Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
You want to get this information to Biden? He's wasting the intelligence community's time if what you say is true.

Can you actually cite a source for your claim? People claiming to speak for the entire medical community haven't cited any sources as far as I know. I've looked for survey's of the medical community and haven't found any. The only claim of consensus I've seen that seems to carry any weight is the one Biden stated about the intelligence community two months ago yesterday.

And your first sentence is simply deranged. It is debated by experts. As I said before, this thread is dominated by arguments that are out of touch with reality. And I mean on all sides.

Not in the literature it isn't. There is little or nothing in the literature that supports a lab leak and a great deal that undermines it. See paper below that reviews the current literature and plausibility (or lack thereof) of the lab leak hypothesis.

https://zenodo.org/record/5075888#.YQBGU6ZKiEB

We contend that there is substantial body of scientific evidence supporting a zoonotic origin for SARS-CoV-2. While the possibility of a laboratory accident cannot be entirely dismissed, and may be near impossible to falsify, this conduit for emergence is highly unlikely relative to the numerous and repeated human-animal contacts that occur routinely in the wildlife trade.
 
So much wrong. Just two simple points: Your paper acknowledges there is a debate. One paper with a dozen or so authors does not prove a consensus.


I didn't read the paper far enough to completely refute the idea it is a review of the literature but I sure didn't see anything remotely resembling that. All I see is their own opinions about the evidence. It doesn't even remotely appear to be a paper about establishing what the consensus is.
 
There are multiple scenarios.

What is this supposed to mean?

What is your problem with that link? Care to elaborate?

My point about smallpox is that the smallpox virus (a very much more dangerous virus than SARS-CoV-2) had to be discovered. (Obviously the disease was known, but the cause had to be isolated). This was done with non of the bio secure facilities we now have. when the only way of studying viruses was by growing them. As opposed to being able to study the DNA, being able to express genes inserted into plasmids etc. that don't actually require dealing with live virus.For over a hundred years virologists have been isolating and studying what were all when first discovered including the smallpox virus a novel virus. Virus hunting is not a new phenomenon. As mentioned above there have been e.g. the Birmingham smallpox outbreak, but despite all the previous conspiracy theories none of the previous epidemic / pandemic viruses have resulted from laboratory escapes, biowarfare experiments etc. Humans like to scapegoat, it is not surprising that they look for a person or persons to blame. But given every other time there has been a viral outbreak / pandemic (or even a bacterial one) it has been due to a host species shift. Smallpox probably arose 4,000 years ago when camels were introduced into East Africa and domesticated and camel pox jumped species into humans. pretty similar to what we see with MERS.
 
But the GoF work was done in Baric's lab. :confused:
Until funding was paused in 2015. The funding ended in 2014 but the NIH allowed Baric and Shi et al to continue what they were working on.

At that point it either stopped, shifted to the WIV, or Shi continued the work without Baric. It's probably the latter.

Baric denies doing anymore GoF work including saying the work he did in 2015 was not GoF despite creating an SL coronavirus chimera. Fauci says the NIH never funded any GoF work. That's clearly false because the funding in 2014 was stopped (Obama admin) due to increasing concerns the work could lead to the creation of a PPP (pandemic potential pathogen).

I don't think Fauci has any fingers in the COVID creation pot. Rand Paul is an ass. And I don't care if Fauci was lying or playing semantic games about the definition of GoF research. None of that is relevant to the more immediate question of the origin of COVID 19.

There is a very thorough discussion of the GoF research here including virologists who say it was and virologists who say it wasn't: The Wuhan Lab and the Gain-of-Function Disagreement There is no smoking gun in the article, just a discussion of the issue including:
Paul described Baric’s research as “gain of function” in collaboration with the Wuhan lab. A 2015 paper by Baric, Shi and others, published with NIH funding in the journal Nature Medicine, examined the potential of SARS-like bat coronaviruses to lead to human disease. Researchers created a “chimeric virus” with the spike protein of the bat coronavirus and a mouse-adapted SARS backbone and found viruses could replicate in human airway cells. The study said “the creation of chimeric viruses … was not expected to increase pathogenicity.”

Fauci told Paul at the hearing: “Dr. Baric does not do gain-of-function research, and if it is, it’s according to the guidelines and it is being conducted in North Carolina, not in China.”

In a statement to us, Baric said: “Our work was approved by the NIH, was peer reviewed, and P3CO reviewed,” meaning reviewed under the HHS 2017 framework. “We followed all safety protocols, and our work was considered low risk because of the strain of coronaviruses being studied. It is because of our early work that the United States was in a position to quickly find the first successful treatment for SARS-CoV-2 and an effective COVID-19 vaccine.”
The 2015 paper is cited in this thread but if you don't want to go looking for it: A SARS-like cluster of circulating bat coronaviruses shows potential for human emergence
Using the SARS-CoV reverse genetics system2, we generated and characterized a chimeric virus expressing the spike of bat coronavirus SHC014 in a mouse-adapted SARS-CoV backbone. The results indicate that group 2b viruses encoding the SHC014 spike in a wild-type backbone can efficiently use multiple orthologs of the SARS receptor human angiotensin converting enzyme II (ACE2), replicate efficiently in primary human airway cells and achieve in vitro titers equivalent to epidemic strains of SARS-CoV. Additionally, in vivo experiments demonstrate replication of the chimeric virus in mouse lung with notable pathogenesis....

On the basis of these findings, we synthetically re-derived an infectious full-length SHC014 recombinant virus and demonstrate robust viral replication both in vitro and in vivo. Our work suggests a potential risk of SARS-CoV re-emergence from viruses currently circulating in bat populations.
 
Last edited:
I'm describing a BSL-3 lab where SARS-COV-2 should be handled. Some of the work could be done in BSL-2 for the pseudotyped virus work that was published. Do we know for sure that the wild type viruses were handled at the wrong containment level?

We know some of the specimens from the mine were collected with some lapses in PPE because there are pictures of them collecting specimens without it. We don't know when the last time they went was.

There's a very thorough paper on the issues with containment at the WIV up thread.

WUHAN LABORATORIES, BAT RESEARCH AND BIOSAFETY

You can open a pdf file of the whole paper (144 pages)

On the 14th of October 2019, The Wuhan Universit Laboratory & Equipment Management Office issued a notice on “further strengthening laboratory safety management during the Military Games" which ordered all University laboratories to undertake “comprehensive investigation and elimination of hidden dangers” in order to ensure the “smooth convening of the 7th World Military Games” (Wuhan University, 2019). This raises the question of Laboratory biosafety at Wuhan University laboratories, further highlighted in 2019 with an intensive inspection report of safety issues at these labs, which revealed among other things:

“There is a lot of debris in the laboratory, The laboratory stores a lot of cartons, which is crowded & chaotic, Experiment & living area not separated, Students are not wearing lab coats, Safety facilities No eyewash, Chemical waste & household waste mixed, temporary storage cabinets have simple disposal of biochemical waste & too much temporary storage” (Lab Report Wuhan University, 2019).

There are many many more examples of lapse containment at the WIV.
 
Last edited:
Lomiller: there are multiple sources for what I've posted you think was lying or misleading or whatever. I'm going to agree to disagree because I don't have the time to address your accusations.

Angrysoba, are you claiming Daszak had no conflict of interest? Are you claiming Daszak never participated in GoF research? What is your point of debating what Daszak meant in the Dec 2019 interview/podcast when he said the coronaviruses are easily manipulated? Maybe if it was more clear what your objections are I could address them.

As for some of the rest of your posts that involve mine, I don't think you read my posts very carefully. I'm not going to get into it with you. I'm also going to agree to disagree because I don't have the time to address your accusations either.
 
Last edited:
So much wrong. Just two simple points: Your paper acknowledges there is a debate. One paper with a dozen or so authors does not prove a consensus.


I didn't read the paper far enough to completely refute the idea it is a review of the literature but I sure didn't see anything remotely resembling that. All I see is their own opinions about the evidence. It doesn't even remotely appear to be a paper about establishing what the consensus is.

Shrug. You can lead a horse to water...

If you think there is actual scientific debate over this go look at some of the peer reviewed papers that say it's a lab leak. There are even a couple out there, but much like we see with climate change denial they don't actually come from people with relevant credentials to their names or they simply can't get published in any respectable journal.
 
Lomiller: there are multiple sources for what I've posted you think was lying or misleading or whatever.

You don't need multiple sources, you need to look at the text of the paper. It doesn't say what you claimed and in fact explicitly refers to the first human infection as a zoonotic event.

Angrysoba, are you claiming Daszak had no conflict of interest? Are you claiming Daszak never participated in GoF research?

I agree with Angrysoba's conclusion that there is no evidence supporting your claim that there was GoF research going on at this particular lab. I also disagree with you unfounded assertion that there is something fundamentally wrong with GoF research.


What is your point of debating what Daszak meant in the Dec 2019 interview/podcast when he said the coronaviruses are easily manipulated? Maybe if it was more clear what your objections are I could address them.

The interviewer and interviewee have both stated outright that the claims there is something nefarious being discussed are completely unfounded and people lime you are misinterpreting the discussion they had.
 
Last edited:
My point about smallpox is that the smallpox virus (a very much more dangerous virus than SARS-CoV-2) had to be discovered. (Obviously the disease was known, but the cause had to be isolated). This was done with non of the bio secure facilities we now have. when the only way of studying viruses was by growing them. As opposed to being able to study the DNA, being able to express genes inserted into plasmids etc. that don't actually require dealing with live virus.For over a hundred years virologists have been isolating and studying what were all when first discovered including the smallpox virus a novel virus. Virus hunting is not a new phenomenon. As mentioned above there have been e.g. the Birmingham smallpox outbreak, but despite all the previous conspiracy theories none of the previous epidemic / pandemic viruses have resulted from laboratory escapes, biowarfare experiments etc. Humans like to scapegoat, it is not surprising that they look for a person or persons to blame. But given every other time there has been a viral outbreak / pandemic (or even a bacterial one) it has been due to a host species shift. Smallpox probably arose 4,000 years ago when camels were introduced into East Africa and domesticated and camel pox jumped species into humans. pretty similar to what we see with MERS.
I'm not going to address CTs as they don't belong in this thread.

As for handling smallpox before proper isolation was available, the virus was not eliminated from humans until 1975 when the last case was found and everyone exposed to the person was quarantined and observed. It was declared eliminated in 1976.

How is it relevant that inadequate containment occurred before that time? A virus can't escape when it's already circulating.

The men who developed the rabies and the smallpox vaccines allowed themselves to be exposed. How is that relevant?


The argument spillover events are more common than lab leaks has been discussed here ad nauseum. Lab accidents are documented including a couple that resulted in smallpox infections. They didn't result in a pandemic because there was a high degree of people who had had smallpox vaccinations.

SARS lab accidents didn't result in a new round of cases because at that time we knew how to contain it.



Just because this is the first worldwide pandemic that might have originated in the lab doesn't mean it couldn't happen. Of course it could have happened. There is no definitive evidence where the virus originated, lab or natural origin.
 
... Most of the work the WIV does is with Corona viruses involves RNA samples collected from bat faeces. There are no live Corona viruses in such samples in such samples. They probably work with these under BSL-2 conditions because of the risk of fungal infections or viruses that could actually survive there.
Evidence from multiple sources documents they did indeed work with live cultures. It's described in their own published papers. There is evidence they had live bats at the WIV.
 
I'm describing a BSL-3 lab where SARS-COV-2 should be handled. Some of the work could be done in BSL-2 for the pseudotyped virus work that was published. Do we know for sure that the wild type viruses were handled at the wrong containment level?
Does that matter if multiple potential lapses in containment have been documented at the WIV?

I imagine you work in a lab or labs that are in tip-top shape. Just out of curiosity how often do those labs have to pass an inspection (licensing and/or accreditation) and when that happens have you ever seen an inspection that finds no faults in compliance?
 
Re a past discussion about what I posted above re Shi claiming the 6 miners had a fungal infection, this is in her own words in 2020 in an addendum to her paper: Addendum: A pneumonia outbreak associated with a new coronavirus of probable bat origin
Recently, we retested the samples with our validated enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) against the SARS coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2) nucleocapsid protein—which has greater than 90% amino acid sequence identity with bat SARSr-CoV Rp3—and confirmed that these patients were not infected by SARS-CoV-2.

We suspected that the patients had been infected by an unknown virus. Therefore, we and other groups sampled animals including bats, rats and musk shrews in or around the cave, and found some alphacoronaviruses1 and paramyxoviruses2. Between 2012 and 2015, our group sampled bats once or twice a year in this cave and collected a total of 1,322 samples. From these samples, we detected 293 highly diverse coronaviruses, of which 284 were designated alphacoronaviruses and 9 were designated betacoronaviruses on the basis of partial RdRp sequences. All of the nine betacoronaviruses are SARSr-CoVs, one of which (sample ID4991; renamed RaTG13 in our Article to reflect the bat species, the location and the sampling year) was described in a 2016 publication1
So the miners didn't have SARS CoV 2 by a sensitive PCR test.

There are two issues here. One, the miners' specimens were collected by hospital staff and we don't know how well the specimens were preserved; and two, they ruled out SARS CoV 2 but we don't know if the miners had a precursor to the pandemic virus if the tests were too specific. The bolded is the biggest problem.

We do know the WIV went on a bat virus collection mission after they were told of the miners illness. And in this addendum Shi herself said they had an unknown virus. There is no mention of a suspected fungal infection in the addendum or in the paper.
 
Evidence from multiple sources documents they did indeed work with live cultures. It's described in their own published papers. There is evidence they had live bats at the WIV.

Evidence they had live bats at the WIV?

Which type of live bats and for what purpose?

My understanding is that the specific types of bats that they were doing coronavirus research on were swabbed and released at the locations they were caught and not transported back to Wuhan.
 
Angrysoba, are you claiming Daszak had no conflict of interest? Are you claiming Daszak never participated in GoF research? What is your point of debating what Daszak meant in the Dec 2019 interview/podcast when he said the coronaviruses are easily manipulated? Maybe if it was more clear what your objections are I could address them.

As for some of the rest of your posts that involve mine, I don't think you read my posts very carefully. I'm not going to get into it with you. I'm also going to agree to disagree because I don't have the time to address your accusations either.

I don’t know how much clearer it is possible to be. Daszak refers to that research as having been done in Baric’s lab.

As for the funding pause, Baric’s lab and that research was exempt.
 
Re a past discussion about what I posted above re Shi claiming the 6 miners had a fungal infection, this is in her own words in 2020 in an addendum to her paper: Addendum: A pneumonia outbreak associated with a new coronavirus of probable bat originSo the miners didn't have SARS CoV 2 by a sensitive PCR test.

There are two issues here. One, the miners' specimens were collected by hospital staff and we don't know how well the specimens were preserved; and two, they ruled out SARS CoV 2 but we don't know if the miners had a precursor to the pandemic virus if the tests were too specific. The bolded is the biggest problem.

We do know the WIV went on a bat virus collection mission after they were told of the miners illness. And in this addendum Shi herself said they had an unknown virus. There is no mention of a suspected fungal infection in the addendum or in the paper.

No She did not say that. She said that she suspected they had an unknown virus infection. If you had asked a bacteriologist I am sure they would opt for suspecting an unknown bacterial infection. There is a huge difference between suspecting and having a definitive diagnosis.
 
No She did not say that. She said that she suspected they had an unknown virus infection. If you had asked a bacteriologist I am sure they would opt for suspecting an unknown bacterial infection. There is a huge difference between suspecting and having a definitive diagnosis.
What is the ******* difference? :rolleyes:

If you suspect a virus in this case, you don't know what it is.

Bottom line, not one mention of a fungus and so far no one here has found said evidence Shi based that claim on. You guys are trying waaay too hard.



Meanwhile, I think I posted this upthread. Here's a letter posted on EchoHealthAliance published in
/ Accepted: 8 January 2018
Wuhan Institute of Virology, CAS and Springer Nature Singapore Pte Ltd..
Daszak and Shi signed it, no Baric.

Serological Evidence of Bat SARS-Related Coronavirus Infection in Humans, China
These results indicate that some SARSr-CoVs may
have high potential to infect human cells, without the
necessity for an intermediate host. However, to date, no
evidence of direct transmission of SARSr-CoVs from bats
to people has been reported
So no direct identification of the miners having a SARSr CoV. No surprise, we already know there wasn't proof of what the miners had.

No mention the following test was used on the miners' serum retesting in 2020:
The Rp3 NP was chosen to develop a SARSr-CoV
specific ELISA for serosurveillance. ...

None of the sera reacted with NPs of either MERS-CoV or EBOV
If someone else finds Shi did use that specific ELISA test on the miners' serum it would be worth posting a link here.

Continuing:
The 2.7% seropositivity for the high risk group of residents
living in close proximity to bat colonies suggests that
spillover is a relatively rare event, however this depends on
how long antibodies persist in people, since other individuals may have been exposed and antibodies waned ...

Our previous work based on cellular and humanized mouse
infection studies suggest that these viruses are less virulent
than SARS-CoV (Ge et al. 2013; Menachery et al. 2016;
Yang et al. 2016). ...

However, considering that
these individuals have a high chance of direct exposure to
bat secretion in their villages, this study further supports
the notion that some bat SARSr-CoVs are able to directly
infect humans without intermediate hosts, as suggested by
receptor entry and animal infection studies (Menachery
et al. 2016).
So some evidence of spillovers, not a large number of incidents, can probably jump to people without an intermediate species, milder than SARS which SARS 2 is.
 
What is the ******* difference? :rolleyes:

If you suspect a virus in this case, you don't know what it is.

Bottom line, not one mention of a fungus and so far no one here has found said evidence Shi based that claim on. You guys are trying waaay too hard.



Meanwhile, I think I posted this upthread. Here's a letter posted on EchoHealthAliance published in Daszak and Shi signed it, no Baric.

Serological Evidence of Bat SARS-Related Coronavirus Infection in Humans, China
So no direct identification of the miners having a SARSr CoV. No surprise, we already know there wasn't proof of what the miners had.

No mention the following test was used on the miners' serum retesting in 2020:If someone else finds Shi did use that specific ELISA test on the miners' serum it would be worth posting a link here.

Continuing:So some evidence of spillovers, not a large number of incidents, can probably jump to people without an intermediate species, milder than SARS which SARS 2 is.

Huh?

To investigate the cause of the respiratory disease, we tested the samples using PCR methods developed in our laboratory targeting the RNA-dependent RNA polymerases (RdRp) of Ebola virus, Nipah virus and bat SARSr-CoV Rp3, and all of the samples were negative for the presence of these viruses.
 
I don’t understand. You say there is no mention of a particular test being used and yet the test is mentioned in the very parts of the papers you quote.

????
 
I'm sure I've misstated something there but let me clarify:

In 2020 they looked specifically for SARS CoV 2 in the miners from a decade ago and that is not what the miners would have had. They would have had a related virus if it was a SARS-Like CoV. So a specific test for SARS CoV 2 wouldn't necessarily have tested positive for a different SL CoV.

From the 2017 letter:
His-tagged nucleocapsid protein (NP) of the following
viruses were expressed and purified in E. coli for this study:
SARSr-CoV Rp3; human coronaviruses (HCoVs) HKU1,
OC43, 229E, NL63; Middle East Respiratory Syndrome
Coronavirus (MERS-CoV)
; and Ebola virus (EBOV). In
addition, the receptor binding domains (RBD) of the spike
protein (S) from SARS-CoV, bat SARSr-CoVs Rp3,
WIV1, and SHC014 were produced in mammalian cells
(Ge et al. 2013; Yang et al. 2016)....

... Cross-activity was evaluated with ELISA and
Western blot (Supplementary Figures S1, S2). No significant cross-activity was detected among NPs and their corresponding antibodies for Rp3, MERS-CoV, NL63, or 229E. Cross-reaction was detected between OC43 and
HKU1 as reported previously
(Lehmann et al. 2008).
The Rp3 NP was chosen to develop a SARSr-CoV specific ELISA for serosurveillance.
It did cross react to the bolded.

In 2020 Shi probably confirmed the serosurveillance test picked up SARS CoV 2 using known patients. But without knowing what the miners had, specific tests from 2017 might not have picked it up if the miners had a related virus. Where was the general test that would pick up a broad number of SL CoVs listed as one of the tests on the miners' serum? Shi describes very specific tests none of which is a broad test.


None of this is critical anyway. We don't know if the specimens from the miners were properly collected and stored. Though it is important to note the tests done in 2020 may have missed some SL CoVs.

There were other specimens from the miners discussed in the thesis that had been sent to other labs. Did Shi note if she made any effort to track down any of the other specimens? Or test them?

The more important bit of evidence with that 2017 letter is that nothing was mentioned about any assessment for a suspected primary fungal infection.
 
Until funding was paused in 2015. The funding ended in 2014 but the NIH allowed Baric and Shi et al to continue what they were working on.

At that point it either stopped, shifted to the WIV, or Shi continued the work without Baric. It's probably the latter.

Baric denies doing anymore GoF work including saying the work he did in 2015 was not GoF despite creating an SL coronavirus chimera. Fauci says the NIH never funded any GoF work. That's clearly false because the funding in 2014 was stopped (Obama admin) due to increasing concerns the work could lead to the creation of a PPP (pandemic potential pathogen).

I don't think Fauci has any fingers in the COVID creation pot. Rand Paul is an ass. And I don't care if Fauci was lying or playing semantic games about the definition of GoF research. None of that is relevant to the more immediate question of the origin of COVID 19.

There is a very thorough discussion of the GoF research here including virologists who say it was and virologists who say it wasn't: The Wuhan Lab and the Gain-of-Function Disagreement There is no smoking gun in the article, just a discussion of the issue including:The 2015 paper is cited in this thread but if you don't want to go looking for it: A SARS-like cluster of circulating bat coronaviruses shows potential for human emergence

But the 2015 paper is in Baric's lab?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom