Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
Going by the cited evidence, there are several sources in this thread with different 'earliest case' scenarios. You don't like the ones that don't confirm your bias, I don't care. It's not a stretch at all that whatever the event was, were it a lab accident it could have occurred before mid-Sept and still fit the genetic time clock.

I don't particularly care. I have seen numerous examples, and every one says it was after the databases were taken down.

I know full well that the first known case was not the first actual case.

The point I am making is judging by the first known case, we cannot know where the virus emerged.

What you think the first known case shows is that it rules out the market. It doesn't.

Why?

Well, obviously it doesn't rule out the market for exactly the same bloody obvious reason that the first known case doesn't rule ANYWHERE out. That goes for the market, that goes for the lab, that goes for outer space. Wherever!

It has been ruled out by multiple sources. Why do you insist it was the initiating location when the evidence of earlier cases exist?

No, it hasn't.

Please understand a very elementary point that I have been making over and over again.

I have NOT said the market is the origin!

I HAVE said, it cannot be ruled out.

You cannot have this both ways. You cannot say, "Ah! First known case (Dec 9th), no connection with the market therefore it categorically rules out the market. Now it is IMPOSSIBLE to come from the market!"

And also say:

"It's defo a lab leak!"



If you have evidence it was the location of the first cases, let's see it.

One more time:

We don't know where the first case was!

That should be bloody obvious. If we knew where the first case was it would tell us the origins. Hello!

In the meantime there are documented earlier cases not connected to any wet market.

Nobody disputes this!


Uhh, because Shi said so and the evidence suggests she is lying about that.

Again, we really don't know.
 
By the way, I want to revisit this. One major peg of Skeptic Ginger's argument has been that Peter Daszak "admitted" to Gain of Function research in the Wuhan Institute of Virology. She kept saying it, even though she refused to quote the relevant part.

Then, suddenly she changed tune when Rand Paul and Tony Fauci went at it, with Fauci saying Paul didn't know what he was talking about when Paul claimed GoF had been done at the WIV.

As for Fauci's definition of GoF and Paul's I've been trying to find a clear-cut difference in how each is defining it. And I intend to go over some past links from the thread. I haven't yet.
I believe Fauci over Paul and I don't expect to find anything different. There is no reason to connect research done at the UNC in 2014-2015 to the current pandemic. Paul is way out of line there. But it doesn't mean no SARS Co V-like coronavirus strains were used in GoF research. I'm still digging there. I do respect the belief by Capsid here that there wasn't any GoF research going on at the WIV. I can't counter that unless I find more evidence. And maybe there isn't any.

Indeed. But Rand Paul was specifically claiming that a 2017 paper of Shi and Daszak et. al was gain of function.

Fauci was specifically saying it was NOT GoF.

So next time you see a claim that there were published papers showing GoF was done at the WIV, then you have to treat it with extreme caution because there is literally no evidence, and the statements by Shi and Daszak that they weren't doing GoF should be respected until there is evidence that they are lying (there is none!).

As for "There is no reason to connect research done at the UNC in 2014-2015 to the current pandemic. Paul is way out of line there." That is exactly what YOU were doing as I pointed out in this post as well as several times previously...

I didn't connect that research specifically. I said there was nothing in the US denying funding that prohibited said research moving to the WIV.

I have different issues with the Daszak interview I'll address later.

Actually, we will see that Skeptic Ginger was doing exactly what Rand Paul was doing. Alledging GoF and tying the UNC gain of function work to the WIV...

In the Daszak interview he discusses the work they were doing and it is clear he didn't yet know about the early pandemic cases. He discussed GoF research, IIRC, and later the WIV said they weren't doing any GoF research recently.

Go back and look at what Daszak said in his interview at the conference and what was posted about that interview. If Daszak knew about the early cases he wouldn't have said the incriminating things about GoF research he said.

What was incriminating about it?

He admitted they were currently doing GoF research. Later that was denied.

LOL! (In the interview he was talking about the work they did in Baric's lab. We know that because in the interview he said "Baric's lab"). LOL!

But I thought I would give Skeptic Ginger the chance to put her case...

Please quote the relevant passages of the interview.

Besides in the interview he was talking about research being done in Baric’s lab. That is in the US. It was no secret what was being done in that lab and the research that he had been doing with Zhengli Shi was no secret either given that they had published papers on the research.

So he doesn’t say they did the GoF in Wuhan but in Baric’s lab. So your claim that he incriminated himself fails.

We discussed that Daszak video at length early on in the thread. Feel free to review what was discussed and get back to us.


So you are ignoring the request to quote the relevant part where he "incriminates himself" because you know that you don't have such a quote from him.

As I suspected. It's just more smearing.

:sdl: :rolleyes:

What part of we already discussed this did you miss? At least I provided the bloody link again which is more than you do telling me to chase some obscure reference back to a previous post.

Look at all the dodges!

Quote the part where Peter Daszak incriminates himself.

Yep, can't attack the argument no worries, you can always attack the arguer. :thumbsup:

Spealing of attacking the arguer, I would like you to address your argument that Peter Daszak incriminated himself. Please quote his incriminating statements.

So basically, Skeptic Ginger is in exactly the same boat as Rand Paul.

Don't tell me, she'll pull out that Mike Pompeo "fact sheet" again and say, "look, many people are saying it came from a lab!"
 
I don't particularly care. I have seen numerous examples, and every one says it was after the databases were taken down.

I know full well that the first known case was not the first actual case.

The point I am making is judging by the first known case, we cannot know where the virus emerged.

What you think the first known case shows is that it rules out the market. It doesn't.

Why?

Well, obviously it doesn't rule out the market for exactly the same bloody obvious reason that the first known case doesn't rule ANYWHERE out. That goes for the market, that goes for the lab, that goes for outer space. Wherever!
No, it hasn't.

Please understand a very elementary point that I have been making over and over again.

I have NOT said the market is the origin!

I HAVE said, it cannot be ruled out.

You cannot have this both ways. You cannot say, "Ah! First known case (Dec 9th), no connection with the market therefore it categorically rules out the market. Now it is IMPOSSIBLE to come from the market!"

And also say:

"It's defo a lab leak!"

One more time:

[snipped shouting as it adds nothing to your argument] That should be bloody obvious. If we knew where the first case was it would tell us the origins. Hello!

Nobody disputes this

Again, we really don't know.
Let's boil this down.

The earliest cases have no connection to the seafood market.

The WHO report makes an unsupported assertion those earliest cases are connected to some other wet markets despite offering no evidence other than claiming they do.

If one is going to claim it could have been the seafood market or some other wet market where the first human exposure occurred, one has to admit that speculation has no more weight than it could have been a lab accident. Because it doesn't.

So stop saying it could have been X when there is zero evidence to support that assertion.

That leaves us back to what does the evidence support and what does it not support?

Nothing supports a wet market. That leaves the only evidence supporting a natural spillover is the fact it is more likely. That's it, nothing else except it could have been.

What supports a lab accident?

Shi has made an unsupportable statement about what the 6 miners had.

China has clamped down, refusing to release records that could clear this up.

Bloom has found evidence in the cloud of genetic evidence that could help clear things up but the person who took the evidence down has not answered his questions about why access to the data has been removed.

There's more but let's say those are the least refutable points.

Then you have the seriously unlikely coincidence the pandemic began in close proximity to both the WIV and the CCDC, both known to be working on coronavirus research.

If as Shi says the removed databases were done to prevent cyber attacks there could be arrangements made to release it to certain individuals. That has not been done.
 
Last edited:
Here's an idea.

With China demanding that Fort Detrick be investigated, maybe the west should call China's bluff and say, "Okay, if you want to investigate Fort Detrick, you can do so in return for an investigation of the Wuhan Institute of Virology..."

As the calls for a second round of investigation into the origins of the coronavirus in China gain momentum, Beijing sharpened its attack on the United States and demanded the World Health Organization (WHO) to inspect a military base in the US instead.

"If labs are to be investigated, then the WHO experts should go to Fort Detrick," said Zhao Lijian, spokesperson of China's Ministry of Foreign Affairs.

Zhao Lijian's statement was with regards to the theory that the coronavirus leaked from a laboratory, was transmitted to a person and then spread across the world. Since the first cases of Covid-19 were reported in Wuhan, a lab in the Chinese city is considered the prime suspect. China, however, has fiercely contested this and alleged on several occasions that supporters of the lab leak theory should be probing biological laboratories in the US, such as the one rumoured to be in Fort Detrick.

Link

Obviously some form of diplomacy is going to be necessary to move the ball forward.
 
By the way, I want to revisit this. One major peg of Skeptic Ginger's argument has been that Peter Daszak "admitted" to Gain of Function research in the Wuhan Institute of Virology. She kept saying it, even though she refused to quote the relevant part.

Then, suddenly she changed tune when Rand Paul and Tony Fauci went at it, with Fauci saying Paul didn't know what he was talking about when Paul claimed GoF had been done at the WIV.

Actually, we will see that Skeptic Ginger was doing exactly what Rand Paul was doing. Alledging GoF and tying the UNC gain of function work to the WIV...

LOL! (In the interview he was talking about the work they did in Baric's lab. We know that because in the interview he said "Baric's lab"). LOL!

But I thought I would give Skeptic Ginger the chance to put her case...

Look at all the dodges!
So basically, Skeptic Ginger is in exactly the same boat as Rand Paul.

Don't tell me, she'll pull out that Mike Pompeo "fact sheet" again and say, "look, many people are saying it came from a lab!"
You are allowing me to make my case? :rolleyes:

That you don't like or don't agree with my answers is in no way me dodging your questions. You try again and again to goad me into some discussion you think is relevant: Ginger said this, Ginger said that....Obviously you'd rather address me than the actual arguments. I'm not going to jump through your hoops.

The Rand Paul-Fauci exchange was about what happened in 2014. It's not very closely related to the current situation. But there are those Fauci emails.

A Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) request has brought to light another damning email showing that Tony Fauci has, in fact, been heavily involved with illegal gain of function research on bat coronaviruses is communist China.

The latest incriminating email to surface was sent to Fauci by EcoHealth Alliance President Peter Daszak back in 2017, in which Daszak admitted that he was,

"doing assays to find out if [manipulated bat coronaviruses] can infect human cells in the lab."


The subject line of the email reads,

"Confidential - A new bat-origin coronavirus emerging in pigs in China discovered under our NIAID R01", ...
I am not the only one addressing Daszak's significant conflict of interest. That is well documented here in this thread but elsewhere are well.

Nature, 2015: Engineered bat virus stirs debate over risky research
In an article published in Nature Medicine1 on 9 November, scientists investigated a virus called SHC014, which is found in horseshoe bats in China. The researchers created a chimaeric virus, made up of a surface protein of SHC014 and the backbone of a SARS virus that had been adapted to grow in mice and to mimic human disease. The chimaera infected human airway cells — proving that the surface protein of SHC014 has the necessary structure to bind to a key receptor on the cells and to infect them. It also caused disease in mice, but did not kill them. ...

But other virologists question whether the information gleaned from the experiment justifies the potential risk. Although the extent of any risk is difficult to assess, Simon Wain-Hobson, a virologist at the Pasteur Institute in Paris, points out that the researchers have created a novel virus that “grows remarkably well” in human cells. “If the virus escaped, nobody could predict the trajectory,” he says.

Jumping to Daszak's role:
The study findings “move this virus from a candidate emerging pathogen to a clear and present danger”, says Peter Daszak, who co-authored the 2013 paper. ...

Studies testing hybrid viruses in human cell culture and animal models are limited in what they can say about the threat posed by a wild virus, Daszak agrees. But he argues that they can help indicate which pathogens should be prioritized for further research attention
What Daszak said in that 2019 interview was that coronaviruses were easy to manipulate.

US Scientist With Close Ties To Wuhan Lab Discussed Manipulating Bat-Based Coronaviruses Just Weeks Before Outbreak
Dr. Peter Daszak, a close associate with China’s premier bat-based coronavirus researcher and a key figure in directing taxpayer funds to the Wuhan Institute of Virology, explained how easy it was to alter coronaviruses during a podcast interview filmed Dec. 9, 2019.

“You can manipulate them in the lab pretty easily,” Daszak said. “Spike protein drives a lot of what happens with the coronavirus. Zoonotic risk. So you can get the sequence, you can build the protein — and we work with Ralph Baric at [the University of North Carolina] to do this — and insert the backbone of another virus and do some work in the lab.”



I have posted multiple sources so cherry picking this one or that one doesn't support your case. It's more of you arguing with me the arguer and not the argument. And if you think the State Department memo was a propaganda piece, address that, not the fact Pompeo and Dump were cooking the books.
 
The Rand Paul-Fauci exchange was about what happened in 2014. It's not very closely related to the current situation.

Wrong! They discussed a 2017 paper. Paul claimed it proved Fauci lied and that there had been GoF in the WIV funded by the NIH.


....

Jumping to Daszak's role:
What Daszak said in that 2019 interview was that coronaviruses were easy to manipulate.

US Scientist With Close Ties To Wuhan Lab Discussed Manipulating Bat-Based Coronaviruses Just Weeks Before Outbreak

Same interview. Again, he was talking about Baric's lab. Again, you get it wrong.

And what a source... The Daily Caller?

:sdl:
 
What are the scenarios for lab virus to infect the surrounding area?

1) Loss of containment. Essentially high containment labs have a big fan that maintains a negative pressure to the outside. The exhaust is sent through HEPA filters to remove any viruses. The air pressure is constantly monitored and an alarm will sound if it rises above a set limit. If the virus did get outside due to lack of negative air pressure then I can't see how it could infect anyone in the vicinity as the infectious titre would be greatly reduced by dispersion. The persons who might be infected are the lab workers and they were tested negative. Also, all work would be done in a safety cabinet that has its own negative pressure environment to protect the worker.

2) Lab worker gets infected and doesn't report the incident. Plausible but see above. The likely scenario is that a culture vessel is dropped outside of the safety cabinet whilst transporting to the incubator. This will generate aerosols that could be breathed in, although the air exchange in the lab is very high and aerosols are removed very quickly.

3) Someone at WIV could have got infected when unpacking samples that had been broken in transit. This would have been done inside the safety cabinet inside the containment lab. It's a major incident and would be reported immediately

This assumes that the WIV has SARS-COV-2 and is hiding the fact.
 

No! You are just making exactly the same claims that Rand Paul made! That is taken from exactly the same paper (the 2017 one) that Rand Paul was saying was illegal and the one that made Rand Paul say that it proved Fauci was lying.


I am not the only one addressing Daszak's significant conflict of interest. That is well documented here in this thread but elsewhere are well.

Nature, 2015: Engineered bat virus stirs debate over risky research

No! You are just making exactly the same claims that Rand Paul made!

That is just remarking on the paper that was done in Baric's lab!

Seriously, you are doing exactly what Rand Paul was doing by mixing up Baric's GoF work in America (legal!) with the WIV work (legal as it wasn't GoF), and then saying it all proves Fauci, and Daszak and the WIV were all doing the illegal GoF.
 
What are the scenarios for lab virus to infect the surrounding area?

1) Loss of containment. Essentially high containment labs have a big fan that maintains a negative pressure to the outside.
This scenario and the others you mention all suppose that we are in fact dealing a high containment lab. But some of the criticism has been that very little work is made under BSL-4 conditions, and far more is made under BSL-2 conditions, comparable to what is used at your local dentist. Apparently, BSL-4 conditions are only used when a virus has been proven to be deadly, because it is much too impractical otherwise.
 
This scenario and the others you mention all suppose that we are in fact dealing a high containment lab. But some of the criticism has been that very little work is made under BSL-4 conditions, and far more is made under BSL-2 conditions, comparable to what is used at your local dentist. Apparently, BSL-4 conditions are only used when a virus has been proven to be deadly, because it is much too impractical otherwise.

I'm describing a BSL-3 lab where SARS-COV-2 should be handled. Some of the work could be done in BSL-2 for the pseudotyped virus work that was published. Do we know for sure that the wild type viruses were handled at the wrong containment level?
 
What are the scenarios for lab virus to infect the surrounding area?

1) Loss of containment. Essentially high containment labs have a big fan that maintains a negative pressure to the outside. The exhaust is sent through HEPA filters to remove any viruses. The air pressure is constantly monitored and an alarm will sound if it rises above a set limit. If the virus did get outside due to lack of negative air pressure then I can't see how it could infect anyone in the vicinity as the infectious titre would be greatly reduced by dispersion. The persons who might be infected are the lab workers and they were tested negative. Also, all work would be done in a safety cabinet that has its own negative pressure environment to protect the worker.

2) Lab worker gets infected and doesn't report the incident. Plausible but see above. The likely scenario is that a culture vessel is dropped outside of the safety cabinet whilst transporting to the incubator. This will generate aerosols that could be breathed in, although the air exchange in the lab is very high and aerosols are removed very quickly.

3) Someone at WIV could have got infected when unpacking samples that had been broken in transit. This would have been done inside the safety cabinet inside the containment lab. It's a major incident and would be reported immediately
This assumes that the WIV has SARS-COV-2 and is hiding the fact.

If this was a laboratory event, then I think 3 most likely. Someone outside of the lab could have sent a specimen inappropriately packed or labelled. I think a new clinical specimen or environmental specimen sent in with a novel virus is most likely scenario for a laboratory escape. A virus that had not been characterised or known to be high risk. Certainly not a virus from 2014. Most escapes are due to human error, people cutting corners. Whatever the miners had it was not SARS-CoV-2 nor a precursor.
 
SciTechDaily: Novel Coronavirus Circulated Undetected for Months Before First COVID-19 Cases Discovered in Wuhan, China

And as for your continued erroneous claim the first cases occurred at the seafood market: And despite multiple claims the WHO investigation found all the earliest cases connected to other wet markets in Wuhan, the only thing in the WHO report about that is speculation.

You are misrepresenting what the paper says.

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7709179/

They are saying that by Dec 7 there are already some cases that don't have an apparent connection to any of the markets. This means community spread had already started and that none of the cases identified in the market or elsewhere are the earliest cases to have occurred.

Their results show that the virus had likely crossed over sometime around Nov 1 and that there should be cases that pre-date the ones documented in Dec. They say nothing about where these cases occurred.
 

You are misrepresenting what the paper says.

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7709179/

They are saying that by Dec 7 there are already some cases that don't have an apparent connection to any of the markets. This means community spread had already started and that none of the cases identified in the market or elsewhere are the earliest cases to have occurred.

Their results show that the virus had likely crossed over sometime around Nov 1 and that there should be cases that pre-date the ones documented in Dec. They say nothing about where these cases occurred.


And as for your continued erroneous claim the first cases occurred at the seafood market: And despite multiple claims the WHO investigation found all the earliest cases connected to other wet markets in Wuhan, the only thing in the WHO report about that is speculation.

This is a lie. No one has claimed all the earliest known cases occurred at the markets. Again the virus had been spreading for 4-6 weeks by the time the earliest confirmed cases were documented. No one expects it to remain confined to it's place of origin this long after the fact.

It is, however, still expected that the most cases would occur within the same network of people where the crossover first occurred. This points to the market.

Something else that points to the market is the fact that 3 out of 4 infections would die out before causing a pandemic. If however you get repeated crossovers from infected animals infecting multiple people the chances of a pandemic become much higher.
 
Interesting that your source says it was circulating for “at most” two months. That negates the claim that the database was taken down in response to a lab leak.

No it doesn't. It's one estimate.

Here is an exact quote from the original paper you were referencing. Also worth noting is the explicit reference to a zoonotic event. The papers authors don't give even slightest consideration to any other origin even though you are offering their results as "evidence" for a lab leak.

Our results highlight the unpredictable dynamics that characterized the earliest days of the COVID-19 pandemic. The successful establishment of SARS-CoV-2 post-zoonosis was far from certain, as more than two-thirds of simulated epidemics quickly went extinct. It is highly probable that SARS-CoV-2 was circulating in Hubei province at low levels in early-November 2019 and possibly as early as mid-October 2019, but not earlier. Nonetheless, the inferred prevalence of this virus was too low to permit its discovery and characterization for weeks or months. By the time COVID-19 was first identified, the virus had firmly established itself in Wuhan. This delay highlights the difficulty in surveillance for novel zoonotic pathogens with high transmissibility and moderate mortality rates.
 
I just told you I don't know and that I think experts don't know.


The experts don't seriously debate this. One thing is commonplace in their field the other has no supporting evidence. Even the ones who say there should be more investigation of the lab say a lab leak is unlikely, and everyone else is simply forging ahead under the assumption it's zoonotic until there is evidence for some other origin.
 
The earliest cases have no connection to the seafood market.

One of the first 2 confirmed cases hadn't been to the market and hadn't been in contact with someone who had. They did however live in close proximity to it as you can see from the map of where the early cases occurred.

picture.php
 
What are the scenarios for lab virus to infect the surrounding area?

1) Loss of containment. Essentially high containment labs have a big fan that maintains a negative pressure to the outside. The exhaust is sent through HEPA filters to remove any viruses. The air pressure is constantly monitored and an alarm will sound if it rises above a set limit. If the virus did get outside due to lack of negative air pressure then I can't see how it could infect anyone in the vicinity as the infectious titre would be greatly reduced by dispersion. The persons who might be infected are the lab workers and they were tested negative. Also, all work would be done in a safety cabinet that has its own negative pressure environment to protect the worker.

2) Lab worker gets infected and doesn't report the incident. Plausible but see above. The likely scenario is that a culture vessel is dropped outside of the safety cabinet whilst transporting to the incubator. This will generate aerosols that could be breathed in, although the air exchange in the lab is very high and aerosols are removed very quickly.

3) Someone at WIV could have got infected when unpacking samples that had been broken in transit. This would have been done inside the safety cabinet inside the containment lab. It's a major incident and would be reported immediately

This assumes that the WIV has SARS-COV-2 and is hiding the fact.

Dr Shi has said that serology samples on WIV staff all came back negative. In typical CT fashion, those who believe there was a lab leak say we can't believe this because Dr Shi is covering up the leak.

This scenario and the others you mention all suppose that we are in fact dealing a high containment lab. But some of the criticism has been that very little work is made under BSL-4 conditions, and far more is made under BSL-2 conditions, comparable to what is used at your local dentist. Apparently, BSL-4 conditions are only used when a virus has been proven to be deadly, because it is much too impractical otherwise.

Most of the work the WIV does is with Corona viruses involves RNA samples collected from bat faeces. There are no live Corona viruses in such samples in such samples. They probably work with these under BSL-2 conditions because of the risk of fungal infections or viruses that could actually survive there.
 
The experts don't seriously debate this. One thing is commonplace in their field the other has no supporting evidence. Even the ones who say there should be more investigation of the lab say a lab leak is unlikely, and everyone else is simply forging ahead under the assumption it's zoonotic until there is evidence for some other origin.
You want to get this information to Biden? He's wasting the intelligence community's time if what you say is true.

Can you actually cite a source for your claim? People claiming to speak for the entire medical community haven't cited any sources as far as I know. I've looked for survey's of the medical community and haven't found any. The only claim of consensus I've seen that seems to carry any weight is the one Biden stated about the intelligence community two months ago yesterday.

And your first sentence is simply deranged. It is debated by experts. As I said before, this thread is dominated by arguments that are out of touch with reality. And I mean on all sides.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom