Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
OK I found this:

But I still don't see a delay getting to the hospital. I'll keep looking.

Guess there's nothing left to reply to except to say I quoted you:And I believe that is not the first time you said it.

Sorry, but this is getting ridiculous. Yes, it is not the first time I have said it. I have pointed out to you that it was in the very source and in the very quote you sent me when I asked what hospital they went to.

This is the last time I show you. If you keep saying you have no idea where the "weeks later" claim comes from then I simply cannot help you:

Oh good grief! Are we sure they weren't infected as an alien experiment? :rolleyes:

Do you ever get out of the country? Every country doesn't look like what you'd see in a Nat Geo expedition. China is a modern country. Yes they have a large area that is rural. But there are several large cities in Yunnan including the city the miners were treated in.

I thought it best if I got more details myself on the hospital the miners died in. They actually do lung transplants at the main hospital in Kunming, Yunnan Province. The miners were treated in a large teaching hospital.

The workers, ages 30 to 63, were scrubbing a copper seam clean of bat faeces in April 2012. Weeks later, they were admitted to a hospital in the provincial capital of Kunming with persistent coughs, fevers, head and chest pains and breathing difficulties. Three eventually died.

I believe this is the hospital:

They've also done kidney transplants since 1983 (same source).

BTW, I'm pretty sure they know what histoplasmosis looks like. I think in one of the two theses it noted the miners may have gotten nosocomial aspergillosis AFTER THEY WERE ADMITTED.
 
Dodging that I quoted you in my reply noted.

From the link which BTW, I have posted many, not all of them consistent with each other:
The workers, ages 30 to 63, were scrubbing a copper seam clean of bat faeces in April 2012. Weeks later, they were admitted to a hospital in the provincial capital of Kunming with persistent coughs, fevers, head and chest pains and breathing difficulties. Three eventually died.
That doesn't say weeks after they got sick. It says weeks after they were scrubbing the a copper seam. I don't see where in that it is consistent with them becoming ill and not being seen at the hospital until weeks later.


Back to the diagnosis, last year Latham and Wilson after careful review of the master's thesis submitted this commentary to Independent Science News:A Proposed Origin for SARS-CoV-2 and the COVID-19 Pandemic It has been cited upthread so this is a review.
The specifics of this mystery disease have been virtually forgotten; however, they are described in a Chinese Master’s thesis written in 2013 by a doctor who supervised their treatment. ...

In a March 2020 interview with Scientific American Zeng-li Shi dismissed the significance of these deaths, claiming the miners died of fungal infections. Indeed, no miners or deaths are mentioned in the paper published by the Shi lab documenting the collection of RaTG13 (Ge et al., 2016).

But Shi’s assessment does not tally with any other contemporaneous accounts of the miners and their illness (Rahalkar and Bahulikar, 2020). ...

The original English version of the abstract implicates a SARS-like coronavirus as the probable causative agent and that the mine “had a lot of bats and bats’ feces”.
I'll come back to that.

Fortunately, a detailed account of the miner’s diagnoses and treatments exists. It is found in a Master’s thesis written in Chinese in May 2013. Its suggestive English title is “The Analysis of 6 Patients with Severe Pneumonia Caused by Unknown viruses“. ...

The six ill miners were admitted to the No. 1. School of Clinical Medicine, Kunming Medical University, in short succession in late April and early May 2012. Kunming is the capital of Yunnan province and 250 Km from Mojiang. ...


Of the descriptions of the miners and their treatments, which include radiographs and numerous CAT scans, several features stand out: ...

[ #1 was a contagion warning]

2) The symptoms (on admission) of the six miners were: a) dry cough, b) sputum, c) high fevers, especially shortly before death d) difficulty breathing, e) myalgia (sore limbs). Some patients had hiccoughs and headaches.

3) Clinical work established that patients 1-4 had low blood oxygen “for sure it was ARDS” (Acute Respiratory Distress Syndrome) and immune damage considered indicative of viral infection. Additionally, a tendency for thrombosis was noted in patients 2 and 4. Symptom severity and mortality were age-related (though from a sample of 6 this must be considered anecdotal).

4) Potential common and rare causes of their symptoms were tested for and mostly eliminated. For patients 3 and 4 these included tests for HIV, Cytomegalovirus, Epstein-Barr Virus (EBV), Japanese encephalitis, haemorrhagic fever, Dengue, Hepatitis B, SARS, and influenza. Of these, only patient 2 tested positive for Hepatitis and EBV.
So it's not like they didn't have a workup.
5) Treatment of the six patients included ventilation (patients 2-4), steroids (all patients), antivirals (all except patient 5), and blood thinners (patients 2 and 4). Antibiotics and antifungal medications were administered to counter what were considered secondary (but significant) co-infections.
Got that? They did not have a primary fungal infection and they didn't die from one.
6) A small number of remote meetings were held with researchers at other universities. One was with Zhong Nanshan at Sun Yat-Sen University, Guangdong. Zhong is the Chinese hero of the SARS epidemic, a virologist, and arguably the most famous scientist in China.
Got that? They consulted with SARS experts as one might in any modern hospital given the circumstances.

7) Samples from the miners were later sent to the WIV in Wuhan and to Zhong Nanshan, further confirming that viral disease was strongly suspected. Some miners did test positive for coronavirus (the thesis is unclear on how many).

8) The source of infection was concluded to be Rhinolophus sinicus, a horseshoe bat and the ultimate conclusion of the thesis reads “the unknown virus lead to severe pneumonia could be: The SARS-like-CoV from the Chinese rufous horseshoe bat.” Thus the miners had a coronavirus but it apparently was not SARS itself. ...

First, in the light of the current coronavirus pandemic it is evident the miners’ symptoms very closely resemble those of COVID-19 (Huang et al, 2020; Tay et al., 2020; M. Zhou et al., 2020). Anyone presenting with them today would immediately be assumed to have COVID-19. Likewise, many of the treatments given to the miners have become standard for COVID-19 (Tay et al., 2020).

Second, the remote meeting with Zhong Nanshan is significant. It implies that the illnesses of the six miners were of high concern and, second, that a SARS-like coronavirus was considered a likely cause.

Third, the abstract, the conclusions, and the general inferences to be made from the Master’s thesis contradict Zheng-li Shi’s assertion that the miners died from a fungal infection. Fungal infection as a potential primary cause was raised but largely discarded.
I'll come back to Shi's assertion in another post. I have to run to the library before they close.
 
OK I found this:

But I still don't see a delay getting to the hospital. I'll keep looking.

Admission to the hospitals came after all but one of the miners went to a local clinic first. Sometimes those dates were not known. The mining activity went from April 2 to Apr 16. Miners 1-4 went the full time. Miners 5-6 were in there 4 days.

I pulled the dates from patient responses upon getting to the larger hospital:

1. Zhou...63yo...Local..4/26.....Kunming..5/1.....Died 5/7
2. Lu.......42yo...Local..4/25.....Yu Xi.......4/30...Died 6/12
3. Guo....45yo....Local ??........Kunming...4/25...Died 8/13
4. Liu.....46yo....Local ??........Kunming....4/26...Left 9/10
5. Wu.....30yo....Local ??........Kunming...5/2.....Left 5/28
6. Li.......32yo....Local X.........Kunming...4/28....Left 5/28
 
Dodging that I quoted you in my reply noted.

From the link which BTW, I have posted many, not all of them consistent with each other:
That doesn't say weeks after they got sick. It says weeks after they were scrubbing the a copper seam. I don't see where in that it is consistent with them becoming ill and not being seen at the hospital until weeks later.

No, it doesn't!

So what? It isn't what I said, is it?

You asked me to back up this...

"Remember that the miners were only admitted to the hospital in Kunming weeks later."

They were tested for SARS and the test came back negative.
 
No, it doesn't!

So what? It isn't what I said, is it?

You asked me to back up this...

"Remember that the miners were only admitted to the hospital in Kunming weeks later."

They were tested for SARS and the test came back negative.

You are still going on and on without admitting that I quoted you.

Dumbing it down to one test when they had full workups and different antibody tests, IgG and IgM, which had different results isn't much of an argument..

No, they did not have SARS. But they had antibodies that cross-reacted and it was unlikely all of those tested had had SARS in the past. I take it you didn't read the quotes I posted from the 2 PhDs who assessed the master's thesis.

There's no point in a discussion if you don't want to address the links or the quotes or anything except foot-stamping that Shi said it was a fungus and trying to make the discussion personal.

You know what it looks like when you address the arguer and not the argument?
 
Admission to the hospitals came after all but one of the miners went to a local clinic first. Sometimes those dates were not known. The mining activity went from April 2 to Apr 16. Miners 1-4 went the full time. Miners 5-6 were in there 4 days.

I pulled the dates from patient responses upon getting to the larger hospital:

1. Zhou...63yo...Local..4/26.....Kunming..5/1.....Died 5/7
2. Lu.......42yo...Local..4/25.....Yu Xi.......4/30...Died 6/12
3. Guo....45yo....Local ??........Kunming...4/25...Died 8/13
4. Liu.....46yo....Local ??........Kunming....4/26...Left 9/10
5. Wu.....30yo....Local ??........Kunming...5/2.....Left 5/28
6. Li.......32yo....Local X.........Kunming...4/28....Left 5/28
Thanks, very useful.

So one died shortly after arriving at the hospital, I incorrectly thought it had been 2 of them.
 
Thanks, very useful.

So one died shortly after arriving at the hospital, I incorrectly thought it had been 2 of them.

i should add that even though most ended up in Kunming, they were not all referred to the same departments. Some started in ER, some went to respiratory, ICU, etc.... It took some time to connect all the dots with the different attending doctors sometimes consulting with different 'experts' at other specialist hospitals.
 
Admission to the hospitals came after all but one of the miners went to a local clinic first. Sometimes those dates were not known. The mining activity went from April 2 to Apr 16. Miners 1-4 went the full time. Miners 5-6 were in there 4 days.

I pulled the dates from patient responses upon getting to the larger hospital:

1. Zhou...63yo...Local..4/26.....Kunming..5/1.....Died 5/7
2. Lu.......42yo...Local..4/25.....Yu Xi.......4/30...Died 6/12
3. Guo....45yo....Local ??........Kunming...4/25...Died 8/13
4. Liu.....46yo....Local ??........Kunming....4/26...Left 9/10
5. Wu.....30yo....Local ??........Kunming...5/2.....Left 5/28
6. Li.......32yo....Local X.........Kunming...4/28....Left 5/28

Well, I just did some Googling for histoplasmosis...

CLINICAL PRESENTATION
Incubation period is typically 3–17 days for acute disease. Ninety percent of infections are asymptomatic or result in a mild influenzalike illness. Some infections may cause acute pulmonary histoplasmosis, manifested by high fever, headache, nonproductive cough, chills, weakness, pleuritic chest pain, and fatigue. Most people spontaneously recover 2–3 weeks after onset of symptoms, although fatigue may persist longer. High-dose exposure can lead to severe pulmonary disease. Dissemination, especially to the gastrointestinal tract and central nervous system, can occur in people who are immunocompromised.

We have a good reason for thinking that the miners may have had high-dose exposure, particularly given that the ones longest in the mine had the most severe illness (3 out of 4 of those died).

Also,...

Radioimmunoassays for IgM and IgG histoplasmal antibodies were developed and proved to be specific for their respective immunoglobulin classes, sensitive, and reproducible. Elevated IgM antibodies were detected in 59.8% of patients with histoplasmosis and 7.9% of control subjects. Elevated IgG antibodies occurred in 80.4% of patients with histoplasmosis but in only 12.9% of control subjects.

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/6408962/

But I don't think we have the full story so it is too difficult to really know what happened.

However, I am going to say that it is really, really going out on a limb to say that the miners definitely died of an unknown virus.
 
i should add that even though most ended up in Kunming, they were not all referred to the same departments. Some started in ER, some went to respiratory, ICU, etc.... It took some time to connect all the dots with the different attending doctors sometimes consulting with different 'experts' at other specialist hospitals.

I started trying to collect all the citations in this thread but gave up because there were too many of them and too little time in my life. :p

But I am going over some of the citations looking for things I set aside at the time, like Quay's papers and on his Spanish language news interview.
 
This is the last time I show you. If you keep saying you have no idea where the "weeks later" claim comes from then I simply cannot help you:

Dodging that I quoted you in my reply noted.

From the link which BTW, I have posted many, not all of them consistent with each other:
That doesn't say weeks after they got sick. It says weeks after they were scrubbing the a copper seam. I don't see where in that it is consistent with them becoming ill and not being seen at the hospital until weeks later.

You are still going on and on without admitting that I quoted you.

Admitting I quoted you? What are you talking about?

As you are aware, it is often hard to discern what Skeptic Ginger is going on and on about.

Skeptic Ginger quoted you in post #1667, which you quoted back to her, with the "Weeks later" in extra-large bold face, in post #1741.

It looks to me as though Skeptic Ginger thinks the "Weeks later" quotation was something you wrote, which would explain why she has been failing to acknowledge that the "Weeks later" came from the source she cited herself.

It is also possible that Skeptic Ginger realizes the "Weeks later" bit came from her own source rather than from you, but somehow thinks her objection to that information ("That doesn't say weeks after they got sick") is somehow related to the fact that she also quoted you in post #1667 or perhaps some other post, and is upset that you aren't saying something like "Oh, I get it: Although the fact that you quoted me in that same post is completely irrelevant, I should have acknowledged that completely irrelevant fact instead of pointing out that you are denying the 'Weeks later' in your own source." That explanation makes no sense, but this wouldn't be the first occasion where we can't make sense of this thread without considering the possibility that some of the arguments being made make no sense.

It is also possible that, for the purposes of this thread, the universe has been replaced by something even more bizarre and inexplicable.
 
Again you claim to know more than the doctors treating the patients. I assure you you do not.

:rolleyes:

No doctor the world is going to know the distinguishing characteristics of a novel virus because by definition they have never seen it before. Again there was no way to accurately identify if someone had Covid back in Jan 2020 because tests were not widely available. It's silly of you to even try to dispute this.



1) This ignores the master's thesis written by the doctors who treated the miners.

The fact that this person was writing a Masters Thesis implies they were a student, not a doctor, at the time they were writing it.
 
As you are aware, it is often hard to discern what Skeptic Ginger is going on and on about.

Skeptic Ginger quoted you in post #1667, which you quoted back to her, with the "Weeks later" in extra-large bold face, in post #1741.

It looks to me as though Skeptic Ginger thinks the "Weeks later" quotation was something you wrote, which would explain why she has been failing to acknowledge that the "Weeks later" came from the source she cited herself.

It is also possible that Skeptic Ginger realizes the "Weeks later" bit came from her own source rather than from you, but somehow thinks her objection to that information ("That doesn't say weeks after they got sick") is somehow related to the fact that she also quoted you in post #1667 or perhaps some other post, and is upset that you aren't saying something like "Oh, I get it: Although the fact that you quoted me in that same post is completely irrelevant, I should have acknowledged that completely irrelevant fact instead of pointing out that you are denying the 'Weeks later' in your own source." That explanation makes no sense, but this wouldn't be the first occasion where we can't make sense of this thread without considering the possibility that some of the arguments being made make no sense.

It is also possible that, for the purposes of this thread, the universe has been replaced by something even more bizarre and inexplicable.

Thanks for chiming in. For a while, I was beginning to wonder if I was losing my mind. Also, you have clarified for me that Skeptic Ginger was accusing me of quoting her quoting me. It's truly bizarre.
 
:rolleyes:

No doctor the world is going to know the distinguishing characteristics of a novel virus because by definition they have never seen it before. Again there was no way to accurately identify if someone had Covid back in Jan 2020 because tests were not widely available. It's silly of you to even try to dispute this.

Indeed. Now we have Skeptic Ginger quoting this bit:

4) Potential common and rare causes of their symptoms were tested for and mostly eliminated. For patients 3 and 4 these included tests for HIV, Cytomegalovirus, Epstein-Barr Virus (EBV), Japanese encephalitis, haemorrhagic fever, Dengue, Hepatitis B, SARS, and influenza. Of these, only patient 2 tested positive for Hepatitis and EBV.

So they were tested for SARS and were not found to be positive for the virus.
[cue Skeptic Ginger asking: "Where are you getting that they didn't test positive for SARS!!!1!"]

In that case, how is it possible that they were found positive for an unknown SARS-like virus and also negative for SARS? What would be the assay that could be used for that? I mean, I don't know about virology and serological testing but surely it would be impossible to test for unknown yet identifiable viruses as a matter of logic, would it not?



The fact that this person was writing a Masters Thesis implies they were a student, not a doctor, at the time they were writing it.

Yeah, I mentioned this way back. I couldn't understand how this would be at the same time an experienced doctor and also a Masters student. It did not make sense.

Furthermore, it seems doubtful that the person writing the Masters saw all of the patients given that they didn't all go to the same hospitals, or even the same city (according to Sherkeu).

It's a pretty flimsy hook to hang an elaborate and Byzantine conspiracy theory on.
 
:rolleyes:

No doctor the world is going to know the distinguishing characteristics of a novel virus because by definition they have never seen it before. Again there was no way to accurately identify if someone had Covid back in Jan 2020 because tests were not widely available. It's silly of you to even try to dispute this.
Distinguishing characteristics is how one makes a diagnosis when one doesn't have a microorganism identified.

As for the master's thesis, it was written by a medical school student supervised by his professors. But it's the content that matters. We also have the PhD dissertation and we have the master's thesis describing consulting with SARS experts among other experts. And in the links to other scientists discussing the thesis, not one says the thesis is inadequate in any way.

I looked again at the thesis. It's a detailed review of the patients from admission to death or discharge including labs x-rays, CT scans. It includes a discussion of said labs and of the circumstances surrounding the men's exposure to the horseshoe bats and a consult with the WIV where it was reported none of the specimens they had collected from the particular bats was contagious to humans.

And in the discussion he explains how he came to the conclusion they had a virus and more specifically it was a SARS-like virus.

From the link I cited above:
The source of infection was concluded to be Rhinolophus sinicus, a horseshoe bat and the ultimate conclusion of the thesis reads “the unknown virus lead to severe pneumonia could be: The SARS-like-CoV from the Chinese rufous horseshoe bat.” Thus the miners had a coronavirus but it apparently was not SARS itself.
That is very specific and supported by the details in the thesis of the 6 miners.
 
Last edited:
Distinguishing characteristics is how one makes a diagnosis when one doesn't have a microorganism identified.

What characteristics of Covid-19 would have allowed to accurately count the number of people who were infected in Jan of 2020?
 
Do the theses describe the antibody assay used? I'd like to know what the target antigen was.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Do the theses describe the antibody assay used? I'd like to know what the target antigen was.

The specific assay might differ between here and China anyway. I know for some antigen and antibody tests I order, the antibody tests have been markedly improved over the last decade so they would have been using cruder tests in 2012. I have only been getting routine viral loads on HIV and Hep C patients in the last couple of years though viral loads have been done for more than a decade. For past viral loads one had to send in deep-frozen specimens within 2 hours of collection to get those PCR results. A p24 antigen (very early HIV) also required those -70F specimens. Now I can send in room temperature serum specimens and get specific viral loads.


Since the sickest, oldest and earliest fatality (pt #1 in the thesis) spent 5 days in the local hospital before being transferred to the teaching hospital, I've decided it best to review the notes now to see what I can find that is relative to your question instead of going by memory.


Also, just a reminder for people who want to discount the master's thesis, it is essentially a careful recording and analysis from the medical records of the exams and treatment the patients got. It's not like the medical student did research on his own care of these patients or devised his own research project. I get annoyed when that thesis keeps getting hand-waved away, presumably by people who haven't really looked at it.
 
Last edited:
The specific assay might differ between here and China anyway. I know for some antigen and antibody tests I order, the antibody tests have been markedly improved over the last decade so they would have been using cruder tests in 2012. I have only been getting routine viral loads on HIV and Hep C patients in the last couple of years though viral loads have been done for more than a decade. For past viral loads one had to send in deep-frozen specimens within 2 hours of collection to get those PCR results. A p24 antigen (very early HIV) also required those -70F specimens. Now I can send in room temperature serum specimens and get specific viral loads.


Since the sickest, oldest and earliest fatality (pt #1 in the thesis) spent 5 days in the local hospital before being transferred to the teaching hospital, I've decided it best to review the notes now to see what I can find that is relative to your question instead of going by memory.


Also, just a reminder for people who want to discount the master's thesis, it is essentially a careful recording and analysis from the medical records of the exams and treatment the patients got. It's not like the medical student did research on his own care of these patients or devised his own research project. I get annoyed when that thesis keeps getting hand-waved away, presumably by people who haven't really looked at it.


Perhaps you can provide links to the translations. Sorry, they maybe up thread. The assay method details should be described. I'm talking about the antibody tests not the PCR .


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom