Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
This seems to be a decent account but isn't behind a paywall.

Baltimore archive: Those Virus Sequences That Were Suddenly Deleted? They’re Back

Looks like there are still a lot of questions about what happened. But I await analysis of the early cases to see if they add anything to the origin question.

I also wonder if there's any more to be found in the "different database, overseen by the Chinese government."
 
Looks like there are still a lot of questions about what happened. But I await analysis of the early cases to see if they add anything to the origin question.

I also wonder if there's any more to be found in the "different database, overseen by the Chinese government."

Again "early cases" in this context means the end of January. This may or may not help track how\when Covid-19 spread out of China but it doesn't seem likely they will show much about it's origin. It's months too late for that.

 
Well, the Republicans have certainly decided that it leaked from a lab, and if there is anyone you can trust on all things Covid, not to mention all other things science, then it is the GOP, amirite!

A preponderance of evidence proves the virus that caused the COVID-19 pandemic leaked from a Chinese research facility, said a report by U.S. Republicans released on Monday, a conclusion that U.S. intelligence agencies have not reached.

The report also cited "ample evidence" that Wuhan Institute of Virology (WIV) scientists - aided by U.S. experts and Chinese and U.S. government funds - were working to modify coronaviruses to infect humans and such manipulation could be hidden.

Representative Mike McCaul, the top Republican on the House Foreign Affairs Committee, released the report by the panel's Republican staff. It urged a bipartisan investigation into the origins of the COVID-19 coronavirus pandemic that has killed 4.4 million people worldwide.

China denies a genetically modified coronavirus leaked from the facility in Wuhan - where the first COVID-19 cases were detected in 2019 - a leading but unproven theory among some experts. Beijing also denies allegations of a cover-up.

Link
 
Of course I know all about that. I've posted stuff on the minks as well. That's more general stuff.

Do you have any evidence that minks were found with a closely related virus not contracted from a human to a mink and which was sold in any Wuhan wet market or elsewhere in China with a possible trail leading to the human cases?

Here is what I said about Minks. Do you see anything in it about " closely related virus not contracted from a human to a mink "

This is a virus that readily infects many different species it spread from Mink to Mink and from cat to cat without gaining any "affinity" why would you assume it needed to gain something to spread from human to human?



Again if SARS-CoV-2 spreads so readily in mink right out of the gate, why would it need to "gain affinity" to spread rapidly in humans?
 
Here is what I said about Minks. Do you see anything in it about " closely related virus not contracted from a human to a mink "

Again if SARS-CoV-2 spreads so readily in mink right out of the gate, why would it need to "gain affinity" to spread rapidly in humans?
Do you not understand the concept of evidence NOT being 'something could have happened'? :rolleyes:

Connect the mink dots to the origin. BTW, it's already well established in this case that a spillover is possible.

But in all cases, viruses don't jump from animals to people in a 'ready to go' state. They might be capable of infecting people but they still need more mutations to spread effectively person to person.

Your mink example is of mink infected by people so the COVID strain of course is ready to go when it moves back from the mink to people.
 
Last edited:
Well, the Republicans have certainly decided that it leaked from a lab, and if there is anyone you can trust on all things Covid, not to mention all other things science, then it is the GOP, amirite!

Link
Totally sucks this additional muddling of the facts.

I read through a couple news stories on this and other than demanding Congress call Daszak to the hearings to explain why he tried to make scientists and the news media believe the lab-leak theory was a CT, I didn't see much in the way of new evidence.

I suspect they were trying to get in front of the National Security report that is soon to be published.
 
Do you not understand the concept of evidence NOT being 'something could have happened'? :rolleyes:

Project much?

In any case SARS-CoV-2 spreading rapidly in minks isn't something that "could have happened" it indisputably DID happen.


But in all cases, viruses don't jump from animals to people in a 'ready to go' state. .

AGAIN SARS-CoV-2 jumped from humans to mink ready to spread rapidly, and it did. This isn't a hypothetical. It happened.

The question I asked you remain. If SARS-CoV-2 can jump to mink ready to spread rapidly why would it need to "gain affinity" in order to spread rapidly in humans?


They might be capable of infecting people but they still need more mutations to spread effectively person to person.

Wrong.

A novel virus need mutations to spread *optimally* in humans, and we see that happing right now with variants. A novel virus does not need, however, to be optimised for a new host to spread rapidly.
 
Simple question: how did COVID 19 get into minks?

Answer, they were infected from humans in mink farms.

How do you know they were 'ready to go' when the mink were infected?

Answer, there are a number of animals with closely related ACE 2 receptors, some more adaptable than others.

Preprint Feb 2021: Predicting the zoonotic capacity of mammal species for SARS-CoV-2
Abstract: Spillback transmission from humans to animals, and secondary spillover from animal hosts back into humans, have now been documented for SARS-CoV-2. In addition to threatening animal health, virus variants arising from novel animal hosts have the potential to undermine global COVID-19 mitigation efforts. Numerous studies have therefore investigated the zoonotic capacity of various animal species for SARS-CoV-2, including predicting both species’ susceptibility to infection and their capacities for onward transmission. A major bottleneck to these studies is the limited number of sequences for ACE2, a key cellular receptor in chordates that is required for viral cell entry. Here, we combined protein structure modeling with machine learning of species’ traits to predict zoonotic capacity of SARS-CoV-2 across 5,400 mammals. High accuracy model predictions were strongly corroborated by in vivo empirical studies, and identify numerous mammal species across global COVID-19 hotspots that should be prioritized for surveillance and experimental validation.

Have fun. There are many animals with the potential to be infected from human COVID cases, some much more 'ready to go' than others.

Animals without perfect 'ready to go' anatomy and physiology can get infected by close contact with people, but don't go on to produce large quantities of viral shedding. Those cases need to circulate a bit before they become easily transmissible in that new species. I described this happening with the HPAI H5N1 flu that is close but has yet to become a well adapted human pathogen.

That's all well and good but you still have not gotten past the 'could have happened' evidence to actual evidence supporting that it happened that way. Note I said supporting evidence not conclusive evidence.

Pretty much most people in this thread, including me, know this. Both spillover and lab-leak origins remain on the table.
Here's your problem. In a year and a half no such precursor species has been found. I believe there are even mink farms in China. Yet no COVID infections have been found including no original cases in humans from the mink farms.

The initial jump to humans happened in Wuhan. Lots of pieces of evidence corroborate this. I'm not going back over them, they're here in the thread for anyone interested. No mink, no mink farms, no cases of SL CoV in any animal species have been found.

The closest genetic match is apparently ~40-50 years away from COVID 19, meaning it would have taken 40 years for enough mutations to occur to get from there to here.


If COVID 19 jumped to humans ready to go, you would need an animal species that had circulating COVID 19 or something very close to it within the species. It only took 4 months to find the civet cats SARS jumped to humans from. The fact it was a couple years to trace the bat source that infected civets is not directly relevant. There were a couple suspect species in the wet markets. There was a direct connection to the earliest cases in Guangdong.

No such species with circulating SL CoV has been found. No species the pathogen was able to reach a 'ready to go jump straight to humans' state in has been found.

OTOH, more and more evidence is accumulating that such a strain could very well have existed in one of the virology labs in Wuhan.


Your assertion the first human infections weren't with a well adapted strain because it has now become more well adapted is not a supportable assertion. It became a world-wide pandemic long before the more transmissible variants started showing up.
 
On to newer curiosities. About those Sept data deletions, apparently this was in the GOP report:

Wuhan Lab Air Circulation Systems Were Defective ahead of First Known COVID Cases, Congressional Report Finds
In the months preceding the first known cases of COVID-19 in Wuhan, China, multiple air ventilation systems within the Wuhan Institute of Virology were not functioning properly and required renovation, ...

In the fall of 2019, while WIV researchers were conducting gain-of-function research on bat coronaviruses, multiple requests for lab maintenance were outstanding, including repair for an “environmental air disinfection system” and “hazardous waste treatment system.” A notice for laboratory inspection was issued in September 2019.
Setting the gain of function issue and the sick lab workers aside for the moment:
Shortly after the WIV took its public virus database off the internet in September 2019, the lab announced a contract competition to renovate its air conditioning system for approximately $606 million. The announcement was later redacted from the Chinese Ministry of Finance website, Washington Post columnist Josh Rogin first noted.

“A defective hazardous waste treatment system and central air conditioning system would increase the likelihood of a lab employee (or several) becoming infected with SARS-CoV-2, as viral particles would be more likely to remain in the air for longer periods of time,” the memo read....

“Based on the material collected and analyzed by the Committee Minority Staff, the preponderance of evidence suggests SARS-CoV-2 was accidentally released from a Wuhan Institute of Virology laboratory sometime prior to September 12, 2019,” the report notes.

It is our belief the virus leaked sometime in late August or early September 2019. When they realized what happened, Chinese Communist Party officials and scientists at the WIV began frantically covering up the leak, including taking their virus database offline in the middle of the night and requesting more than $1 million for additional security.


Then there is this (yeah I know, National Review, a GOP mouthpiece; and worse it's written by Tom Cotton, and this is from the GOP report) Coronavirus Lab-Leak-Theory Proponents Have Been Vindicated
First, the Chinese government has not behaved like an innocent victim. Instead, it has acted consistently as if it’s covering up a terrible secret in Wuhan. In December 2019, the WIV’s infamous bat expert, Dr. Shi Zhengli, deleted data and purged phrases such as “wild animal samples,” “cross-species infection,” and “emerging infectious diseases” from institute databases. The next month, the Chinese government installed its top military epidemiologist at the WIV, putting it under the control of the People’s Liberation Army. Last February, Chairman Xi Jinping announced that China would fast-track legislation to reform the nation’s biosecurity laws. Chapter Five of that law addresses “biosafety of pathogenic microorganism laboratories” — in other words, lab leaks. And the Chinese government purged hundreds of studies relating to bat-coronavirus research, including research by Dr. Shi.


I consider this weak evidence at this point because of the source. But it could explain how 2 lineages emerged early in Wuhan and how the Sept 9th data purge fits the scenario. And some/most of this might be corroborated by additional evidence.


There is still the matter of the Oct military games in Wuhan and the earliest cases in the US and Italy which might prove beneficial if the cases can be connected.
 
Last edited:
Simple question: how did COVID 19 get into minks?

Answer, they were infected from humans in mink farms.

How do you know they were 'ready to go' when the mink were infected?

Answer, there are a number of animals with closely related ACE 2 receptors, some more adaptable than others.

Preprint Feb 2021: Predicting the zoonotic capacity of mammal species for SARS-CoV-2

Have fun. There are many animals with the potential to be infected from human COVID cases, some much more 'ready to go' than others.

Animals without perfect 'ready to go' anatomy and physiology can get infected by close contact with people, but don't go on to produce large quantities of viral shedding. Those cases need to circulate a bit before they become easily transmissible in that new species. I described this happening with the HPAI H5N1 flu that is close but has yet to become a well adapted human pathogen.

That's all well and good but you still have not gotten past the 'could have happened' evidence to actual evidence supporting that it happened that way. Note I said supporting evidence not conclusive evidence.

Pretty much most people in this thread, including me, know this. Both spillover and lab-leak origins remain on the table.
Here's your problem. In a year and a half no such precursor species has been found. I believe there are even mink farms in China. Yet no COVID infections have been found including no original cases in humans from the mink farms.

The initial jump to humans happened in Wuhan. Lots of pieces of evidence corroborate this. I'm not going back over them, they're here in the thread for anyone interested. No mink, no mink farms, no cases of SL CoV in any animal species have been found.

The closest genetic match is apparently ~40-50 years away from COVID 19, meaning it would have taken 40 years for enough mutations to occur to get from there to here.


If COVID 19 jumped to humans ready to go, you would need an animal species that had circulating COVID 19 or something very close to it within the species. It only took 4 months to find the civet cats SARS jumped to humans from. The fact it was a couple years to trace the bat source that infected civets is not directly relevant. There were a couple suspect species in the wet markets. There was a direct connection to the earliest cases in Guangdong.

No such species with circulating SL CoV has been found. No species the pathogen was able to reach a 'ready to go jump straight to humans' state in has been found.

OTOH, more and more evidence is accumulating that such a strain could very well have existed in one of the virology labs in Wuhan.


Your assertion the first human infections weren't with a well adapted strain because it has now become more well adapted is not a supportable assertion. It became a world-wide pandemic long before the more transmissible variants started showing up.

SG, if we don’t know where it came from, then we clearly don’t know how easy it would be to find the spillover route. Remember that the discovery of SARS in palm covers did not actually happen in the wet markets it apparently hopped from but from a market in Shenzhen. It was more extrapolated to have been from palm civets to humans in Guangdong from that discovery and that discovery was itself a lucky find.

There are many other routes for potential spillover: people drinking date palm sap (Nipah), or wandering around a python cave covered in bat crap (a particular variant of Marburg) or even more difficult to detect origins with HIV etc….it can take a lot of time and sometimes luck.
 
SG, if we don’t know where it came from, then we clearly don’t know how easy it would be to find the spillover route. Remember that the discovery of SARS in palm covers did not actually happen in the wet markets it apparently hopped from but from a market in Shenzhen. It was more extrapolated to have been from palm civets to humans in Guangdong from that discovery and that discovery was itself a lucky find.

There are many other routes for potential spillover: people drinking date palm sap (Nipah), or wandering around a python cave covered in bat crap (a particular variant of Marburg) or even more difficult to detect origins with HIV etc….it can take a lot of time and sometimes luck.

Don't conflate "we know" with "we can't rule X out."

Once again here I am repeating what I have made perfectly clear numerous times in this thread. There is no proof yet of either origin theory.

But what we do have is a fair amount and growing body of evidence supporting the lab leak origin and very little supporting the spillover origin.
 
Don't conflate "we know" with "we can't rule X out."
Once again here I am repeating what I have made perfectly clear numerous times in this thread. There is no proof yet of either origin theory.

But what we do have is a fair amount and growing body of evidence supporting the lab leak origin and very little supporting the spillover origin.

Indeed. Which means we have numerous possibilities. We cannot even rule out the Huanan Market as I have made clear many times.

Has anyone looked at the Wuhan Zoo?
 
Indeed. Which means we have numerous possibilities. We cannot even rule out the Huanan Market as I have made clear many times.

Has anyone looked at the Wuhan Zoo?
That does not mean it is a reasonable hypothesis just because you believe it is possible. It sounds like a person who can't let go of an early suspected origin that has been for all intents and purposes ruled out.

If your criteria is anything you want it to be, why not include space alien experiments?

There is a point where you need to shrink your list and I'd say dump that unsupportable seafood market unless you can connect it to earlier cases. There has been no connection found.

Not only that but Daszak has been discredited by multiple sources and it's pretty clear he pushed the WHO team to conclude there must have been some other market despite there being no evidence of another Wuhan wet market connected to any cases.

Anyone looking at this question needs to seriously consider that Daszak's attempts to steer the investigation away from any lab origin included pushing the idea it was a CT and an insult to the fine scientists at the WIV.

Of all the things we do have overwhelming evidence to support, it is that Daszak led an effort to quash the lab origin hypothesis and he succeeded in delaying an investigation of the lab origin for at least a year.

Think about it, we can't really trust much about the lab origin that came from the Trump administration and that includes taking the latest report from the GOP with a serious grain of salt. I'm still ambivalent about some of the evidence like the ill lab workers and a number of the 'cables' we have seen. To resolve that I expect some corroboration of that suspect evidence is needed.

And despite there being references to GoF research going on at the WIV, I'm willing to put that one on the maybe shelf until more corroborating evidence is found. I think there is evidence but not everyone agrees.

So far nothing has corroborated Daszak's suspect assertions except that the spillover hypothesis is one recognized origin of many zoonoses. There's no more reason to trust him at this point than there is reason to trust anything from the Trump admin. or the GOP.


There have been no animal species found after a year and a half that the virus had been circulating in. I looked again at the source of SARS. Despite it taking a number of years to find the initial source of SARS, the actual connection to the wet markets in Guangdong and specifically to the civet cats in the market was found in about 4 months. There were at least 5 different wet markets tied directly to the SARS cases about the same time right out of the gate.
 
Last edited:
That does not mean it is a reasonable hypothesis just because you believe it is possible. It sounds like a person who can't let go of an early suspected origin that has been for all intents and purposes ruled out.
If your criteria is anything you want it to be, why not include space alien experiments?

There is a point where you need to shrink your list and I'd say dump that unsupportable seafood market unless you can connect it to earlier cases. There has been no connection found.

Not only that but Daszak has been discredited by multiple sources and it's pretty clear he pushed the WHO team to conclude there must have been some other market despite there being no evidence of another Wuhan wet market connected to any cases.

Anyone looking at this question needs to seriously consider that Daszak's attempts to steer the investigation away from any lab origin included pushing the idea it was a CT and an insult to the fine scientists at the WIV.

Of all the things we do have overwhelming evidence to support, it is that Daszak led an effort to quash the lab origin hypothesis and he succeeded in delaying an investigation of the lab origin for at least a year.

Think about it, we can't really trust much about the lab origin that came from the Trump administration and that includes taking the latest report from the GOP with a serious grain of salt. I'm still ambivalent about some of the evidence like the ill lab workers and a number of the 'cables' we have seen. To resolve that I expect some corroboration of that suspect evidence is needed.

And despite there being references to GoF research going on at the WIV, I'm willing to put that one on the maybe shelf until more corroborating evidence is found. I think there is evidence but not everyone agrees.

So far nothing has corroborated Daszak's suspect assertions except that the spillover hypothesis is one recognized origin of many zoonoses. There's no more reason to trust him at this point than there is reason to trust anything from the Trump admin. or the GOP.


There have been no animal species found after a year and a half that the virus had been circulating in. I looked again at the source of SARS. Despite it taking a number of years to find the initial source of SARS, the actual connection to the wet markets in Guangdong and specifically to the civet cats in the market was found in about 4 months. There were at least 5 different wet markets tied directly to the SARS cases about the same time right out of the gate.

Nice uses of the passive.

The Huanan market has been ruled out.

Daszak has been discredited.

By whom? Multiple sources? Oh well, if "multiple sources" have discredited something or ruled something out, then of course it must be ruled out.

That is simply not true.

I completely agree that the Huanan Seafood Market may have been a superspreader event, but that does not mean that it was its only role. If many of the early cases are linked to the Seafood Market, then we don't know how long the virus was spreading from there.

Besides, and to keep reminding you, if the early cases had no connection to the Seafood Market was enough of a reason to rule out the Seafood Market then by that logic you would be forced to rule out everything else that the early cases had no connection to, such as obviously the Wuhan Institute of Virology.

However, you seem extremely eager to rule out the Seafood Market as though transmission of the virus could only have been later. It may have been making people ill for weeks, for all we know.

Like I said, WE JUST DON'T KNOW!
 
By the way, speaking of ruling things in and out, while China are being extremely opaque and uncooperative (for example, we don't know what they are doing regarding searching back through the wildlife farms route - or maybe I should just say, I haven't heard anything), but what about stuff that the west could do without worrying about what China says or does.

If, for example, the Wuhan Military Games was suspected of being a superspreader event, then why is there not some investigation into those who felt sick after the games, or simply some kind of serological survey of all the athletes. I would have thought that given the athletes are in militaries around the world, it would be extremely easy for the governments of those countries to check the records, test the athletes and investigating from there.

Does anyone know if any of this is being done?
 
Nice uses of the passive.

The Huanan market has been ruled out.
In context, the market was proclaimed to be the source. Then the evidence didn't support that claim at all. If you want to go on ignoring the evidence, that's your problem, not mine.

Daszak has been discredited.

By whom? Multiple sources? Oh well, if "multiple sources" have discredited something or ruled something out, then of course it must be ruled out.
Oh come on, keep up.

... completely agree that the Huanan Seafood Market may have been a superspreader event, but that does not mean that it was its only role. If many of the early cases are linked to the Seafood Market, then we don't know how long the virus was spreading from there.

Besides, and to keep reminding you, if the early cases had no connection to the Seafood Market was enough of a reason to rule out the Seafood Market then by that logic you would be forced to rule out everything else that the early cases had no connection to, such as obviously the Wuhan Institute of Virology.

However, you seem extremely eager to rule out the Seafood Market as though transmission of the virus could only have been later. It may have been making people ill for weeks, for all we know.

Like I said, WE JUST DON'T KNOW!
You keep reminding me? As if that means anything. :rolleyes: I'm sorry, it doesn't.

Find some ******* evidence if you want me to reconsider the wet market. I don't care if you don't know, don't drag "we" into it unless you have some evidence.

And don't assume you know I'm anxious to rule anything out because that's nonsense.

Post some ******* evidence that supports the wet market might still be the source. Space monkeys from Mars could be the source.

I have asked numerous times for someone to find where in the WHO final report there is a shred of evidence besides assumptions that other cases were all exposed to some wet market somewhere in Wuhan.

No one here has found anything tangible to quote, or if they have they haven't posted it.
 
Last edited:
NY Post: Who is Peter Daszak, the nonprofit exec who sent taxpayer money to Wuhan lab?
The nonprofit exec whose organization sent nearly $600,000 in US taxpayer money to a Chinese lab that may have been the source of COVID-19 masterminded an effort near the start of the pandemic to squelch the notion that the coronavirus was man-made, a new report reveals.

National Review: China Apologist Peter Daszak Has Some Explaining to Do
On the menu today: Peter Daszak recuses himself from the COVID-19 Commission established by the medical journal The Lancet, after accusations that he hid his conflicts of interest in the past. That’s barely enough, because back in February, he was doing interviews with Chinese-state-run media backing up Beijing’s implausible theory that COVID-19 was imported to Wuhan from Cambodia, Thailand, or Japan. Meanwhile, at home, Democrats run into brick walls of reality, and we wonder why anyone believes Michael Wolff’s tall tales anymore.

American Thinker: June 14, 2021 - Stunning video reveals Daszak and WHO lied when claiming no bats in the Wuhan Lab
One key element of that cover-up was the hiding of the fact that the Wuhan lab was working on bats because the virus was a variant of an existing bat-borne virus. The cover story, that a wet market led to the dispersal of COVID-19, would have looked awfully weak had it been known that the WIV was creating new viruses from bats. Both the World Health Organization and Peter Daszak, who acted as an investigator for WHO, outright denied that the WIV had live bats in its research facility.

Australian journalist Sheri Markson has come into possession of stunning video from China uncovered by an underground research group that calls itself "Drastic" that shows live bats at the WIV and much, much more. The newly uncovered video was produced by the Chinese Academy of Sciences in May 2017 commemorating the opening of WIV.

At a minimum, Daszak is as unreliable as anything Trump or the GOP are.
 
In context, the market was proclaimed to be the source. Then the evidence didn't support that claim at all. If you want to go on ignoring the evidence, that's your problem, not mine.

Oh come on, keep up.

You keep reminding me? As if that means anything. :rolleyes: I'm sorry, it doesn't.

Find some ******* evidence if you want me to reconsider the wet market. I don't care if you don't know, don't drag "we" into it unless you have some evidence.

And don't assume you know I'm anxious to rule anything out because that's nonsense.

Post some ******* evidence that supports the wet market might still be the source. Space monkeys from Mars could be the source.

I have asked numerous times for someone to find where in the WHO final report there is a shred of evidence besides assumptions that other cases were all exposed to some wet market somewhere in Wuhan.

No one here has found anything tangible to quote, or if they have they haven't posted it.

Well actually we have told you that there were positive samples in the drains of the wet market. We know there were wild animals sold there. The Chinese government shut the place down. That in and of itself makes it plausible as a possible spillover location.

As for “Oh come on, keep up!” maybe I don’t share the same assumptions as you do.

You are making it extremely obvious where your biases are, so I am not assuming anything about it what you are doing.
 

NYPost, American Thinker, National Review!

What no Daily Caller this time? No climate change denying think tanks?

Of course Daszak has been discredited by far right loons and fascists! But that is not a point in your favour is it?
 
NYPost, American Thinker, National Review!

What no Daily Caller this time? No climate change denying think tanks?

Of course Daszak has been discredited by far right loons and fascists! But that is not a point in your favour is it?
You can dismiss that all you want. The evidence supports what is claimed in the articles. I know they are right wing sources.

Here's another one: Peter Daszak’s EcoHealth Alliance Has Hidden Almost $40 Million In Pentagon Funding And Militarized Pandemic Science

I don't think we have a lot of evidence the Chinese military was involved in this research.That specific claim is specious. But the rest? Not so much.

Are you still claiming Daszak had no conflict of interest? Or you just don't want to let go of a documented source that supports your confirmation bias?


I'm saying this: Daszak is as unreliable as Trump and GOP sources for the same reason, both have serious conflicts of interest.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom