Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
Well, we have over a hundred years of virus research including really nasty viruses such as yellow fever, if you want to read a tragedy of viral research read the history of yellow fever, all I remember is that nearly all the researchers die of it. Yes, for all that time people were looking by definition for new viruses; there was a day when smallpox was the new virus on the block. During this time we have had new viral epidemics and pandemics. None of which were due to a laboratory leak, most of which were due to a a species shift. Flu pandemics, HIV, MERS, SARS, Ebola, West Nile, Zika et al.

ETA laboratory biosecurity was far worse in the past than it is now.

And this is relevant why?
 
That's crap. There is a lot of evidence. And no one is saying "scientists" are covering up. The Chinese government is and it is well documented. Shi might be but it's also likely she has been silenced by her government, something also well documented.

There is zero evidence for this and for the engineered virus origin. So there is a reason this is considered to be a low likelihood.

No one is talking about China keeping military secrets. You really need to read more about just what China is refusing to disclose. It isn't military secrets.

I don’t think Shi is silenced by her government. She is doing lectures and virtual conference talks.

She seems to have been pretty open in the past and has also says she would welcome the lab being investigated. She doesn’t get to call the shots though, I would presume.

However, you have accused her of lying because of what she was reported as saying in an article. I have already suggested that she may have used more qualifiers or talked more at length than she was reported as saying in the article. You cannot always accept a report of second hand words to be faithfully reported as you could end up with….*ahem* Chinese whispers.
 
Seriously? The seafood market was the location of a super-spreader event.

Anyone still claiming that was where or could have been where the first cases occurred isn't following the evidence both genetic and chronological. How can you still be repeating this?

I think I said this before, expose a lie, wait long enough and people will remember the lie, not the fact it was exposed as untrue.

This was an interesting study modeling the genetic clock of the virus.

SciTechDaily: Novel Coronavirus Circulated Undetected for Months Before First COVID-19 Cases Discovered in Wuhan, China

And as for your continued erroneous claim the first cases occurred at the seafood market: And despite multiple claims the WHO investigation found all the earliest cases connected to other wet markets in Wuhan, the only thing in the WHO report about that is speculation.

Interesting that your source says it was circulating for “at most” two months. That negates the claim that the database was taken down in response to a lab leak.
 
You seem to be missing the point.


Do you think Covid would refuse to escape from a lab just because it's a new virus? Is there some honor code among viruses I'm unaware of?


The point is that we know lab leaks can happen because they have happened. The fact that they haven't caused a pandemic yet is just luck.


How many labs in 1978 were even involved in going out and aggressively looking for new viruses?


Look at lomillers last post for an incredibly bad comparison:




That's an idiotic juxtaposition. Relevant labs have only existed for a matter of decades. "never" is not a relevant word yet. "never happened" doesn't carry any weight as an argument until we have a lot of experience doing this. It may never become meaningful if we keep expanding the laboratories and developing new techniques for searching for new viruses.

It still would leave us with the question of where the virus came from if you argue it escaped from a lab. If you do that, what is the most plausible scenario?
 
Well, we have over a hundred years of virus research including really nasty viruses such as yellow fever, if you want to read a tragedy of viral research read the history of yellow fever, all I remember is that nearly all the researchers die of it. Yes, for all that time people were looking by definition for new viruses; there was a day when smallpox was the new virus on the block. During this time we have had new viral epidemics and pandemics. None of which were due to a laboratory leak, most of which were due to a a species shift. Flu pandemics, HIV, MERS, SARS, Ebola, West Nile, Zika et al.

ETA laboratory biosecurity was far worse in the past than it is now.

As potholer54 points out there are places in China storing viruses without using any public databases, or filing system in which animals are infected all the time and there are no bio security protocols at all. It is called the countryside.
.
 
It still would leave us with the question of where the virus came from if you argue it escaped from a lab. If you do that, what is the most plausible scenario?
We don't want plausible, we want somebody to blame. In particular those elitist scientists who think they are so much smarter than us, and especially the Chinese. That way we can hide our own incompetence and stupidity in letting the virus run rampant.
 
It still would leave us with the question of where the virus came from if you argue it escaped from a lab. If you do that, what is the most plausible scenario?
I don't know. Do you? Multiple large institutions with far more knowledge of the subject than me don't seem to know.

BTW your question seems to have a grammatical problem. Hard to tell what the word "that" refers it. Grammatically your question seems to parse as "If you argue that it escaped from a lab, what is the most plausible scenario?". Is that what you meant?
 
Last edited:
This is the sort of response an eight year old would make. If you have nothing useful to say, say nothing. Now go and stand in the corner.
Same to you. Just because you are saying lots of words doesn't mean they're useful.


This just applies to our recent exchange, I have no idea what your general contributions are like.
 
I don't know. Do you? Multiple large institutions with far more knowledge of the subject than me don't seem to know.

BTW your question seems to have a grammatical problem. Hard to tell what the word "that" refers it. Grammatically your question seems to parse as "If you argue that it escaped from a lab, what is the most plausible scenario?". Is that what you meant?

Yeah, maybe an autocorrect issue. But if you argue it is from a lab, what is the most plausible scenario for the virus being there in the first place?
 
Interesting that your source says it was circulating for “at most” two months. That negates the claim that the database was taken down in response to a lab leak.

No it doesn't. It's one estimate.

We do know the first identified cases are not the first cases because there were already 2 lineages.

As for Shi, if you believe the Chinese government doesn't hold tight reins of what she can say about the lab, you have a poor understanding of Chinese censorship. Shi would have to be motivated to whistle blow on her own lab and or colleagues. Or if the leak occurred at the CCDC lab, Shi might not even be aware of the accident.

Have you found that evidence yet supporting Shi's claim the miners died of a fungal infection? It's incredibly suspicious as is the paper removed more recently that Bloom uncovered. He was only able to recover some of the genome data and the author who withdrew the paper hasn't answered Bloom's request for an explanation.


I think the next big revelation is going to be looking at the first cases in the US which were only recently found. Those involve a patient here and a patient there in multiple states. There were those military games in Wuhan that 9,000 people from all over the world attended in Oct. Tracking the earliest cases in Italy and in the US could shed some light there.
 
Last edited:
.... ETA laboratory biosecurity was far worse in the past than it is now.
Adding some additional notes to this, so it went from atrocious to just very bad?

People (not just you) have this idealistic belief that health care institutions run perfectly or nearly so, everyone taking proper infection control measures, labs with perfect or nearly perfect safety records.

It's simply not true. I have been fighting with employees over the last 30 years to take infection control more seriously. Reality is this doesn't happen. Why do you think nosocomial infections are so rampant? You would think we would know better, but we don't. It's all about what you pay attention to.

Take the nurse who gives excellent clinical care including acting to prevent nosocomial infections but when they get a needle stick, not only do they not know the procedure, neither does the nurse manager. I spent 6 months documenting all the errors causing and following up on needle sticks. I presented my findings to the nurses and nurse managers. Then I waited a month and collected the same data for the next 6 months. NOTHING CHANGED. This is where I learned from one of the nursing educators to look for something besides a knowledge deficit.

Look what happened when the nurse in TX contracted ebola. The large hospital in TX that should have been prepared to receive patients with exotic diseases was unprepared for the ebola patient. That was in 2014! You think hospitals are better prepared now?

Oct. 13, 2014 -- Nina Pham, a 26-year-old nurse at Texas Health Presbyterian Hospital, is the first person to catch Ebola in the U.S.
She wasn’t one of the 48 people who were already being watched because they had contact with Duncan while he was contagious. Her diagnosis has put the U.S. health care system on alert that better training and protective equipment might be needed before all hospitals can safely care for Ebola patients....

Health officials aren’t sure how Pham was exposed to the virus. On Sunday, Daniel Varga, MD, chief clinical officer at Texas Health Resources, said she was wearing a gown, gloves, mask, and face shield while she cared for Duncan at the hospital.

SARS spread in a Toronto, CA hospital because they hadn't yet figured out one could not reuse protective gowns.

SARS victims and heroes remembered
"In terms of containing the risks to those on the front lines of SARS, that was one of the key problems. And when I say the infrastructure, I mean from the top down. Decisions were not made in a timely manner and when they were made, they were not made (communicated) to the front lines."

There was that ED doctor in Hong Kong who treated SARS patients, developed a fever and still went on vacation to Disneyland Tokyo.

I have so many horror stories people who don't work with compliance would be shocked. How does the biolab at UNC keep losing their research mice? That's nuts! And that F&M lab leak in the UK, the organisms were discharged in the waste effluent, picked up on car tires and spread from there.

We just are not the perfect little compliant health care workers and researchers people imagine us to be.

And in this thread specific problems at the WIV are well documented.
 
We don't want plausible, we want somebody to blame. In particular those elitist scientists who think they are so much smarter than us, and especially the Chinese. That way we can hide our own incompetence and stupidity in letting the virus run rampant.

I don't find this very credible. An accident happens with disastrous consequences. The Chinese government has every reason to cover that up.

On a separate note, Fauci argues with Rand Paul over whether or not the US funded Gof research at the WIV in 2014. Fauci quibbles over semantics. Paul shows his true motive was to claim the US funded the research which might have resulted in COVID. That's pure bull **** and Fauci was right to stop Paul peddling his political crap.


Some people might be looking for someone to blame. The rest of us want to know what happened so we can prevent the next disaster.
 
Last edited:
Seriously? The seafood market was the location of a super-spreader event.

Anyone still claiming that was where or could have been where the first cases occurred isn't following the evidence both genetic and chronological. How can you still be repeating this?

I think I said this before, expose a lie, wait long enough and people will remember the lie, not the fact it was exposed as untrue.

This was an interesting study modeling the genetic clock of the virus.

SciTechDaily: Novel Coronavirus Circulated Undetected for Months Before First COVID-19 Cases Discovered in Wuhan, China

Using molecular dating tools and epidemiological simulations, researchers at University of California San Diego School of Medicine, with colleagues at the University of Arizona and Illumina, Inc., estimate that the SARS-CoV-2 virus was likely circulating undetected for at most two months before the first human cases of COVID-19 were described in Wuhan, China in late-December 2019.

And as for your continued erroneous claim the first cases occurred at the seafood market: And despite multiple claims the WHO investigation found all the earliest cases connected to other wet markets in Wuhan, the only thing in the WHO report about that is speculation.

Interesting that your source says it was circulating for “at most” two months. That negates the claim that the database was taken down in response to a lab leak.

No it doesn't. It's one estimate.

Do you trust the estimate? If not, then why cite a source as though it definitely proves something?

Ah, but you want to cherry pick information from it saying one part is true and another part is not.

And for the record, it is not a "lie" to suggest the Huanan Market may have had a role in the origins of the virus. Sure, it may have also been a superspreader location, but it doesn't mean it didn't start there.

Pointing out what everybody knows about the first known case (Dec 9th) leaves out the fact that there were probably other cases before that.

We can't rule out the Huanan wet market using that first case unless you are also happy to rule out the WIV if that first case has no connection to the WIV.

Do you really not understand this?



Have you found that evidence yet supporting Shi's claim the miners died of a fungal infection?

Of course not! I am not looking for evidence of a fungal infection. Why should I?

I have already said pretty much all I can on that which is that we don't know what killed the miners.
 
Do you trust the estimate? If not, then why cite a source as though it definitely proves something?

Ah, but you want to cherry pick information from it saying one part is true and another part is not.
Going by the cited evidence, there are several sources in this thread with different 'earliest case' scenarios. You don't like the ones that don't confirm your bias, I don't care. It's not a stretch at all that whatever the event was, were it a lab accident it could have occurred before mid-Sept and still fit the genetic time clock.

And for the record, it is not a "lie" to suggest the Huanan Market may have had a role in the origins of the virus. Sure, it may have also been a superspreader location, but it doesn't mean it didn't start there.
It has been ruled out by multiple sources. Why do you insist it was the initiating location when the evidence of earlier cases exist?

Pointing out what everybody knows about the first known case (Dec 9th) leaves out the fact that there were probably other cases before that.

We can't rule out the Huanan wet market using that first case unless you are also happy to rule out the WIV if that first case has no connection to the WIV.

[snipped snarky insult that has no place in this discussion]
If you have evidence it was the location of the first cases, let's see it. In the meantime there are documented earlier cases not connected to any wet market.

Of course not! I am not looking for evidence of a fungal infection. Why should I?.
Uhh, because Shi said so and the evidence suggests she is lying about that.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom