Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
Perhaps you can provide links to the translations. Sorry, they maybe up thread. The assay method details should be described. I'm talking about the antibody tests not the PCR .


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
I don't think they are described. And yes, I knew you were talking about the antibody tests. I just noted changes on the clinical front in general.

Here's the link to the master's thesis, pdf English translation:
"The Analysis of Six Patients With Severe Pneumonia Caused By Unknown Viruses"
School/ College: No. 1 School of Clinical Medicine, Kun Ming Medical University
Student’s Name: Li Xu
Study field: Clinical Medicine and Emergency Medicine
May, 2013


I haven't looked through the case reports since glancing at them earlier, later tonight maybe.

I'll look for the PhD thesis and links to other sources of lab reports done on the miners.
 
Last edited:
I don't think they are described. And yes, I knew you were talking about the antibody tests.

Here's the link to the master's thesis, pdf English translation:
"The Analysis of Six Patients With Severe Pneumonia Caused By Unknown Viruses"
School/ College: No. 1 School of Clinical Medicine, Kun Ming Medical University
Student’s Name: Li Xu
Study field: Clinical Medicine and Emergency Medicine
May, 2013


I haven't looked through the case reports since glancing at them earlier, later tonight maybe.

I'll look for the PhD thesis and links to other sources of lab reports done on the miners.


There is no description of the antibody assay. I'm not even sure it is a test for CoV specific antibodies but rather a general higher level of serum IgM that indicates a viral infection.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Link to the PhD thesis: Canping Huang PhD - “Novel Virus Discovery in Bat and the Exploration of Receptor of Bat Coronavirus HKU9”

The Canping Huang thesis substantiates several aspects of the Mojiang Miners Passage theory. But perhaps the most significant of all its statements is that samples from four of the miners were tested at the WIV for IgG antibodies against the SARS virus. According to the PhD (see Fig. 3), all samples were positive. (This test is distinct from the IgM test mentioned in the Master’s thesis).
I posted about this a couple posts up. It was unlikely these miners had had SARS in the past.

Working back from the CounterPunch citation, it was noted that:

In their November addendum Zheng-li Shi and her colleagues at the WIV confirmed receiving thirteen serum samples–taken at approximately monthly intervals in 2012–from four of the hospitalised miners. But here there is a major discrepancy. Referring to the miner serum samples, the addendum states:

“To investigate the cause of the respiratory disease, we tested the samples using PCR methods developed in our laboratory targeting the RNA-dependent RNA polymerases of Ebola virus, Nipah virus and bat SARSr-CoVRp3, and all the samples tested negative for these viruses. We also tested the serum samples for the presence of antibodies against the nucleocapsid proteins of these three viruses, and none of the samples gave a positive result. Recently, we retested the samples with our validated enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) against the SARS coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2) nucleocapsid protein–which has greater than 90% amino acid sequence identity with SARSr-CoVRp3–and confirmed that these patients were not infected by SARS-CoV-2.” (Zhou et al., 2020, addendum)

The implication is that, though various tests were performed at the WIV, SARS-CoV-2 was not found and no evidence for any other coronavirus was found either.

This obviously contradicts the Master’s thesis
.


The difference between these two positions is crucial. If a coronavirus of any kind was found in the miners’ samples it would likely alter our whole understanding of the pandemic origin.

This is because every possible effort would surely have been made to identify it, grow it in cultured human cells, sequence its genome, characterise its infectivity, and much more. There are two primary reasons for this. ...

By the same token, if a coronavirus was found in the 2012 miners’ samples it would surely also mean that subsequent research, presumably at the WIV, has been concealed.
There's more than enough evidence supporting the fact these miners did not have histoplasmosis except as a secondary diagnosis if that. Their chest x-rays and CT scans look nothing like histoplasmosis.


To be continued. I wanted to get the link to the PhD thesis posted again.
 
There is no description of the antibody assay. I'm not even sure it is a test for CoV specific antibodies but rather a general higher level of serum IgM that indicates a viral infection.
I'm pretty sure it was specifically for SARS CoV. There was a serious concern this was a new spillover of SARS. Why would they have not looked specifically for SARS antibodies?

And in the PhD thesis it was reported that serum samples from the miners sent to the WIV tested positive for SARS IgG. See my post above.
 
I'm pretty sure it was specifically for SARS CoV. There was a serious concern this was a new spillover of SARS. Why would they have not looked specifically for SARS antibodies?

And in the PhD thesis it was reported that serum samples from the miners sent to the WIV tested positive for SARS IgG. See my post above.

*ahem*

4) Potential common and rare causes of their symptoms were tested for and mostly eliminated. For patients 3 and 4 these included tests for HIV, Cytomegalovirus, Epstein-Barr Virus (EBV), Japanese encephalitis, haemorrhagic fever, Dengue, Hepatitis B, SARS, and influenza. Of these, only patient 2 tested positive for Hepatitis and EBV.
 
Learning Japanese has come in useful for being able to read some Chinese,

And to some extent the reverse is also true: when I've been in Japan being able to read Chinese helped me a little in getting around, particularly being able to read some of the signs when taking the subway. :)

When I was studying Chinese at 交通大学 they split us into a "Westerner" class and an "Asian" class (mainly Japanese and Koreans). I think they said that the Asian class would reach a level in six months that would take us 2 years.
 

We know they didn't have SARS. I'm not sure what you are confused about. They had SARS antibodies which were believed to have been indicative of another SARS-like corona virus.

If you'd take a more thorough look at the master's thesis you would know that.
 
I'm pretty sure it was specifically for SARS CoV. There was a serious concern this was a new spillover of SARS. Why would they have not looked specifically for SARS antibodies?

And in the PhD thesis it was reported that serum samples from the miners sent to the WIV tested positive for SARS IgG. See my post above.


Yes, but that test may not be able to discriminate between sarbecoviruses or perhaps even the seasonal coronaviruses. The miners could be positive from an infection they caught before they entered the mine.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
 
I can't find that stated in the linked document. :confused:

It seems that this is what SG is talking about...

(I seem to remember posting this, or a similar extract saying that the thesis shows it was inconclusive what the cause of death was)
 

Attachments

  • PhD thesis.jpg
    PhD thesis.jpg
    48.6 KB · Views: 13
It seems that this is what SG is talking about...

(I seem to remember posting this, or a similar extract saying that the thesis shows it was inconclusive what the cause of death was)

Thanks, that could mean they got infected with a coronavirus before they entered the cave. The IgM result from the master's thesis was not virus-specific so we can't say that the acute IgM response was due to a SARS-like infection at the time the miners were hospitalized.
 
Thanks, that could mean they got infected with a coronavirus before they entered the cave. The IgM result from the master's thesis was not virus-specific so we can't say that the acute IgM response was due to a SARS-like infection at the time the miners were hospitalized.

Indeed. I think that serological surveys of villages in Yunnan have often found people testing positive for SARS IgG. This is one of the clues that led to the discovery of the original bat-borne version of SARS. Perhaps, in fact, it was the Mojiang miners's that tipped them off...

In many bat dwellings Shi has sampled, including Shitou Cave, “constant mixing of different viruses creates a great opportunity for dangerous new pathogens to emerge,” says Ralph Baric, a virologist at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill. In the vicinity of such viral melting pots, Shi says, “you don’t need to be a wildlife trader to be infected.”

Near Shitou Cave, for example, many villages sprawl among the lush hillsides in a region known for its roses, oranges, walnuts and hawthorn berries. In October 2015 Shi’s team collected blood samples from more than 200 residents in four of those villages. It found that six people, or nearly 3 percent, carried antibodies against SARS-like coronaviruses from bats—even though none of them had handled wildlife or reported SARS-like or other pneumonialike symptoms. Only one had traveled outside of Yunnan prior to the sampling, and all said they had seen bats flying in their village.

Three years earlier Shi’s team had been called in to investigate the virus profile of a mine shaft in Yunnan’s mountainous Mojiang County—famous for its fermented Pu’er tea—where six miners suffered from pneumonialike diseases and two died. After sampling the cave for a year, the researchers discovered a diverse group of coronaviruses in six bat species. In many cases, multiple viral strains had infected a single animal, turning it into a flying factory for new viruses.

“The mine shaft stunk like hell,” says Shi, who, like her colleagues, went in wearing a protective mask and clothing. “Bat guano, covered in fungus, littered the cave.” Although the fungus turned out to be the pathogen that had sickened the miners, she says it would have been only a matter of time before they caught the coronaviruses if the mine had not been promptly shut.

https://www.scientificamerican.com/...wn-viruses-from-sars-to-the-new-coronavirus1/
 
Link to the PhD thesis: Canping Huang PhD - “Novel Virus Discovery in Bat and the Exploration of Receptor of Bat Coronavirus HKU9”

I posted about this a couple posts up. It was unlikely these miners had had SARS in the past.

Working back from the CounterPunch citation, it was noted that:




There's more than enough evidence supporting the fact these miners did not have histoplasmosis except as a secondary diagnosis if that. Their chest x-rays and CT scans look nothing like histoplasmosis.


To be continued. I wanted to get the link to the PhD thesis posted again.

Histoplasmosis does not occur as a secondary infection following viral infections.

Could you perhaps expand on your assertion that the CXR and CT scans look nothing like histoplasmosis?
 
It seems that this is what SG is talking about...

(I seem to remember posting this, or a similar extract saying that the thesis shows it was inconclusive what the cause of death was)

The list of viruses that they tested for is odd. Most e.g. dengue, hepatitis, are not viruses that would cause pneumonia. Locally we would test for flu A/B, RSV, Rhino, HMP, Adeno, corona. Depending on the situation SARS and MERS. Hanta virus was not tested for, but would be a possibility for a point outbreak severe pneumonia. legionella (not a virus) was not tested for but certainly would also fit with a point outbreak of a severe pneumonia with no person to person transmission.

The long and uneven latency (time between exposure and illness) does not fit for viral infections, it fits best with a fungal infection. Virus infections tend to cause pneumonia early and at a fairly constant time after infection. In viral terms Covid-19 has a long latency between infection and clinical presentation with pneumonia 2 - 3 weeks.

In any case this episode of pneumonia really does not make any difference to the case for or against a laboratory source. Since no precursor to SARS-CoV-2 was found this is obviously a distraction. If someone was infected with a precursor and a sample was sent to WIV and escaped from there it was clearly from a different patient. I have seen no one suggesting this was the only clinical sample on someone with a severe pneumonia sent to WIV. Not that this cave was the only place where environmental sampling was done. The case for a laboratory source is just as strong if you ignore this outbreak.
 
Last edited:
The list of viruses that they tested for is odd. Most e.g. dengue, hepatitis, are not viruses that would cause pneumonia. Locally we would test for flu A/B, RSV, Rhino, HMP, Adeno, corona. Depending on the situation SARS and MERS. Hanta virus was not tested for, but would be a possibility for a point outbreak severe pneumonia. legionella (not a virus) was not tested for but certainly would also fit with a point outbreak of a severe pneumonia with no person to person transmission.

The long and uneven latency (time between exposure and illness) does not fit for viral infections, it fits best with a fungal infection. Virus infections tend to cause pneumonia early and at a fairly constant time after infection. In viral terms Covid-19 has a long latency between infection and clinical presentation with pneumonia 2 - 3 weeks.

In any case this episode of pneumonia really does not make any difference to the case for or against a laboratory source. Since no precursor to SARS-CoV-2 was found this is obviously a distraction. If someone was infected with a precursor and a sample was sent to WIV and escaped from there it was clearly from a different patient. I have seen no one suggesting this was the only clinical sample on someone with a severe pneumonia sent to WIV. Not that this cave was the only place where environmental sampling was done. The case for a laboratory source is just as strong if you ignore this outbreak.

I think the theory is this...

Six miners get sick and some of them die.

The WIV finds out about it and Peter Daszak gets very excited and says, "This is just what we are looking for..."

Then Zhengli Shi is all, "Shhhhhh...Peter...don't tell anyone about this. This is our big chance to go and get a wild virus..."

And Peter's all confused and thinking...."But... isn't our mission to get funding from zoonotic spillover?"

And Zhengli Shi is like, "No... our mission is to do Gain of Function research..."

Of course Peter is really confused and tries to explain that he can't get funding to do it in Wuhan...

Anyway, okay, there are some plot holes, but what happens is that the WIV people get some viruses and take them back to WIV and do secret GoF. Then, to cover up, they also produce other research, and make a public database.

Then, Peter Daszak turns up in loads of conferences and goes on and on about GoF on podcasts and stuff...

Then someone lets the GoF virus out...let's say in September 2019. So, then Zhengli Shi is like, "Holy crap, why did we put our secret viruses on the public database?" So she takes it down.

Then there are the Wuhan Military Games so Wuhan secretly locks down 11 million people in the city. Fortunately, nobody notices not even the US consulate, the UK consulate and the French consulate (what do we pay these guys for, eh?)

The WIV think they have got away with it so they start going to conferences and restaurants and karaoke and silly Peter Daszak goes back to bragging about GoF research...

...but then, some people start getting sick.

All the world's virologists wonder what is going on. A teleconference is convened in which Tony Fauci, Francis Collins, Kristian Andersen, Peter Daszak, Patrick Vallance, Jeffrey Farrar, Marian Koopmans look at the virus and say, "Oh Geez! The Chinese made this in a lab using that secret gain of function stuff that Peter Daszak was always bragging about and which Zhengli Shi put up on the database! This is really serious. It's time for Operation Sweep It Under the Rug!"

Someone questions why they would do this just to cover China's butt, and wouldn't it be crazy to do that when the easiest thing to do is demand China pay for what it did. But Tony Fauci says, "See that lampshade over there?" Everyone looks and nobody notices the plothole so they move on.

Anyway, it carries on like this until DRASTIC pull the mask off the virus and it turns out it was Peter Daszak all along and he says, "I would have gotten away with it too, if it hadn't been for you meddling internet sleuths".

I think that about covers it.
 
I think the theory is this...

Six miners get sick and some of them die.

The WIV finds out about it and Peter Daszak gets very excited and says, "This is just what we are looking for..."

Then Zhengli Shi is all, "Shhhhhh...Peter...don't tell anyone about this. This is our big chance to go and get a wild virus..."

And Peter's all confused and thinking...."But... isn't our mission to get funding from zoonotic spillover?"

And Zhengli Shi is like, "No... our mission is to do Gain of Function research..."

Of course Peter is really confused and tries to explain that he can't get funding to do it in Wuhan...

Anyway, okay, there are some plot holes, but what happens is that the WIV people get some viruses and take them back to WIV and do secret GoF. Then, to cover up, they also produce other research, and make a public database.

Then, Peter Daszak turns up in loads of conferences and goes on and on about GoF on podcasts and stuff...

Then someone lets the GoF virus out...let's say in September 2019. So, then Zhengli Shi is like, "Holy crap, why did we put our secret viruses on the public database?" So she takes it down.

Then there are the Wuhan Military Games so Wuhan secretly locks down 11 million people in the city. Fortunately, nobody notices not even the US consulate, the UK consulate and the French consulate (what do we pay these guys for, eh?)

The WIV think they have got away with it so they start going to conferences and restaurants and karaoke and silly Peter Daszak goes back to bragging about GoF research...

...but then, some people start getting sick.

All the world's virologists wonder what is going on. A teleconference is convened in which Tony Fauci, Francis Collins, Kristian Andersen, Peter Daszak, Patrick Vallance, Jeffrey Farrar, Marian Koopmans look at the virus and say, "Oh Geez! The Chinese made this in a lab using that secret gain of function stuff that Peter Daszak was always bragging about and which Zhengli Shi put up on the database! This is really serious. It's time for Operation Sweep It Under the Rug!"

Someone questions why they would do this just to cover China's butt, and wouldn't it be crazy to do that when the easiest thing to do is demand China pay for what it did. But Tony Fauci says, "See that lampshade over there?" Everyone looks and nobody notices the plothole so they move on.

Anyway, it carries on like this until DRASTIC pull the mask off the virus and it turns out it was Peter Daszak all along and he says, "I would have gotten away with it too, if it hadn't been for you meddling internet sleuths".

I think that about covers it.
:thumbsup:
 
Yes, but that test may not be able to discriminate between sarbecoviruses or perhaps even the seasonal coronaviruses. The miners could be positive from an infection they caught before they entered the mine.
If they had IgM, that would be an acute SARS-like coronavirus infection. I thought those tests were negative but my memory was faulty.

None of the other coronaviruses would have put 6 people in the hospital killing 4 of them except MERS and there would not have been MERS in the mine.
 
Thanks, that could mean they got infected with a coronavirus before they entered the cave. The IgM result from the master's thesis was not virus-specific so we can't say that the acute IgM response was due to a SARS-like infection at the time the miners were hospitalized.

I'm not sure where you are getting that the miners tested positive for some kind of general IgM. I'm not even sure what test that is. As for the IgM being from another coronavirus, why wouldn't that be in the record?

No they didn't have a definitive test for whatever the miners had. But they certainly needed to rule out SARS under the circumstances so they would have been testing for SARS antibodies.

As I said in the above post, none of the other 4 human coronaviruses cause severe disease.

I'm not sure of your point. Are you are suggesting they had a new coronavirus unrelated to SARS CoV? That's a stretch.

It's also a stretch that finding wouldn't have made it to a published paper about this discovery.
 
Indeed. I think that serological surveys of villages in Yunnan have often found people testing positive for SARS IgG. This is one of the clues that led to the discovery of the original bat-borne version of SARS. Perhaps, in fact, it was the Mojiang miners's that tipped them off...

https://www.scientificamerican.com/...wn-viruses-from-sars-to-the-new-coronavirus1/
...nearly 3 percent...
It has already been noted that it was unlikely all 6 of these miners had past SARS infections.

100% of the miners had severe pneumonia and we have their chest x-rays and CT chest scans.

Claiming those serologies were reactions to past coronaviruses unrelated to SARS is a very hard argument to make.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom