Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
We know some of the specimens from the mine were collected with some lapses in PPE because there are pictures of them collecting specimens without it. We don't know when the last time they went was.

There's a very thorough paper on the issues with containment at the WIV up thread.

WUHAN LABORATORIES, BAT RESEARCH AND BIOSAFETY

You can open a pdf file of the whole paper (144 pages)



There are many many more examples of lapse containment at the WIV.
That's not a loss of containment just poor housekeeping. The main concerning finding with that report that I see is the lack of PPE when collecting bat samples in the wild. I don't see any direct evidence for a lab leak though.
 
Does that matter if multiple potential lapses in containment have been documented at the WIV?

I imagine you work in a lab or labs that are in tip-top shape. Just out of curiosity how often do those labs have to pass an inspection (licensing and/or accreditation) and when that happens have you ever seen an inspection that finds no faults in compliance?

"Potential" lapses but no direct evidence.

We have 6 monthly shutdowns on which all the equipment is fully serviced. Pressure testing is done for lab integrity, the filters are changed, the cabinets are serviced. This is to avoid a failed inspection which would be very costly and shut the lab down.
 
But the 2015 paper is in Baric's lab?
Yes. Why does that matter when no one is saying the chimera or anything like it is related to COVID 19.?

It doesn't change the fact that work was going on at the WIV, in particular with collecting specimens from the mine.
 
That's not a loss of containment just poor housekeeping. The main concerning finding with that report that I see is the lack of PPE when collecting bat samples in the wild. I don't see any direct evidence for a lab leak though.
That was one example from the very long paper. You want me to go through the paper you obviously haven't to find something more specific than an understaffed sloppy level 4 lab when you yourself know there were multiple other points the virus could have leaked from the lab?

You're being ridiculous. Multiple failures to contain biohazards resulting in infections, some fatal were cited in this thread. You want to see one at the WIV when you know damn well no one said there was direct evidence yet of where this virus came from.

There isn't a source pinned down where this 'ready out of the box' pathogen emerged in a natural spillover event either.

I have said multiple times neither hypothesis has been eliminated or ruled in. There isn't a whole lot of evidence to be posted about the presumed natural spillover event. Maybe some of you should find all those volumes of evidence instead of saying you (the general you) believe a natural spillover should be the default position.

There is a volume of evidence here. Piecemeal picking apart that evidence rather than looking at the whole of it does not support a natural spillover event. It supports a number of people in this thread bound and determined not to find it was a lab spillover.
 
Yes. Why does that matter when no one is saying the chimera or anything like it is related to COVID 19.?

It doesn't change the fact that work was going on at the WIV, in particular with collecting specimens from the mine.

Because the accusation is that GoF is undertaken at WIV. There is no evidence for this.

It's being confused with culturing bat viruses on human cell lines which is being done to identify the potential for spillover events and what the WIV got funding to do.
 
"Potential" lapses but no direct evidence.

We have 6 monthly shutdowns on which all the equipment is fully serviced. Pressure testing is done for lab integrity, the filters are changed, the cabinets are serviced. This is to avoid a failed inspection which would be very costly and shut the lab down.
Again, point to the post where I said here is the direct evidence.

What evidence supports the natural event: 'It could have.' That's it, that and asserting the initial contact was some other unidentified market in Wuhan (The WHO report). And/or saying it started in some wild animal farm, where's that evidence? Or in frozen food, where is that evidence? Where is the evidence of any earlier outbreak outside of Wuhan? You claimed the 2 lineages was proof it didn't start in Wuhan (or whatever you said). Where is the said evidence of where those 2 lineages diverged?

China is not allowing anyone to look at numerous evidence they have been requested to allow. The head of WHO said their own report was inadequate. A paper with the genetic codes of the first known cases was removed from the NIH record and the researcher hasn't responded to Bloom's request for why.

We don't know if anyone has yet looked at the 9,000+ people from all over the world who attended the military games in Wuhan in Oct 2019, nor do we know if any of the earliest cases in the US and/or in Italy might be connected to those military personnel. I would think the US intelligence service working on the 90-day report Biden asked for might shed more light on that possibility.

Do you have evidence Shi used to support the claim the miners died of a fungal infection? Why would she say that when every indication is they died of an unknown virus?
 
Because the accusation is that GoF is undertaken at WIV. There is no evidence for this.

It's being confused with culturing bat viruses on human cell lines which is being done to identify the potential for spillover events and what the WIV got funding to do.
Somewhere the virus gained an affinity for person to person spread. Where do you think that happened and why is there no evidence of it?
 
Somewhere the virus gained an affinity for person to person spread. Where do you think that happened and why is there no evidence of it?

In the wildlife farms, or by the repeated spread across intermediate animal hosts back and forth leading to a variant that can infect humans efficiently.
 
That was one example from the very long paper. You want me to go through the paper you obviously haven't to find something more specific than an understaffed sloppy level 4 lab when you yourself know there were multiple other points the virus could have leaked from the lab?
I went through it. It conflated the BSL-2, 3 and 4 labs, assuming that an event in a BSL-2 lab would also mean it happened in the higher containment labs. The main conclusion focussed on the lack of PPE and not lack of containment by the lab plant.
 
Again, point to the post where I said here is the direct evidence.

What evidence supports the natural event: 'It could have.' That's it, that and asserting the initial contact was some other unidentified market in Wuhan (The WHO report). And/or saying it started in some wild animal farm, where's that evidence? Or in frozen food, where is that evidence? Where is the evidence of any earlier outbreak outside of Wuhan? You claimed the 2 lineages was proof it didn't start in Wuhan (or whatever you said). Where is the said evidence of where those 2 lineages diverged?

China is not allowing anyone to look at numerous evidence they have been requested to allow. The head of WHO said their own report was inadequate. A paper with the genetic codes of the first known cases was removed from the NIH record and the researcher hasn't responded to Bloom's request for why.

We don't know if anyone has yet looked at the 9,000+ people from all over the world who attended the military games in Wuhan in Oct 2019, nor do we know if any of the earliest cases in the US and/or in Italy might be connected to those military personnel. I would think the US intelligence service working on the 90-day report Biden asked for might shed more light on that possibility.

Do you have evidence Shi used to support the claim the miners died of a fungal infection? Why would she say that when every indication is they died of an unknown virus?
I think we are agreeing that there is nothing conclusive.
I haven't made any comment about the miner's fungal infection. I've deliberately kept out of that as I'm not medically qualified.
 
In the wildlife farms, or by the repeated spread across intermediate animal hosts back and forth leading to a variant that can infect humans efficiently.
That's all well and good, is there any evidence? Papers written on why this is more viable an option than any other speculation? There hasn't even been a close SL CoV in any animal tested so far at the animal market.

Any explanation written up as to why this viral strain made it to Wuhan only?

I'm waiting for the natural spillover event to be substantiated by something, anything.

There is some evidence the virus could have come directly from the bats in the Yunnan area. I just posted a seroprevalence study on the local populations near the mine and evidence of past spillover events was there. How did a spillover event show up only in Wuhan where none of the relevant bat species exist.

I posted that. Did I miss or forget that someone else in this thread dug it up?
 
I went through it. It conflated the BSL-2, 3 and 4 labs, assuming that an event in a BSL-2 lab would also mean it happened in the higher containment labs. The main conclusion focussed on the lack of PPE and not lack of containment by the lab plant.
I don't think they made that assumption. I'll review it again.
 
I think we are agreeing that there is nothing conclusive.
And yet I keep having to repeat my position as I am frequently having to respond to posts written as if I don't know what the actual evidence is. IOW posts that suggest all the evidence I've been posting is akin to the nonsense we see in the 911 CT Inside Job.

May not be your fault posts attack me along that line. But you cherry picked the GoF chimera species Baric and Shi worked on in the UNC and said it wasn't at the WIV while you ignored any related evidence about the work done at the WIV. And you are certainly downplaying the sloppy infection control described at the WIV.


I haven't made any comment about the miner's fungal infection. I've deliberately kept out of that as I'm not medically qualified.
So you can't read the relevant issues like no document of any kind where Shi explains or describes how she went from "they had an unknown virus" to her statement to Scientific American in June that the miners all had a fungal infection?

Can you comment on the weight we should give to the miners' specimens collected by hospital staff a decade ago, stored under unknown conditions along that journey, now having no evidence specifically of SARS CoV 2?

Can you comment on what we know about WIV1-CoV and WIV14-CoV? I've not found anything specific yet as to how closely or not those two viruses are related to SARS CoV 2?

This is Baric's paper on them from 2016: PNAS: SARS-like WIV1-CoV poised for human emergence
 
Last edited:
Somewhere the virus gained an affinity for person to person spread.

This is a virus that readily infects many different species it spread from Mink to Mink and from cat to cat without gaining any "affinity" why would you assume it needed to gain something to spread from human to human?

Where do you think that happened and why is there no evidence of it?
SARS-CoV-2 can infect many different species because it's spike and binding domain are able to bind efficiently to many different species. There is significant evidence that this is a trait that has been evolving in closely related viruses for decades.
 
For Capsid: More source material on WIV-14, not related to SARS CoV 2. Jnl of Virology: Any reference to SARS refers to SARS 1, not SARS 2. I have an understanding how far apart genetically SARS 1 and 2 are. I was just curious about the WIV 1 and 14 because they aren't mentioned in anything I've found on SARS 2. Thanks. No hurry.

A detailed comparison of protein sequences between SARS-CoV GZ02, a strain from an early-phase patient, and all reported bat SL-CoVs indicated that WIV16 is the closet progenitor of the SARS-CoV in most proteins, particularly in the S protein (Table 1). ...

Nucleotide sequence accession number.
The full genomic sequence of SL-CoV WIV16 was deposited in GenBank under accession number KT444582.
 
Last edited:
This is a virus that readily infects many different species it spread from Mink to Mink and from cat to cat without gaining any "affinity" why would you assume it needed to gain something to spread from human to human?

SARS-CoV-2 can infect many different species because it's spike and binding domain are able to bind efficiently to many different species. There is significant evidence that this is a trait that has been evolving in closely related viruses for decades.
I don't see any evidence posted here, just more speculation that 'it could have'. We know that, it is already a given.
 
I don't see any evidence posted here, just more speculation that 'it could have'. We know that, it is already a given.

I've previously posted evidence for this being a trait naturally evolving in relations viruses. If you refused to read it then I don't see why it would be different this time.

The infectiousness to Mink and other animals was widely reported on last year and should be common knowledge by now.
 
I've previously posted evidence for this being a trait naturally evolving in relations viruses. If you refused to read it then I don't see why it would be different this time.

The infectiousness to Mink and other animals was widely reported on last year and should be common knowledge by now.
Of course I know all about that. I've posted stuff on the minks as well. That's more general stuff.

Do you have any evidence that minks were found with a closely related virus not contracted from a human to a mink and which was sold in any Wuhan wet market or elsewhere in China with a possible trail leading to the human cases?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom