Whether the patients had SARS or not is irrelevant. SARS is not a predecessor to SARS-CoV-2. They did not isolate SARS virus despite having sent material for PCR testing. The description could fit many pneumonias including SARS but not SARS-CoV-2 which has distinct features.
No one is saying the miners had SARS or that SARS is a precursor to COVID.

For whatever reason you are not following the issues here. The men had diagnosis of a viral pneumonia of unknown etiology.
First and foremost, this is not PROOF. Why do you think I am saying it is?
Neither is there proof of the natural spillover. In fact there is much less evidence supporting a natural event. It mostly consists of claiming it is more likely and the claim in the WHO report that the early patients had some contact with some nearby wet market even though no such contact has been pinned down and no other wet markets in the area have been shown to have any evidence of COVID 19. That hasn't stopped multiple sources claiming in fact that the WHO report supports multiple wet market exposures in all the early cases.
See for yourself:
WHO-convened Global Study of Origins of SARS-CoV-2: China Part Joint WHO-China Study 14 January-10 February 2021 Joint Report
THE MINERS DID NOT HAVE A PRIMARY FUNGAL DISEASE. Support your diagnosis, don't just keep claiming it could have been. The doctors in China at a large teaching hospital 10 years ago were not practicing backward medicine.
The men worked in a mine with bats that carried a number of SL CoV (SARS Like coronavirus) strains.
The medical record of the 6 cases is reported in detail in the master's thesis including corroborating consults that were made at the time the miners were in the hospital.
Are there other possibilities? Obviously.
What is the point of going on and on trying to dismiss the evidence when no one has said here's the proof? Look at the evidence for what it is: suspicious for multiple reasons.
You can argue they
could have had an infection from aliens, that doesn't change the facts. The WIV was notified. The WIV collected samples multiple times from the mine. Serum specimens were sent to the WIV and elsewhere.
And for some reason as yet to be made clear Shi claimed the miners never had an SL CoV but rather had a primary fungal infection. There is nothing prior to the current pandemic that supports her claim.
It should have been big news: 'False alarm, SARS did not emerge a second time, patients had a fungal disease'. Where is anything prior to the pandemic with that kind of report?
Think about it, this is Shi's main work—finding the source of SARS. They were concerned enough the went collecting more specimens from the mine.
If anyone has an explanation that is more than 'it could have been something else' let's hear it. We have the patients' medical records and the thinking at the time this could be a new SL CoV.
Is it proof? Let me say it again: of course not! That seems to be one of the problems in this discussion, poking holes in some claim of having proof that was never made.
We do know the infection the miners had did not pass to other people. That is typical of a new spillover event. You would think a new spillover event would support the natural origin of COVID.
You would think Shi could discuss in detail why this wasn't a spillover event and what evidence supported that. Nope, we have crickets.
Eight years later a SARS-like CoV begins spreading person to person with no evidence of a natural source. China clamps down on research, especially any examination of data that would be useful to sort out the origin, natural or otherwise. Shi claims without presenting supporting evidence that the miners had a fungal disease.
The clampdown was long before Dump politicized the origin.
Daszak is accused by many researchers of having a conflict of interest yet he was part of the WHO investigation. And he's accused of steering the investigation away from a lab origin including planting the seeds such an hypothesis was a CT.
Want to see the supporting documents for that again?
Plan said:
Interestingly despite the concern of invasive aspergillosis, Aspergillus antigen test (galactomannan) was not reported as being done on blood or bronchial samples, nor was Aspergillum serology reported, nor was Aspergillus PCR reported. This was either a patient that was inadequately investigated or the report is inadequate.
So? The patient records are what they are. If you want to imagine the doctors in China were incompetent, that doesn't change the records we have.
What if the miners really had a space virus? How do you know they didn't?
The diagnosis was not histoplasmosis or any other acute primary fungal infection. And
you've not presented what in those medical records supports a primary fungal diagnosis. You have Shi's claim and nothing else short of calling the physicians incompetent.
Plan said:
Case 5 note the steroids were started after the deterioration, so you cannot say that the aspergillus / histoplasmosis (if any) was a reactivation caused by immunosuppression with prednisolone. It was treated with prednisolone. Which makes me wonder if they thought about cryptogenic organising pneumonia, or an inhalation pneumonia such as hypersensitivity pneumonitis, which is why one would give steroids to someone with a deteriorating pneumonia despite antibiotics. The steroid doses were not high, similar or lower to what you would use to treat and asthma or COPD exacerbation. Not the doses we would normally expect to cause a reactivation of histoplasmosis, and the steroids have to be given fairly longterm for reactivation to occur not a reducing doses over a few days.
Aspergillus is an organism patients in critical care get. It is listed as such in the patients' records.
People with chronic histoplasmosis can suffer disseminated disease or even an exacerbation when they are immunosuppressed. If it was an acute primary diagnosis it would have meant case 5 had something different than the other 5 patients. And for whatever reason said primary fungal disease got better despite getting steroids.
And it's bull **** that a chronic case of histo couldn't be exacerbated with the treatment and illness case 5 suffered.
Those
are the meds he was given in the hospital. The translation "after hospitalization" means after admission. Only the last 2 were discharge meds. I had to re-look at those today myself. It was getting late when I posted that. It should have been obvious IV drips and injections were not discharge meds. I missed that too.
First day of hospitalization: 2012/5/2; Day of Discharge: 2012/5/28, total of 26 days
So he was in the hospital 26 days, where he got a rapid steroid induction followed by a taper; 30mg of prednisone is a moderate dose, not a low dose.
Plan said:
Poor assumption, whether yours or the author of the thesis, people do get better by themselves, as you reference most people with histoplasmosis have a mild self limiting illness. That he got better without anti fungal treatment does not exclude a fungal infection.
Oh for pity's sake, give it up. Of course people get better on their own. Who said they don't?
The doctors in China at a large teaching hospital 10 years ago were not practicing in the dark.
To summarize for people who don't read long posts:
No one is claiming this is proof, neither origin has been proven. It is a piece of evidence among many other pieces of evidence.
Because something "could have been" is not evidence of what the men had.
Nothing backs up Shi's fatal fungus claim.
China clamped down on any information that might have a bearing on the origin.
Daszak with a serious conflict of interest tried to inject the assertion the lab leak was a CT. It was successful at first but no longer is.