angrysoba
Philosophile
Going by the cited evidence, there are several sources in this thread with different 'earliest case' scenarios. You don't like the ones that don't confirm your bias, I don't care. It's not a stretch at all that whatever the event was, were it a lab accident it could have occurred before mid-Sept and still fit the genetic time clock.
I don't particularly care. I have seen numerous examples, and every one says it was after the databases were taken down.
I know full well that the first known case was not the first actual case.
The point I am making is judging by the first known case, we cannot know where the virus emerged.
What you think the first known case shows is that it rules out the market. It doesn't.
Why?
Well, obviously it doesn't rule out the market for exactly the same bloody obvious reason that the first known case doesn't rule ANYWHERE out. That goes for the market, that goes for the lab, that goes for outer space. Wherever!
It has been ruled out by multiple sources. Why do you insist it was the initiating location when the evidence of earlier cases exist?
No, it hasn't.
Please understand a very elementary point that I have been making over and over again.
I have NOT said the market is the origin!
I HAVE said, it cannot be ruled out.
You cannot have this both ways. You cannot say, "Ah! First known case (Dec 9th), no connection with the market therefore it categorically rules out the market. Now it is IMPOSSIBLE to come from the market!"
And also say:
"It's defo a lab leak!"
If you have evidence it was the location of the first cases, let's see it.
One more time:
We don't know where the first case was!
That should be bloody obvious. If we knew where the first case was it would tell us the origins. Hello!
In the meantime there are documented earlier cases not connected to any wet market.
Nobody disputes this!
Uhh, because Shi said so and the evidence suggests she is lying about that.
Again, we really don't know.