Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
Apart from the fact that every other epidemic infection from plague to smallpox including HIV and TB, SARS and MERS has originated from a cross over from an animal source to humans. None of these were due to an escape from a laboratory.
Uh, yeah. Half of those are from times before labs even existed.

There have been lab leaks. The fact that none have lead to pandemics is basically a matter of luck.

Note that you mentioned smallpox. The last known death from small pox was most likely a lab leak. Note the article also cites a suspicious case in the same area prior to that.
 
Last edited:
Apart from the fact that every other epidemic infection from plague to smallpox including HIV and TB, SARS and MERS has originated from a cross over from an animal source to humans. None of these were due to an escape from a laboratory. So you are presenting a whole new level of exceptionalism that this one virus epidemic event cannot be a natural crossover. (I do recall allegations that HIV was created in a laboratory, but I don't think anyone still believes that).
The default has to be natural like every other event, the burden of proof is on the laboratory source.
:rolleyes:

Yeah if you don't look at all at lab accidents, no wonder it looks like only natural events have ever occurred.

Several well documented cases of smallpox and SARS infecting people after lab accidents have occurred. It's just that when they happened people actually looked at the lab sources and didn't try to cover them up. Suppose in those cases the infected individuals weren't detected right away. There would have been at a minimum several serious outbreaks.

There is no "exceptionalism" here, not even close. I have posted at least 2 links in this thread detailing extensively, not just past lab leak incidents but specifically detailing how the WIV did not have the safety record of the pretend meticulous fantasy researchers.


As for which side has a burden of proof, that's just stupid, both arguments have the same burden. Pretty much people not wedded to the natural spillover agree both origins need to be investigated. There is no default 'burden of proof' of a lab leak here except by people who cannot prove the natural origin so they fall back on that one and only argument.


Throwing out ridiculous straw men CTs like you did there with HIV are not supporting your case, BTW. And TB, OMG, MT has very ancient origins: it has survived over 70,000 years. What animal spillover incident do you believe resulted in TB entering the human population?

Once again no attempt is being made to actually present evidence of this natural spillover event. Maybe that's why there is so much evidence in this thread supporting the lab accident compared to that supporting a natural event.
 
Uh, yeah. Half of those are from times before labs even existed.....
That's right. I already noted TB is an ancient human pathogen. And no legit researchers ever said we should investigate HIV as an accident during vaccine manufacture.

It's been so long ago the details of the HIV CT escape me. But I do recall there was a long video cassette like the Loose Change CT video re 911 about how the virus supposedly was created using cows to produce vaccines. That had to be the mid 1980s. I watched it out of curiosity and because I had a particular interest in HIV. I had friends dying from it.
 
Apart from the fact that every other epidemic infection from plague to smallpox including HIV and TB, SARS and MERS has originated from a cross over from an animal source to humans. None of these were due to an escape from a laboratory. So you are presenting a whole new level of exceptionalism that this one virus epidemic event cannot be a natural crossover. (I do recall allegations that HIV was created in a laboratory, but I don't think anyone still believes that).
The default has to be natural like every other event, the burden of proof is on the laboratory source.
Remember Rolfe pointed out, and I need to check, that the foot and mouth epidemic around 2000 came from a lab.
 
Remember Rolfe pointed out, and I need to check, that the foot and mouth epidemic around 2000 came from a lab.

From the Guardian last Feb
It was immediately clear the disease had already spread across the country with most evidence indicating that infected animal products had been imported from the far east and had been used as animal feed on pig farms, passing on the virus.
 
But to summarize lab spillover events and a source that does cite a F&M escape from a UK lab:

THE DISTURBING HISTORY OF VIRUSES ESCAPING FROM RESEARCH LABS

Headlines in the article:
THE 1977 INFLUENZA PANDEMIC MAY HAVE STARTED IN A LAB

SMALLPOX ESCAPED FROM BRITISH LABS 3 TIMES

A 1995 ENCEPHALITIS OUTBREAK MAY HAVE COME FROM A LAB

SARS HAS ESCAPED SIX DIFFERENT TIMES IN THREE COUNTRIES

A U.K. LAB RELEASED FOOT AND MOUTH DISEASE

A NEW YORK RESEARCH LAB HAD SEVERAL ACCIDENT

FOUR LAB WORKERS IN VIRGINIA CONTRACTED EBOLA

A SECRET SOVIET FACILITY RELEASED ANTHRAX ON ACCIDENT

THERE WERE THREE ACCIDENTS WITH TWO DEADLY VIRUSES IN ONE RUSSIAN LAB

UNIVERSITY OF NORTH CAROLINA KEEPS LOSING INFECTED TEST MICE

OVER 6,000 PEOPLE GOT SICK IN CHINA FROM A LAB RELEASE [Brucellosis]

A DANGEROUS BACTERIA ESCAPES FROM A LOUISIANA LAB [Burkholderia pseudomallei]

Re F&M in the UK
After six dormant years, FMD appeared some two miles from the*Institute for Animal Health in Pirbright. An investigation ordered by the House of Commons revealed "that*the virus had most likely leaked out from drainage pipework at the Pirbright facility, contaminating the surrounding soil and then was carried from the Pirbright site by vehicles." The Pirbright lab is a*Bio Safety Level 4 lab, the highest level, and mud on a car driving through it caused a panic that saw hundreds of animals put down and the British beef industry suffered a major loss.
So a separate incident? It's confusing because they seem to be equating it to hand foot and mouth which is a mild virus kids get. Those are 2 different pathogens. And they are talking about 2 different incidents because the main epidemic more than a million animals were culled and in this one they mention "hundreds".

It needs more investigating. I also see they left a few off. The US has lost track of anthrax specimens more than once and they didn't mention the near miss of the Reston Virginia incident.

Note the UNC is where coronavirus GoF work was being done by Baric et al.
 
Last edited:
Throughout this thread I've noted any number of circumstances enumerated which suggest a lab leak of some sort - no doubt SG could give chapter and verse - but if there was no connection to the lab all those circumstances would have to be pure coincidence. Sure, coincidences happen, but the sheer number suggests otherwise.
 
Apart from the fact that every other epidemic infection from plague to smallpox including HIV and TB, SARS and MERS has originated from a cross over from an animal source to humans. None of these were due to an escape from a laboratory. So you are presenting a whole new level of exceptionalism that this one virus epidemic event cannot be a natural crossover. (I do recall allegations that HIV was created in a laboratory, but I don't think anyone still believes that).
The default has to be natural like every other event, the burden of proof is on the laboratory source.

Look into any well publicized epidemic\pandemic in the last 50 years and you will likely find people who claim it came from a lab. Eg:

Zika 2018

https://www.newyorker.com/news/daily-comment/the-dangerous-conspiracy-theories-about-the-zika-virus

At least one Zika conspiracy, by far the most damaging, may be hard to ignore. More than a third of the Americans surveyed in a poll, out this week, from the University of Pennsylvania’s Annenberg Public Policy Center believe that genetically modified mosquitoes caused the spread of Zika. This is a particularly dangerous misapprehension, because, for now, controlling mosquitoes may be the only way we can hope to control Zika.

Ebola 2014
https://www.nytimes.com/2014/10/19/sunday-review/the-ebola-conspiracy-theories.html

THE spread of Ebola from western Africa to suburban Texas has brought with it another strain of contagion: conspiracy theories.

The outbreak began in September, when The Daily Observer, a Liberian newspaper, published an article alleging that the virus was not what it seemed — a medical disaster — but rather a bioweapon designed by the United States military to depopulate the planet. Not long after, accusations appeared online contending that the federal Centers for Disease Control and Prevention had patented the virus and was poised to make a fortune from a new vaccine it had created with the pharmaceutical industry.

H1N1 2009
https://www.globaldashboard.org/2009/04/26/swine-flu-cooked-up-in-a-lab/

From 9/11 truther mission control, Infowars, comes stunning news: “deadly swine flu… was cooked up in a lab.”

Yes – the first swine flu conspiracy theories are hitting the Internets, providing a rare opportunity to view these numb skull paranoids as they struggle to assemble a few fragments of information into a suitably cunning plot.

SARS 2004

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SARS_conspiracy_theory
The widespread reporting of claims by Kolesnokov and Filatov caused controversy in many Chinese internet discussion boards and chat rooms. Many Chinese believed that the SARS virus could be a biological weapon manufactured by the United States, which perceived China as a potential threat.[9] The failure to find the source of the SARS virus further convinced these people and many more that SARS was artificially synthesised and spread by some individuals and even governments.

The irony of this one is that this was predominantly a Chinese CT. The final nail in the coffin of this CT came when Shi Zhengli identified the original animal source. This time around Shi is vilified in an American CT as being a Chinese pawn (or mastermind depending on the day) covering up the lab origins of SARS-CoV-2
 
Look into any well publicized epidemic\pandemic in the last 50 years and you will likely find people who claim it came from a lab. Eg:
Zika 2018
https://www.newyorker.com/news/daily-comment/the-dangerous-conspiracy-theories-about-the-zika-virus
Ebola 2014
https://www.nytimes.com/2014/10/19/sunday-review/the-ebola-conspiracy-theories.html
H1N1 2009
https://www.globaldashboard.org/2009/04/26/swine-flu-cooked-up-in-a-lab/
SARS 2004
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SARS_conspiracy_theory

The irony of this one is that this was predominantly a Chinese CT. The final nail in the coffin of this CT came when Shi Zhengli identified the original animal source. This time around Shi is vilified in an American CT as being a Chinese pawn (or mastermind depending on the day) covering up the lab origins of SARS-CoV-2
You know you are using the most basic faulty logic here, right? Because there have been past CTs about those evil science labs that is somehow an argument all lab spillovers are CT claims. :rolleyes:

This differs from examples of natural spillover and examples of lab accidents as they go directly to credulity. I suppose the difference is hard to understand.


The current general consensus is both origins—the lab and natural—are possible. Neither has been ruled in or out. In the meantime, China refuses to cooperate in the investigation.

With call for ‘raw data’ and lab audits, WHO chief pressures China on pandemic origin probe
At a press conference on 15 July and in a statement made yesterday at an information session on the pandemic’s origin, Tedros called for more aggressively probing the two leading theories of how SARS-CoV-2 first infected humans and then emerged in Wuhan, China, in December 2019: that the virus made a natural “zoonotic” jump from an unknown animal species into humans or, more controversially, that it first infected a human during laboratory or field studies of coronaviruses found in animals. ...

Researchers who have been critical of WHO’s handling of the origin issue welcome Tedros’s tougher tone. “It’s a sign that the WHO might be able to do more credible or balanced investigation,” says Alina Chan, a gene therapy researcher at the Broad Institute, who with 17 other scientists co-authored a 14 May letter in Science that argued the lab theory deserves a more balanced assessment. But Chan doubts China will agree to audits of its labs. “Right now, the lack of clarity is in China’s interest,” she says.

Another author of the Science letter, microbiome researcher David Relman of Stanford University, wished Tedros had owned up to past WHO “missteps.” “I don’t think he can simply just take the next step and not worry about what’s happened so far.”...
 
Last edited:
Moving on..

Part of this made sense and I accept the premise which has been discussed here, but there is one glaring error in logic I had been meaning to address and here is an opportunity to point it out.

Wuhan Lab-Leak Theory: “Rare” Genetic Sequence Doesn’t Mean the COVID Virus Was Engineered
An important way scientists can determine the origin of a virus is by looking at its genome. In the WSJ article, the authors, Prof Richard Muller, an astrophysicist, and Dr Steven Quay, physician and chief executive of Atossa Therapeutics, claim Sars-CoV-2 has “genetic fingerprints” of a lab-origin virus. They say that the presence of a particular genetic sequence (CGG-CGG) is a sign that the virus originated in a lab....

The authors of the WSJ article argue that Sars-CoV-2 originated in a lab based on the presence of a “CGG-CGG” sequence. They claim this is a “readily available and convenient” codon pair that scientists prefer to use to produce the amino acid arginine. But to anyone with an understanding of the techniques required for genetic modification, this double-CGG is usually no more difficult or easy to produce than any other pair of codons that encode arginines. ...

... The authors of the WSJ article argue that Sars-CoV-2 originated in a lab based on the presence of a “CGG-CGG” sequence. They claim this is a “readily available and convenient” codon pair that scientists prefer to use to produce the amino acid arginine. But to anyone with an understanding of the techniques required for genetic modification, this double-CGG is usually no more difficult or easy to produce than any other pair of codons that encode arginines....
I can agree with that. Not to mention in my assessment the codon issue would have meant 'engineered' and I don't think that is the most likely scenario unless one wants to consider selection for certain properties out of naturally diverging strains. IOW 'breeding' (perhaps there is a better word) for gain of function rather than 'engineering' for GoF.

Engineering would mean one is simply looking for what genetic changes need to happen in the wild. Breeding would be showing how that could occur as well.

But this is nonsense:
The final claim that the first sequenced Sars-CoV-2 virus was ideally suited to the human host neglects evidence of viral circulation in local animal populations, animal-to-animal transmission, and the rapid evolution that is driving the increasing transmissibility of the newer variants. If the virus was ideally adapted to humans, why is so much further evolution evident?
Because the virus was adapted to humans in the earliest cases in no way means there would therefore be no room for improvement.

And they were doing so well noting the codons were not impossible in nature. :(
 
Last edited:
I looked a little deeper into the "ground glass" appearance on the chest radiology exams of the miners. While it is a non-specific finding there are certain conditions that are specifically included.

Radiopaedia: Ground-glass opacification
Broadly speaking, the differential for ground-glass opacification can be split into:
infectious processes (opportunistic vs non-opportunistic)
chronic interstitial diseases
acute alveolar diseases
other causes​
We are of course concerned with infectious processes.

Non-opportunistic
viral pneumonia
human coronaviruses
COVID-19
Middle East respiratory syndrome coronavirus (MERS-CoV) infection
severe acute respiratory syndrome (SARS)​
herpesviridae​

Rare causes
....
aspergillosis: a nodule with surrounding ground-glass opacity (CT halo sign) is rare except in severely immunocompromised patients
....
pulmonary cryptococcus infection: solitary or multiple pulmonary nodules with or without peripheral GGO​

Nothing about histoplasmosis but that is no surprise. Nothing about any infectious bacterial pathogens. Under opportunistic infections fungal infections are not on the list. But with opportunistic infections one would not expect to see a cluster of 6 people.
 
You know you are using the most basic faulty logic here, right? Because there have been past CTs about those evil science labs that is somehow an argument all lab spillovers are CT claims.
Zoonotic crossover has been occurring for hundreds of millions of year, possibly even billion of years. It’s well known well understood and has been a factor in every known pandemic. A pandemic started by a lab leak has never happened, but nonetheless conspiracy theories about laboratory involvement arise every time a pandemic occurs.

Such theories are the very definition of an extraordinary claim. It’s not that they can’t happen, but if you are going to suggest it you need to bring forward extraordinary evidence. Not only do you not have extraordinary evidence you don’t even have ordinary evidence.

You are blaming this lack of evidence on a conspiracy of scientists to cover that evidence up. Maybe this time the conspiracy is real, but again you have no evidence (because the conspiracy is covering it up). There is good reason why such theories are derided and discredited. One of these days one of these conspiracies will turn out to be real but don’t hold your breath.

The current general consensus is both origins—the lab and natural—are possible. Neither has been ruled in or out. In the meantime, China refuses to cooperate in the investigation.
The cold food chain wasn’t ruled out either and is given similarly very low likelihood of having actually happened.


No investigation will ever satisfy the people who have become emotionally invested in this theory. Regardless, the fact is that some parts of the Wuhan lab will forever be off limits, just as the US military lab at Ft Detrick will forever be off limits to investigators.

Something I find notable is that the people insisting on “turning over every stone” have no interest in further investigating cold food chain or the possibility of a lab leak at Ft Detrick carried to Wuhan for the military games. Personally I couldn’t care less if these never receive the type of investigation being called for wrt the Wuhan lab because the likelihood of their being involved is almost nil but I do note the inconsistency in calls for “more investigation”. (remember Wuhan lab leak is comparable in likelihood to cold food chain)
 
Uh, yeah. Half of those are from times before labs even existed.

There have been lab leaks. The fact that none have lead to pandemics is basically a matter of luck.

Note that you mentioned smallpox. The last known death from small pox was most likely a lab leak. Note the article also cites a suspicious case in the same area prior to that.

Sorry my post was ambiguous. I meant new epidemic, like Covid-19. Not new outbreaks of a known infection. I am familiar with the Birmingham Smallpox outbreak (not an epidemic), the Pirbright foot and mouth leak (not an epidemic, an epizootic).
 
Throughout this thread I've noted any number of circumstances enumerated which suggest a lab leak of some sort - no doubt SG could give chapter and verse - but if there was no connection to the lab all those circumstances would have to be pure coincidence. Sure, coincidences happen, but the sheer number suggests otherwise.

I guess you will also have to weigh it against the coincidence that two-thirds of the early cases of Covid-19 were found to have links to the Huanan wet market, that a number of environmental samples from the wet market also showed evidence of SARS-CoV2 and that many of those were taken from drains near where wild animals were kept and slaughtered, and that this paralleled the way in which the first SARS spilled over to humans.
 
Sorry my post was ambiguous. I meant new epidemic, like Covid-19. Not new outbreaks of a known infection. I am familiar with the Birmingham Smallpox outbreak (not an epidemic), the Pirbright foot and mouth leak (not an epidemic, an epizootic).
You seem to be missing the point.


Do you think Covid would refuse to escape from a lab just because it's a new virus? Is there some honor code among viruses I'm unaware of?


The point is that we know lab leaks can happen because they have happened. The fact that they haven't caused a pandemic yet is just luck.


How many labs in 1978 were even involved in going out and aggressively looking for new viruses?


Look at lomillers last post for an incredibly bad comparison:



Zoonotic crossover has been occurring for hundreds of millions of year, possibly even billion of years. It’s well known well understood and has been a factor in every known pandemic. A pandemic started by a lab leak has never happened, but nonetheless conspiracy theories about laboratory involvement arise every time a pandemic occurs.
That's an idiotic juxtaposition. Relevant labs have only existed for a matter of decades. "never" is not a relevant word yet. "never happened" doesn't carry any weight as an argument until we have a lot of experience doing this. It may never become meaningful if we keep expanding the laboratories and developing new techniques for searching for new viruses.
 
...
You are blaming this lack of evidence on a conspiracy of scientists to cover that evidence up.
That's crap. There is a lot of evidence. And no one is saying "scientists" are covering up. The Chinese government is and it is well documented. Shi might be but it's also likely she has been silenced by her government, something also well documented.

The cold food chain wasn’t ruled out either and is given similarly very low likelihood of having actually happened,
There is zero evidence for this and for the engineered virus origin. So there is a reason this is considered to be a low likelihood.

No investigation will ever satisfy the people who have become emotionally invested in this theory. Regardless, the fact is that some parts of the Wuhan lab will forever be off limits, just as the US military lab at Ft Detrick will forever be off limits to investigators.
No one is talking about China keeping military secrets. You really need to read more about just what China is refusing to disclose. It isn't military secrets.

[snipped the rest.]
 
Sorry my post was ambiguous. I meant new epidemic, like Covid-19. Not new outbreaks of a known infection. I am familiar with the Birmingham Smallpox outbreak (not an epidemic), the Pirbright foot and mouth leak (not an epidemic, an epizootic).

I'm pretty sure no one here thought F&M was a human disease.

As for a 'known' vs a 'previously unknown' pathogen, that's an arbitrary distinction that allows you and others to dismiss the lab accident history trying to prove only natural spillovers have occurred.
 
You seem to be missing the point.


Do you think Covid would refuse to escape from a lab just because it's a new virus? Is there some honor code among viruses I'm unaware of?


The point is that we know lab leaks can happen because they have happened. The fact that they haven't caused a pandemic yet is just luck.


How many labs in 1978 were even involved in going out and aggressively looking for new viruses?


Look at lomillers last post for an incredibly bad comparison:




That's an idiotic juxtaposition. Relevant labs have only existed for a matter of decades. "never" is not a relevant word yet. "never happened" doesn't carry any weight as an argument until we have a lot of experience doing this. It may never become meaningful if we keep expanding the laboratories and developing new techniques for searching for new viruses.

Well, we have over a hundred years of virus research including really nasty viruses such as yellow fever, if you want to read a tragedy of viral research read the history of yellow fever, all I remember is that nearly all the researchers die of it. Yes, for all that time people were looking by definition for new viruses; there was a day when smallpox was the new virus on the block. During this time we have had new viral epidemics and pandemics. None of which were due to a laboratory leak, most of which were due to a a species shift. Flu pandemics, HIV, MERS, SARS, Ebola, West Nile, Zika et al.

ETA laboratory biosecurity was far worse in the past than it is now.
 
Last edited:
I guess you will also have to weigh it against the coincidence that two-thirds of the early cases of Covid-19 were found to have links to the Huanan wet market, that a number of environmental samples from the wet market also showed evidence of SARS-CoV2 and that many of those were taken from drains near where wild animals were kept and slaughtered, and that this paralleled the way in which the first SARS spilled over to humans.
Seriously? The seafood market was the location of a super-spreader event.

Anyone still claiming that was where or could have been where the first cases occurred isn't following the evidence both genetic and chronological. How can you still be repeating this?

I think I said this before, expose a lie, wait long enough and people will remember the lie, not the fact it was exposed as untrue.

This was an interesting study modeling the genetic clock of the virus.

SciTechDaily: Novel Coronavirus Circulated Undetected for Months Before First COVID-19 Cases Discovered in Wuhan, China
Using molecular dating tools and epidemiological simulations, researchers at University of California San Diego School of Medicine, with colleagues at the University of Arizona and Illumina, Inc., estimate that the SARS-CoV-2 virus was likely circulating undetected for at most two months before the first human cases of COVID-19 were described in Wuhan, China in late-December 2019.

Writing in the March 18, 2021, online issue of Science, they also note that their simulations suggest that the mutating virus dies out naturally more than three-quarters of the time without causing an epidemic....

“To answer this question, we combined three important pieces of information: a detailed understanding of how SARS-CoV-2 spread in Wuhan before the lockdown, the genetic diversity of the virus in China, and reports of the earliest cases of COVID-19 in China. By combining these disparate lines of evidence, we were able to put an upper limit of mid-October 2019 for when SARS-CoV-2 started circulating in Hubei province.”

And as for your continued erroneous claim the first cases occurred at the seafood market:
The first cluster of cases — and the earliest sequenced SARS-CoV-2 genomes — were associated with the Huanan Seafood Wholesale Market, but study authors say the market cluster is unlikely to have marked the beginning of the pandemic because the earliest documented COVID-19 cases had no connection to the market.
And despite multiple claims the WHO investigation found all the earliest cases connected to other wet markets in Wuhan, the only thing in the WHO report about that is speculation.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom