Merged Pearl Harbor: "Revisionists" vs. "Traditionalists"

I'll repeat what I've explained before: Grogan's bearings were essentially/substantially triangulated because he took numerous bearings of the course of several days on a huge, slow-moving target. The fact that his bearings are so consistent with the course that the task force took is strong evidence that he was tracking the task force..


Now you just need to provide (a) a plausible explanation for why a task force engaged on a supposedly top secret mission would be broadcasting so many radio messages; and (b) documentary evidence from Japanese sources which demonstrate the task force was transmitting so many radio messages.

If you can do that, then you've really got something. If you can't, then you've got nothing.
 
Ships in formation do not spread out willy-nilly and drive around at the whim of the CO. They stay in their assigned sector in the formation until tasked otherwise or from urgent necessity. There would be no "huge" target. All ships would have been within a few miles of each other. This is just Grogan trying to rescue his bearing scatter by claiming the task force spread out.

The Kido Butai traveled in three columns with destroyer screen. Each column had two carriers and BBs and/or CAs in train.

The Kido Butai did not transmit during the trip.
 
I'll repeat what I've explained before: Grogan's bearings were essentially/substantially triangulated because he took numerous bearings of the course of several days on a huge, slow-moving target. The fact that his bearings are so consistent with the course that the task force took is strong evidence that he was tracking the task force.

I've been busy doing another article, but I intend to post more material on Grogan's bearings in the near future.

Oh, and my name is Mike Griffith. "Bobtaftfan" is just my handle for this forum.

That's not how triangulation works Mike. And if you did DF work you'd know that. What Grogan had was a series of bearings taken at different times while his reciever was in different locations. No distances. Therefore what Grogan got was useless without corroboration (say another reciever picking up the same transmission and able to get an accurate backbearing).
 
As noted above by others above. To make your tale even remotely plausible seek out a Japanese source who was on those ships, there are a number of personal monographs by Japanese who were on that fleet, most are still only available in Nihongo and many were never published in book form but placed as hand written memoirs into the National Diet Library.

Do some research, at present you would be deemed 'jukeisha' academically

I knew one of the men who flew as a gunner on a Japanese torpedo plane. One thing I remember that he said when he visited Hawaii, was how pleased his squadron commander was that they had achieved complete surprise
 
Last edited:
I'll repeat what I've explained before: Grogan's bearings were essentially/substantially triangulated because he took numerous bearings of the course of several days on a huge, slow-moving target. The fact that his bearings are so consistent with the course that the task force took is strong evidence that he was tracking the task force.

I've been busy doing another article, but I intend to post more material on Grogan's bearings in the near future.

Oh, and my name is Mike Griffith. "Bobtaftfan" is just my handle for this forum.

Hmmmm, please show us a diagram of how those triangulation "triangles" would appear.
 
Oopsie, copied the wrong URL. Here's the Tom Cruise-free Minority Report: http://www.ibiblio.org/pha/pha/congress/minority.html

You have posted that document a number of times, and I worry why CT people refuse to read it. Something that always stood out is how much the train of mistakes look like malice in hindsight, reflect exactly how how the 911 report reads.

I am always reminded in these moments of a line from a Nina Hagen song. Everyone's a super hero, everyone's a captain Kirk. To read this or the 911 document and arrive at a CT is to completely remove any evidence of human fallibility.

The guys who first tried to raise the alarm of the incoming flight, should not have even been at the radar station. The truck to pick them up for breakfast got a flat tire. The officer they rang has far more immediate concerns on his mind on a sleepy Sunday morning than a massive Japanese attack.

James Bond always gets it right - In my 50 years on this planet I am yet to meet anyone even close to that good. But then perhaps I don't get my understanding of the human condition from movies
 
As noted above by others above. To make your tale even remotely plausible seek out a Japanese source who was on those ships, there are a number of personal monographs by Japanese who were on that fleet, most are still only available in Nihongo and many were never published in book form but placed as hand written memoirs into the National Diet Library.

Do some research, at present you would be deemed 'jukeisha' academically

I knew one of the men who flew as a gunner on a Japanese torpedo plane. One thing I remember that he said when he visited Hawaii, was how pleased his squadron commander was that they had achieved complete surprise

And in all these years nothing has come from Japan, even though they more than anyone on this planet have a vested interest in proving the US set them up. To this day many Japanese are deeply ashamed for what occurred.

In the west we sometimes consider it denial, but they know, and they want it to go away. If they had the slightest glimmer this alternate truth can be supported they would devote their customary energy to making the world aware.
 
The Japanese I have spoken with are quite proud of the mission per se, even if the results had consequences they didn't care for. If you want to make one of them furious, just say that people in the US believe FDR knew about it in advance. Some of those people had family with Kido Butai.
 
Hmmmm, please show us a diagram of how those triangulation "triangles" would appear.

That's what I'd like to see too. I'm not an expert in radio DF, but I know some basic physics and geometry. No matter how hard I try, I can't for the life of me figure out how you can triangulate on a moving target, using one receiver that is itself on a moving platform.
 
And in all these years nothing has come from Japan, even though they more than anyone on this planet have a vested interest in proving the US set them up. To this day many Japanese are deeply ashamed for what occurred.

In the west we sometimes consider it denial, but they know, and they want it to go away. If they had the slightest glimmer this alternate truth can be supported they would devote their customary energy to making the world aware.

Well that's the thing, CTs build an alternative world while ignoring 1/2 of the people involved in it.
 
Well that's the thing, CTs build an alternative world while ignoring 1/2 of the people involved in it.
Yep, you'd think while we conducting trials for war crimes they might have mounted a "FDR let it happen" defense. ;)
 
Yep, you'd think while we conducting trials for war crimes they might have mounted a "FDR let it happen" defense. ;)

They need a time traveller to tell them it wasn't REALLY their fault!
 
Even assuming--which I don't--that the Americans knew the attack was coming and wanted it to succeed unopposed, that still doesn't explain why the Kido Butai would transmit.

Seriously, bobtaftan, your argument here is that the Japanese were so stupid that they broadcast their fleet movements all the way to Pearl, and the only reason they weren't intercepted and sunk is that the Americans wanted it that way. The only way your argument makes sense is if the Japanese and the Americans were conspiring together. Might as well come right out and claim that all of history is a hoax, and we're all in on it except you.

The operational security measures recognized and implemented by the Japanese--according to their own records!--are widely recognized as being reasonable, desirable, and feasible. Everybody agrees that keeping radio silence was something the Kido Butai should do, and that it's something the Kido Butai could do.

Since they should do it, and they could do it, your claim that they didn't do it is quite frankly the least plausible explanation for Grogan's narrative. More plausible explanations include: 1) somebody is lying, 2) somebody is mistaken, 3) somebody is deluding themselves, and 4) some combination of 1, 2, and 3. "Kido Butai transmitted even though they didn't have to and also they knew better" doesn't even make the top 10.

That.

- It would be gross incompetence for a fleet commander to allow his task-force to be trackable. Now, 'radio silence' is not a condition, it is a priority. Thus, a task force may occasionally break it, if some message is sufficiently important. After all, the Pacific Ocean was not assumed by anyone to be entirely devoid of Japanese units, so the occasional signal would really not tell a potential enemy anything. However, even a beginner would make sure there was not signals enough that a pattern could be deduced. And the Japanese commanders were far from beginners.

It is simply implausibe that they should have allowed themselves to be tracked.

Hans
 
Apparently you did not read the article by Wilford and Villa, which I linked in a previous reply and to which I have referred in other replies.

The Lurline antenna array was at the top of the huge luxury liner, nearly 80 feet above the water, and, yes, the ship had direction-finding capability.

A civilian ship does not, in that era, have efficient direction finding capability, why should it? And even the best DF system of that era was very uncertain.


Grogan mentioned that he was able to get good bearings on the Japanese ships:

"We continue to pick up the bold Japanese general order signals--it can't be anything else. We got good radio direction finder bearings, mostly coming from a Northwesterly direction from our position. The Jap floating units continue their bold repetition of wireless signals, presumably for the smaller craft in their vanguard of ships."

Improbable. As mentiined, radio silence is imperative in such an operation. The Japanese commanders were not fools, they would not have let themselves be discovered till the moment that attackt was well under way.

The "mostly come from" statement rings true to my own DFing when I was in the Army. In nearly all cases, we would get one or two bearings that were way off from the others. We were taught in our training that this would happen, and that we should ignore bearings that were so markedly different from most of the others.

When were you in the army? What were the frequencies you were using?

Hans
 
Improbable. As mentiined, radio silence is imperative in such an operation. The Japanese commanders were not fools, they would not have let themselves be discovered till the moment that attackt was well under way.


You'd have thought Japanese SIGINT would have warned the IJN they were tracking a large Japanese fleet heading eastward. "Admiral-san, we don't know what you're up to but everybody and his little brother can hear your fleet transmitting."
 
After I reply to the quoted comment, I will respond to other points that have been made.

And to avoid confusion or outright falsehoods, the Minority Report text is here:

http://www.ibiblio.org/pha/pha/congress/keefe.html

I'm guessing you did not bother to read the article before you posted this comment. Actually, every page-number reference for the quoted sections from the minority report is linked to the entire minority report.

Also, the link you provide is not the link for the minority report--it's the link for Congressman Frank Keefe's "Additional Views" addendum.

Now, to respond to other points that have been made:

* I seriously doubt that Jacobsen's article Grogan's bearings does not "demolish" or "destroy" the evidence that they were obtained from signals from the task force. I will obtained and read Jacobsen's article. To explain away Grogan's bearings, Jacobsen will need to explain the evidence presented by Farago, Hill, Wilford, and Toland. He will need to explain why Japanese fishing ships in Japanese home waters would have been using repeat-back transmissions and how Grogan could have heard those transmissions when he heard them. He will also need to explain the evidence from USN reports, including from Station Hypo, that indicates Grogan was indeed tracking the task force.

* If I were to use Gawdzilla's approach toward evidence, I would simply summarily dismiss Jacobsen's article, since Jacobsen was a traditionalist and thus his writings are traditionalist sources.

* When I cite sources that contain evidence that substantiates my statements, some folks, such as Gawdzilla, automatically reject them because they are "CT" sources. A fact is a fact regardless of the source in which it is stated. To simply wave aside serious, scholarly books and articles because their authors hold a different viewpoint from yours suggests that those doing the rejecting are perhaps overly biased and not open to persuasion.

* My initial reference that the 12/6 message from the Alaska Defense Command put the task force within aircraft striking distance of Hawaii was mistaken.

* Some of the replies about my comments regarding DFing in relation to signal strength and signal characteristics assume arguments I have not made. I did not say Grogan used DFing to determine that the signals he was hearing were low power. I'm guessing that the folks who are making these arguments still have not read Hill and Wilford's article on the Lurline DF bearings.

* We should not be too shocked that FDR would have allowed an aerial attack on Pearl Harbor when we know for a fact that he--through Marshall, Stimson, etc.--misled MacArthur into thinking that defense of the Philippines was a top priority and that reinforcements would be there soon. We now know that, contrary to what he was telling MacArthur, FDR had no intention of strongly defending the Philippines, as Dr. George Victor and others have documented in detail.

* Regarding the repeated challenge that I produce a map showing how Grogan's bearings would have been triangulated, is that really necessary? Is it so hard to understand that multiple bearings taken over the space of several days on a huge, slow-moving target would essentially, roughly enable triangulation?

You have a huge ocean liner with pretty good DF equipment for that day taking numerous bearings over the space of several days on a huge, slow-moving target. Now, granted, with DF technology back then, you did not know from just a single bearing from which direction the signal was coming. But, with numerous bearings taken over several days on a target that was a group of ships, you could quickly and easily determine the general direction from which the signals were coming.

You would know where you had been when you took the previous bearings, and you would have numerous bearings taken over several days with which to work.

* Finally, the argument that the bomb plot messages were of little value or importance ignores their content, ignores the fact that the Japanese sought those data only about Pearl Harbor and no other harbor, and that a number of intelligence officers recognized the importance of those messages and tried very hard to inform Kimmel and Short about them.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom