Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
Well actually we have told you that there were positive samples in the drains of the wet market. We know there were wild animals sold there. The Chinese government shut the place down. That in and of itself makes it plausible as a possible spillover location....
Here you go again with the claim "we have told you". Your claim of asserting facts without evidence is frankly stupid.

Where's the quote and source to back up the claim that the earliest cases were connected to another Wuhan wet market?

Quote where you are getting this assertion.
 
Here you go again with the claim "we have told you". Your claim of asserting facts without evidence is frankly stupid.

Where's the quote and source to back up the claim that the earliest cases were connected to another Wuhan wet market?

Quote where you are getting this assertion.

Where is the quote to back up a claim I haven’t made? Well clearly I don’t need a source to back a claim I haven’t made because I haven’t made the claim. I am not going to go back and forth over many pages to correct your reading errors.
 
Are you still claiming Daszak had no conflict of interest?.

Now you are flat out lying. I have repeatedly acknowledged his conflict of interest. Repeatedly.

I will say it again:

I acknowledge Peter Daszak has a conflict of interest.

If you try this BS again of asserting that I have not acknowledged or I have denied a conflict of interest, then you will simply be lying.

Kindly stop lying!
 

wow you are really delving down the right wing rabbit hole. These are sources that specialise in right wing partisan politics with a hyper-nationalist slant. They all have a history of promoting pseudo-science and questionable "facts" in support of their far right agenda. The New York Post things "God is the best scientific theory to explain life on earth" the National review has promoted climate change denial for decades and still alternates between "there were WMD in Iraq" and "it's the Democrats fault we thought there were WMD in Iraq" and American thinker is a clearing house for any and every crazy libertarian pseudoscience you can name.
 
Hmmmm... this is interesting.

Does this mean the US intelligence agencies have found the databases?

Or perhaps they are following Bloom's lead in using the cloud to patch together what had already been accessed.

Washington (CNN)US intelligence agencies are digging through a treasure trove of genetic data that could be key to uncovering the origins of the coronavirus -- as soon as they can decipher it.

This giant catalog of information contains genetic blueprints drawn from virus samples studied at the lab in Wuhan, China which some officials believe may have been the source of the Covid-19 outbreak, multiple people familiar with the matter tell CNN.

It's unclear exactly how or when US intelligence agencies gained access to the information, but the machines involved in creating and processing this kind of genetic data from viruses are typically connected to external cloud-based servers -- leaving open the possibility they were hacked, sources said.

Still, translating this mountain of raw data into usable information -- which is only one part of the intelligence community's 90-day push to uncover the pandemic's origins -- presents a range of challenges, including harnessing enough computing power to process it all. To do that, intelligence agencies are relying on supercomputers at the Department of Energy's National Labs, a collection of 17 elite government research institutions.

Link
 
//nypost.com/
tps://www.nationalreview.com

tps://www.americanthinker.com/blog

I cannot believe that you are citing these sources. Cannot believe it. NY Post is conservative propaganda tabloid. National Review is far-right and pushes some nonsense. But wow. The American Thinker? Really? They are full-on bigots, fascist-enablers and climate deniers.

tps://www.independentsciencenews.org/
Media Bias Fact-Check: Independent Science News dot org

CONSPIRACY-PSEUDOSCIENCE

Sources in the Conspiracy-Pseudoscience category may publish unverifiable information that is not always supported by evidence. These sources may be untrustworthy for credible/verifiable information, therefore fact checking and further investigation is recommended on a per article basis when obtaining information from these sources. See all Conspiracy-Pseudoscience sources.

Overall, we rate Independent Science News a moderate Pseudoscience source as they publish occasional scientific misinformation.

I am sorry for butting in; I don't know the science well enough to comment, but I'm really interested in the lab-leak conspiracy theories, so have been reading the thread with interest.
 
wow you are really delving down the right wing rabbit hole. These are sources that specialise in right wing partisan politics with a hyper-nationalist slant. They all have a history of promoting pseudo-science and questionable "facts" in support of their far right agenda. The New York Post things "God is the best scientific theory to explain life on earth" the National review has promoted climate change denial for decades and still alternates between "there were WMD in Iraq" and "it's the Democrats fault we thought there were WMD in Iraq" and American thinker is a clearing house for any and every crazy libertarian pseudoscience you can name.

I've heard of it referred to as "American Stinker".

From Wikipedia: "Right Wing Watch has written about American Thinker, including that the site had in 2014 published a complimentary piece on white nationalist Jared Taylor and in 2015 asserted that rainbow-colored Doritos are a "gateway snack to introduce children to the joys of homosexuality"."

Though I don't doubt that their coverage of the origins of SARS-CoV2 is exemplary.
 
I cannot believe that you are citing these sources. Cannot believe it. NY Post is conservative propaganda tabloid. National Review is far-right and pushes some nonsense. But wow. The American Thinker? Really? They are full-on bigots, fascist-enablers and climate deniers.


Media Bias Fact-Check: Independent Science News dot org



I am sorry for butting in; I don't know the science well enough to comment, but I'm really interested in the lab-leak conspiracy theories, so have been reading the thread with interest.

This one doesn't look much better but it's left leaning with an anti-GMO focus that occasionally into pseudoscience and CT. It's much less prominent than the earlier right wing sites though, so unless you poke around you may not know what it is.

https://mediabiasfactcheck.com/independent-science-news/

 
Now you are flat out lying. I have repeatedly acknowledged his conflict of interest. Repeatedly.

I will say it again:

I acknowledge Peter Daszak has a conflict of interest.

If you try this BS again of asserting that I have not acknowledged or I have denied a conflict of interest, then you will simply be lying.

Kindly stop lying!

Calling it a conflict of interest is a little misleading IMO. The Wuhan lab is a global center for research on this type of virus. It's unlikely you will find any legitimate experts on SARS related Coronaviruses who don't have some type of connection to it.

These scientists will invariably have their opinions on the WiV and the work it does. Such opinions formed from first hand knowledge only get called "conflict of interest" if they are generally positive. What's interesting is that we don't know of any researchers with this type of direct first hand experience who take the negative view.

In any case when people form opinions based on first hand experience it's not bias. If we exclude anyone with first hand knowledge and having a "conflict of interest" we are running the risk of throwing away any real data on how reliable Chinese virologists are. The WHO certainly though of Daszak as a valuable expert not someone who was compromised and unreliable.
 
Where is the quote to back up a claim I haven’t made? Well clearly I don’t need a source to back a claim I haven’t made because I haven’t made the claim. [snipped snark]

You said that you have told me [whatever] a few posts back. Maybe you don't know how that comes across.

as said:
Well actually we have told you that there were positive samples in the drains of the wet market.

Is your issue you supposedly only said it once? :rolleyes:



Moving on. ...

I addressed the fact I was citing right-wing sources. I stated the claims needed corroboration. Ridiculing the sources adds nothing to the debate here.

If you know about Daszak's conflict of interest why to you keep citing his claims without noting the claims are suspect?

IIRC there was one market besides the seafood market were one positive sample in one additional drain was found and it was noted that it could have come from people not a source animal.

Bottom line there is no evidence directly connecting any of the earliest cases to any wet market.
as said:
We know there were wild animals sold there. The Chinese government shut the place down. That in and of itself makes it plausible as a possible spillover location....
Like I said, the same amount of evidence supports the claim aliens from Mars was the source.


Think about it. Do you think it's equally possible it started in Italy? The Chinese government said that and they also claimed there was a US lab at Fort Detrick that could have been the source. They went even further yesterday.

US urged to explain truth behind EVALI, closure of Fort Detrick biolab
In July 2019, there was an outbreak of the e-cigarette or vaping product use-associated lung illness (EVALI) in Wisconsin, the US. The disease then swept through multiple states, with doctors describing patients with symptoms that barely differ from those of COVID-19, but the cause of the illness was unknown.

Coincidentally, it was also in July 2019 that the Fort Detrick biological lab was suddenly shut down and that a retirement community an hour's drive from the lab experienced unexplained respiratory diseases.

Should we include that US lab as a potential origin? The Chinese government is certainly throwing out flak in that direction.


The new genetic data is very interesting. :popcorn1
 
Ridiculing the Posting right-wing disinformation sources adds nothing to the debate here.

fixed.

ETA - and left-wing disinformation sources as well, like "global times.cn," a pro-china misinformation publication.

media bias fact check said:
Overall, we rate Global Times Questionable based on the promotion of Pro-Chinese Government propaganda. We also rate them Mixed for factual reporting due to bias by omission as well as failed fact checks.

I would at least re-consider my stance if my evidence kept coming from questionable sources. Alex Jones and the Q people promoted the Fort Detrick conspiracy theory as well.
 
Last edited:
fixed.

ETA - and left-wing disinformation sources as well, like "global times.cn," a pro-china misinformation publication.



I would at least re-consider my stance if my evidence kept coming from questionable sources. Alex Jones and the Q people promoted the Fort Detrick conspiracy theory as well.
:rolleyes:

First those links are about what is in the GOP Congressional Report so you are griping about the message vehicle. You should be addressing the GOP report, not the fact the right wing media is amplifying the messages.

The GOP Report is here. I could have gone straight there but it was late and it would have taken more time while the news sources summarized the information just fine.

Look at what is in those citations: specific checkable facts. Cited here already was an evaluation of the biosafety at the WIV done in 2019 before the pandemic started.

For example, if there was an order to fix Wuhan lab air circulation systems that were defective ahead of first known COVID Cases, there should be corroborating evidence for that.

Here's the evidence for that translated from Chinese:

Announcement of winning the bid for the procurement project of the environmental air disinfection treatment system and the scalable automated sample storage management system of the Wuhan Institute of Virology, Chinese Academy of Sciences
August 14, 2019 15:18 Source: China Government Procurement Network

Who cares which source I quoted when there is corroborating evidence for the facts.
Feel free to find some corroborating evidence this source is either fake or really applies to something else.

Post a cite with a rebuttal how this didn't matter and couldn't have resulted in an airborne leak of any SL CoVs the lab might have been working on.


See how that works?
 
SG. I can’t really help you if you rely on far right sources to make your claims and you have now started claiming that it is just as likely to have come from Mars as it is to have come from animals on Earth. I think your attempts to ridicule the very idea of zoonosis have totally jumped the shark.
 
SG. I can’t really help you if you rely on far right sources to make your claims and you have now started claiming that it is just as likely to have come from Mars as it is to have come from animals on Earth. I think your attempts to ridicule the very idea of zoonosis have totally jumped the shark.
Why would I want your help???

And you missed the point about no evidence is just that, no evidence. We know the first cases in Wuhan were not connected to the seafood market, full stop.


I take it from your post you missed the corroborating evidence for the claim that was summarized in my right-wing citation?


Care to address the evidence instead of the link?

Here, I'll make it more clear:

1) Right-wing citation describes something in the GOP report that just came out.

2) It's confirmed that what the right wing source claimed is indeed accurately reporting on what is in the GOP report.

3) In the GOP report they assert the WIV was seeking a contractor to help with the non-functioning air circulation system in the biosafety lab.

4) Given this was in Sept of 2019, it is not a request for bids on the WIV labs air circulation system during its initial construction.

5) The actual request form was linked to in the GOP report.

6) I linked to that form and it corroborates the GOP report claim.
 
Last edited:
Much as I have learned not to get my climate science from Senator Inhofe, I won't be getting my Covid info from Congressional Republicans who have already killed half a million Americans with their nonsense.

See # 1-6 in my above post and you won't need to fuss about who made it public first.
 
We know the first cases in Wuhan were not connected to the seafood market, full stop.

Oh, I see. So now you are going to show me how the first cases in Wuhan were connected to the Wuhan Institute of Virology. No doubt that evidence is right at your fingertips.

Let's see it!
 
:rolleyes:

First those links are about what is in the GOP Congressional Report so you are griping about the message vehicle. You should be addressing the GOP report, not the fact the right wing media is amplifying the messages.

The GOP Report is here. I could have gone straight there but it was late and it would have taken more time while the news sources summarized the information just fine.

Look at what is in those citations: specific checkable facts. Cited here already was an evaluation of the biosafety at the WIV done in 2019 before the pandemic started.

For example, if there was an order to fix Wuhan lab air circulation systems that were defective ahead of first known COVID Cases, there should be corroborating evidence for that.

Here's the evidence for that translated from Chinese:

Announcement of winning the bid for the procurement project of the environmental air disinfection treatment system and the scalable automated sample storage management system of the Wuhan Institute of Virology, Chinese Academy of Sciences

Who cares which source I quoted when there is corroborating evidence for the facts.
Feel free to find some corroborating evidence this source is either fake or really applies to something else.

Post a cite with a rebuttal how this didn't matter and couldn't have resulted in an airborne leak of any SL CoVs the lab might have been working on.

See how that works?

From your source (translated by Google translate):

"Tender announcement date for this project": July 18, 2019
What is the project?

"Purchasing project of environmental air disinfection system and scalable automated sample storage management system of Wuhan Institute of Virology, Chinese Academy of Sciences"

BFD!

You are again making many assumptions about what this could possibly mean, and then demanding everyone else prove a negative.

Instead, maybe you should be asking your GOP buddies why a tender to procure equipment for the WIV can only mean that SARS-CoV2 leaked from a lab.

How do you know it was not part of the WIV's drive to get international scientists from around the world to come to the lab?

Capsid earlier posted the Nipah Conference proceedings from December 2019 in which Zhengli Shi was advertising her lab as a location for scientists who wanted to use the BSL-4:

Page 65 said:
The Wuhan
facility offers repositories of
biological resources, conducts R&D
and biosafety training, and aims to
be accredited as a WHO reference
laboratory for one or more BSL-4
pathogens.
Nipah represents a priority
pathogen for the Wuhan facility,
due to 1) its ability to infect animals
and humans; 2) its high mortality
in humans; and 3) the prevalence
of henipaviruses and henipa-like
viruses in countries of Southeast
Asia, including China. Work on
Nipah is divided into six work
packages: 1) NiV pathogenesis; 2)
Epidemiology; 3) Development
of a DC-based prophylactic
mucosal vaccine; 4) Therapeutics
development; 5) Diagnostics
development; 6) Biostatistics
analyses.
The Wuhan BSL-4 facility has
an annual call around April for
external organisations wanting
access to the facility to test their
own samples or use samples
from the in-house repositories.

Link
 
...3) In the GOP report they assert the WIV was seeking a contractor to help with the non-functioning air circulation system in the biosafety lab.
Not quite correct, Skeptic Ginger.
The report on pages 19 and 20 has a list of maintenance and renovation projects. Commonsense says this would be expected for any laboratory because equipment ages needing repair and becomes outdated. Some projects were for the BSL-3 and animal center at the WNBL. The locations of others were unclear. Then we have a comment from a committee of Republican politicians.
The references to maintenance at the BSL-3 and animal center at the WNBL, the procurement of an environmental air disinfection system, and renovations to the hazardous waste treatment system and central air conditioning system all raise questions about how well these systems were functioning in the months prior to the outbreak of COVID-19
That is evidence of a functioning air circulation system that is being maintained and renovated. The unanswered question is how well the systems were functioning.

The report is biased. There is no "preponderance of evidence" suggesting that SARS-CoV-2 was accidentally released from the Wuhan Institute of Virology. They present no evidence that the virus was ever at WIV.
For example they cite Current status and future challenges of high-level biosafety laboratories in China by Yuan Zhiming.
High-level biosafety laboratories are safe and secure platforms which integrate reliable containment, well-trained personnel, and specific biosafety manuals and practices to protect researchers from being infected while manipulating microbial pathogens and prevent pathogens from being released into the outside environment. During the past decades, laboratories with different protection levels have been constructed and operated, the legal framework and a laboratory biosafety management system have been established, and these operational laboratories have played an essential role in combatting emerging and re-emerging infectious diseases in China. Here, we have summarized the significant achievements of high-level laboratory planning, construction, and operation in China, as well as the challenges that we face in the future. Additionally, we have briefly discussed the national plan for construction of high-level biosafety laboratories from 2016-2025 and “biosafety-motivated” management system. This review might be informative for further understanding the present situation and future function of high-level biosafety laboratories in China.
This is a general review, not an analysis of the WIV.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom