Merged Pearl Harbor: "Revisionists" vs. "Traditionalists"

The OP is also a creationist. WIth his Pearl Harbor theories, and his Neo Confederate "THe South Was The Real Defender Of Freedom" viewpoints,he seems to be batting pretty high in the crackpot average.
 
The OP is also a creationist. WIth his Pearl Harbor theories, and his Neo Confederate "THe South Was The Real Defender Of Freedom" viewpoints,he seems to be batting pretty high in the crackpot average.

Great. Another neo-Confederate singing praises of the failed war to preserve slavery.
 
Bob, how about we not leave the DF issue?

I doubt that Mr Grogan, while a radio officer, was trained in direction finding. I also doubt that a cruise liner had anything other than a simple transmitter and reciever. If that is the case, how is he doing the DF'ing?
 
How about we talk about the bomb plot messages? Someone seemed to suggest that there was no important or unique intelligence in those messages and that therefore the fact that they were not relayed to Kimmel and Short proves nothing.

How about you stop doing the Gish gallop?
 
What other group of ships halted on 12/2 for whatever reason--or at least slowed down markedly enough to give the impression from DF bearings that it had stopped on that day?

Moving towards or away from the reciever or the receiver moving towards or away from the transmitter?
 
Bob, how about we not leave the DF issue?

I doubt that Mr Grogan, while a radio officer, was trained in direction finding. I also doubt that a cruise liner had anything other than a simple transmitter and reciever. If that is the case, how is he doing the DF'ing?

They would probably have had a simple rotating loop to take bearnings. Cruise Liners usualy didn't own their radio gear, it was on rent from a company like Marconi who provided the operator as well. I know that's what happened on British Ships up into the 60s and 70s. If there was a Direction Finding set that would be part of the navigation eqpt and on the Bridge.
 
Thanks Capt.

The question would then be why Grogan would bother taking bearings to those transmissions, vice the other ones I had since your answer would indicate that the equipment could derive a bearing and Grogan would then likely have known how to use it to get a bearing.

Why would the radio officer, in addition to all his other duties, track transmissions in Japanese coming from the area of Japan?
 
Why would the radio officer, in addition to all his other duties, track transmissions in Japanese coming from the area of Japan?

Professional curiosity. I've done stranger things that wasn't required as part of my duties in navigation but I did them anyway because I could use them to fix my ship's position, or at least get a line of position, which in the days before GPS was quite precious. Grogan's claim to have tracked radio bearings did not raise any red flag for me because I could see myself doing what he did too.

His interpretation of his data however...

A radio officer on a cruise liner wouldn't have any additional duties.
 
A Radio Officer on a Cruise liner would probably be employed by the company leasing the radio equipment. I don't knbow any Radio Officer that was part of a ships company doing OOW and that includes in the RN>
 
My experience is with UK shipping, the US might have been different.
My dad was with the P&O in the 50s and 60s and on Tankers in the 70s and 80s, he retired as a Chief Engineer. I know that up into the late 60s at least the P&O Liners and Cargo ships had radio gear on lease from marconi and they provided the signals staff with the gear. They were exerienced in it's repair and operation. Theyir only duties was signals. On a Liner or Cruise ship there is a lot of signals traffic as the passengers have access to Telegraphy and RT services.
On the ships I served on in the RN the Signals Officer never stood an OOW. You have to have passed courses before you can be OOW, specialist officers tend not to do them, they are too busy doing their specialist courses ans work aboard ship.
 
My experience is with UK shipping, the US might have been different.
My dad was with the P&O in the 50s and 60s and on Tankers in the 70s and 80s, he retired as a Chief Engineer. I know that up into the late 60s at least the P&O Liners and Cargo ships had radio gear on lease from marconi and they provided the signals staff with the gear. They were exerienced in it's repair and operation. Theyir only duties was signals. On a Liner or Cruise ship there is a lot of signals traffic as the passengers have access to Telegraphy and RT services.
On the ships I served on in the RN the Signals Officer never stood an OOW. You have to have passed courses before you can be OOW, specialist officers tend not to do them, they are too busy doing their specialist courses ans work aboard ship.

I was thinking more about Navy ships. The officers tended to cross-train when they could because their next billet might not have anything to do with their specialty.
 
Bob, how about we not leave the DF issue?

I doubt that Mr Grogan, while a radio officer, was trained in direction finding. I also doubt that a cruise liner had anything other than a simple transmitter and reciever. If that is the case, how is he doing the DF'ing?

Apparently you did not read the article by Wilford and Villa, which I linked in a previous reply and to which I have referred in other replies.

The Lurline antenna array was at the top of the huge luxury liner, nearly 80 feet above the water, and, yes, the ship had direction-finding capability. Grogan mentioned that he was able to get good bearings on the Japanese ships:

"We continue to pick up the bold Japanese general order signals--it can't be anything else. We got good radio direction finder bearings, mostly coming from a Northwesterly direction from our position. The Jap floating units continue their bold repetition of wireless signals, presumably for the smaller craft in their vanguard of ships."

The "mostly come from" statement rings true to my own DFing when I was in the Army. In nearly all cases, we would get one or two bearings that were way off from the others. We were taught in our training that this would happen, and that we should ignore bearings that were so markedly different from most of the others.

The fact that must be faced is that Grogan's DF bearings closely correspond to the route that the task force took. Wilford and Villa:

"Most significantly, Grogan's reports and observations are entirely consistent with the documented movements of the Kido Butai during the period in question. For example, position reports made by the 3rd Battleship Division indicated that the Kido Butai moved about ten degrees east along the forty-second parallel (179°W to 169°W) from 30 November to 2 December, Lurline time." (“Warning at Pearl Harbor: Leslie Grogan and the Tracking of the Kido Butai,” The Northern Mariner, volume 11, number 2, April 2001, p. 6)

It is worth pointing out that there is yet another piece of evidence that Grogan was tracking the task force: Grogan said he heard larger ships repeat radio messages for smaller ships. This fits in with Admiral Nagumo's radio communications plan, which directed that the Tokyo broadcasts be rebroadcast by larger ships for the smaller warships within the task force.

Former British officer and World War II scholar A. J. Barker studied the Lurline evidence and concluded that Grogan must have been tracking the task force; he also rejected the myth of radio silence with some very sound, common-sense reasoning (Pearl Harbor, New York: Ballantine Books, 1969, p. 81).

I would again recommend Wilford and Villa's article:

“Warning at Pearl Harbor: Leslie Grogan and the Tracking of the Kido Butai,” The Northern Mariner, volume 11, number 2 (April 2001), pp. 1-17, available at http://www.thestormunleashed.com/files/docs/warning_at_ph.pdf.

Robert Stinnett has a good discussion on the Lurline bearings as well in Day of Deceit, pp. 196-198, available online at http://mailstar.net/pearl-harbor.html#Myth of the radio silence.

This evidence is just a small part of the evidence that debunks the claim of radio silence. Stinnett found archival evidence that there were 129 Japanese naval intercepts to/from the task force obtained by US naval monitor stations between November 15 and December 6, and that over 100 of them came from the task force (Day of Deceit, pp. 208-210).

And then there is the mass of evidence that British and Dutch intelligence heard and tracked the Japanese task force, and much of this evidence comes from men who were senior British and Dutch officers, including the former head of England's Joint Intelligence Committee. Documentation of this evidence can be found in the following sources:

Wilford, Pearl Harbor Redefined: USN Radio Intelligence in 1941 (New York: University Press of America, 2001), pp. 97-102.

Victor, The Pearl Harbor Myth: Rethinking the Unthinkable (Washington, D.C.: Potomac Books, 2007), pp. 42-47.

Toland, Infamy: Pearl Harbor and Its Aftermath (New York: Doubleday, 1992), pp. 280-301, 316-322.

Wilford, "Watching the North Pacific: British and Commonwealth Intelligence Before Pearl Harbor," Intelligence and National Security, 17:4, 2002, pp. 140-142. (You can buy this article here: http://www.ingentaconnect.com/content/routledg/int/2002/00000017/00000004/art00006.)

Rusbridger and Nave, Betrayal at Pearl Harbor (New York: Summit Books, 1991), pp. 137-142, 275-276.
 
Last edited:
Even assuming--which I don't--that the Americans knew the attack was coming and wanted it to succeed unopposed, that still doesn't explain why the Kido Butai would transmit.

Seriously, bobtaftan, your argument here is that the Japanese were so stupid that they broadcast their fleet movements all the way to Pearl, and the only reason they weren't intercepted and sunk is that the Americans wanted it that way. The only way your argument makes sense is if the Japanese and the Americans were conspiring together. Might as well come right out and claim that all of history is a hoax, and we're all in on it except you.

The operational security measures recognized and implemented by the Japanese--according to their own records!--are widely recognized as being reasonable, desirable, and feasible. Everybody agrees that keeping radio silence was something the Kido Butai should do, and that it's something the Kido Butai could do.

Since they should do it, and they could do it, your claim that they didn't do it is quite frankly the least plausible explanation for Grogan's narrative. More plausible explanations include: 1) somebody is lying, 2) somebody is mistaken, 3) somebody is deluding themselves, and 4) some combination of 1, 2, and 3. "Kido Butai transmitted even though they didn't have to and also they knew better" doesn't even make the top 10.
 
Last edited:
Seriously, bobtaftan, your argument here is that the Japanese were so stupid that they broadcast their fleet movements all the way to Pearl, and the only reason they weren't intercepted and sunk is that the Americans wanted it that way.
Considering they never broadcast them ever again during the war, one does have to wonder.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom