Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
It has already been noted that it was unlikely all 6 of these miners had past SARS infections.

100% of the miners had severe pneumonia and we have their chest x-rays and CT chest scans.

Claiming those serologies were reactions to past coronaviruses unrelated to SARS is a very hard argument to make.


Seasonal Coronaviruses that cause the common cold could have been positive by the IgG assay.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Histoplasmosis does not occur as a secondary infection following viral infections.

Could you perhaps expand on your assertion that the CXR and CT scans look nothing like histoplasmosis?
I believe it was discussed as a radiologic finding that they might have had past TB.. Some histo and some old TB cases have similar cavitary nodules on their chest x-rays.

American Thoracic Society Histoplasmosis
However, most healthy people exposed to this fungus recover from the infection with minimal or no symptoms. Even if you do not have symptoms, you may be left with small spots (scars) on your lungs. ...

If you smoke cigarettes and have emphysema, you are at risk for developing a
form of histoplasmosis that can look like tuberculosis. This type of histoplasmosis (called chronic or cavitary histoplasmosis), is often difficult to treat.

A chest X-ray (CXR) may show that you have an infection, but histoplasmosis can look like many other conditions such as pneumonia, lung cancer or tuberculosis.
There was one miner who had nodules on a chest x-ray described as 'walnuts'. Near the end of his disease he was given an anti-fungal and got better. But another miner who was given no anti-fungals also recovered and was discharged.


As for a secondary infection, one can get disseminated histoplasmosis when one's immune system is deficient. A person with chronic low-grade histo could most certainly have an opportunistic exacerbation.
People who are at the highest risk for developing severe forms of histoplasmosis (disseminated histoplasmosis) are infants and those with poor immunity (such as if you have HIV, have received an organ transplant, or if you take medications like steroids or TNF inhibitors used for rheumatologic conditions).
That is some heavy duty immunosuppression there.

These guys were very ill and they were given steroids so if one is going to claim all 6 got life-threatening histoplasmosis before they were seen in the hospital it makes no ******* sense unless one is trying very hard to dismiss the evidence.

It's very clear in the patient work-ups described in the master's thesis that a primary fungal infection of any kind was not something they concluded the patients had. It's also very clear one does not see 6 people in a cluster getting severe histoplasmosis with 3 fatalities.

You can look this **** up. I'm really getting tired of this same argument that uses cherry picked bits of data without looking at the whole picture. Latching on to the fact they got anti-fungals when they also got anti-virals and antibiotics is ludicrous cherry picking.


I repeat, Shi had nothing to back up that claim and nothing in the patient medical records suggests they had primary histoplasmosis. So unless one is claiming the doctors who saw these patients were grossly incompetent, these patients did not have any mysterious fungal infections.
 
Seasonal Coronaviruses that cause the common cold could have been positive by the IgG assay.
And the IgM then???

Once again people are dismissing the medical workup these guys had where are straight from the master's thesis. That thesis was written years before COVID-19 began and clearly they were worked up for SARS because of the history, the clinical presentation, and the danger a new SARS outbreak or a new SARS-like outbreak was very real.

Where is Shi's paper describing how they investigated and found this was a false alarm? :rolleyes:

Instead she makes a bizarre comment that they had a fungal disease but if they had worked in the mine longer they might have gotten a coronavirus.


Could we please get real in this discussion? If you (the general you) are going to nitpick the findings of the medical doctors that saw 6 miners with severe viral pneumonia that was concluded to be a SARS-like coronavirus, then how about nitpicking the nonsense there were several wet-markets that supposedly other Wuhan citizens were infected at, citing the WHO report which does not substantiate that claim with any evidence?

A little more even-handedness and a little less trying to make SG look like a conspiracy theorist would go a long way.
 
Last edited:
Well, this is interesting. From a different case, but it has some similarities...


In March 2019, 14 Chinese employees from Chongqing Bosai Mining Company, China, were engaged in manganese mining in Guyana and presented with unexplained fever. Two of them died. After preliminary examination by the local hospital, some potential infectious pathogens were excluded, including Leptospira, HIV, influenza H1N1, Zika virus, Chikungunya virus, Dengue virus, and Influenza A and B viruses. Histoplasmosis is a fungal disease caused by members of the genus Histoplasma and is mainly prevalent in the American continents. Histoplasma is capable of survival in moist soils and can often be isolated from soils containing decaying feces of bats and birds. Human activities in the surface soil produce aerosols, which in turn are inhaled to cause infection.

Link
 
And the IgM then???

Once again people are dismissing the medical workup these guys had where are straight from the master's thesis. That thesis was written years before COVID-19 began and clearly they were worked up for SARS because of the history, the clinical presentation, and the danger a new SARS outbreak or a new SARS-like outbreak was very real.

Where is Shi's paper describing how they investigated and found this was a false alarm? :rolleyes:

Instead she makes a bizarre comment that they had a fungal disease but if they had worked in the mine longer they might have gotten a coronavirus.


Could we please get real in this discussion? If you (the general you) are going to nitpick the findings of the medical doctors that saw 6 miners with severe viral pneumonia that was concluded to be a SARS-like coronavirus, then how about nitpicking the nonsense there were several wet-markets that supposedly other Wuhan citizens were infected at, citing the WHO report which does not substantiate that claim with any evidence?

A little more even-handedness and a little less trying to make SG look like a conspiracy theorist would go a long way.

Maybe it would be better if you sought out the answers to these questions from infectious disease experts.

I mean, Capsid is a virologist and Planigale is, if I understand correctly an NHS doctor working on the frontlines of the pandemic.

If you don't trust what they have to say, surely you must have some connections who would be happy to listen to what you have to say.

Or maybe write up a paper of some kind that is even-handed in its approach and see what qualified experts make of it.

Because the point it, while you argue, "Surely a Masters student could not have got it wrong!", this is the premise on which you build an argument that virologists in Wuhan have been lying and covering up a zoonotic spillover for.....reasons....

What do you want the rest of us to say? You want everyone just to agree with you that you have blown the case apart and that somehow this event proves....something...?
 
Well, this is interesting. From a different case, but it has some similarities...

Link
From your link:
... unexplained disease cluster ...

... two deaths, one severe case, and nine mild cases...

Most patients started with fever, headache, myalgia, loss of appetite, and hemorrhagic eruption on the skin.
Does that say presented with pneumonia and low O2 sats? Does it say clusters are common?

Generally, Histoplasma can be diagnosed by microscopic identification of H. capsulatum from the microbial culture of tissues or body fluids or from biopsy tissue samples ...
Does that say difficult to diagnose?

Clinical features and endemic trend of histoplasmosis in China: A retrospective analysis and literature review
Cases of histoplasmosis were sporadic in China....
You know what sporadic means, right?

Results: Thirty-four patients were included in the study, male predominance. About 44.1% were combined with underlying disease and HIV infection was observed in eight patients. Common clinical manifestations were fever (94.1%), followed by lymphadenopathy (70.6%) and anemia (67.6%). Organ involvement included lungs (52.9%), oral cavity (5.9%) and intestine (5.9%). Patients were diagnosed by bone marrow smears (44.1%), lymph node biopsy (41.1%), lung tissue biopsy (8.8%) and intestinal tissue biopsy (5.9%). About 70.6% received amphotericin B, while 38.2% received itraconazole therapy and 79.4% were improved. About 611 cases of histoplasmosis in the Chinese mainland were obtained in the study from the related literature, with 217 (37.0%) cases occurred in Yunnan province, 69 (11.9%) cases in Hunan province and 67 (11.6%) cases in Hubei province. All of them were high incidence area of histoplasmosis.

Conclusion: Histoplasmosis is a rare mycosis with high diagnosis rate and has a prominent geographical distribution in China, which should be considered highly in clinical work.
Does that say primarily presented with pneumonia and low O2 sats?

Does it say clusters were common? Does it say they were treated with fluconazole? Think they didn't have any amphotericin B in the main teaching hospital in Yunnan? Itraconazole is a broader spectrum anti-fungal. Why would they chose fluconazole which had a narrower spectrum if they didn't have a firm diagnosis?


Have you even once in this discussion looked for the evidence that explained the gaping holes in Shi's story? Did I miss that?

This is exactly what I'm talking about. You aren't interested in discussing the evidence, you are for the most part only interested in proving SG wrong.
There isn't a spec of evidence the miners had histoplasmosis except maybe the one with the nodules on his chest x-ray and that was not part of his primary diagnosis.

I think this line of inquiry is done. :mad:
 
Maybe it would be better if you sought out the answers to these questions from infectious disease experts....
Now you are getting into personal insults? I have been a specialist in occupational infectious disease for ~30 years. I'm certified in infection control in addition to my family practice and occupational health certifications.

And what are your qualifications? You can do a Google search for articles you don't fully understand?

:rolleyes:
 
Now you are getting into personal insults? I have been a specialist in occupational infectious disease for ~30 years. I'm certified in infection control in addition to my family practice and occupational health certifications.

And what are your qualifications? You can do a Google search for articles you don't fully understand?

:rolleyes:

No, you are reading into my posts insults that are not there and frankly you have been more than happy to insult me a number of times, so this pearl-clutching of yours is hypocritical at best.

I have never made claims to having medical expertise, quite the contrary, as I have repeatedly denied having any. But that just goes to underscore my point. Why are you trying to persuade me of your opinions when you surely know people who are far more qualified to know about this stuff?

What do your colleagues in infectious disease control say? What about those who specialize in this very area?
 
I believe it was discussed as a radiologic finding that they might have had past TB.. Some histo and some old TB cases have similar cavitary nodules on their chest x-rays.

American Thoracic Society Histoplasmosis
There was one miner who had nodules on a chest x-ray described as 'walnuts'. Near the end of his disease he was given an anti-fungal and got better. But another miner who was given no anti-fungals also recovered and was discharged.


As for a secondary infection, one can get disseminated histoplasmosis when one's immune system is deficient. A person with chronic low-grade histo could most certainly have an opportunistic exacerbation. That is some heavy duty immunosuppression there.

These guys were very ill and they were given steroids so if one is going to claim all 6 got life-threatening histoplasmosis before they were seen in the hospital it makes no ******* sense unless one is trying very hard to dismiss the evidence.

It's very clear in the patient work-ups described in the master's thesis that a primary fungal infection of any kind was not something they concluded the patients had. It's also very clear one does not see 6 people in a cluster getting severe histoplasmosis with 3 fatalities.

You can look this **** up. I'm really getting tired of this same argument that uses cherry picked bits of data without looking at the whole picture. Latching on to the fact they got anti-fungals when they also got anti-virals and antibiotics is ludicrous cherry picking.


I repeat, Shi had nothing to back up that claim and nothing in the patient medical records suggests they had primary histoplasmosis. So unless one is claiming the doctors who saw these patients were grossly incompetent, these patients did not have any mysterious fungal infections.

So this is the problem when you don't quite understand what happens, you misinterpret terminology. Classically in cavers exposed to a high dose of histoplasmosis spores they develop an acute ARDS like pneumonia. The story of a group of cavers presenting with a pneumonia is a classical story for histoplasmosis. The fungus grows in bat guano. Time to onset and severity of illness can be strongly related to inhaled dose. Very much like what is described here. The radiology would fit with acute severe histoplasmosis. It does not look like the patchy wedge shaped peripheral bilateral predominantly lower lobe GGO seen in COVID-19.

People with less intense exposure may only get a few spots on their lungs and this can produce the TB like picture you describe, and ultimately a miliary type pattern on CXR.

As for a secondary infection, one can get disseminated histoplasmosis when one's immune system is deficient.
This is not a secondary infection this is a reactivation of a pre-existing infection. Secondary infections are new infections that would not normally occur but develop because of lung injury from the primary infection. People do not catch histoplasmosis in hospital. What happens is they carry histoplasmosis which rather like TB can persist for years but held in check by the immune system when immunosuppressed it can start to grow.

To repeat the thesis IS grossly incompetent. This is something produced at intern level before going onto speciality training. This is not the product of a specialist in infectious diseases or pulmonology. I would have sent it back for a redo. I would expect if they were going to conclude that it was an unknown virus that caused this that fungal infections in particular histoplasmosis which would be a pretty good fit here had been excluded. There is no comment of testing for fungal infections. Were antibody tests sent for histoplasmosis? Legionell might be another possibility no comment on testing for this. Hanta virus might be another, no comment on testing for this. pulmonary leptospirosis, no comment on this.

The mortality rate is too high for covid-19 in relatively young people. The timing is wrong.

The laboratory source theory does not depend on these individuals having an unrelated coronavirus infection.
 
From your link:Does that say presented with pneumonia and low O2 sats? Does it say clusters are common?

Does that say difficult to diagnose?

Clinical features and endemic trend of histoplasmosis in China: A retrospective analysis and literature reviewYou know what sporadic means, right?

Does that say primarily presented with pneumonia and low O2 sats?

Does it say clusters were common? Does it say they were treated with fluconazole? Think they didn't have any amphotericin B in the main teaching hospital in Yunnan? Itraconazole is a broader spectrum anti-fungal. Why would they chose fluconazole which had a narrower spectrum if they didn't have a firm diagnosis?


Have you even once in this discussion looked for the evidence that explained the gaping holes in Shi's story? Did I miss that?

This is exactly what I'm talking about. You aren't interested in discussing the evidence, you are for the most part only interested in proving SG wrong.
There isn't a spec of evidence the miners had histoplasmosis except maybe the one with the nodules on his chest x-ray and that was not part of his primary diagnosis.

I think this line of inquiry is done. :mad:

Patients were diagnosed by bone marrow smears (44.1%), lymph node biopsy (41.1%), lung tissue biopsy (8.8%) and intestinal tissue biopsy (5.9%)

None of which are reported as having been done in these cases! So we can't say they had the tests done to make the diagnosis which then turned out negative.
 
Regards the IgM test. The masters thesis says

The patient tested positive for Serum IgM by the WuHan Institute of Virology. It suggested the existence of virus infection.

It doesn’t state the test used. Do we assume it tested for SARS? It’s strange that it’s not mentioned in later publications.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
 
Some people in this thread are still convinced the lab leak theory is a CT and that seems to be the focus of their posts. It's a very thin disguise. There is no reason for me to reply to any posts not attempting (IMO of course) to engage in a serious discussion of the evidence in this thread thread. I'm sure few will care.


Moving on to another review of the master's thesis. There's been so much evidence-based material to go through on this I hadn't spent enough time reviewing the thesis. This is what I've found tonight that I think is relevant:

The miners did not have histoplasmosis and I've posted more than enough evidence for that conclusion. It was on the differential during the some of the patients' workups but was not concluded as the diagnosis. So right there, the doctors looked for histo but it wasn't found except in case 5 and it wasn't his primary diagnosis.

There was a reference to a secondary aspergillosis in the master's thesis which I've quoted below.

If someone can find the basis for Shi claiming the the miners died of a fungal infection that would be worth discussing. I have looked extensively and not found anything.

If anyone cares to challenge the miners' diagnosis that they had a virus and more specifically it was a SARS-like coronavirus there is quite a bit of territory to address in that master's thesis.

Case 4 was the seriously ill patient who went on to recover. Cases 1,2 and 3 were the fatalities. I haven't gone over those records yet. This post is already longer than anyone here appears to be reading anyway.
Case 4
2012/7/6 CT scan: lung marking increased and blurry, ground-glass exudation in both lungs. ...

2012/7/11 CT scan: increased lung marking and blurry, ground-glass exudation same as above, the consolidation of the upper and lower right lung remain the same. ...
Now I'm curious to look at the SARS cases and ARDS cases to see if that "ground glass" is noted on chest x-rays. I didn't work in the ICU when SARS emerged.

... 2012/5/18 mucus culture: acinetobacter baumannii
This is a common secondary infection in ventilated patients and the previous cultures were negative. Then he got another infection we see in ICU patients:
2012/7/2 blood culture: klebsiella pnuemoniae

Case 4 was given a number of anti-fungals because of this:
2012/5/29 CT reports: There were frosty glass like density increased and hollows in both lungs. The temperature fluctuate between 36.8 – 37.4 Celsius. Possibly having secondary infection caused by Invasive pulmonary aspergillosis....

... On 2012/6/4, Dr. Xie Can Mao, Chief Physician, Respiratory department of The First Affliated Hospital, Sun Yat-Sen University, gave us some suggestions in a remote meeting. He diagnosed: 1. Interstitial pneumonia, great possibility for fungal infection. 2. Invasive pulmonary aspergillosis (secondary infection). 3. pulmonary embolism. ...

... For the antifungal medicine, we agreed to switch to Caspofungin and Fluconazole for treatment. On 6/8, PCT was 0.61ng/ml and on 6/11 was 0.11 ng/ml. The CT scan on 6/12, the hollows in the right lungs were slightly absorbed. The frosty glass like density has decreased and less dense. The improvement reflects on the effectiveness of fungal treatment.
No mention of histoplasmosis and nothing suggesting the aspergillosis was primary.

This was interesting as a curiosity for me, not as something specific to SARS-like infections:
With the help of increasing nutrients, prone position and treatment for swollen lung, the patient still couldn’t get rid of the ventilation machine.
I can't recall from my ICU days (1980s) that we ever put ventilated patients prone.
On June 19, we had Dr. Zhong Nan Shan from the Respiratory department of The First Affiliated Hospital, Sun Yat-Sen University to join our team remotely. He diagnosed: 1. Interstitial pneumonia, great possibility for virus infection. 2. Invasive pulmonary aspergillosis (secondary infection). He suggested 1. Visit the Animal lab in Kun Ming to confirm the species of the bat. 2. Conduct a swab test and SARS antibody examination. ...
And finally:
On 8/15, blood culture (oxygen demand and anaerobic) reports negative. On 8/30, the infection related protein test: CRP 12.5 mg/L, PCT 0.04 ng/ml, SAA 3.22ng/L, the upper part of the lungs basically back to normality. The body temperature remained around 36.5 Celsius. Besides, the symptom of coughing, coughing with mucus, difficulty in breathing and soreness in limbs is gone. We decided to suspend every other medicine besides the anticoagulation one. The patient was discharged on 2012/9/10.


Neither case 5 or 6 were intubated, both had milder disease.

Case 5 was the patient who had the 'walnut' shaped lesions on his chest x-ray but it was "chestnut" not 'walnut. Such is my aging memory. This is the closest any of them came to having a histoplasmosis diagnosis and as I noted a person with chronic histoplasmosis can indeed get worse when immunosuppressed. I quoted his discharge meds to show how much immunosuppressants he was on.
CT on 2012/4/28: chestnut shaped nodules in both lungs, shadow of multiple exudation. Initial diagnosis after admission: Further confirmation on the exudation and shadow of the nodules in the lungs (possibly inhaling pneumonia, check with pneumoconiosis)
I think they mean silica dust when they say inhaling pneumonia, but they could mean some other kind of dust coal miners inhale.
2012/4/28 CT: multiple chestnut shaped nodules, ...

... Discharge diagnosis: Multiple nodules in the lungs, need further confirmation for the exudation (possibly Histoplasmosis also need to check for the possibility for pneumoconiosis)
And here they are talking about the lung nodules and the fact he got better:
The patient is young adult. After taking anti-infection and antifungal treatment, the disease was under control while hospitalization. No reoccurrence of fever, coughing, coughing with mucus, tightness of chest and short in breath. The patient did not take any anti-virus medicine during rehabilitation, yet he has recovered. It indicates that his own immune system play a big role in fighting the disease. ...

Prescription after hospitalization:
2012/5/2 – 2012/5/10 Sulbencillin 1.0 g x 4 shots, ivgtt, Q8h
2012/5/7 – 2012/5/27 L – Fluconazole 0.2 g x 1, ivgtt, Q12h
2012/5/7 – 2012/5/9 (J) Methlyprednisolone injection 40mg x 1 shot, ivgtt, Qd
2012/5/9 – 2012/5/14 Prednisolone 10mg x 3 shots, ivgtt, Qd
2012/5/14 – 2012/5/15 Prednisolone 10mg x 2 shots, ivgtt, Qd
2012/5/15 – 2012/5/21 Prednisone Acetate tablet 20mg, po, Qd
2012/5/21 – Discharge, Prednisone Acetate tablet 15mg, po, Qd
2012/5/22 – Discharge, Thymosin, 1.0 mg x 2 shots, ivgtt, Qd
He relapsed and was treated in May which sounded like an outpatient treatment:
On May 6, according to the CT plain scan, the illness was getting worse. Therefore, we prescribed the antifungal medication and some hormone. The consolidation exudation in the upper lung has improved five days after. The temperature has dropped to normal. It indicates that antifungal med and hormones were effective. The cause of recovery: The patient is younger with stronger immune system. In addition, he did not spend a long time in the mining field, The treatment was immediate and effective



Case 6.
The patient is a young adult. After receiving the anti-infection, anti inflammation and antivirus treatment, the patient has started to recover. The body temperature was kept in the normal range. No reoccurrence of coughing, coughing with mucus or any difficulty in breathing. The patient did not receive any anti-fungal medicine for treatment, yet still recovered. This suggested that the possibility of the illness being triggered by fungal infection is slim.
That's in the thesis, those are not my words.


Comprehensive analysis:
4. After admitted to the hospital, the percentage and count for T, B, NK cells were all substantially low, which means the immune system of the patients were in severe impairment and created chances for multiple infections. In 2011, a scholar mentioned the importance of low CD4 + T lymph in virus infection reference 5. Therefore, presume that all 6 patients were infected by the virus.

5. After admission, Patient Guo and Liu did test for etiology (swabs and blood) for SARS-CoV, hemorrhagic fever, Dengue fever, Japanese encephalitis, Influenza A virus and other related virus by Chen Du army reserved Center for Disease Prevention and Control, the result were all negative. A negative on a onetime etiology test could not exempt other related virus. ...

8. According to Table 3: In the first infection related protein test of all 6 patients, SAA were noticeably increasing, PCT remained in the normal range. It suggested that the six patients possibly had virus infection.

14. Gaps and failings: (1) Initially, the patients were tested for etiology (swabs and blood) by Chen Du army reserved Center for Disease Prevention and Control and the result was negative. However, a negative on a onetime etiology test could not exempt the possibility of infections caused by other related viruses. In the later stage, we worked with Dr. Zhong Nan Shan and did some sampling. The patient tested positive for Serum IgM by the WuHan Institute of Virology. It suggested the existence of virus infection.
I don't know why the WIV would do a non-specific IgM level or why it isn't clear here if they had done one or more disease specific IgM levels. What I can say is neither the IgM nor the IgG serologies are all that we have to go on with these miners.


Future Research

3. With the Kunming Institute of Zoology, we confirmed that the six patients were exposed to Chinese rufous horseshoe bat, which caused the disease. However, a paper published in Science magazine in 2005 by Scientist Shi Zheng Li and Zhang Shu Yi from Wuhan Institute of Virology under Chinese Academy of Science, concluded that the SARS-like-CoV carried by bats is not contagious to humans. This contradiction indicates the importance of these six cases: the severe pneumonia caused by the unknown virus and the bats in the cave merit further investigation and research.
This is why little word from Shi or the WIV is so unusual. They were called about this case, they received serum from the patients, and they returned numerous times to collect specimens from the mine. The idea Shi would make a comment the miners had a fungus without any publication, especially one contemporary to 2012, to back it up makes no sense.

IV. Conclusion
Based on the above mentioned cases and related researches, the unknown virus lead to severe pneumonia could be: The SARS-like-CoV from the Chinese rufous horseshoe bat or Bats kind SARS-like CoV.
Those may be the student's words but they weren't written without input from his medical school professors.
 
Last edited:
Regards the IgM test. The masters thesis says

The patient tested positive for Serum IgM by the WuHan Institute of Virology. It suggested the existence of virus infection.

It doesn’t state the test used. Do we assume it tested for SARS? It’s strange that it’s not mentioned in later publications.
I noted that in the very long post I just wrote including the comment the record is incomplete without knowing what the WIV actually tested for and why they would do a nonspecific IgM or if it was specific, why it is not in the thesis or patient medical records.

I have no answer. It's not even clear if that was only on one patient or if it was also done on all the specimens from the 4 patients which were available.

But it is not all we have to go on.
 
None of which are reported as having been done in these cases! So we can't say they had the tests done to make the diagnosis which then turned out negative.
What are you talking about? Are you still going on about they could of had histoplasmosis? :rolleyes:

What tests do you think were or were not done?

If you are just talking about histoplasmosis I covered that in my review of three of the patients' medical records in the thesis. Have you even bothered to look at the medical records on the 6 miners?

The idea they all needed biopsies to test for histo is absurd.
 
Last edited:
So this is the problem when you don't quite understand what happens, you misinterpret terminology. ....
Bull ****.

Did you miss the sporadic nature of histoplasmosis in my link? You're still trying to support an unsupportable diagnosis. I'm not the one with issues looking at medical records.

If this was 6 miners with histoplasmosis then you are calling their doctors incompetent. That's what happens when you try to find evidence to support a diagnosis instead of looking at what the patient is actually presenting with.
 
Last edited:
No, you are reading into my posts insults that are not there ...
:rolleyes:

I have never made claims to having medical expertise, quite the contrary, as I have repeatedly denied having any. But that just goes to underscore my point. Why are you trying to persuade me of your opinions when you surely know people who are far more qualified to know about this stuff?

What do your colleagues in infectious disease control say? What about those who specialize in this very area?
I'm not trying to persuade you of anything. That's your problem.

I was addressing the unsupportable claim these miners had a primary fungal infection because that's a clear piece of evidence Shi is lying. And so far no one here has any evidence to support that she had a basis for that assertion.

All this histo nonsense is no more than a 'see that squirrel' distraction which is not a diagnosis supported in the miners' medical records.

As for my colleagues.. why would I have this discussion with them? We don't sit around debating about the origin of COVID.
 
Well, Jeremy Farrar's insider memoir, Spike, definitely sounds as though there is plenty of questions related to the origins of Covid-19:

Farrar is similarly honest about his other biases and in a reflective passage on his initial willingness to entertain the laboratory conspiracy theory, he admits: “I had put two and two together and made five.” But perhaps the bigger surprise, given the fact that in February 2020 Farrar had lent his name to a controversial letter in the Lancet “strongly” condemning speculation about Covid’s non-natural origins, is that he entertained the theory at all (in a rare oversight, Farrar and Ahuja fail to mention the Lancet letter).

I suspect these passages will prove the most controversial, particularly given the Biden administration’s recent decision to reopen the lab leak investigation and the recent publication of a follow-up Lancet letter in which Farrar and other prominent scientists reaffirm their view that the weight of “credible”, peer-reviewed scientific evidence points to a natural origin.

Certainly, as a long-time Farrar watcher (disclosure: some of my research has been supported by the Wellcome Trust and I’ve also interviewed Farrar for my podcast), I was astonished to learn that a month before the publication of the first Lancet letter Farrar had scheduled a confidential call with Anthony Fauci, the director of the US National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases, to discuss the evidence for and against the lab leak theory, after which Farrar was still split 50-50. Equally astonishing is the revelation that he was so spooked by the possibility that the virus was human-made that he raised it with Eliza Manningham-Buller, the former head of M15 and a Wellcome trustee (it was Manningham-Buller who advised Farrar to get a burner phone and beef up his security). Indeed, the most compelling passages of Spike are where Farrar, skilfully aided by Ahuja, takes us through the complex scientific case for and against the lab leak theory, as he wrestles with his conscience and who he should let in on the secret lest something ill should befall him. John le Carré couldn’t have plotted it better. Despite this, many readers may feel Farrar’s conclusion is a bit of a cop-out – without access to the laboratory records, he says, we may never be able to definitively rule out the lab leak theory “but the simplest explanation remains the likeliest: nature plus bad luck”. No less easy is the question whether Farrar would have done better to break ranks with Boris Johnson’s government earlier. “Does staying in an advisory role mean being complicit in the outcomes of bad decisions?” he asks at one point.
 
Case 4 was the seriously ill patient who went on to recover. Cases 1,2 and 3 were the fatalities. I haven't gone over those records yet. This post is already longer than anyone here appears to be reading anyway.
Quote:
Case 4
2012/7/6 CT scan: lung marking increased and blurry, ground-glass exudation in both lungs. ...

2012/7/11 CT scan: increased lung marking and blurry, ground-glass exudation same as above, the consolidation of the upper and lower right lung remain the same. ...
Now I'm curious to look at the SARS cases and ARDS cases to see if that "ground glass" is noted on chest x-rays. I didn't work in the ICU when SARS emerged.

Whether the patients had SARS or not is irrelevant. SARS is not a predecessor to SARS-CoV-2. They did not isolate SARS virus despite having sent material for PCR testing. The description could fit many pneumonias including SARS but not SARS-CoV-2 which has distinct features.

Case 4 was given a number of anti-fungals because of this:
2012/5/29 CT reports: There were frosty glass like density increased and hollows in both lungs. The temperature fluctuate between 36.8 – 37.4 Celsius. Possibly having secondary infection caused by Invasive pulmonary aspergillosis....

... On 2012/6/4, Dr. Xie Can Mao, Chief Physician, Respiratory department of The First Affliated Hospital, Sun Yat-Sen University, gave us some suggestions in a remote meeting. He diagnosed: 1. Interstitial pneumonia, great possibility for fungal infection. 2. Invasive pulmonary aspergillosis (secondary infection). 3. pulmonary embolism. ...

... For the antifungal medicine, we agreed to switch to Caspofungin and Fluconazole for treatment. On 6/8, PCT was 0.61ng/ml and on 6/11 was 0.11 ng/ml. The CT scan on 6/12, the hollows in the right lungs were slightly absorbed. The frosty glass like density has decreased and less dense. The improvement reflects on the effectiveness of fungal treatment.
No mention of histoplasmosis and nothing suggesting the aspergillosis was primary.

Interestingly despite the concern of invasive aspergillosis, Aspergillus antigen test (galactomannan) was not reported as being done on blood or bronchial samples, nor was Aspergillum serology reported, nor was Aspergillus PCR reported. This was either a patient that was inadequately investigated or the report is inadequate.

This was interesting as a curiosity for me, not as something specific to SARS-like infections:
With the help of increasing nutrients, prone position and treatment for swollen lung, the patient still couldn’t get rid of the ventilation machine.
I can't recall from my ICU days (1980s) that we ever put ventilated patients prone.

I cannot answer for the ICU you worked in , nor your memory, but prone ventilation was done for severe ARDS in the 80s. It was introduced in the mid 70s.
Douglas WW, Rehder K, Beynen FM, Sessler AD, Marsh HM. Improved oxygenation in patients with acute respiratory failure: the prone position. Am Rev Respir Dis. 1977;115:559–566
Piehl MA, Brown RS. Use of extreme position changes in acute respiratory failure. Crit Care Med. 1976;4:13–14

Case 5 note the steroids were started after the deterioration, so you cannot say that the aspergillus / histoplasmosis (if any) was a reactivation caused by immunosuppression with prednisolone. It was treated with prednisolone. Which makes me wonder if they thought about cryptogenic organising pneumonia, or an inhalation pneumonia such as hypersensitivity pneumonitis, which is why one would give steroids to someone with a deteriorating pneumonia despite antibiotics. The steroid doses were not high, similar or lower to what you would use to treat and asthma or COPD exacerbation. Not the doses we would normally expect to cause a reactivation of histoplasmosis, and the steroids have to be given fairly longterm for reactivation to occur not a reducing doses over a few days.

Case 6.
The patient is a young adult. After receiving the anti-infection, anti inflammation and antivirus treatment, the patient has started to recover. The body temperature was kept in the normal range. No reoccurrence of coughing, coughing with mucus or any difficulty in breathing. The patient did not receive any anti-fungal medicine for treatment, yet still recovered. This suggested that the possibility of the illness being triggered by fungal infection is slim.
That's in the thesis, those are not my words.

Poor assumption, whether yours or the author of the thesis, people do get better by themselves, as you reference most people with histoplasmosis have a mild self limiting illness. That he got better without anti fungal treatment does not exclude a fungal infection.

Normally when one reports results of an IgG or IgM test in a case report one gives the exact details of the test (manufacturer, whether it is an ELISA etc.) and the actual result e.g. 1:256. The lack of these details just shows that major facts one would expect to be given are left out. The details given are too sketchy to be relied on. Certainly it is so sketchy I would not give any credence to the authors opinion. He never gives a reasonable differential and how these had been excluded. Attributing these cases to a novel virus without isolating the virus requires a Holmesian rigorous exclusion of alternatives.
 
Last edited:
Whether the patients had SARS or not is irrelevant. SARS is not a predecessor to SARS-CoV-2. They did not isolate SARS virus despite having sent material for PCR testing. The description could fit many pneumonias including SARS but not SARS-CoV-2 which has distinct features.
No one is saying the miners had SARS or that SARS is a precursor to COVID. :confused: For whatever reason you are not following the issues here. The men had diagnosis of a viral pneumonia of unknown etiology.

First and foremost, this is not PROOF. Why do you think I am saying it is?

Neither is there proof of the natural spillover.
In fact there is much less evidence supporting a natural event. It mostly consists of claiming it is more likely and the claim in the WHO report that the early patients had some contact with some nearby wet market even though no such contact has been pinned down and no other wet markets in the area have been shown to have any evidence of COVID 19. That hasn't stopped multiple sources claiming in fact that the WHO report supports multiple wet market exposures in all the early cases.

See for yourself: WHO-convened Global Study of Origins of SARS-CoV-2: China Part Joint WHO-China Study 14 January-10 February 2021 Joint Report


THE MINERS DID NOT HAVE A PRIMARY FUNGAL DISEASE. Support your diagnosis, don't just keep claiming it could have been. The doctors in China at a large teaching hospital 10 years ago were not practicing backward medicine.

The men worked in a mine with bats that carried a number of SL CoV (SARS Like coronavirus) strains.

The medical record of the 6 cases is reported in detail in the master's thesis including corroborating consults that were made at the time the miners were in the hospital.

Are there other possibilities? Obviously. What is the point of going on and on trying to dismiss the evidence when no one has said here's the proof? Look at the evidence for what it is: suspicious for multiple reasons.

You can argue they could have had an infection from aliens, that doesn't change the facts. The WIV was notified. The WIV collected samples multiple times from the mine. Serum specimens were sent to the WIV and elsewhere.

And for some reason as yet to be made clear Shi claimed the miners never had an SL CoV but rather had a primary fungal infection. There is nothing prior to the current pandemic that supports her claim.

It should have been big news: 'False alarm, SARS did not emerge a second time, patients had a fungal disease'. Where is anything prior to the pandemic with that kind of report? Think about it, this is Shi's main work—finding the source of SARS. They were concerned enough the went collecting more specimens from the mine.

If anyone has an explanation that is more than 'it could have been something else' let's hear it. We have the patients' medical records and the thinking at the time this could be a new SL CoV.

Is it proof? Let me say it again: of course not! That seems to be one of the problems in this discussion, poking holes in some claim of having proof that was never made.


We do know the infection the miners had did not pass to other people. That is typical of a new spillover event. You would think a new spillover event would support the natural origin of COVID. You would think Shi could discuss in detail why this wasn't a spillover event and what evidence supported that. Nope, we have crickets.

Eight years later a SARS-like CoV begins spreading person to person with no evidence of a natural source. China clamps down on research, especially any examination of data that would be useful to sort out the origin, natural or otherwise. Shi claims without presenting supporting evidence that the miners had a fungal disease.

The clampdown was long before Dump politicized the origin.


Daszak is accused by many researchers of having a conflict of interest yet he was part of the WHO investigation. And he's accused of steering the investigation away from a lab origin including planting the seeds such an hypothesis was a CT.

Want to see the supporting documents for that again?


Plan said:
Interestingly despite the concern of invasive aspergillosis, Aspergillus antigen test (galactomannan) was not reported as being done on blood or bronchial samples, nor was Aspergillum serology reported, nor was Aspergillus PCR reported. This was either a patient that was inadequately investigated or the report is inadequate.
So? The patient records are what they are. If you want to imagine the doctors in China were incompetent, that doesn't change the records we have.

What if the miners really had a space virus? How do you know they didn't?

The diagnosis was not histoplasmosis or any other acute primary fungal infection. And you've not presented what in those medical records supports a primary fungal diagnosis. You have Shi's claim and nothing else short of calling the physicians incompetent.


Plan said:
Case 5 note the steroids were started after the deterioration, so you cannot say that the aspergillus / histoplasmosis (if any) was a reactivation caused by immunosuppression with prednisolone. It was treated with prednisolone. Which makes me wonder if they thought about cryptogenic organising pneumonia, or an inhalation pneumonia such as hypersensitivity pneumonitis, which is why one would give steroids to someone with a deteriorating pneumonia despite antibiotics. The steroid doses were not high, similar or lower to what you would use to treat and asthma or COPD exacerbation. Not the doses we would normally expect to cause a reactivation of histoplasmosis, and the steroids have to be given fairly longterm for reactivation to occur not a reducing doses over a few days.
Aspergillus is an organism patients in critical care get. It is listed as such in the patients' records.

People with chronic histoplasmosis can suffer disseminated disease or even an exacerbation when they are immunosuppressed. If it was an acute primary diagnosis it would have meant case 5 had something different than the other 5 patients. And for whatever reason said primary fungal disease got better despite getting steroids.

And it's bull **** that a chronic case of histo couldn't be exacerbated with the treatment and illness case 5 suffered.

Those are the meds he was given in the hospital. The translation "after hospitalization" means after admission. Only the last 2 were discharge meds. I had to re-look at those today myself. It was getting late when I posted that. It should have been obvious IV drips and injections were not discharge meds. I missed that too.
First day of hospitalization: 2012/5/2; Day of Discharge: 2012/5/28, total of 26 days
So he was in the hospital 26 days, where he got a rapid steroid induction followed by a taper; 30mg of prednisone is a moderate dose, not a low dose.


Plan said:
Poor assumption, whether yours or the author of the thesis, people do get better by themselves, as you reference most people with histoplasmosis have a mild self limiting illness. That he got better without anti fungal treatment does not exclude a fungal infection.
Oh for pity's sake, give it up. Of course people get better on their own. Who said they don't?

The doctors in China at a large teaching hospital 10 years ago were not practicing in the dark.

To summarize for people who don't read long posts:

No one is claiming this is proof, neither origin has been proven. It is a piece of evidence among many other pieces of evidence.

Because something "could have been" is not evidence of what the men had.

Nothing backs up Shi's fatal fungus claim.

China clamped down on any information that might have a bearing on the origin.

Daszak with a serious conflict of interest tried to inject the assertion the lab leak was a CT. It was successful at first but no longer is.​
 
Last edited:
No one is saying the miners had SARS or that SARS is a precursor to COVID. :confused: For whatever reason you are not following the issues here. The men had diagnosis of a viral pneumonia of unknown etiology.

First and foremost, this is not PROOF. Why do you think I am saying it is?

Neither is there proof of the natural spillover.
In fact there is much less evidence supporting a natural event. It mostly consists of claiming it is more likely and the claim in the WHO report that the early patients had some contact with some nearby wet market even though no such contact has been pinned down and no other wet markets in the area have been shown to have any evidence of COVID 19. That hasn't stopped multiple sources claiming in fact that the WHO report supports multiple wet market exposures in all the early cases.

Apart from the fact that every other epidemic infection from plague to smallpox including HIV and TB, SARS and MERS has originated from a cross over from an animal source to humans. None of these were due to an escape from a laboratory. So you are presenting a whole new level of exceptionalism that this one virus epidemic event cannot be a natural crossover. (I do recall allegations that HIV was created in a laboratory, but I don't think anyone still believes that).
The default has to be natural like every other event, the burden of proof is on the laboratory source.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom