit, but I'm having trouble digging up anything about the 37th Infantry Division and where it was deployed in late 1941.

EDIT: Found something!

Why was Alaska Defense Command sending naval warnings about Japanese fleet positions to a newly-activated Army National Guard unit apparently stationed at Camp Shelby, Mississippi?

I hate to a) come this late to the party, and b) weigh in on the CT side, but the above information falls under the category of "true, but irrelevant". In context, the referenced unit is the 37th Infantry Regiment. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/37th_Infantry_Regiment_(United_States)
 
It occurs to me that my previous post is a trifle unclear. I do not, overall, support the revisionist position. All I meant was that the claim of knowledge by a company commander in the 37th of a sighting south of Dutch Harbor is at least internally consistent.

That said, the claim is preposterous as a support for the claim that the Govt ignored such a sighting in order to permit the attack on Pearl to succeed. As has been pointed out, such a sighting could not possibly be connected with the Japanese task force, since it never got within 1000 miles of the reported location.
 
It occurs to me that my previous post is a trifle unclear. I do not, overall, support the revisionist position. All I meant was that the claim of knowledge by a company commander in the 37th of a sighting south of Dutch Harbor is at least internally consistent.

Thank you. I was misled by the description of "37th Infantry Division".
 
Thank you. I was misled by the description of "37th Infantry Division".

Not a problem. The evolution of military units has been marked by all sorts of inconsistencies. For future use, keep in mind that a standalone numerical designation can refer to an army, a corps, a division, a brigade, a regiment, or a Regimental Combat Team (RCT). And even, occasionally, down to the company level.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom