Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
Please. You are smuggling very disputed claims iinto the narrative as though they were established fact.

You. DO. NOT. KNOW. They had a SARS virus.
Oh stop it! Yes we do, it was the diagnosis at the time and the master's thesis from said doctor who saw the patient made that diagnosis. If you want to argue, don't argue with me, address how you simply don't believe the doctors who treated these patients or how you don't think a SARS Co V-like infection is close enough for your learned-self to agree.
You would do yourself a big favor to start addressing the evidence and stop addressing me.


As for Fauci's definition of GoF and Paul's I've been trying to find a clear-cut difference in how each is defining it. And I intend to go over some past links from the thread. I haven't yet.

I believe Fauci over Paul and I don't expect to find anything different. There is no reason to connect research done at the UNC in 2014-2015 to the current pandemic. Paul is way out of line there. But it doesn't mean no SARS Co V-like coronavirus strains were used in GoF research. I'm still digging there. I do respect the belief by Capsid here that there wasn't any GoF research going on at the WIV. I can't counter that unless I find more evidence. And maybe there isn't any.
 
Last edited:
Oh stop it! Yes we do, it was the diagnosis at the time and the master's thesis from said doctor who saw the patient made that diagnosis. If you want to argue, don't argue with me, address how you simply don't believe the doctors who treated these patients or how you don't think a SARS Co V-like infection is close enough for your learned-self to agree.

I'm saying it is disputed. You are using this as though it was uncontroversial and undisputed fact.

As for Fauci's definition of GoF and Paul's I've been trying to find a clear-cut difference in how each is defining it. And I intend to go over some past links from the thread. I haven't yet.

I believe Fauci over Paul and I don't expect to find anything different. There is no reason to connect research done at the UNC in 2014-2015 to the current pandemic. Paul is way out of line there. But it doesn't mean no SARS Co V-like coronavirus strains were used in GoF research. I'm still digging there. I do respect the belief by Capsid here that there wasn't any GoF research going on at the WIV. I can't counter that unless I find more evidence. And maybe there isn't any.

Indeed. But Rand Paul was specifically claiming that a 2017 paper of Shi and Daszak et. al was gain of function.

Fauci was specifically saying it was NOT GoF.

So next time you see a claim that there were published papers showing GoF was done at the WIV, then you have to treat it with extreme caution because there is literally no evidence, and the statements by Shi and Daszak that they weren't doing GoF should be respected until there is evidence that they are lying (there is none!).

As for "There is no reason to connect research done at the UNC in 2014-2015 to the current pandemic. Paul is way out of line there." That is exactly what YOU were doing as I pointed out in this post as well as several times previously...

For goodness sake! We've all seen the damn video!

My point is that you misquote it.

Look, let me help you:

Daszak says: "You can manipulate them in the lab pretty easily...spike protein drives a lot of what happens with coronavirus zoonotic risk. So you can get the sequence you can build the protein and we work with Ralph Baric at UNC to do that, insert it into the backbone of another virus, and do some work in the lab, and you can get more predictive when you find a sequence..."

Notice, as I have been repeating endlessly to you whenever you wave your hand vaguely in the direction of this interview, that he is explicitly talking about Ralph Baric's lab.
 
I'm saying it is disputed. You are using this as though it was uncontroversial and undisputed fact.
By whom?

Once again you fail to address the evidence from the source. Are you claiming there are valid scientific quibbles with the master's thesis? Who are those valid quibblers and do you have any citations where they directly challenge the thesis diagnosis? Or is this just you and promoters of the natural spillover argument making the claim?

Shi claiming they died from a fungus goes against the evidence and she's not cited anything supporting that assertion. Nor have you.

Remember, the miners having had a SARS Co V-like virus can actually support a natural spillover event. It's one reason it is puzzling that Shi is dismissing that the miners had, at a minimum, a virus they were infected with in the mine.

AS said:
As for "There is no reason to connect research done at the UNC in 2014-2015 to the current pandemic. Paul is way out of line there." That is exactly what YOU were doing as I pointed out in this post as well as several times previously...
I didn't connect that research specifically. I said there was nothing in the US denying funding that prohibited said research moving to the WIV.

I have different issues with the Daszak interview I'll address later.
 
Last edited:
By whom?

Once again you fail to address the evidence from the source. Are you claiming there are valid scientific quibbles with the master's thesis? Who are those valid quibblers and do you have any citations where they directly challenge the thesis diagnosis? Or is this just you and promoters of the natural spillover argument making the claim?

Shi claiming they died from a fungus goes against the evidence and she's not cited anything supporting that assertion. Nor have you.

Remember, the miners having had a SARS Co V-like virus can actually support a natural spillover event. It's one reason it is puzzling that Shi is dismissing that the miners had, at a minimum, a virus they were infected with in the mine.

Indeed, Shi says it was a fungus, and I believe that the PhD thesis said that the cause of death was not conclusive. They apparently had samples in the WIV and claim not to have found any sign of SARS or SAR--CoV-2

According to the Wuhan Institute of Virology's Shi Zhengli, China's top bat coronavirus researcher, the workers' pneumonia-like symptoms were caused by a fungal infection. Shi and her team also said in research published last November that they had retested 13 serum samples from four of the patients and found no sign they had been infected with SARS-CoV-2.

Link

From the Addendum on the paper related to RaTG13:

“To investigate the cause of the respiratory disease, we tested the samples using PCR methods developed in our laboratory targeting the RNA-dependent RNA polymerases of Ebola virus, Nipah virus and bat SARSr-CoVRp3, and all the samples tested negative for these viruses. We also tested the serum samples for the presence of antibodies against the nucleocapsid proteins of these three viruses, and none of the samples gave a positive result. Recently, we retested the samples with our validated enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) against the SARS coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2) nucleocapsid protein–which has greater than 90% amino acid sequence identity with SARSr-CoVRp3–and confirmed that these patients were not infected by SARS-CoV-2.” (Zhou et al., 2020, addendum)


And yes, surely the fact that the miners deaths from a spillover is dog-that-didn't-bark evidence.
 
Indeed, Shi says it was a fungus, and I believe that the PhD thesis said that the cause of death was not conclusive. They apparently had samples in the WIV and claim not to have found any sign of SARS or SAR--CoV-2

They actually sent samples to Wuhan and Wuhan said it looked like a virus because of positive antibody tests. If I recall, the Phd paper said 4 samples had SARS-like antibodies, but of course no test could be specific and confirming without knowing the virus beforehand. They said they didnt find any match to anything when they sampled in the cave so could not say for sure what it was..

I believe the reason for the switch from fungus to virus was that the progression of the patients after 2 whole months of intubated medicated treatments was unlike other fungal infections resulting in ARDS.
 
Last edited:
lomiller posted:

............................................

I have been looking to pre-pandemic scientific info sources to try to get to what could be true. There are some things China could not hide though in their rush to contain a dramatic outbreak.
But anyone can go on believing China "data" if they want. The timing looks pretty darn suspicious to me!!!

JAN 19, 2020: BBC - The new Chinese virus which has already spread abroad "is still preventable and controllable", China says.

Its National Health Commission warned, however, that close monitoring was needed given the source, transmission and mutation methods were unknown. Two people are known to have died from the respiratory illness which appeared in Wuhan city in December.



JAN 23, 2020: BEIJING (Reuters) - The Chinese city of Wuhan is rapidly building a new 1,000-bed hospital to treat victims of a new coronavirus, mobilizing machinery to get it ready by early next week, state media said.

The virus has killed 25 people in China and infected more than 800, the government said on Friday.

“The construction of this project is to solve the shortage of existing medical resources,” the report said.

[qimg]https://s.france24.com/media/display/72af7952-3f5f-11ea-b0a1-005056a98db9/w:600/p:16x9/China%20new%20hospital%20m.webp[/qimg]


eta: I dont think I need to mention the other 1500 bed hospital they started the next day, do I?
By this time internal China flights were cancelled. International flights were not.

The test for covid was developed in mid Jan and wouldn't be available in any numbers for weeks yet. The distinguishing characteristic of Covid induced pneumonia were also not identified yet so there was no way to tell who had Covid and who had any other flu like disease.

The ratio of infections to serious cases showing up at hospitals was also not known yet so there were ~40X as many infected people as anyone suspected. 25 deaths at 1% IFR, 5 day incubation, 10-15 days until death suggests 15K - 30K infected people were currently walking around spreading the disease. It hadn't even been established that it was a true respiratory virus that could spread human to human SARS and MERS would have been controllable with the numbers they were seeing, and there was no way to know just how far Covid had already spread.

I expect every nation on the planet would have thought the virus could still be contained given what little was known at the time.
 
They actually sent samples to Wuhan and Wuhan said it looked like a virus because of positive antibody tests.

If they had a cold in the previous year they could have antibodies from a Corona virus, since 15% of colds are caused by Corona viruses. Antibodies to a novel virus would take up to a month to show up, with to my understanding doesn't fit with when the samples were taken.

I believe the reason for the switch from fungus to virus was that the progression of the patients after 2 whole months of intubated medicated treatments was unlike other fungal infections resulting in ARDS.

Wouldn't that favor a fungal infection? I thought the treatment duration for fungal pneumonia tended to be long, up to an year in some cases.
 
Last edited:
Nothing about the cases resembled a "fungal infection". To claim otherwise is to imagine you know more than the doctors treating the patients.

lomiller said:
The distinguishing characteristic of Covid induced pneumonia were also not identified yet so there was no way to tell who had Covid and who had any other flu like disease.
Again you claim to know more than the doctors treating the patients. I assure you you do not.

But as for what the miners had that Shi seems to not fully address:

The genetic structure of SARS‐CoV‐2 does not rule out a laboratory origin
We discovered that the RdRp of RaTG13 has 100% nucleotide identity with the sequence BtCoV/4991 (KP876546), which was identified by Ge et al.[ 5 ] in a Rhinolophus affinis bat in the Yunnan province in 2013, same location and year as RaTG13. BtCoV/4991 was collected in a mine colonized by bats near Tongguanzhen, Mojiang, Yunnan. The WIV researchers were invited to investigate the mine after six miners there had contracted severe pneumonia in 2012iii, and three of the miners have died.[ 6 ] The miners have been tasked with clearing out bat droppings in the mine, and the severity of their pneumonia correlated with the duration of exposure to the mine.[ 7 ] Four miners’ samples subsequently underwent testing at WIV, where Immunoglobulin G (IgG) antibodies against SARS were identified in all samples.[ 8 ] Considering that only about 5300 people were infected in mainland China during the SARS outbreak of 2002–2004, most of whom resided in Guandong, the odds of four miners in Yunnan retaining antibodies from the 2002–2004 SARS outbreak are negligible. On the other hand, it is possible that the SARS antibody test administered to the miners cross‐reacted with a novel SARS‐like bat virus that the miners had acquired at the mine. Ge et al.[ 5 ] have identified a number of CoVs in the mine, but based on the phylogenetic analysis, BtCoV/4991 was the only SARS‐related strain, clearly separated from all known alpha‐ and beta‐CoVs at that time. BtCoV/4991 was also different from other bat CoVs in the phylogenetic analysis carried out by Wang et al. in 2019.[ 9 ] Chen et al.[ 10 ] identified BtCoV/4991 as the closest sequence to SARS‐CoV‐2 because RaTG13 had not yet been published at that time. BtCoV/4991 and RaTG13 have been later asserted to be two different coding names of the same strain, as their original authors at WIV registered the two strains as one entry in the Database of Bat‐associated Viruses (DBatVir).iv
Note the invitation to take samples from the mine came because the miners contracted a severe pneumonia. They were not diagnosed with a fungal infection as both histoplasmosis and aspergillosis would not have been a mystery infection. And a cluster of 6 cases of undiagnosed pneumonia in miners working where SARS likely originated would raise a big red flag which resulted in contacting the WIV.
Add to that what was the presumptive diagnoses the physician taking care of these patients stated in the master's thesis and you have a likely SARS CoV-like viral pneumonia.

Of course this is that paper by Segreto and Deigin that has been hand-waved away because of some reason over their hypothesis on the furin cleavage sites.


You all can spin your wheels over this all you want, it doesn't change the evidence based facts.
 
Nothing about the cases resembled a "fungal infection". To claim otherwise is to imagine you know more than the doctors treating the patients.

Again you claim to know more than the doctors treating the patients. I assure you you do not.

But as for what the miners had that Shi seems to not fully address:

The genetic structure of SARS‐CoV‐2 does not rule out a laboratory originNote the invitation to take samples from the mine came because the miners contracted a severe pneumonia. They were not diagnosed with a fungal infection as both histoplasmosis and aspergillosis would not have been a mystery infection. And a cluster of 6 cases of undiagnosed pneumonia in miners working where SARS likely originated would raise a big red flag which resulted in contacting the WIV.
Add to that what was the presumptive diagnoses the physician taking care of these patients stated in the master's thesis and you have a likely SARS CoV-like viral pneumonia.

Of course this is that paper by Segreto and Deigin that has been hand-waved away because of some reason over their hypothesis on the furin cleavage sites.


You all can spin your wheels over this all you want, it doesn't change the evidence based facts.

Why the WIV? They were not the local centre for virology. Where is the evidence that WIV was contacted at the time?

May I repeat as someone who actually has seen and treated people with covid-19 pneumonia. These people did not have covid-19 pneumonia. There is no evidence they were tested for histoplasmosis. There is no evidence they were treated for legionella. Both of which would fit the picture (clinical and radiological) better than covid-19. The mortality rate is too high for Covid-19 in young people with no co-morbidities. The radiology is wrong. The blood results are wrong. The samples that are available are negative for covid-19. They did not have SARS. They did not have SARS-CoV-2.
 
Why the WIV? They were not the local centre for virology. Where is the evidence that WIV was contacted at the time?
They absolutely were the center for SARS virus research in the same area that they'd been doing since ~2003 on a quest to find the origin of SARS that led to the civet cats spreading it to people.


May I repeat as someone who actually has seen and treated people with covid-19 pneumonia. These people did not have covid-19 pneumonia. There is no evidence they were tested for histoplasmosis. There is no evidence they were treated for legionella. Both of which would fit the picture (clinical and radiological) better than covid-19. The mortality rate is too high for Covid-19 in young people with no co-morbidities. The radiology is wrong. The blood results are wrong. The samples that are available are negative for covid-19. They did not have SARS. They did not have SARS-CoV-2.
1) This ignores the master's thesis written by the doctors who treated the miners.

2) You should be well aware you don't hone in on a diagnosis by pulling numbers from a hat.

Remember there are things like an H&P which includes labs and radiological tests, knowledge of what is circulating at the time, and a differential to put things in the order of likelihood.
 
Last edited:
They absolutely were the center for SARS virus research in the same area that they'd been doing since ~2003 on a quest to find the origin of SARS that led to the civet cats spreading it to people..

The WIV did NOT detect SARS in civets. That was done by Hong Kong University.

The WIV also looo at other types of viruses, and I believe there were other teams looking in the minds from other institutions as well. If you remember one of the viruses mentioned at first was a Nipah-type virus. This is, I think, from another team that were looking in the same mines.
 
The WIV did NOT detect SARS in civets. That was done by Hong Kong University.
I'm pretty sure I was clear in what I wrote. Let me see: "the same area that they'd been doing since ~2003 on a quest to find the origin of SARS" Yep, it was pretty clear.


The WIV also looo at other types of viruses, and I believe there were other teams looking in the minds from other institutions as well. If you remember one of the viruses mentioned at first was a Nipah-type virus. This is, I think, from another team that were looking in the same mines.
And?
 
I'm pretty sure I was clear in what I wrote. Let me see: "the same area that they'd been doing since ~2003 on a quest to find the origin of SARS" Yep, it was pretty clear.


And?

I don’t know. Maybe there was no obvious alert to the specific SARS Centre?

The researchers also apparently turned up something like six months later. There did not seem to be a hurry, for some reason.

Also, the timeline seems important. Remember that the miners were only admitted to the hospital in Kunming weeks later. That certainly seems a long time for the original SARS.
 
So now you think that because the WIV researchers didn't get to Yunnan fast enough ergo the miners didn't have a SARS CoV-like viral pneumonia? :rolleyes:

And do you have a link for that delay "admitted to the hospital weeks later" you keep repeating? I don't think 2 of them even lived that long.
 
So now you think that because the WIV researchers didn't get to Yunnan fast enough ergo the miners didn't have a SARS CoV-like viral pneumonia? :rolleyes:

And do you have a link for that delay "admitted to the hospital weeks later" you keep repeating? I don't think 2 of them even lived that long.

You posted the "weeks later" thing. Scroll back and read your own damn posts and your own damn links.

It is tedious work making you read your own claims and having to always tidy up for you. I seem to be doing it incessasantly in this thread, and yet when you finally see what I have been pointing out to you over and over again, you will say, "Oh finally you have shown it" and I'll get no thank yous or anything.
 
OK I found this:

iii) The length of infection experienced by the miners (especially patients 2, 3 and 4) far exceeded that of an ordinary coronavirus infection. From first becoming too sick to work in the mine, patient 2 survived 57 days until he died. Patient 3 survived 120 days after stopping work. Patient 4 survived 117 days and then was discharged as cured. Each had been exposed in the mine for 14 days prior to the onset of severe symptoms; thus each presumably had nascent infections for some time before calling in sick (See Table 2 of the thesis).
But I still don't see a delay getting to the hospital. I'll keep looking.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom