Merged Pearl Harbor: "Revisionists" vs. "Traditionalists"

* Regarding the repeated challenge that I produce a map showing how Grogan's bearings would have been triangulated, is that really necessary? Is it so hard to understand that multiple bearings taken over the space of several days on a huge, slow-moving target would essentially, roughly enable triangulation?
Dodge. Show it graphically. Then we'll know for sure how many 1000s of Nautical Miles "roughly enable" includes.
 
I'm guessing they would look like this:
__________________________________________

Funny looking triangle. :D

I'm thinking more like a huge scattering of infinitely long crossed chopsticks where the triangles end up being bigger than North America.

Funny thing is, there are methods for what he is talking about that were possibly in use at the time for undersea warfare, involving sonar bearings, however they used dead reckoning tables generally installed in the Combat Information Center on Navy vessels, which I am certain our intrepid liner radioman did not have access to.
 
I'm guessing they would look like this:
__________________________________________

Funny looking triangle. :D

Triangulating the source of a radio transmitter using a single mobile direction finder is common practice.

Wildlife tracking
Location of radio-tagged animals by triangulation is a widely applied research technique for studying the movement of animals. The technique was first used in the early 1960s, when the technology used in radio transmitters and batteries made them small enough to attach to wild animals, and is now widely deployed for a variety of wildlife studies. Most tracking of wild animals that have been affixed with radio transmitter equipment is done by a field researcher using a handheld radio direction finding device. When the researcher wants to locate a particular animal, the location of the animal can be triangulated by determining the direction to the transmitter from several locations.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Direction_finding

And before you say this only started in 1960, this refers to the attachment of radio transmitters to animals.
 
* Finally, the argument that the bomb plot messages were of little value or importance ignores their content, ignores the fact that the Japanese sought those data only about Pearl Harbor and no other harbor, and that a number of intelligence officers recognized the importance of those messages and tried very hard to inform Kimmel and Short about them.
After laughing at the rest of the post, I came to this part. First, the information was not forwarded to the fleet in that format, so we can be absolutely certain it was not intended for tactical use.

Second, the Japanese planes has "windows". The pilots saw something similar to the pix below. They didn't need a tic-tac-toe board.

g182874.jpg
 
* Some of the replies about my comments regarding DFing in relation to signal strength and signal characteristics assume arguments I have not made. I did not say Grogan used DFing to determine that the signals he was hearing were low power.


No one said you did. I said you can not know if a signal you heard was from a high-power transmitter that is far away or from a low-power transmitter that is close. The direction a signal comes from is irrelevant to its power, except stronger signals give more accurate bearings than weak signals.


I'm guessing that the folks who are making these arguments still have not read Hill and Wilford's article on the Lurline DF bearings.


You guessed wrong.


* Regarding the repeated challenge that I produce a map showing how Grogan's bearings would have been triangulated, is that really necessary?


It is absolutely necessary.


Is it so hard to understand that multiple bearings taken over the space of several days on a huge,


Again with the "huge". The error in your understanding DFing has been explained to you repeatedly but you refuse to learn from people who know what they're talking about. Your failure to learn can no longer be attributed to ignorance, but only to dishonesty.

You have a huge ocean liner with pretty good DF equipment for that day


Citation needed. What was the make and model of the equipment Grogan used?

You are only assuming a luxury liner had quality DF equipment. Sure, for taking bearings to radio beacons, but DF equipment and communication equipment do not have the same bearing accuracy because DF equipment uses the null generated by the loop antenna and radio equipment uses the max signal.


taking numerous bearings over the space of several days on a huge, slow-moving target. Now, granted, with DF technology back then, you did not know from just a single bearing from which direction the signal was coming.


WHAT??? That is exactly the only thing you knew! Bearing, bearing, bearing and only bearing!


But, with numerous bearings taken over several days on a target that was a group of ships, you could quickly and easily determine the general direction from which the signals were coming.


If it's so easy then why have you avoided showing us how to do it?


You would know where you had been when you took the previous bearings, and you would have numerous bearings taken over several days with which to work.


Repeating the wrong thing over and over again does not suddenly make it right.
 
but DF equipment and communication equipment do not have the same bearing accuracy because DF equipment uses the null generated by the loop antenna and radio equipment uses the max signal. .

Strange that direction finding using VHF equipment (common frequency range for comms) without the use of a loop aerial is very succesfull in the african bush.

Now, I am not making any statements about what went down in the Pacific, but, the one statement I will make is:

The USA must have been pretty thick if they believed Pearl Harbour was not a serious target for the Japanese.

The world was at war, the Japanese were allies with the Germans and the germans were already attacking the american liberty ships.
 
Regards

With regards to Anti Submarine Warfare sub locating techniques, yes, since it was not their job, plus not he would not have a Dead Reckoning Table either.

Was Grogan tracking submarines?

Serious question as I am not knowledgable wrt the Pacific theatre.
 
Strange that direction finding using VHF equipment (common frequency range for comms) without the use of a loop aerial is very succesfull in the african bush.

Now, I am not making any statements about what went down in the Pacific, but, the one statement I will make is:

The USA must have been pretty thick if they believed Pearl Harbour was not a serious target for the Japanese.

The world was at war, the Japanese were allies with the Germans and the germans were already attacking the american liberty ships.

The Phillipines were seen as a much more likely target. Look at the geography of the Pacific Ocean and tell me you think that Hawaii is an easy target.
 
Strange that direction finding using VHF equipment (common frequency range for comms) without the use of a loop aerial is very succesfull in the african bush.

Now, I am not making any statements about what went down in the Pacific, but, the one statement I will make is:

The USA must have been pretty thick if they believed Pearl Harbour was not a serious target for the Japanese.

The world was at war, the Japanese were allies with the Germans and the germans were already attacking the american liberty ships.

The US didn't know the IJN had mastered underway refueling to the level they had. They also didn't think the Japanese would open the war with an attack instead of a dec-o-war. Nor did they think the IJN would risk six carriers against the base.

On the obverse, they stationed two divisions of soldiers plus attached units, heavy on the AAA, on Oahu to protect the fleet. The problem was they had to peace-time commanders in charge.
 
I'm thinking more like a huge scattering of infinitely long crossed chopsticks where the triangles end up being bigger than North America.

Funny thing is, there are methods for what he is talking about that were possibly in use at the time for undersea warfare, involving sonar bearings,


The methods were developed in the late 50s, specifically the Ekelund range, which revolutionized passive sonar tracking. To do an Ekelund range requires the submarine to measure the bearing rate and speed across the line of sight, change course by no less than 50°, preferably 120° or more, measure the new bearing rate and speed across the line of sight, plug the differences into a calculator (or dial it into a specially-made circular sliderule called a "bearing rate computer"), and obtain the range.
 
The Phillipines were seen as a much more likely target. Look at the geography of the Pacific Ocean and tell me you think that Hawaii is an easy target.

Nothing in war is easy when you are looking to surprise the enemy.
 
Citation needed. What was the make and model of the equipment Grogan used?

Here is what was available to the Canadians.

I am sure other countries had similar technology.

http://jproc.ca/rrp/sradequ.html


"DF Outfit Nomenclature
DF outfits (aerial, receiver and goniometer) produced for the British Admiralty used the nomenclature
listed below. FH-3, FH-4 and FM-12 sets saw service with the Royal Canadian Navy during WWII.
FIRST LETTER
A = Adcock aerial system
F = Fixed frame coil aerial system
L = loop aerial system
R = Rotating frame coil aerial system
SECOND LETTER
A = Alternative HF/DF or MF/DF
C = Common aerial. For simultaneous reception on HF and MF but alternative DF.
H = HF/DF only
M = MF/DF only
S = Simultaneous HF/DF and MF/DF.

FH-1 HF/DF Outfit
This set was never used by the RCN. It is just listed here for reference.
FH-2 HF/DF Outfit
There is no evidence to show it was ever used by the RCN so its just listed here for reference.
FH-3 HF/DF Outfit
Used by the RCN, it relied on operators manually scanning suspected U-boat frequencies. Detection was provided by an audio signal heard in a headphone.Distance was impossible to determine accurately, but operators soon learned to distinguish HF ground waves from sky waves. Since ground waves could only be detected 12 to 14 miles from the transmitter, FH-3 operators knew when an intercepted signal represented a dangerously close U-boat. The FH-3 incorporated the B21B receiver which had a frequency coverage from 1 to 20 Mc. It was connected to a fixed aerial system consisting of two crossed, screened loops (Bellini-Tosi system) for direction finding and a vertical aerial for sense detection. For testing the performance of the apparatus, Frame Coil S25B was used. This is an arrangement in which a signal was injected into the unit and would simulate a bearing at GREEN 45 degrees
While in service, and on a weekly basis, the F/A and P/S loop coils were tested to ensure that their respective resistance did not exceed 0.5 ohms. On a bi-weekly basis, the field coils were tested to ensure that there was not more than 0.1 ohms resistance. Between either loop and ground, the resistance could not be less than 3 megaohms. Search coils could not exceed 0.3 ohms. The FH3 was powered by a 230 volt AC source, which when rectified, produced a B+ of 160 volts to run the receiver. Filament power was 6.3 volts.
Photos of the FH3 receiver and antenna.
FH-4 HF/DF Outfit
This was a 1 to 24 Mc HF/DF receiver which had a cathode ray scope for direct visual bearing indication and was superior to its predecessor due to the ability of being able to distinguish between the sky wave and the ground wave. Its scope was as big as a pie plate, and was surrounded by a compass rose. Accuracy was limited from 2 to 10 degrees and the unit was powered by a 230 VAC 50 Hz mains source. The FH4 was connected to a Bellini-Tosi aerial array consisting of fore/aft (F/A), port/starboard (P/S) loops and a sense aerial. The initial sets were designed with five RF and IF coils that had to be changed for different frequency ranges. In 1945, the set was improved by the addition of a band changing switch.
As one WWII Sparker summed it up: " Changing frequency bands was a bitch with the early model particularly since the set had to be recalibrated every time you did it. Your chances of getting a bearing on a U-boat "B-bar" message of as little as seven letters were abysmal."
FH-4 photos
Select this link to read Authur Bauer's technical paper on the FH4 DF set. FM12 MF/DF Receiver
fm12.jpg
See description in HAIDA Radio 4 section.
















"
 
Strange that direction finding using VHF equipment (common frequency range for comms) without the use of a loop aerial is very succesfull in the african bush.


Why is that strange? Are you suggesting just because the VHF frequencies are commonly used for communication that therefore DF equipment and radio communication equipment have the same directional accuracy? What is the bearing accuracy of a handheld VHF Yagi antenna?
 
The methods were developed in the late 50s, specifically the Ekelund range, which revolutionized passive sonar tracking. To do an Ekelund range requires the submarine to measure the bearing rate and speed across the line of sight, change course by no less than 50°, preferably 120° or more, measure the new bearing rate and speed across the line of sight, plug the differences into a calculator (or dial it into a specially-made circular sliderule called a "bearing rate computer"), and obtain the range.

Thanks, I wasn't sure when the techniques were developed.
 
Was Grogan tracking submarines?

Serious question as I am not knowledgable wrt the Pacific theatre.

No, but the principle is pretty much the same of combining bearing only information with ship movement in order to get a fix on a target. It would have been to my mind the only technique that Grogan could have employed to get a real location in 1941, and seeing as it was a technique developed in the 50s, not so good a fit.

It's up to our CT theorist to show if there was some other method that Grogan could have employed. Good luck there...
 
What is the bearing accuracy of a handheld VHF Yagi antenna?

The accuracy of the handheld VHF yagi is good enough to triangulate the precise location small animals in the bush.

Surely the same approach can give a half decent triangulation on a fleet of ships using the available marine radio technology.

This of course assumes that the sought after ships were transmitting every now and then.

As I say, I have no dog in this fight, but this is a sceptics forum and I am sceptical about every anonomous internet arguer from each side of a given debate.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom